From mostly humble origins in, say, Garbatulla, Kenya's political leadership seems increasingly like a bunch of, you got it, Grabatullahs!
They (and if not they, their relatives or surrogates) grab anything in sight: Public land, forest reserves, the nation's strategic grain reserves, public tenders, food for the poor, CDF funds, bursary funds, donor funds, donations to IDPs, ECK returning officers, political power (through rigged party nominations or national and civic elections, and through gerrymandered constituency and administrative boundaries), civil society organizations and leaderships, community organizations, public appointments (through nepotism and other forms of particularism), funeral gatherings, and anything else you remember (that I have inadvertently omitted). And they protect each other by: lying, cheating and more grabbing.
Matters have become decidedly worse in the last 12 months or so. Meritocracy is a fairy-tale.
This is the reign of the Grabatullahs.
Showing posts with label Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Election. Show all posts
Thursday, April 02, 2009
Monday, March 23, 2009
The Kisumu Molasses Company
Today's dailies report that Raila Odinga, Kenya's PM, has pledged that members of the public who contributed shares to the molasses plant (close to twenty years ago!), will be allocated shares "once we are listed in the stock exchange." My guess is that listing will not take place any time soon; certainly not before the 2012 General Elections (I don't think Uhuru Kenyatta, who as Finance Minister has a say, will countenance that), and probably not before 2017 (or even 2020, or even 2030). So, if there was any cheering at the Tom Mboya Labour College where the announcement was made, who's kidding whom?
The bigger question, though, is this: What makes Raila Odinga think he's the one to decide when -- or, as has clearly been the case to-date, if -- co-shareholders of the molasses plant are to be allowed into the company, to share in the olemo with the Odinga family?
On page 20 of the busiess section of Daily Nation of March 23, 2009, Raila himself reveals that: "Locals contributed Sh 1.7 billion and a developer (Spectre International) brought $15 million (Sh 1.2 billion). This enabled the moribund plant to get on its feet." Does that not give "locals" a controlling 58.62% of the company? Instead of the Odinga family, shouldn't they, and those who set up the company prior to its becoming moribund, be calling the shots?
A pertinent point here is this: The Luo have no royal family, and never had! Just imagine what Kikuyus would have thought of James Mwangi if he had adopted the same selfish attitude with respect to the founding shareholders of what is now the giant Equity Bank -- in which I myself have a very few shares!
Yes, we can blame past governments for Nyanza's backwardness; but the condenscending attitude displayed by Raila over the weekend is very much part of the reason Nyanza continues to stagnate and whine in despondency. In effect, the buck stops with him. Increasingly, the electorate is restless in the face of this perpetuity -- which is worse in many ways than the impunity everyone is talking about these days. This is impunity squared; and the joke is in the absence of detail and credibility.
The only silver lining I see in the pronouncement is that the intense pressure on the Odinga family by grass-roots Luo is finally having some effect. But promises will not do; nor will passing the buck to the usual "bogeymen".
And then there is the historic injustice personified by the Luo Thrift Union. When will that be addressed? This was no Mbi-I-Kamiti, nor Nyakinyua, nor those many group land-buying companies that Central Province is so well known for.
If you ask me, the share allocation at Kisumu Molasses Company should have been effected at least a decade ago. In fact, subscribers should as a matter of course already know how many shares they have, and should already be co-beneficiaries of any dividend distribution so far authorized and made. They should not be treated like other retail investors who might wish to scramble for "peanut" share allocations during a promissory IPO which may not come in the lifetime of many in the rapidly aging and permanently deprived "cheering crowd" of Nyanza.
The time to allocate the shares is now, long before the 2012 election frenzy; and this does not require NSE listing. This should be the kind of gonywa Nyanza electors should be shouting about. The time to get serious is now. The people want to concentrate on development. It is the politicians who will not put politics aside. The people are not perpetually running for president, it is Raila who is -- clearly not satisfied with being Prime Minister. Perhaps we should bite the bullet and keep the "Premiership" out of the constitution. Out, out, kabisa. It does not seem to be doing anyone any "real good" (power-wise), least of all Raila.
The bigger question, though, is this: What makes Raila Odinga think he's the one to decide when -- or, as has clearly been the case to-date, if -- co-shareholders of the molasses plant are to be allowed into the company, to share in the olemo with the Odinga family?
On page 20 of the busiess section of Daily Nation of March 23, 2009, Raila himself reveals that: "Locals contributed Sh 1.7 billion and a developer (Spectre International) brought $15 million (Sh 1.2 billion). This enabled the moribund plant to get on its feet." Does that not give "locals" a controlling 58.62% of the company? Instead of the Odinga family, shouldn't they, and those who set up the company prior to its becoming moribund, be calling the shots?
A pertinent point here is this: The Luo have no royal family, and never had! Just imagine what Kikuyus would have thought of James Mwangi if he had adopted the same selfish attitude with respect to the founding shareholders of what is now the giant Equity Bank -- in which I myself have a very few shares!
Yes, we can blame past governments for Nyanza's backwardness; but the condenscending attitude displayed by Raila over the weekend is very much part of the reason Nyanza continues to stagnate and whine in despondency. In effect, the buck stops with him. Increasingly, the electorate is restless in the face of this perpetuity -- which is worse in many ways than the impunity everyone is talking about these days. This is impunity squared; and the joke is in the absence of detail and credibility.
The only silver lining I see in the pronouncement is that the intense pressure on the Odinga family by grass-roots Luo is finally having some effect. But promises will not do; nor will passing the buck to the usual "bogeymen".
And then there is the historic injustice personified by the Luo Thrift Union. When will that be addressed? This was no Mbi-I-Kamiti, nor Nyakinyua, nor those many group land-buying companies that Central Province is so well known for.
If you ask me, the share allocation at Kisumu Molasses Company should have been effected at least a decade ago. In fact, subscribers should as a matter of course already know how many shares they have, and should already be co-beneficiaries of any dividend distribution so far authorized and made. They should not be treated like other retail investors who might wish to scramble for "peanut" share allocations during a promissory IPO which may not come in the lifetime of many in the rapidly aging and permanently deprived "cheering crowd" of Nyanza.
The time to allocate the shares is now, long before the 2012 election frenzy; and this does not require NSE listing. This should be the kind of gonywa Nyanza electors should be shouting about. The time to get serious is now. The people want to concentrate on development. It is the politicians who will not put politics aside. The people are not perpetually running for president, it is Raila who is -- clearly not satisfied with being Prime Minister. Perhaps we should bite the bullet and keep the "Premiership" out of the constitution. Out, out, kabisa. It does not seem to be doing anyone any "real good" (power-wise), least of all Raila.
Labels:
2012,
2017,
Election,
IPO,
Kenya,
Kenyatta,
Kikuyu,
Kisumu Molasses,
Luo,
Luo Thrift,
Mbo-I-Kamiti,
Mboya,
Nyakinyua,
Nyanza,
Odinga,
Olemo,
PM,
Raila,
Shares,
Stock Exchange
Tuesday, September 23, 2008
Kriegler's Verdict
South Africa's Judge Johann Kriegler, Chair of Kenya's Kriegler Commission (and the person who oversaw South Africa's first post-apartheid elections), held a press conference in Nairobi last Friday, September 19th, at which he highlighted the Commission's findings regarding the controversy and widespread violence that surrounded Kenya's Presidential elections held in December 2007. The Commission's main task had been to determine who actually had won the contest, Kibaki or Raila, and to recommend the way forward.
Why had the Commission been seen as the vehicle for settling the dispute? According to Kofi Annan, "They had considered everything, recount, re-tallying or forensic audit, all agreed an independent committee was the viable option."
What was the verdict of the Kriegler Commission, as reported in the media? First and foremost, that it was impossible to determine who actually won the Presidential contest. Why? Because in the December elections, his Commission had found, "ballot boxes were stuffed all over the country...there was vote-buying, bribery, intimidation, and women were not allowed to stand for certain offices."
And this was not a one-off event. As he had noted on KTN's live TV show Thursday night (see last week's issue of The Standard on Saturday):
Moreover, he added, this "problem of many decades" is:
So that now, he said at the press conference:
In his view (in The Standard on Saturday), "The integrity of the process and the credibility of the results were so gravely impaired by...manifold irregularities and defectsthat it is irrelevant whether or not there was actual rigging at the national tally centre. The results are irretrievably polluted."
Hey, wait a minute, a number of commentators have argued: Doesn't that mean that President Kibaki is in office illegally? No, answered the Judge on TV Thursday night, "but I do think the question of the legitimacy of the elections will become a very serious problem in future if people do not decide that they are tired of playing games of democracy and decide that they are entitled to choose their leaders through the ballot."
Clearly, pending specific constitutional reforms, a disputed Presidential election favours any incumbent who believes he/she has won, and on that basis chooses to stay put. On what grounds would the opponent(s) legally, or even forcefully, remove him/her in order to take over? Failure to determine who won does not now, as it did not in January, add any iota of rationale or legitimacy for a Raila takeover. Thus, we can only look to the future for a solution, starting now -- if not yesterday.
One option for the future is to constitutionally mandate the Speaker or Chief Justice, or, in their "absence" (or due to specified incapacity), or their deputies, to assume the office of Acting President while disputed results are sorted out -- even through a fresh election.
Concurrent with this would have to be the requirement that no swearing-in of a new President, or an incumbent in his/her second term, shall take place earlier than 14 days from the date of the announcement of the Presidential election results. This will give time for petitions to be lodged and heard, and will discourage the mischief of hurried and even secretive swearings-in which Kenya has witnessed twice already.
The Kriegler Commission's verdict has, at the very least, put a stamp of judicial authority on an educated view which most thoughtful Kenyans had already silently formed months ago -- as early as January. There are millions of this silent majority, who nevertheless found themselves powerless to influence the post-election turn of events in the crucial first 40 to 60 days or so. Both the President (Kibaki) and the Prime Minister (Raila) have now accepted the verdict, and promised to implement its recommendations. We will just have to wait and see.
Clearly, the Electoral Commission would have to be overhauled, as recommended. However, if there was one item that the Kriegler Commission failed to pay adequate attention to, it was the even greated mess that occurred within the constituencies in relation to Parliamentary and Civic elections. These were so intertwined with the Presidential elections that it is something of a deliberate abdication of duty not to have included in the Commission's terms of reference items specific to these levels, and not to have had something sobstantial to say in the report.
