I was elected Dean of the Faculty of Arts, University of Nairobi, in December 1998. As Dean, I oversaw the launch of the Module II programme in the Faculty of Arts in 1999. Work toward the launch had in fact begun in the latter half of 1998, and I was involved in that too.
Through the development of a wide range of innovative, market-driven curricula under the Module II (Parallel) Programme, I steered the transformation of the Faculty of Arts into the country's cutting-edge player in university education. That programme opened up university-level learning opportunities for hundreds of Kenyans who had previously been shut out, and enabled many for the first time to further their education while keeping their jobs -- in other words, while at the same time continuing to earn a living.
During my watch, the Faculty's Module II revenue grew as follows, having been nil in the period running from July 1st, 1997 to June 30, 1998:
1. 1998/1999: Kshs. 12 million
2. 1999-2000: Kshs. 52 million
3. 2000/2001: Kshs 80 million
4. 2001/2002: Kshs. 105 million.
By the time I left office in late 2002, the Faculty had grossed some Kshs. 280 million in about four years of actual Module II operation. Only the Faculties of Commerce and Medicine had grossed more. Not many of Kenya's SME's could beat that.
The Faculty had in the process more than doubled the gross monthly income of about 100 lecturers involved in Module II teaching within the Faculty. It did so while saving the country millions of shillings in foreign exchange, which might have been spent by the same students if they had opted to go to foreign universities.
In so doubling lecturers’ income, Module II had great material effect on their personal lives. It rescued their household economies (in particular, a good number of cars) from ICU, as we used to say. I got some credit for that as Dean, but in reality we all made it happen with our collective effort; indeed, with our own sweat!
Those were heady days, as I recall -- certainly for me. Over time, however, one gets used to the gains (any gains, and any fruits of effort, in fact). Change -- changed circumstances, that is -- however much fought for, and however much for the better, becomes, inexorably, routine. And while routine embodies remembrance, it also tends to blur the very reasons which brought it about in the first place.
For a while there, Faculties first pushed for and then enjoyed a real devolution with respect to Module II resources -- vis-a-vis Central Administration. It seemed that we had created a way of doing things which nobody could seriously reverse. In effect, we had "CDF" before Kenya's Parliament invented CDF. Gradually, however, that window of devolved power closed (after my term), and Faculties are all the poorer for it.
Showing posts with label 2002. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2002. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 11, 2008
Faculty of Arts: A Note on Module II Revenue, 1999-2002
Labels:
1998,
1999,
2002,
Arts,
Commerce,
Curriculum,
Dean,
Devolution,
Faculty,
Forex,
Households,
Income,
Lecturers,
Market-driven,
Medicine,
Module II,
Parallel,
Revenue,
SME,
University education
Sunday, June 08, 2008
Message From The Dean: A History of the Faculty of Arts, University of Nairobi, 1956-2002
[In early 2002 the Faculty of Arts produced its 2002/2003 Prospectus. The prospectus had this slogan, which I had coined: “Skills to Navigate the Global Village.” It was the first and only prospectus during my two-term Deanship, and the second ever. The Faculty’s very first prospectus had been produced in 1980, during Dr. Micere Mugo’s tenure as Dean, and under the editorial guidance of the late Dr. George Katama Mkangi, who was a Sociologist. Patchy as that record may be – and the Faculty has produced no other prospectus since 2002 -- I wanted to reproduce, as this blog post and for the record, my “Message from the Dean” which appeared in that 2002/2003 issue (see pp. 3-5). I wanted, too, to strike a blow against shelf-dust – that great afflicter of publications and sly bringer, perhaps, of self-doubt. So, here goes:]
The Faculty of Arts, University of Nairobi, is the scholastic home to some 170 academics spread across nine departments and one sub-department, namely: Economics, French (sub-department), Geography, Government, Government, History, Philosophy, Linguistics and African Languages, Literature, Religious Studies, and Sociology. The Faculty traces its university roots back to April 1956, some forty four years ago, when the then Royal Technical College admitted its lot of “A Level” Arts students working toward their London GCE and equivalent examinations. These students were served by the Departments of Economics, English, geography, History and Mathematics.