We cannot clean up the presidential election process if we do not also, or first, clean up the process at these lower levels. In very many constituencies, the agents of the presidential candidates were also the agents of their parties' parliamentary and civic candidates -- or vice versa. I saw it in Kisumu Rural. Doing all the dirty work for the presidential candidate, or seeming to, provided a perverse sort of justification (and cover) for doing as much dirty work as was necessary to ensure the parliamentary or civic candidate's own victory.
The corruption is systemic, but has so far been treated as the secret weapon for electoral victory -- which the likes of Kriegler should not be made fully privy to, and certainly should not take away in one "pathetic" instance of inquiry. That's why we'll just have to wait and see.
Why had the Commission been seen as the vehicle for settling the dispute? According to Kofi Annan, "They had considered everything, recount, re-tallying or forensic audit, all agreed an independent committee was the viable option."
What was the verdict of the Kriegler Commission, as reported in the media? First and foremost, that it was impossible to determine who actually won the Presidential contest. Why? Because in the December elections, his Commission had found, "ballot boxes were stuffed all over the country...there was vote-buying, bribery, intimidation, and women were not allowed to stand for certain offices."
And this was not a one-off event. As he had noted on KTN's live TV show Thursday night (see last week's issue of The Standard on Saturday):
"You have been having very bad elections for many years, you have had violence, fraud, vote buying, bribery, intimidation, so election after election you have been prepared for that process... It has now caught up with you and it was a lesson that made Kenyans think of what to do...with what has not been a very good election track record."
Moreover, he added, this "problem of many decades" is:
"...partly the leaders, partly the people, partly your history, partly the electoral commission's fault...everybody has some answering to do for what went wrong that day."
So that now, he said at the press conference:
"If you think it's vital to find out if there was rigging at KICC [where voting results from the country's 210 constituencies were tallied by the Kivuitu-led Electoral Commission] to determine if Raila or Kibaki won...God help you! We could not." And, "If we didn't settle somebody's wish as to who won, I am sorry we are not members of a Jockey Club, we had a job to do."
In his view (in The Standard on Saturday), "The integrity of the process and the credibility of the results were so gravely impaired by...manifold irregularities and defectsthat it is irrelevant whether or not there was actual rigging at the national tally centre. The results are irretrievably polluted."
Hey, wait a minute, a number of commentators have argued: Doesn't that mean that President Kibaki is in office illegally? No, answered the Judge on TV Thursday night, "but I do think the question of the legitimacy of the elections will become a very serious problem in future if people do not decide that they are tired of playing games of democracy and decide that they are entitled to choose their leaders through the ballot."
Clearly, pending specific constitutional reforms, a disputed Presidential election favours any incumbent who believes he/she has won, and on that basis chooses to stay put. On what grounds would the opponent(s) legally, or even forcefully, remove him/her in order to take over? Failure to determine who won does not now, as it did not in January, add any iota of rationale or legitimacy for a Raila takeover. Thus, we can only look to the future for a solution, starting now -- if not yesterday.
One option for the future is to constitutionally mandate the Speaker or Chief Justice, or, in their "absence" (or due to specified incapacity), or their deputies, to assume the office of Acting President while disputed results are sorted out -- even through a fresh election.
Concurrent with this would have to be the requirement that no swearing-in of a new President, or an incumbent in his/her second term, shall take place earlier than 14 days from the date of the announcement of the Presidential election results. This will give time for petitions to be lodged and heard, and will discourage the mischief of hurried and even secretive swearings-in which Kenya has witnessed twice already.
The Kriegler Commission's verdict has, at the very least, put a stamp of judicial authority on an educated view which most thoughtful Kenyans had already silently formed months ago -- as early as January. There are millions of this silent majority, who nevertheless found themselves powerless to influence the post-election turn of events in the crucial first 40 to 60 days or so. Both the President (Kibaki) and the Prime Minister (Raila) have now accepted the verdict, and promised to implement its recommendations. We will just have to wait and see.
Clearly, the Electoral Commission would have to be overhauled, as recommended. However, if there was one item that the Kriegler Commission failed to pay adequate attention to, it was the even greated mess that occurred within the constituencies in relation to Parliamentary and Civic elections. These were so intertwined with the Presidential elections that it is something of a deliberate abdication of duty not to have included in the Commission's terms of reference items specific to these levels, and not to have had something sobstantial to say in the report.
We cannot clean up the presidential election process if we do not also, or first, clean up the process at these lower levels. In very many constituencies, the agents of the presidential candidates were also the agents of their parties' parliamentary and civic candidates -- or vice versa. I saw it in Kisumu Rural. Doing all the dirty work for the presidential candidate, or seeming to, provided a perverse sort of justification (and cover) for doing as much dirty work as was necessary to ensure the parliamentary or civic candidate's own victory.
The corruption is systemic, but has so far been treated as the secret weapon for electoral victory -- which the likes of Kriegler should not be made fully privy to, and certainly should not take away in one "pathetic" instance of inquiry. That's why we'll just have to wait and see.
Wednesday, August 06, 2008
A Grumpy Turn in US Presidential Elections
In the last two weeks or so, the US Presidential campaign season has taken a decidedly grumpy turn, thanks to Sen John McCain and his campaign team. Right now, energy is probably the big issue. Before that, McCain had tried, with considerable initial (two-week?) success, to turn Obama's celebrity status, following (and even during) his Grand Tour (some chose to call it World Tour), into an issue and a liability. In between, there was the matter of race.
Just as he recently trivialized Obama's tour, McCain is intrivializing the energy debate. And he is doing so to the point of, in effect, trivializing his own candidacy, and -- worst of all -- US Presidential elections (and the very Presidency to which the elections pertain). He seems, in this, rather like a Third World leader who has no respect for logic, reasonableness -- and civility. There's plenty of those around. HE should be different -- for Pete's sake!
As I see it, amid all the buzz, he has roughly a 50-50 chance of being the next US President. Alright, let's correct that to an eventual 47-53 chance, or thereabouts. Consequently, leaders around the world must have begun to wonder -- they would be wondering despondently were it not for the general thrust of those stats -- if that is the same style (if style it be) he would use in prosecuting US foreign policy, and in particular dealing with world leaders who may happen to have strongly held opinions different from his own. What do you do with a President who believes, indeed who has claimed publicly, that he knows how to win wars -- when no one can remember any military war that he has won, or even really led.
Will he seek to demean -- and even to intimidate -- them. Can he succeed? Will they let him? His first challenge might be Iraq itself, where the leaders are likely to call, in the name of national sovereignty, for a specific timetable for US troop withdrawal, to be completed (as they have already suggested to Obama) by the end of 2010. McCain has argued on TV that Iraqi leaders will NOT insist on such a deadline. Presumably they wont if it is McCain in the White House; and presumably if it is the kind of Iraqi leaders a President McCain will insist on having after January 20th.
McCain seems inclined, in a dangerously self-defeating way, to ignore Truth even when Truth stares him in the face -- or to accept it most grudgingly. As President, he would portray the US as mean-spirited and even small-minded -- except that the US is so consequential in world affairs (just as China is about to become) that the rest of us can ill afford to give up on her.
What would await such a one, in a world increasingly interdependent and increasingly self-assured? Certainly something more consequential than a Paris Hilton chide (and shine!); and perhaps a world less at ease with the US President, and with itself, than it already is.
As things stand now, the world no doubt takes comfort in the unlikelihood of such a one -- that is, let's be blunt, in the likelihood of a McCain defeat in November. But does the world matter to the US? Of course it does. And if not, it should; and if shouldn't, it will!
Just as he recently trivialized Obama's tour, McCain is intrivializing the energy debate. And he is doing so to the point of, in effect, trivializing his own candidacy, and -- worst of all -- US Presidential elections (and the very Presidency to which the elections pertain). He seems, in this, rather like a Third World leader who has no respect for logic, reasonableness -- and civility. There's plenty of those around. HE should be different -- for Pete's sake!
As I see it, amid all the buzz, he has roughly a 50-50 chance of being the next US President. Alright, let's correct that to an eventual 47-53 chance, or thereabouts. Consequently, leaders around the world must have begun to wonder -- they would be wondering despondently were it not for the general thrust of those stats -- if that is the same style (if style it be) he would use in prosecuting US foreign policy, and in particular dealing with world leaders who may happen to have strongly held opinions different from his own. What do you do with a President who believes, indeed who has claimed publicly, that he knows how to win wars -- when no one can remember any military war that he has won, or even really led.
Will he seek to demean -- and even to intimidate -- them. Can he succeed? Will they let him? His first challenge might be Iraq itself, where the leaders are likely to call, in the name of national sovereignty, for a specific timetable for US troop withdrawal, to be completed (as they have already suggested to Obama) by the end of 2010. McCain has argued on TV that Iraqi leaders will NOT insist on such a deadline. Presumably they wont if it is McCain in the White House; and presumably if it is the kind of Iraqi leaders a President McCain will insist on having after January 20th.
McCain seems inclined, in a dangerously self-defeating way, to ignore Truth even when Truth stares him in the face -- or to accept it most grudgingly. As President, he would portray the US as mean-spirited and even small-minded -- except that the US is so consequential in world affairs (just as China is about to become) that the rest of us can ill afford to give up on her.
What would await such a one, in a world increasingly interdependent and increasingly self-assured? Certainly something more consequential than a Paris Hilton chide (and shine!); and perhaps a world less at ease with the US President, and with itself, than it already is.
As things stand now, the world no doubt takes comfort in the unlikelihood of such a one -- that is, let's be blunt, in the likelihood of a McCain defeat in November. But does the world matter to the US? Of course it does. And if not, it should; and if shouldn't, it will!
Labels:
2010,
Celebrity,
China,
Election,
Energy,
Hilton (Paris),
Iraq,
McCain,
Obama,
President,
US,
Video
Monday, June 30, 2008
A Peace-Keeping Force For Zimbabwe? An Idea Whose Time Will Not Come
Does anyone seriously think that either AU or UN forces are going to be sent to restore or keep the peace in Zimbabwe any time soon, or in the foreseeable future? I certainly don't. And one may even ask: To keep what peace? Dictator Mugabe is back in power, thanks in no small measure to Tsvangirai's weak will.
In the aftermath of last week's election runoff (the results of which were this time announced with speed), Tsvangirai and his MDC will have even less negotiating clout than Raila and ODM had in Kenya earlier this year. It seems to me that the Zanu-PF lot have deep contempt for Tsvangirai's leadership. It seems that they knew something about his character that the rest of us are only beginning to come to terms with.
He clearly is no Raila, and no Ruto -- and yet we all know how unsatisfactory to many of ODM's supporters the Kenyan dealmaking itself was. Tsvangirai can expect far less than that -- and little more than crumbs from Mugabe's table, insistent though he is, partly from the safety of the Dutch embassy, that talks for some kind of Grand Coalition begin.
The best he can do for the people of Zimbabwe after the election fiasco, for which he is substantially responsible by default, is to step aside for the likes of Biti and Dr. Makoni -- who seem to have more courage.
Certainly, Mugabe must go (though, now, God only knows when). But so must Tsvangirai!
In the aftermath of last week's election runoff (the results of which were this time announced with speed), Tsvangirai and his MDC will have even less negotiating clout than Raila and ODM had in Kenya earlier this year. It seems to me that the Zanu-PF lot have deep contempt for Tsvangirai's leadership. It seems that they knew something about his character that the rest of us are only beginning to come to terms with.
He clearly is no Raila, and no Ruto -- and yet we all know how unsatisfactory to many of ODM's supporters the Kenyan dealmaking itself was. Tsvangirai can expect far less than that -- and little more than crumbs from Mugabe's table, insistent though he is, partly from the safety of the Dutch embassy, that talks for some kind of Grand Coalition begin.
The best he can do for the people of Zimbabwe after the election fiasco, for which he is substantially responsible by default, is to step aside for the likes of Biti and Dr. Makoni -- who seem to have more courage.
Certainly, Mugabe must go (though, now, God only knows when). But so must Tsvangirai!
Labels:
AU,
Biti,
Election,
Grand Coalition,
Kenya,
Makoni,
MDC,
Mugabe,
Negotiation,
ODM,
Peace-Keeping Force,
Production,
Raila,
Ruto,
Tsvangirai,
UN,
Zanu-PF,
Zimbabwe
Wednesday, June 04, 2008
Barack Obama: Presumptive Presidential Nominee of the Democratic Party
Yesterday, 3rd June 2008, was a truly historic day on many accounts in the United States -- and in Kenya. Dare I add Africa and the world at large? Circumspection, alone, holds me back -- but not my [My! My! My!] exclamation! Since we are hours ahead of America here in Kenya, that moment of glory, when Obama reached and then passed the pivotal total of 2118 pledged delegates and superdelegates, a moment which will be etched indelibly (dare I say for eons?) in the annals of at least two great countries, actually occurred very early this morning -- June 4th. A son of Kenya (for that he is) -- alright, a son of America and Kenya both -- had won a presidential marathon in that same America in which Kenyan runners are so used to winning marathons; and in which Americans are so used to seeing, and cheering, them! Cheers, America! And cheers Jatelo!
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
Labels:
2008,
America,
CNN,
Delegate,
Democrat,
East African,
Election,
Hillary,
Jackson,
Jatelo,
Kenya,
Leader,
Mugabe,
Obama,
President,
Republican,
Runners,
Somalia,
Tanzania,
Vice President
Tuesday, June 03, 2008
Kenya's Vernacular Radio Stations: To Ban Or Not To Ban?
Kenya’s ex-President, Daniel Arap Moi, wants the Government to ban the country’s “mushrooming” crop of vernacular radio stations, according to Saturday Nation of May 31, 2008. His reasons for this are that they are giving rise to “tribal chiefs”, and are fanning ethnic animosity by serving as vehicles for divisive politics. He justifies his call with the example of Rwanda in the early nineties, when broadcasts from such stations prompted anarchy and a genocidal orgy. The catalytic factor there, however, was not the existence of the stations per se but rather the assassination of the Rwandese President, Juvenal Habyarimana, when his plane was downed as it approached Kigali. The culprits remain at large still; as well camouflaged now, perhaps, as when they carried out their murderous act in 1994.
Still, the ex-President has a valid example. This is reinforced by Kenya’s own experience in January and February of 2008, particularly in the expansive Rift Valley. Protests against the announced presidential election results quickly took a violent turn. The violence then quickly became inter-ethnic because, in the eyes of ODM supporters in the Rift Valley and parts of Western Province, the “stolen presidential election” meant that there was not going to be a resolution of the land issue this time either. There was not going to be a resolution, just as there had not been during the 24-year presidency of Arap Moi, himself a son of the Rift Valley -- a 24-year reign during which Moi was, indeed, l’état.
The land issue – precisely who (or which ethnic community) really was entitled to the land that colonial farmers left behind at independence, or soon thereafter? -- had remained unresolved for much longer than the 24 years, in fact; that is, since independence on December 12, 1963. During the 2007 campaign, ODM supporters had been promised by their political leaders, in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, that this time around the issue would at last be resolved, upon the much-anticipated victory of ODM’s presidential and parliamentary candidates. This time, the justice that Moi had failed or neglected to dispense for 24 years would e dispensed, with finality.
Needless to say, then, the inter-ethnic violence in Kenya was triggered by a disputed presidential election result, and by adverse message it signaled vis-Ã -vis the land issue, not by the existence of the radio stations as such. There have been claims, to be sure, that certain radio stations in the Rift Valley and elsewhere did prompt their listeners to xenophobic pillage and murder – and revenge. In Rwanda, fortunately, such urgings were recorded by those who would subsequently prosecute the perpetrators. I am not aware that similar recordings exist in Kenya to serve as evidence for the prosecution – perhaps I have not paid sufficient attention to the adduced evidence. If such recordings exist, they should be used in court without fear or favour.
The said Saturday Nation issue reminds the reader that Moi made a similar but unsuccessful banning call in August 2000, when he was still president, arguing that radio stations should broadcast only in English and Kiswahili – Kenya’s official and national languages, respectively. But his own Minister for Information at the time, Mr. Johnstone Makau, would hear none of it, arguing that “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture.” It is intriguing that Moi allowed his minister to win that particular argument.
That “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture” is precisely the point, but we can say more: These radio stations are the only viable, nearly always-on and commute-free channels of contact with the world beyond the confines of the village for a wide cross-section of Kenya’s rural communities, where English and Kiswahili remain at the margin of daily life. They are an indispensable source of broadcasts rich in locally relevant content: news (local, regional and national), announcements (including funeral announcements, the occasional obituary and visits by dignitaries and government officials), entertainment (particularly music, comedy and story-telling), radio-evangelism, language-teaching (particularly of urban youth, since many of these broadcasts reach urban areas as well) and the growth of the vernaculars themselves, as broadcasters struggle to domesticate new concepts or standardize usages arising from day-to-day local living or from farther afield. Lately, mobile phones (some 13 million Kenyans have them now, out of a population of 35 million) have emphatically arrived to challenge the vernacular radio stations as channels of communication, but not in the domain of impersonal or mass communication.
Vernacular radio stations are tailor-made avenues for reaching members of local communities during emergencies and disaster situations, and should be recognized as such in emergencies, scenario-building and disaster plans. When easily accessible and trusted information sources, and easily understood messages are at a premium, vernacular radio stations are an asset, not a liability.
What is more, these stations already offer sustainable jobs to more Kenyans than, I believe, are employed abroad in our embassies and high commissions. They also extend marketing and advertising channels to parts of the Kenyan market which manufacturers and service providers, usually based in the cities, would find it harder to reach than they now do. Viewed thus, they are an essential component of wealth-creation in the country. Demand for their services grows demand for radios and batteries, thereby further sustaining local industries and jobs, to the extent that these are not undercut by subsidized or cheaper imports.
The foregoing suggests that the use of vernacular radio stations in ways that subvert the national good tends to coincide with the onset of transitional periods, or periods of high anxiety that cut across ethnicities and regions to engulf a whole country – such as during general elections. If that is the case, then the challenge to policy-makers is how to put in place measures that effectively monitor and punish, early enough, errant stations in their specificities – during those periods of great risk. The policy solution should not be unimaginative and too unself-critical. We should not impose blanket punishment against vernacular radio stations as a generic category, in the mistaken calculation that one offender implicates and damns all. During periods of normalcy, live and let live is clearly the norm across the country – and should be the catch-phrase.
In conclusion, it needs to be said that to ban vernacular radio stations would be to ban the future, or certainly to attempt to do so. In the sense that these radio stations are almost by definition, given their foregoing characterization, an integral part of the African renaissance -- which several thinkers have been calling for or endeavouring to realize, in our time. That is, moreover, if one defines the African renaissance as the simultaneous re-flowering and re-configuration – indeed, the elevation (or levitation?) to a distinctly higher plane – of the African way of life, and of the associated modes of expressing it.
Still, the ex-President has a valid example. This is reinforced by Kenya’s own experience in January and February of 2008, particularly in the expansive Rift Valley. Protests against the announced presidential election results quickly took a violent turn. The violence then quickly became inter-ethnic because, in the eyes of ODM supporters in the Rift Valley and parts of Western Province, the “stolen presidential election” meant that there was not going to be a resolution of the land issue this time either. There was not going to be a resolution, just as there had not been during the 24-year presidency of Arap Moi, himself a son of the Rift Valley -- a 24-year reign during which Moi was, indeed, l’état.
The land issue – precisely who (or which ethnic community) really was entitled to the land that colonial farmers left behind at independence, or soon thereafter? -- had remained unresolved for much longer than the 24 years, in fact; that is, since independence on December 12, 1963. During the 2007 campaign, ODM supporters had been promised by their political leaders, in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, that this time around the issue would at last be resolved, upon the much-anticipated victory of ODM’s presidential and parliamentary candidates. This time, the justice that Moi had failed or neglected to dispense for 24 years would e dispensed, with finality.
Needless to say, then, the inter-ethnic violence in Kenya was triggered by a disputed presidential election result, and by adverse message it signaled vis-Ã -vis the land issue, not by the existence of the radio stations as such. There have been claims, to be sure, that certain radio stations in the Rift Valley and elsewhere did prompt their listeners to xenophobic pillage and murder – and revenge. In Rwanda, fortunately, such urgings were recorded by those who would subsequently prosecute the perpetrators. I am not aware that similar recordings exist in Kenya to serve as evidence for the prosecution – perhaps I have not paid sufficient attention to the adduced evidence. If such recordings exist, they should be used in court without fear or favour.
The said Saturday Nation issue reminds the reader that Moi made a similar but unsuccessful banning call in August 2000, when he was still president, arguing that radio stations should broadcast only in English and Kiswahili – Kenya’s official and national languages, respectively. But his own Minister for Information at the time, Mr. Johnstone Makau, would hear none of it, arguing that “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture.” It is intriguing that Moi allowed his minister to win that particular argument.