On 25th June 1961, the then Royal Technical College was transferred, via an Act of the East African Common Services Organization (EACSO) into the second University College in East Africa – the first being the University College of Makerere. It was renamed Royal College, Nairobi, at the same time being formally affiliated to the University of London. The Faculty of Arts was thus a key feature of the Royal College from the very beginning. One could say that, even in those early days, the market, such as it was, spoke with its “demand” – and its message was that there was indeed a need for Arts-based skills even in that vice-grip of the colonial economy in which the :native” was supposed to be confined, in a caste-like fashion, to artisanal (blue collar) skills.
When, on 20th May, 1964, the Royal College, Nairobi, became the University College, Nairobi, and a constituent college of the University of East Africa, the students and staff of the Faculty of Arts became an integral part of that enlarged, regional institution – and of the processes which the change entailed.
The period from May 1964 to June 1970 witnessed considerable transformation in the Faculty. The academic year 1965/66 saw the establishment of the Department of Education and the Centre for Economics. The latter soon became the Institute for Development Studies. The Department of Political Science was established in 1966/67, and was later renamed the department of Government. In 1968/69, what had started as a sub-department within the Department of Economics was elevated to the Department of Sociology. In 1969/70, the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies was established.
Only during 1967-70 was the Department of Mathematics finally transferred from the Faculty of Arts to the Faculty of Science. During the same period, the sub-department of Linguistics and African Languages moved out of the Department of English to become itself a department; while the Department of English (still hosting the sub-department of French) assumed a new name: the Department of Literature. The Department of Education was transformed into a Faculty in 1970/71, which relocated to Kenyatta University College. In 1980/81 the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies was split into two departments (Department of Philosophy and Department of Religious Studies).
For some twenty years now, the Faculty of Arts has had exactly the same configuration of nine departments and one sub-department as it had in 1980/81. The era of further departmental expansion, which some had predicted, never materialized in the Eighties, or even Nineties. When the Department of Psychology was eventually established, it was located, not in the Faculty of arts, but rather in the Faculty of Education at the Kikuyu Campus of the University of Nairobi. Neither the Department of Theatre Arts nor that of Archaeology has seen the light of day. And when the Diplomacy Programme of the Department of Government became an independent entity, it was taken out of the Faculty of Arts to become the Institute of Diplomacy and International Studies.
Our student population has witnessed great expansion since the early days. In 1961/62, the Faculty had only 14 students. By 1981/82, this population had grown more than a hundred-fold to 1,635, which affirmed the Faculty’s ranking as the largest in the country. That number had, as of September 1999, more than doubled again to some 2,900 regular B.A students, some 230 Module II B.A. students and 180 postgraduate students (both regular and Module II) – in addition to whom there are currently 140 students pursuing Certificate, Bridging and Ordinary Diploma courses. Our Faculty thus continues to be the largest today. With a teaching staff of some 170 academics, it is likewise one of the largest in that category.
The greater part of the Eighties and Nineties now turn out to have been essentially a period of “creative drought” -- little else of a structural nature happened, many (the public was in fact made to believe all) valued academics were forced or induced by one circumstance or another to leave the Faculty and the university (often to newer local universities), and the burden of the double intakes associated with 8.4.4 wore down even the hardiest. All of this caused growing despondency and prompted further flight by both lecturers and prospective students. Confronted, furthermore, with frequent closures of local universities, parents had begun to look elsewhere in earnest for their children’s university education. The annual cost to the country of that flight to foreign universities is currently estimated to be some Kshs. 15 billion in foreign exchange (or US$ 200,000,000). Even half of that would be more than our depressed coffee industry now generates.
There was growing agitation during that period for a university curriculum relevant to the future of the country. A litany of public pronouncements declared Arts subjects an irrelevance, and, given frequent strike actions by Arts students, perhaps even dangerous. But as we lived through all that, and perhaps because of it, new thinking began imperceptibly to germinate. This germination has been, precisely, the story of the last ten years; which, in semiotic terms, can be labeled the era of 8.4.4, UASU, and Module II.
The 8.4.4 system of education reached the tertiary level in 1990/91. Having the largest intake capacity, this Faculty carried more than its fair share of the 8.4.4. burden, in terms of student-teacher ratios, lecture-room and library facilities, and other essential requirements. And when cost-sharing eventually caught up with university students, the Faculty of Arts served largely as a source for developing “more essential” faculties. In a way, it became the university’s Third World. And when, in the early Nineties, the university’s academic staff, under UASU, began forcefully to agitate for a staff union, the Faculty of Arts found itself in the very eye of the storm. More academics left the university. More parents took their children elsewhere or abroad.