That “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture” is precisely the point, but we can say more: These radio stations are the only viable, nearly always-on and commute-free channels of contact with the world beyond the confines of the village for a wide cross-section of Kenya’s rural communities, where English and Kiswahili remain at the margin of daily life. They are an indispensable source of broadcasts rich in locally relevant content: news (local, regional and national), announcements (including funeral announcements, the occasional obituary and visits by dignitaries and government officials), entertainment (particularly music, comedy and story-telling), radio-evangelism, language-teaching (particularly of urban youth, since many of these broadcasts reach urban areas as well) and the growth of the vernaculars themselves, as broadcasters struggle to domesticate new concepts or standardize usages arising from day-to-day local living or from farther afield. Lately, mobile phones (some 13 million Kenyans have them now, out of a population of 35 million) have emphatically arrived to challenge the vernacular radio stations as channels of communication, but not in the domain of impersonal or mass communication.
Vernacular radio stations are tailor-made avenues for reaching members of local communities during emergencies and disaster situations, and should be recognized as such in emergencies, scenario-building and disaster plans. When easily accessible and trusted information sources, and easily understood messages are at a premium, vernacular radio stations are an asset, not a liability.
What is more, these stations already offer sustainable jobs to more Kenyans than, I believe, are employed abroad in our embassies and high commissions. They also extend marketing and advertising channels to parts of the Kenyan market which manufacturers and service providers, usually based in the cities, would find it harder to reach than they now do. Viewed thus, they are an essential component of wealth-creation in the country. Demand for their services grows demand for radios and batteries, thereby further sustaining local industries and jobs, to the extent that these are not undercut by subsidized or cheaper imports.
The foregoing suggests that the use of vernacular radio stations in ways that subvert the national good tends to coincide with the onset of transitional periods, or periods of high anxiety that cut across ethnicities and regions to engulf a whole country – such as during general elections. If that is the case, then the challenge to policy-makers is how to put in place measures that effectively monitor and punish, early enough, errant stations in their specificities – during those periods of great risk. The policy solution should not be unimaginative and too unself-critical. We should not impose blanket punishment against vernacular radio stations as a generic category, in the mistaken calculation that one offender implicates and damns all. During periods of normalcy, live and let live is clearly the norm across the country – and should be the catch-phrase.
In conclusion, it needs to be said that to ban vernacular radio stations would be to ban the future, or certainly to attempt to do so. In the sense that these radio stations are almost by definition, given their foregoing characterization, an integral part of the African renaissance -- which several thinkers have been calling for or endeavouring to realize, in our time. That is, moreover, if one defines the African renaissance as the simultaneous re-flowering and re-configuration – indeed, the elevation (or levitation?) to a distinctly higher plane – of the African way of life, and of the associated modes of expressing it.
Labels:
1963,
1994,
2000,
2007,
2008,
Election,
Ethnic,
Genocide,
Habyarimana,
Kenya,
Moi,
ODM,
Radio,
Rift,
Rwanda,
Vernacular,
Violence,
Western,
Xenophobia
Wednesday, May 28, 2008
On the Importance of Being Namwamba
Just three months ago, as I have exclaimed elsewhere, who would have imagined that Kenya's talking heads would be as embroiled in the Grand Opposition debate as they are? I didn't. Still, I am certainly enjoying this enthralling phase of our political evolution. Enthralling, that is, if Namwamba and his team don't betray the cause.
It's all been very dialectical. First, the general election of December 2007. Then the disputed presidential election results. Then the chaos and the blood-letting. "Den cometh Koffi, den de peace -- which only a true peacemaker bringeth." Then Kibaki and Raila negotiate an unbelievably skewed distribution of cabinet slots. Then the fallout of disappointment at Raila's performance, left alone with Kibaki. In Kisumu, that disappointment exploded a few weeks ago into what must be the first true expression of proletarian (and semi-proletarian) disenchantment with the dominant power structure in those parts! The rest, as one might say, is this unfolding -- this current -- history that we are very much a part of.
On the night Kenya's parliament elected the new speaker, my impression of Namwamba was of someone who needed to grow up a just little more. Less than three months later, he has become the symbol, the robust new face, of Kenya's never-say-die politics. In a way, he is the new Orengo (and perhaps Raila, if he can secure a solid political base).
How did things change so fast that Raila, the doyen of opposition politics, is now seen as the apologist for an established political order of which he is only tenuously a part; the defender of a status quo which seeks to concentrate political power (and then economic power) in the hands of the very wenyewe whom the Second Liberation was supposed to "drive out of town"? Whichever way it happened, it is the very reason for the rise of Namwamba and his team -- motley as it is, and flawed as some of its members are.
"We are now in government," Raila reminds the team (in an earlier day they would have been the vinyangalika) -- who must be shown and kept in their place. If they want to form a Grand Opposition, then they must resign from parliament and seek fresh mandate from the people under the banner of parties of their choice. Certainly not ODM or PNU, without which they (with the exception of Jirongo and only a fistful more) would not be in parliament now.
Since ODM and PNU are in government, he reasons, and their members cannot be both in government and opposition. That, in his view, is an irreconcilable contradiction. The cabinet even convinced itself that it had the power to veto the Grand Coalition. Veto it as what? As an insolent thought? As a piece of legislation yet to be tabled? Then ODM called a meeting at Safari Park Hotel to thrash out this apparent confusion of memes. According to reports, however, only some 40 out of 96 ODM MPs (including Namwamba and "the little Ruto") attended. There was a stalemate.
I don't know what Namwamba's career path is going to be in the years and decades to come, but right now he has a very important role to play -- a role so dramatically abandoned by Raila at potentially the moment of his greatest triumph yet. Right now, Ababu (Don't-abandon-the-cause) Namwamba is the symbol of hope for a system of governance with proper checks and balances -- a system disdainful of private interest masquerading as public interest.
The idea of the Grand Opposition is borne of necessity. With almost everybody in government now, it is something of a deception, and politically fraudulent, to insist that Namwamba and his team seek to establish what could equally be achieved by the back bench -- achieved, that is, without in the process ruffling the feathers of the mighty. In the present circumstances, clearly, the back bench would be a divide-and-rule device, a smokescreen for grand mischief. As a solution, it is highly unsatisfactory vis-a-vis the right of the people to express and realize their will, unfettered, through their elected representatives. It is indeed a corrosion and even a negation of that right. And it displays a basic and hidden fear, on the part of those who would use the parliamentary system to ascend to power, of the principle of advice-and-consent -- in the true meaning of the term -- which ought to govern all democratic discourse.
So such negations must in turn, or preemptively, be negated. It is all very dialectical, as I said. But our history is peopled by individuals who rose on the back of the people's aspirations for a good life, only to succumb to the lure of personal aggrandizement, or the fear (in the face of unrelenting intimidation and assault) of unbearable personal loss. I don't know how Namwamba will deal with such pressure, which will surely come. But let him run the good race. As long as he can, let him carry the baton -- in this race whose length, in time and space, no one can tell. Someone will surely be there when it is time to pass the baton. Namwamba's historic significance is that he was there when it needed to be passed.
And his team should take solace in the fact that those opposed to the Grand Opposition will soon ask for its support to pass in parliament whatever version of the new constitution the Grand Coalition will craft for the people's approval. The time for a quid pro quo awaits in the near distance -- near, yes, but out of view for the near-sighted who want to eat their cake and have it.
It's all been very dialectical. First, the general election of December 2007. Then the disputed presidential election results. Then the chaos and the blood-letting. "Den cometh Koffi, den de peace -- which only a true peacemaker bringeth." Then Kibaki and Raila negotiate an unbelievably skewed distribution of cabinet slots. Then the fallout of disappointment at Raila's performance, left alone with Kibaki. In Kisumu, that disappointment exploded a few weeks ago into what must be the first true expression of proletarian (and semi-proletarian) disenchantment with the dominant power structure in those parts! The rest, as one might say, is this unfolding -- this current -- history that we are very much a part of.
On the night Kenya's parliament elected the new speaker, my impression of Namwamba was of someone who needed to grow up a just little more. Less than three months later, he has become the symbol, the robust new face, of Kenya's never-say-die politics. In a way, he is the new Orengo (and perhaps Raila, if he can secure a solid political base).
How did things change so fast that Raila, the doyen of opposition politics, is now seen as the apologist for an established political order of which he is only tenuously a part; the defender of a status quo which seeks to concentrate political power (and then economic power) in the hands of the very wenyewe whom the Second Liberation was supposed to "drive out of town"? Whichever way it happened, it is the very reason for the rise of Namwamba and his team -- motley as it is, and flawed as some of its members are.
"We are now in government," Raila reminds the team (in an earlier day they would have been the vinyangalika) -- who must be shown and kept in their place. If they want to form a Grand Opposition, then they must resign from parliament and seek fresh mandate from the people under the banner of parties of their choice. Certainly not ODM or PNU, without which they (with the exception of Jirongo and only a fistful more) would not be in parliament now.
Since ODM and PNU are in government, he reasons, and their members cannot be both in government and opposition. That, in his view, is an irreconcilable contradiction. The cabinet even convinced itself that it had the power to veto the Grand Coalition. Veto it as what? As an insolent thought? As a piece of legislation yet to be tabled? Then ODM called a meeting at Safari Park Hotel to thrash out this apparent confusion of memes. According to reports, however, only some 40 out of 96 ODM MPs (including Namwamba and "the little Ruto") attended. There was a stalemate.
I don't know what Namwamba's career path is going to be in the years and decades to come, but right now he has a very important role to play -- a role so dramatically abandoned by Raila at potentially the moment of his greatest triumph yet. Right now, Ababu (Don't-abandon-the-cause) Namwamba is the symbol of hope for a system of governance with proper checks and balances -- a system disdainful of private interest masquerading as public interest.
The idea of the Grand Opposition is borne of necessity. With almost everybody in government now, it is something of a deception, and politically fraudulent, to insist that Namwamba and his team seek to establish what could equally be achieved by the back bench -- achieved, that is, without in the process ruffling the feathers of the mighty. In the present circumstances, clearly, the back bench would be a divide-and-rule device, a smokescreen for grand mischief. As a solution, it is highly unsatisfactory vis-a-vis the right of the people to express and realize their will, unfettered, through their elected representatives. It is indeed a corrosion and even a negation of that right. And it displays a basic and hidden fear, on the part of those who would use the parliamentary system to ascend to power, of the principle of advice-and-consent -- in the true meaning of the term -- which ought to govern all democratic discourse.
So such negations must in turn, or preemptively, be negated. It is all very dialectical, as I said. But our history is peopled by individuals who rose on the back of the people's aspirations for a good life, only to succumb to the lure of personal aggrandizement, or the fear (in the face of unrelenting intimidation and assault) of unbearable personal loss. I don't know how Namwamba will deal with such pressure, which will surely come. But let him run the good race. As long as he can, let him carry the baton -- in this race whose length, in time and space, no one can tell. Someone will surely be there when it is time to pass the baton. Namwamba's historic significance is that he was there when it needed to be passed.
And his team should take solace in the fact that those opposed to the Grand Opposition will soon ask for its support to pass in parliament whatever version of the new constitution the Grand Coalition will craft for the people's approval. The time for a quid pro quo awaits in the near distance -- near, yes, but out of view for the near-sighted who want to eat their cake and have it.
Labels:
Ababu,
Amendment,
Constitution,
Election,
Grand Coalition,
Jirongo,
Kibaki,
Kisumu,
Namwamba,
ODM,
Opposition,
Orengo,
Parliament,
PNU,
Power,
Proletariat,
Raila,
Ruto
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Mauri Yambo: Political Biosheet, 2008
In 1968, I was the elected President of the Student Union at Strathmore College. I was also the elected Secretary of Foreign Affairs, National Union of Kenya Students (NUKS). Chibule wa Tsuma was the NUKS President. As Secretary of Foreign Affairs, I visited Holland and Finland. And I led an orderly student protest in Nairobi against the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia – you should have heard how many pronounced it! Uniformed policemen closely followed us throughout, ostensibly to maintain law and order. There were more policemen than demonstrators, and they appeared to onlookers and on TV to be part of the protest!
In 1969, I was the elected NUKS President. My Vice President was Peter Anyang’-Nyongo. As NUKS President, I visited the UK and Uganda as a guest of the national students’ unions. I also started my undergraduate studies at Dar Es Salaam – though I had preferred UoN. While in Uganda, I engaged in a well-received TV debate; and attended a dinner hosted for student leaders at State House by Milton Obote and the First Lady. Other guests included Kenneth Kaunda and Idi Amin Dada. Amin sat at a table behind me, and I heard him say quite audibly at one point that he did not believe in military coups!
The NUKS Patron was T.J. Mboya, whom I met once, and whose funeral I attended on Rusinga Island in July 1969. The evening of the funeral, many sailed back to Kisumu on a vessel apparently provided by the government for the occasion. I vividly remember that one of the passengers was Jaramogi Oginga Odinga. Even as we sailed, he held court with people more prominent than I. While I caught a free train ride back to Nairobi, there to flag off a reciprocal charter flight of NUKS members for a one-month visit to the UK, Jaramogi and his entourage disembarked at Kisumu and clearly travelled to their preferred destinations.
From July 1970 to March 1972, I was a member of the Editorial Committee of TAAMULI, a Political Science Bulletin published at the University of Dar-Es-Salaam. While at Dar, I met Agostino Neto of Angola. Walter Rodney was one of our lecturers. Paulo Freire visited. So did J.M. Kariuki. And I attended several “Sunday schools” which he – and Yoweri Museveni – attended, and where we discussed deep ideological issues from a radical perspective. With my TAAMULI colleagues, were invited guests one weekday morning at Ikulu in Dar-Es-Salaam. Our host was Mwalimu Julius Nyerere himself! There were no other guests on that occasion!
I joined the University of Nairobi as Lecturer in June 1980. I was the Editor of African Journal of Sociology from May 1981 to January 1989. And from January 1991 to January 1995, I was the Kenyan Co-ordinator of the University of Nairobi-Indiana University Exchange Programme, which I and my Indiana contact co-initiated from scratch. The Department of Sociology, of which I was then Chairman, sent five Kenyans for Ph.D studies at Indiana University, Bloomington, USA. All completed their studies. There were also Exchange Visitors from Indiana.
I myself had visited Indiana University from January 18th to 30th, 1992. While there, I also gave a Guest Lecture at Lees College in Jackson, Kentucky, on January 27th, 1992. From June 12th to 30th, 1993, I was Visiting Professor at the University of Bayreuth, in Germany; and presented a paper at a Conference on “The Power of Identity – The Identity of Power.”
From 1996 to 1999, I was a member of the National Task Force for the Review of Laws Relating to Women (in Kenya). And on December 18, 1998, I was Elected by an electorate of some 170 academic staff members for a two-year term as Dean, Faculty of Arts, at the UoN. I beat three other candidates, including an “incumbent.”
As Dean, also became a member of the Senate of the University of Nairobi. More importantly, I was central to the launch of the Module II programme in the Faculty of Arts. I was re-elected for the second and final term as Dean in 2001. By 2002, when my term ended, our Faculty’s Module II programme had grown to be the third largest by revenue at the university – from zero to over 100,000,000/- annually! I am proud that Module II under my stewardship doubled the average take-home pay of all the Faculty’s lecturers – and thereby significantly improved their quality of life, which for long had been in “ICU”.
I took the early-retirement option and left the UoN in 2002 to vie for the Kisumu Rural parliamentary seat in that year’s General Elections. I was runner-up. I returned to the university. I tried gain in 2007, and was again runner-up, having been rigged out by ODM headquarters at the nomination stage, and having had to secure nomination in an alternative party. I am back at the University of Nairobi. On another occasion, I will write to show how dirty the ODM nomination exercise was, and to describe the extensive rigging machinery that ODM operated in Kisumu Rural for the Parliamentary and Presidential elections of December 2007. For the time being, here is one media account of the rigging that took place in Kisumu Rural; and one broader observation on the 2007 elections as a whole.
I have undertaken research and consultancies on key issues in Kenya’s development. Here is a sample of titles highlighting my area of specialization (Industrial Sociology), and my broader interest in development: (a) “Poverty Eradication and Employment Creation in Kenya: Conceptual Challenges, Policy Articulation and Plan Targets”; (b) Gerrishon K. Ikiara, Mauri Yambo and Gerda Merckx, An Integrated Policy Approach to Youth employment in Kenya (Addis Ababa: ILO/JASPA); (c) Training Needs Assessment of the Kenyan Informal Sector (Nairobi: KIE, KREP, KIM and MTTAT); (d) "Demand-Supply Linkages for Scientific and Technical Skills in Kenya: Constraints, Opportunities and Discontinuities" in a book edited by Denise Weiner and titled The Role of Scientific and Engineering Societies in Development (Washington, D.C.: American Association for the Advancement of Science); (e) Kirimi Mwarania, Eddah Gachukia, Mauri Yambo and John Alwar (Eds.), Children and Women in Kenya: A Situation Analysis 1992 (Nairobi: GoK and UNICEF); (f) Technical Training and Work Experience in Kenya: A national Tracer Study of the Leavers of Harambee Institutes of Technology and Youth Polytechnics (Nairobi: DANIDA).
I will soon publish a book of poems titled Field of Aaru. The book’s title is taken from that of the main poem in the collection, which revisits the post-election violence which gripped Kenya following the general elections of 27th December 2007. My “narrative” ends with the departure from Kenya of that great peacemaker, Koffi Annan, in February 2008.
In 1969, I was the elected NUKS President. My Vice President was Peter Anyang’-Nyongo. As NUKS President, I visited the UK and Uganda as a guest of the national students’ unions. I also started my undergraduate studies at Dar Es Salaam – though I had preferred UoN. While in Uganda, I engaged in a well-received TV debate; and attended a dinner hosted for student leaders at State House by Milton Obote and the First Lady. Other guests included Kenneth Kaunda and Idi Amin Dada. Amin sat at a table behind me, and I heard him say quite audibly at one point that he did not believe in military coups!
The NUKS Patron was T.J. Mboya, whom I met once, and whose funeral I attended on Rusinga Island in July 1969. The evening of the funeral, many sailed back to Kisumu on a vessel apparently provided by the government for the occasion. I vividly remember that one of the passengers was Jaramogi Oginga Odinga. Even as we sailed, he held court with people more prominent than I. While I caught a free train ride back to Nairobi, there to flag off a reciprocal charter flight of NUKS members for a one-month visit to the UK, Jaramogi and his entourage disembarked at Kisumu and clearly travelled to their preferred destinations.
From July 1970 to March 1972, I was a member of the Editorial Committee of TAAMULI, a Political Science Bulletin published at the University of Dar-Es-Salaam. While at Dar, I met Agostino Neto of Angola. Walter Rodney was one of our lecturers. Paulo Freire visited. So did J.M. Kariuki. And I attended several “Sunday schools” which he – and Yoweri Museveni – attended, and where we discussed deep ideological issues from a radical perspective. With my TAAMULI colleagues, were invited guests one weekday morning at Ikulu in Dar-Es-Salaam. Our host was Mwalimu Julius Nyerere himself! There were no other guests on that occasion!
I joined the University of Nairobi as Lecturer in June 1980. I was the Editor of African Journal of Sociology from May 1981 to January 1989. And from January 1991 to January 1995, I was the Kenyan Co-ordinator of the University of Nairobi-Indiana University Exchange Programme, which I and my Indiana contact co-initiated from scratch. The Department of Sociology, of which I was then Chairman, sent five Kenyans for Ph.D studies at Indiana University, Bloomington, USA. All completed their studies. There were also Exchange Visitors from Indiana.
I myself had visited Indiana University from January 18th to 30th, 1992. While there, I also gave a Guest Lecture at Lees College in Jackson, Kentucky, on January 27th, 1992. From June 12th to 30th, 1993, I was Visiting Professor at the University of Bayreuth, in Germany; and presented a paper at a Conference on “The Power of Identity – The Identity of Power.”
From 1996 to 1999, I was a member of the National Task Force for the Review of Laws Relating to Women (in Kenya). And on December 18, 1998, I was Elected by an electorate of some 170 academic staff members for a two-year term as Dean, Faculty of Arts, at the UoN. I beat three other candidates, including an “incumbent.”
As Dean, also became a member of the Senate of the University of Nairobi. More importantly, I was central to the launch of the Module II programme in the Faculty of Arts. I was re-elected for the second and final term as Dean in 2001. By 2002, when my term ended, our Faculty’s Module II programme had grown to be the third largest by revenue at the university – from zero to over 100,000,000/- annually! I am proud that Module II under my stewardship doubled the average take-home pay of all the Faculty’s lecturers – and thereby significantly improved their quality of life, which for long had been in “ICU”.