Module II, an income generating strategy based on the provision of the very services which it is the university’s mission to provide, began somewhat inconspicuously at this university in 1998. There are varying accounts as to its true genesis. Some trace its inspiration back to the establishment of the mortuary facility at the university’s Chiromo Campus, some to the Makerere experiment in income generation, others simply to the final realization that neither the government nor the donor community had the means or the inclination to restore the University of Nairobi to its “old glory”, much less to reengineer it into a “top flight” global institution of the 21st century. Be that as it may, this realization that we were, in the end, on our own has proven a most energizing and empowering frame of mind.
If 8.4.4 was imposed on the university’s body politic from the outside, Module II was created internally. That essential difference explains why, compared to the former, the latter has grown so dynamically in so short a time – despite considerable initial skepticism, even from within.
Following in the footsteps of the Faculties of Commerce and Law, the Faculty of Arts admitted its first intake of Module II students in January 1999, when 87 students registered for various B.A. courses. Considerable curriculum development, which had begun in earnest in October 1998, continued even after that first intake.
Thus, when the second intake arrived in May 1999, it had a selection of over 17 market-responsive M.A. degrees and postgraduate Diplomas, 14 B.A. degrees, 2 Bridging Courses, 5 Ordinary Diplomas, and 7 Certificate courses to choose from depending on need. During the September 1999 intake, a new degree programme (B.A. in Public Administration) was offered to students by the Department of Political Science and Public Administration. There have been even more programmes in the new millennium, details of which are provided throughout this prospectus. Among these will be Mathematics, which in a way conjoins Module II with this Faculty’s roots, and a number of courses in the Department of Geography. Several departments are also revamping their M.A. programmes in readiness for the future.
The Faculty’s Curriculum Committee has its hands full with programme documents from the departments. The Faculty has become a virtual 24x7 “idea factory”, with Just-In-Time ambitions. Though we have started with astoundingly meagre resources, we are working hard to make our students an integral part of all this. Tell-tale signs of positive change have begun to appear, as one will witness any Saturday at the Main Campus: around the Great Court, near the Fountain of Knowledge, inside the Main Library – and in the corridors of Gandhi Wing, where six of the Faculty’s ten departments as well as the Dean’s Office are located.
What is absolutely pleasing in all of this is that more and more Kenyans are voting with their feet and cheque books in support of Module II. For us in the Faculty of Arts, that support means even more: it is proving that the irrelevance which Arts supposedly embodied was always, in reality, a mirage. We will do all we can to retain it. As we continue to subscribe to the call “Let the programmes be market-driven”, we are encouraged by the realization that many of our programmes are already proving to be so driven.
As we stand, one must of course ask: is that support ill-advised? We believe not, for the disciplines that make up the Faculty of Arts do permit all sorts of permutations and combinations the connecting threads of which are the abilities and frames of mind absolutely necessary for navigating, and surviving, in a 21st century which promises to be, above all, one of intense and in so many ways instant global and local communication and exchange and networking, of cultural hybridity, of unprecedented mass travel and nomadic existence – in which the most essential survival kit must surely include the ability to articulate one’s thought and to understand (and stand!) otherness.
Signed
PROF. MAURI YAMBO
DEAN, FACULTY OF ARTS.
NOTE: Data on the Faculty’s early history to 1981/82 was gleaned from the Faculty’s earlier prospectus, and from other University of Nairobi records.
The Faculty of Arts, University of Nairobi, is the scholastic home to some 170 academics spread across nine departments and one sub-department, namely: Economics, French (sub-department), Geography, Government, Government, History, Philosophy, Linguistics and African Languages, Literature, Religious Studies, and Sociology. The Faculty traces its university roots back to April 1956, some forty four years ago, when the then Royal Technical College admitted its lot of “A Level” Arts students working toward their London GCE and equivalent examinations. These students were served by the Departments of Economics, English, geography, History and Mathematics.