I took the early-retirement option and left the UoN in 2002 to vie for the Kisumu Rural parliamentary seat in that year’s General Elections. I was runner-up. I returned to the university. I tried gain in 2007, and was again runner-up, having been rigged out by ODM headquarters at the nomination stage, and having had to secure nomination in an alternative party. I am back at the University of Nairobi. On another occasion, I will write to show how dirty the ODM nomination exercise was, and to describe the extensive rigging machinery that ODM operated in Kisumu Rural for the Parliamentary and Presidential elections of December 2007. For the time being, here is one media account of the rigging that took place in Kisumu Rural; and one broader observation on the 2007 elections as a whole.
I have undertaken research and consultancies on key issues in Kenya’s development. Here is a sample of titles highlighting my area of specialization (Industrial Sociology), and my broader interest in development: (a) “Poverty Eradication and Employment Creation in Kenya: Conceptual Challenges, Policy Articulation and Plan Targets”; (b) Gerrishon K. Ikiara, Mauri Yambo and Gerda Merckx, An Integrated Policy Approach to Youth employment in Kenya (Addis Ababa: ILO/JASPA); (c) Training Needs Assessment of the Kenyan Informal Sector (Nairobi: KIE, KREP, KIM and MTTAT); (d) "Demand-Supply Linkages for Scientific and Technical Skills in Kenya: Constraints, Opportunities and Discontinuities" in a book edited by Denise Weiner and titled The Role of Scientific and Engineering Societies in Development (Washington, D.C.: American Association for the Advancement of Science); (e) Kirimi Mwarania, Eddah Gachukia, Mauri Yambo and John Alwar (Eds.), Children and Women in Kenya: A Situation Analysis 1992 (Nairobi: GoK and UNICEF); (f) Technical Training and Work Experience in Kenya: A national Tracer Study of the Leavers of Harambee Institutes of Technology and Youth Polytechnics (Nairobi: DANIDA).
I will soon publish a book of poems titled Field of Aaru. The book’s title is taken from that of the main poem in the collection, which revisits the post-election violence which gripped Kenya following the general elections of 27th December 2007. My “narrative” ends with the departure from Kenya of that great peacemaker, Koffi Annan, in February 2008.
Labels:
Annan,
Biosheet,
Dean,
Editor,
Election,
Field of Aaru,
Idi Amin,
Indiana,
Kaunda,
Kisumu,
Mboya,
Module II,
Nairobi,
Neto,
Nyerere,
Obote,
Odinga,
Rusinga,
Strathmore,
Yambo
Friday, May 02, 2008
Zimbabwe: Presidential Election Run-Off
Zimbabweans might just be vindicated in their reported claim that they do their politics differently from Kenyans, and that the "Kenyan way" (the Kenyan inclination to resort to violence to resolve political/electoral disputes) is not only not for them but also something not to write home about. I guess we'll just have to wait a little longer and see.
The month-long delay in announcing the results of the general elections -- both Presidential and Parliamentary -- led world opinion to the conclusion that here was a country which was violating basic electoral principles and trashing democracy even more blatantly than Kenya. Mugabe was simply going to go on despite his apparent rejection by the governed -- a rejection which seemed confirmed by the Electoral Commission's refusal (under orders from above, it was feared) simply to report how the people had actually voted. He appeared hell-bent on confirming all the negatives that were being labelled on him.
But then the results of Parliamentary elections were announced after a suspenseful wait which, it appeared (while it lasted), would not end. And MDC turned out the winner with a majority. Soon, however, a highly ssuspicious decision was made to recount parliamentary votes in just about the number of constituencies which gave MDC its majority. Eventually, however, that majority was confirmed -- to the surprise of most observers (including yours truly) who had feared the worst of intentions on the part of the ruling party. But MDC supporters were in no mood to celebrate, their eyes unblinkingly cocked, as it were, on the main prize -- the Presidency.
And then, about a month after the March 29th elections, it was officially announced that MDC's Tsvangirai had actually, sobject to verification, received more votes than Zanu-PF's Mugabe (47% to 43%). This was, of course, taken by MDC as Mugabe's way of subverting the people's will, since MDC believed what its own figures told it -- namely, that Tsvangirai had scored an outright win with some 50.3% of the Presidential votes cast. The percentages officially announced meant, of course, that there would have to be a run-off between the two leading candidates, according to a constitution which stipulates that a winner on the first ballot must obtain at least 50% plus one of all the Presidential votes cast.
MDC has rejected the official figures, and threatens to boycott the run-off. This would be extremely unwise, and would be something of the very "Kenyan way" which Zimbabweans are disdainful of. You cannot be both a player and referee -- a contestant who arrogates to himself/herself the right to announce who the winner is (precisely/invariably the contestant). The threat to boycott is also based on another kind of fear, reflected in what is already happening. The fear is that Mugabe's goons will terrorize opposition strongholds to ensure a narrow victory in the second round.
But the MDC leadership has survived this terror before, and should not appear overly inclined to flee. Staying put is a posture it can indeed learn from Kenyans -- or re-learn from its own recent past. The Kenyans, of course, are at a different point in the trajetory of political succession -- the December 2007 elections having presented a real opportunity to elect Kenya's fourth President since independence in 1963. Zimbabwean's are still struggling to replace their founding President, by the ballot.
Legitimate as the fear of violence and intimidation may be, Tsvangirai and his MDC must agree to participate in the Presidential run-off election. They owe this to themselves, to Zimbabweans, to Africans (including Kenyans) and to Democracy in general. Let them use the vaunted Zimbabwean discipline to block all rigging avenues and mount a winning campaign -- just as they did in March. Let them call on all well-wishers to help them monitor the run-off. If they don't participate, they certainly cannot (will not) win. If they do participate, in alliance hopefully with Simba Makoni's side, victory appears certain. Perhaps this is Mugabe's honourable exit strategy. And even if it is not, let us see this election season to its logical conclusion
The month-long delay in announcing the results of the general elections -- both Presidential and Parliamentary -- led world opinion to the conclusion that here was a country which was violating basic electoral principles and trashing democracy even more blatantly than Kenya. Mugabe was simply going to go on despite his apparent rejection by the governed -- a rejection which seemed confirmed by the Electoral Commission's refusal (under orders from above, it was feared) simply to report how the people had actually voted. He appeared hell-bent on confirming all the negatives that were being labelled on him.
But then the results of Parliamentary elections were announced after a suspenseful wait which, it appeared (while it lasted), would not end. And MDC turned out the winner with a majority. Soon, however, a highly ssuspicious decision was made to recount parliamentary votes in just about the number of constituencies which gave MDC its majority. Eventually, however, that majority was confirmed -- to the surprise of most observers (including yours truly) who had feared the worst of intentions on the part of the ruling party. But MDC supporters were in no mood to celebrate, their eyes unblinkingly cocked, as it were, on the main prize -- the Presidency.
And then, about a month after the March 29th elections, it was officially announced that MDC's Tsvangirai had actually, sobject to verification, received more votes than Zanu-PF's Mugabe (47% to 43%). This was, of course, taken by MDC as Mugabe's way of subverting the people's will, since MDC believed what its own figures told it -- namely, that Tsvangirai had scored an outright win with some 50.3% of the Presidential votes cast. The percentages officially announced meant, of course, that there would have to be a run-off between the two leading candidates, according to a constitution which stipulates that a winner on the first ballot must obtain at least 50% plus one of all the Presidential votes cast.
MDC has rejected the official figures, and threatens to boycott the run-off. This would be extremely unwise, and would be something of the very "Kenyan way" which Zimbabweans are disdainful of. You cannot be both a player and referee -- a contestant who arrogates to himself/herself the right to announce who the winner is (precisely/invariably the contestant). The threat to boycott is also based on another kind of fear, reflected in what is already happening. The fear is that Mugabe's goons will terrorize opposition strongholds to ensure a narrow victory in the second round.
But the MDC leadership has survived this terror before, and should not appear overly inclined to flee. Staying put is a posture it can indeed learn from Kenyans -- or re-learn from its own recent past. The Kenyans, of course, are at a different point in the trajetory of political succession -- the December 2007 elections having presented a real opportunity to elect Kenya's fourth President since independence in 1963. Zimbabwean's are still struggling to replace their founding President, by the ballot.
Legitimate as the fear of violence and intimidation may be, Tsvangirai and his MDC must agree to participate in the Presidential run-off election. They owe this to themselves, to Zimbabweans, to Africans (including Kenyans) and to Democracy in general. Let them use the vaunted Zimbabwean discipline to block all rigging avenues and mount a winning campaign -- just as they did in March. Let them call on all well-wishers to help them monitor the run-off. If they don't participate, they certainly cannot (will not) win. If they do participate, in alliance hopefully with Simba Makoni's side, victory appears certain. Perhaps this is Mugabe's honourable exit strategy. And even if it is not, let us see this election season to its logical conclusion
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Smart Move -- Raila and Kalonzo!
By Prof. Mauri Yambo
It was reassuring to hear the two ODM-K leading lights, Raila and Kalonzo, come out so clearly -- and quite passionately -- early in the week in support of the delegate option for nominating the ODM-K presidential candidate. Raila's arguments were quite detailed and persuasive, and quite impressive for having been made at a public rally and therefore essentially off-the-cuff. Kalonzo reminded us that this has been his view all along, and there is reason to believe him.
Uhuru was quite brave to have come out a few days earlier -- and indeed he received some flack for it. Part of his reason for preferring this method, he indicated obliquely in a TV soundbite -- and historians will have to check out his claim -- was that the consensus option had indeed been exercised, after a crude fashion, in 2002! His point was that prospective successors to President Moi within the then ruling party has agreed to have Moi anoint one of them as the flag-bearer in the 2002 , and to support Moi's choice. But when Moi settled for Uhuru, the others jumped ship -- with disastrous consequences for the "project".
All of this can only help nurture internal democracy within Kenya's political parties, which have so far proven quite archaic in their governance -- and blindly, self-destructively Machiavellian.
It was reassuring to hear the two ODM-K leading lights, Raila and Kalonzo, come out so clearly -- and quite passionately -- early in the week in support of the delegate option for nominating the ODM-K presidential candidate. Raila's arguments were quite detailed and persuasive, and quite impressive for having been made at a public rally and therefore essentially off-the-cuff. Kalonzo reminded us that this has been his view all along, and there is reason to believe him.
Uhuru was quite brave to have come out a few days earlier -- and indeed he received some flack for it. Part of his reason for preferring this method, he indicated obliquely in a TV soundbite -- and historians will have to check out his claim -- was that the consensus option had indeed been exercised, after a crude fashion, in 2002! His point was that prospective successors to President Moi within the then ruling party has agreed to have Moi anoint one of them as the flag-bearer in the 2002 , and to support Moi's choice. But when Moi settled for Uhuru, the others jumped ship -- with disastrous consequences for the "project".
All of this can only help nurture internal democracy within Kenya's political parties, which have so far proven quite archaic in their governance -- and blindly, self-destructively Machiavellian.
Sunday, January 28, 2007
Democracy Eventually Catches Up With The Leaders
By Prof. Mauri Yambo
Kenya’s political climate in the 21st century is quite different from what it was when Jomo Kenyatta was president, and during most of Moi’s 24-year presidency. The year 2002 was a dramatic watershed. Kenya’s experience suggests that in countries steeped in years of one-man rule, the “democratic bug” – some would now call it the democratic meme (a sort of “mind virus”) – is first genuinely, and even innocently, caught by the people (the voters). Eventually, it must catch up with the leaders too – both those in power and in opposition.
Through many sacrifices, shifting coalitions and unforgettable cliff-hangers, Kenya’s democratic space has in the last decade and a half evolved to be, now, much wider, deeper and more vibrant. In the post-2002 period, it continues to evolve. But not fast enough. In particular, the democratic space within political parties remains scandalously under-evolved – and the membership under-involved!
Party governance, even among opposition parties, remains steeped in the big-man mindset of yesteryear, no matter how many position papers are developed in the name of democracy. However, 2007 may be a landmark year, certainly for opposition parties, and particularly for ODM-K. The party must somehow choose a presidential candidate in the next six months, and rally behind that choice, without tearing itself apart. Obviously, the party of the incumbent (President Kibaki), whichever party it is, will not be under the same kind of pressure in 2007. Its choice is already in State House, and will run again – unopposed by any of the GNU parties.
So what is ODM-K going to do? How, exactly, is it going to choose its presidential, parliamentary and civic candidates? In the name of democracy, the answer should be obvious – and yet there is much beating about the bush. There is much lingering suspicion among the party luminaries, though they will publicly deny it. And MPs continue to hog party organs and functions as though no one else has a voice, a mind or an iota of legitimacy.
Consistent with basic democratic principles, party rank-and-file should be involved in choosing party candidates at various levels, through direct voting during primaries in respective constituencies, and/or a graduated delegate system. Such voting may be by secret ballot or some version of queuing (mlologo). The former is preferably, though the logistics and cost of doing so may be prohibitive, even at the constituency level, for a cash-strapped party.
If the 2002 experience is anything to go by, the direct-voting route favours incumbents, or aspirants who have the ears of those at headquarters – and who offer to foot the bill. Queuing is a public spectacle whose results, in an organized environment, are there for all to see. However, it disenfranchises those who arrive after the lining- up phase is closed and the counting begins, or who must leave before it is completed. And so it has too many flaws itself to be adopted during general elections proper.
Though there has been much debate and agonizing about how ODM-K should choose its Presidential candidate, some agreement seems at last to have been arrived at. What is unsettling many observers (members of the silent majority) is that, having agreed on the version of the delegate system to adopt for nominating its presidential candidate, and how the actual voting will broadly be conducted, some ODM-K luminaries seem to be developing cold feet even before the ink dries on the paper on which their agreement was presumably penned. We are back to the notion that, somehow, a consensus among the aspirants is the best way to choose the presidential candidate. Great danger lurks in this apparent change of mind.
In the first place, a consensus cannot by definition be imposed – particularly among forces of roughly equal power or influence. Consensus implies unanimity among those involved in trying to reach it. Consequently, no consensus can be reached which does not in fact anoint the aspirant who believes, rightly or wrongly, that the delegate system would deliver him or her the nomination which the consensus might, by subterfuge, deny him or her. To threaten such a candidate with ostracism and even expulsion from the party is to threaten the very existence of the very party whose presidential candidate every luminary wants to be. As I see it, and I want to be forthright here, consensus, as it is conceived of now, is just another word for Tosha! Because of 2002, and of what has transpired in Kenyan politics since, Tosha has become a dirty five-letter word. The sooner it is abandoned the better it with be for the social capital of those associated with it.
Secondly, attempts to broker a consensus among ODM-K luminaries and those close to them – away from the ordinary members’ prying eyes – are a very loud and clear message that the leaders (at least some of them) do not trust the people, who trust them. They do not trust the people’s judgement on this matter. But why on this matter, and why now, if the people’s judgement in 2002 and 2005 continues to be the subject of so much chest-thumping? Moreover, these attempts bring to mind a discredited practice exemplified by Mayor Daley’s Chicago of the 1950s and ’60s. Senator Obama, and ODM-K’s donors such as NDI and IRI, would caution us against this practice, if we chose to consult them or heed their advice.
I believe that the delegate system will choose for ODM-K not only the right candidate but more importantly the only presidential candidate it can legitimately and democratically choose – indeed, the winning candidate. The challenge for each aspirant is to network within genuine democratic parameters such as these to put together a winning combination. Power comes from the people. We should consistently preach this and show that we mean it by practicing it. And as Mwalimu Nyerere used to say, though he did not treat his own opponents kindly (but that was another era, which must not return), “It can be done!”
To suggest that voters registered in certain regions should by definition be disqualified from the ODM-K presidential nomination process – or that their votes should be less than equal (that is, a fraction) those of their counterparts in other regions – is to tell them to take or keep their support elsewhere. You cannot win by being associated with such a view, or by forgoing such large chunks of votes! It simply does not make sense – even in the name of enlightened self-interest.
Come to think of it, that is the same kind of “Siasa mbaya, maisha mbaya” attitude, in top government circles, which has denied an equitable share of development resources and state appointments to “opposition areas” from 1963 to 2007! The widespread rejection of this attitude across the country provides the basic explanation for the equally widespread support, reported in recent months by Steadman, which ODM-K continues to enjoy.
It should be expected that the eventual ODM-K candidate will campaign in all regions of the country during the actual presidential elections, and will not surrender any votes anywhere to anyone. This, one suspects, will also be President Kibaki’s strategy for victory.
The trouble with trying too hard to tilt the democratic process in one’s favour, to ensure one’s own victory, is that one’s opponents or co-contestants – if they are not to be presumed dumb – can see through this too clearly for one’s eventual comfort. This is particularly so in arenas where the goodwill of at least some of one’s peers is a prerequisite for the looked-for victory. They may for a time be silent or muted, or even confused, about what they see, but such seeing and such machinations are a lethal combination. The combination has easily predictable consequences. For our political leaders, this is the fundamental lesson of Kenya’s general elections of 2002, and the referendum of 2005. The end does not, should not, always justify the means.
What is my prognosis? Attempts to broker a consensus will fail. For the sake of Democracy, they should not and must not succeed! Democracy will catch up with ODM-K luminaries and MPs in 2007. For goodness’ sake, the D in the party’s name stands for Democratic – without quote unquote! ODM-K will choose its presidential candidate through the delegate system, which will perhaps have been amended more than once between now and June. The losing presidential aspirants will rally fairly forcefully behind the winner – perhaps on the uncertain promise of the Prime Minister’s job.
Abandoning the party after a well-organized leadership selection exercise via the delegate system would spell doom to the political future, nationally, of those who do so. And, it seems mathematically clear to me at this point, the chosen candidate will have a better that 50-50 chance of winning the actual presidential elections in 2007. However, should ODM-K formally break up before its candidate is officially nominated, into pro-consensus and anti-consensus camps, then – from that moment of split and long before the elections are actually held – the country will know the winner of the 2007 presidential elections, and that the winner will be the incumbent, President Mwai Kibaki.
Can the country live with that? Sure. We have done so since 2003. Can the losing luminaries do so? Yes, at a terrible price. The inevitable consequence of a second Kibaki victory would be a passionate scramble for new leadership in various areas across the country, as Democracy finally catches up with the remaining diehards – reluctant democrats. Democracy should be a quality of mind inscribed in our routine practice, not merely something we occasionally preach.
Only one eventuality can radically change much of the above scenario, while still delivering victory to President Kibaki in 2007. It is the push particularly by LDP, unlikely to succeed this year, to make ODM-K strictly a party of regional parties allowing only for corporate membership and run on the basis of a coalition of “like-minded” parties. While it has become too late to choose the ODM-K flag-bearer this way this year, this scenario is entirely possible in 2012.
Nairobi: Sunday, January 28, 2007.
Kenya’s political climate in the 21st century is quite different from what it was when Jomo Kenyatta was president, and during most of Moi’s 24-year presidency. The year 2002 was a dramatic watershed. Kenya’s experience suggests that in countries steeped in years of one-man rule, the “democratic bug” – some would now call it the democratic meme (a sort of “mind virus”) – is first genuinely, and even innocently, caught by the people (the voters). Eventually, it must catch up with the leaders too – both those in power and in opposition.
Through many sacrifices, shifting coalitions and unforgettable cliff-hangers, Kenya’s democratic space has in the last decade and a half evolved to be, now, much wider, deeper and more vibrant. In the post-2002 period, it continues to evolve. But not fast enough. In particular, the democratic space within political parties remains scandalously under-evolved – and the membership under-involved!
Party governance, even among opposition parties, remains steeped in the big-man mindset of yesteryear, no matter how many position papers are developed in the name of democracy. However, 2007 may be a landmark year, certainly for opposition parties, and particularly for ODM-K. The party must somehow choose a presidential candidate in the next six months, and rally behind that choice, without tearing itself apart. Obviously, the party of the incumbent (President Kibaki), whichever party it is, will not be under the same kind of pressure in 2007. Its choice is already in State House, and will run again – unopposed by any of the GNU parties.
So what is ODM-K going to do? How, exactly, is it going to choose its presidential, parliamentary and civic candidates? In the name of democracy, the answer should be obvious – and yet there is much beating about the bush. There is much lingering suspicion among the party luminaries, though they will publicly deny it. And MPs continue to hog party organs and functions as though no one else has a voice, a mind or an iota of legitimacy.
Consistent with basic democratic principles, party rank-and-file should be involved in choosing party candidates at various levels, through direct voting during primaries in respective constituencies, and/or a graduated delegate system. Such voting may be by secret ballot or some version of queuing (mlologo). The former is preferably, though the logistics and cost of doing so may be prohibitive, even at the constituency level, for a cash-strapped party.
If the 2002 experience is anything to go by, the direct-voting route favours incumbents, or aspirants who have the ears of those at headquarters – and who offer to foot the bill. Queuing is a public spectacle whose results, in an organized environment, are there for all to see. However, it disenfranchises those who arrive after the lining- up phase is closed and the counting begins, or who must leave before it is completed. And so it has too many flaws itself to be adopted during general elections proper.
Though there has been much debate and agonizing about how ODM-K should choose its Presidential candidate, some agreement seems at last to have been arrived at. What is unsettling many observers (members of the silent majority) is that, having agreed on the version of the delegate system to adopt for nominating its presidential candidate, and how the actual voting will broadly be conducted, some ODM-K luminaries seem to be developing cold feet even before the ink dries on the paper on which their agreement was presumably penned. We are back to the notion that, somehow, a consensus among the aspirants is the best way to choose the presidential candidate. Great danger lurks in this apparent change of mind.
In the first place, a consensus cannot by definition be imposed – particularly among forces of roughly equal power or influence. Consensus implies unanimity among those involved in trying to reach it. Consequently, no consensus can be reached which does not in fact anoint the aspirant who believes, rightly or wrongly, that the delegate system would deliver him or her the nomination which the consensus might, by subterfuge, deny him or her. To threaten such a candidate with ostracism and even expulsion from the party is to threaten the very existence of the very party whose presidential candidate every luminary wants to be. As I see it, and I want to be forthright here, consensus, as it is conceived of now, is just another word for Tosha! Because of 2002, and of what has transpired in Kenyan politics since, Tosha has become a dirty five-letter word. The sooner it is abandoned the better it with be for the social capital of those associated with it.
Secondly, attempts to broker a consensus among ODM-K luminaries and those close to them – away from the ordinary members’ prying eyes – are a very loud and clear message that the leaders (at least some of them) do not trust the people, who trust them. They do not trust the people’s judgement on this matter. But why on this matter, and why now, if the people’s judgement in 2002 and 2005 continues to be the subject of so much chest-thumping? Moreover, these attempts bring to mind a discredited practice exemplified by Mayor Daley’s Chicago of the 1950s and ’60s. Senator Obama, and ODM-K’s donors such as NDI and IRI, would caution us against this practice, if we chose to consult them or heed their advice.
I believe that the delegate system will choose for ODM-K not only the right candidate but more importantly the only presidential candidate it can legitimately and democratically choose – indeed, the winning candidate. The challenge for each aspirant is to network within genuine democratic parameters such as these to put together a winning combination. Power comes from the people. We should consistently preach this and show that we mean it by practicing it. And as Mwalimu Nyerere used to say, though he did not treat his own opponents kindly (but that was another era, which must not return), “It can be done!”
To suggest that voters registered in certain regions should by definition be disqualified from the ODM-K presidential nomination process – or that their votes should be less than equal (that is, a fraction) those of their counterparts in other regions – is to tell them to take or keep their support elsewhere. You cannot win by being associated with such a view, or by forgoing such large chunks of votes! It simply does not make sense – even in the name of enlightened self-interest.
Come to think of it, that is the same kind of “Siasa mbaya, maisha mbaya” attitude, in top government circles, which has denied an equitable share of development resources and state appointments to “opposition areas” from 1963 to 2007! The widespread rejection of this attitude across the country provides the basic explanation for the equally widespread support, reported in recent months by Steadman, which ODM-K continues to enjoy.
It should be expected that the eventual ODM-K candidate will campaign in all regions of the country during the actual presidential elections, and will not surrender any votes anywhere to anyone. This, one suspects, will also be President Kibaki’s strategy for victory.
The trouble with trying too hard to tilt the democratic process in one’s favour, to ensure one’s own victory, is that one’s opponents or co-contestants – if they are not to be presumed dumb – can see through this too clearly for one’s eventual comfort. This is particularly so in arenas where the goodwill of at least some of one’s peers is a prerequisite for the looked-for victory. They may for a time be silent or muted, or even confused, about what they see, but such seeing and such machinations are a lethal combination. The combination has easily predictable consequences. For our political leaders, this is the fundamental lesson of Kenya’s general elections of 2002, and the referendum of 2005. The end does not, should not, always justify the means.
What is my prognosis? Attempts to broker a consensus will fail. For the sake of Democracy, they should not and must not succeed! Democracy will catch up with ODM-K luminaries and MPs in 2007. For goodness’ sake, the D in the party’s name stands for Democratic – without quote unquote! ODM-K will choose its presidential candidate through the delegate system, which will perhaps have been amended more than once between now and June. The losing presidential aspirants will rally fairly forcefully behind the winner – perhaps on the uncertain promise of the Prime Minister’s job.
Abandoning the party after a well-organized leadership selection exercise via the delegate system would spell doom to the political future, nationally, of those who do so. And, it seems mathematically clear to me at this point, the chosen candidate will have a better that 50-50 chance of winning the actual presidential elections in 2007. However, should ODM-K formally break up before its candidate is officially nominated, into pro-consensus and anti-consensus camps, then – from that moment of split and long before the elections are actually held – the country will know the winner of the 2007 presidential elections, and that the winner will be the incumbent, President Mwai Kibaki.
Can the country live with that? Sure. We have done so since 2003. Can the losing luminaries do so? Yes, at a terrible price. The inevitable consequence of a second Kibaki victory would be a passionate scramble for new leadership in various areas across the country, as Democracy finally catches up with the remaining diehards – reluctant democrats. Democracy should be a quality of mind inscribed in our routine practice, not merely something we occasionally preach.
Only one eventuality can radically change much of the above scenario, while still delivering victory to President Kibaki in 2007. It is the push particularly by LDP, unlikely to succeed this year, to make ODM-K strictly a party of regional parties allowing only for corporate membership and run on the basis of a coalition of “like-minded” parties. While it has become too late to choose the ODM-K flag-bearer this way this year, this scenario is entirely possible in 2012.
Nairobi: Sunday, January 28, 2007.
Saturday, January 13, 2007
IPOs and Kenyan Politicians
Kenyan politicians must root for the small investor. It is in their best interest. There are now over 500,000 such investors. By election time later in 2007, their number will probably have reached 750,000, particularly with the expected Safaricom IPO. Most of these are young Kenyans, and there is a growing number of women -- who refuse to be left behind. Their recent involvement in the stock market will be one potent reason for them to vote one way or another at the next general elections. They will at last have something very tangible to protect, something directly and personally beneficial to them.That’s a lot of votes to lose, for those who rub them the wrong way!
The small investor is a very determined and perceptive lot. Determined because the poverty line gives them nightmares, and they are driven to stay above it – well above. Perceptive in that they have discovered two things. First, that a well managed stock market offers them the most promising opportunity for asset-building, on a scale which no politician has offered them since the heyday (some decades ago now) of land-buying groups; and for staying above the poverty line despite widespread neglect by politicians. And they know that group land-buying, part of the old ethnicity, was essentially a kitchen cabinet project which politicians in many parts of the country did not have the motivation to emulate or counter -- and no discernible inclination to match for the benefit of their own constituents, as opposed to their own personal gain!
Second, that there is real “magic of compounding” in the stock market which politicians, themselves a perceptive lot, have all along known about and quietly enjoyed but which, left to their own devices, would rather not share with wananchi. We say: Keep this gate open! Share the planet!
It is one thing to fault the 2006 IPOs on the grounds that, starting with the “book building”scam attempted during the KenGen IPO, efforts were made to favour institutional investors (and some efforts succeeded, particularly in subsequent IPOs); or to query the mystery and illegal 5% holding by a third party in Safaricom; or to take measures to ensure that CMA and NSE do not “even think about it” in 2007 and beyond. But it is quite another and dangerous thing to make blanket statements of intention to repossess for the state, presumably by executive order or through a parliamentary vote, the shares which investors bought in 2006. Repossess and then do what? This would clearly be a case of repossess and dispossess. Dispossess for whose benefit?
In an election year, in which the margin of victory is unlikely to be larger than that witnessed during the 2005 referendum, it is highly risky and probably political suicide to make 750,000 individual investors highly nervous about the future of their hard-won, and now compounded, assets; or about the future of IPOs in general. Individual (or “small-holder”) shareholding is beginning to acquire the characteristics and passions of a new ethnicity, politician beware. It is a passion, indeed, that is sweeping the whole world – including the ex-communist states of China and Russia.
The small investor is a very determined and perceptive lot. Determined because the poverty line gives them nightmares, and they are driven to stay above it – well above. Perceptive in that they have discovered two things. First, that a well managed stock market offers them the most promising opportunity for asset-building, on a scale which no politician has offered them since the heyday (some decades ago now) of land-buying groups; and for staying above the poverty line despite widespread neglect by politicians. And they know that group land-buying, part of the old ethnicity, was essentially a kitchen cabinet project which politicians in many parts of the country did not have the motivation to emulate or counter -- and no discernible inclination to match for the benefit of their own constituents, as opposed to their own personal gain!
Second, that there is real “magic of compounding” in the stock market which politicians, themselves a perceptive lot, have all along known about and quietly enjoyed but which, left to their own devices, would rather not share with wananchi. We say: Keep this gate open! Share the planet!
It is one thing to fault the 2006 IPOs on the grounds that, starting with the “book building”scam attempted during the KenGen IPO, efforts were made to favour institutional investors (and some efforts succeeded, particularly in subsequent IPOs); or to query the mystery and illegal 5% holding by a third party in Safaricom; or to take measures to ensure that CMA and NSE do not “even think about it” in 2007 and beyond. But it is quite another and dangerous thing to make blanket statements of intention to repossess for the state, presumably by executive order or through a parliamentary vote, the shares which investors bought in 2006. Repossess and then do what? This would clearly be a case of repossess and dispossess. Dispossess for whose benefit?
In an election year, in which the margin of victory is unlikely to be larger than that witnessed during the 2005 referendum, it is highly risky and probably political suicide to make 750,000 individual investors highly nervous about the future of their hard-won, and now compounded, assets; or about the future of IPOs in general. Individual (or “small-holder”) shareholding is beginning to acquire the characteristics and passions of a new ethnicity, politician beware. It is a passion, indeed, that is sweeping the whole world – including the ex-communist states of China and Russia.
Labels:
2005,
2006,
2007,
Book Building,
China,
CMA,
Election,
Ethnicity,
Investors,
IPO,
KenGen,
Land-Buying,
Magic of Compounding,
NSE,
Politicians,
Referendum,
Russia,
Safaricom
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)