On 25th June 1961, the then Royal Technical College was transferred, via an Act of the East African Common Services Organization (EACSO) into the second University College in East Africa – the first being the University College of Makerere. It was renamed Royal College, Nairobi, at the same time being formally affiliated to the University of London. The Faculty of Arts was thus a key feature of the Royal College from the very beginning. One could say that, even in those early days, the market, such as it was, spoke with its “demand” – and its message was that there was indeed a need for Arts-based skills even in that vice-grip of the colonial economy in which the :native” was supposed to be confined, in a caste-like fashion, to artisanal (blue collar) skills.
When, on 20th May, 1964, the Royal College, Nairobi, became the University College, Nairobi, and a constituent college of the University of East Africa, the students and staff of the Faculty of Arts became an integral part of that enlarged, regional institution – and of the processes which the change entailed.
The period from May 1964 to June 1970 witnessed considerable transformation in the Faculty. The academic year 1965/66 saw the establishment of the Department of Education and the Centre for Economics. The latter soon became the Institute for Development Studies. The Department of Political Science was established in 1966/67, and was later renamed the department of Government. In 1968/69, what had started as a sub-department within the Department of Economics was elevated to the Department of Sociology. In 1969/70, the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies was established.
Only during 1967-70 was the Department of Mathematics finally transferred from the Faculty of Arts to the Faculty of Science. During the same period, the sub-department of Linguistics and African Languages moved out of the Department of English to become itself a department; while the Department of English (still hosting the sub-department of French) assumed a new name: the Department of Literature. The Department of Education was transformed into a Faculty in 1970/71, which relocated to Kenyatta University College. In 1980/81 the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies was split into two departments (Department of Philosophy and Department of Religious Studies).
For some twenty years now, the Faculty of Arts has had exactly the same configuration of nine departments and one sub-department as it had in 1980/81. The era of further departmental expansion, which some had predicted, never materialized in the Eighties, or even Nineties. When the Department of Psychology was eventually established, it was located, not in the Faculty of arts, but rather in the Faculty of Education at the Kikuyu Campus of the University of Nairobi. Neither the Department of Theatre Arts nor that of Archaeology has seen the light of day. And when the Diplomacy Programme of the Department of Government became an independent entity, it was taken out of the Faculty of Arts to become the Institute of Diplomacy and International Studies.
Our student population has witnessed great expansion since the early days. In 1961/62, the Faculty had only 14 students. By 1981/82, this population had grown more than a hundred-fold to 1,635, which affirmed the Faculty’s ranking as the largest in the country. That number had, as of September 1999, more than doubled again to some 2,900 regular B.A students, some 230 Module II B.A. students and 180 postgraduate students (both regular and Module II) – in addition to whom there are currently 140 students pursuing Certificate, Bridging and Ordinary Diploma courses. Our Faculty thus continues to be the largest today. With a teaching staff of some 170 academics, it is likewise one of the largest in that category.
The greater part of the Eighties and Nineties now turn out to have been essentially a period of “creative drought” -- little else of a structural nature happened, many (the public was in fact made to believe all) valued academics were forced or induced by one circumstance or another to leave the Faculty and the university (often to newer local universities), and the burden of the double intakes associated with 8.4.4 wore down even the hardiest. All of this caused growing despondency and prompted further flight by both lecturers and prospective students. Confronted, furthermore, with frequent closures of local universities, parents had begun to look elsewhere in earnest for their children’s university education. The annual cost to the country of that flight to foreign universities is currently estimated to be some Kshs. 15 billion in foreign exchange (or US$ 200,000,000). Even half of that would be more than our depressed coffee industry now generates.
There was growing agitation during that period for a university curriculum relevant to the future of the country. A litany of public pronouncements declared Arts subjects an irrelevance, and, given frequent strike actions by Arts students, perhaps even dangerous. But as we lived through all that, and perhaps because of it, new thinking began imperceptibly to germinate. This germination has been, precisely, the story of the last ten years; which, in semiotic terms, can be labeled the era of 8.4.4, UASU, and Module II.
The 8.4.4 system of education reached the tertiary level in 1990/91. Having the largest intake capacity, this Faculty carried more than its fair share of the 8.4.4. burden, in terms of student-teacher ratios, lecture-room and library facilities, and other essential requirements. And when cost-sharing eventually caught up with university students, the Faculty of Arts served largely as a source for developing “more essential” faculties. In a way, it became the university’s Third World. And when, in the early Nineties, the university’s academic staff, under UASU, began forcefully to agitate for a staff union, the Faculty of Arts found itself in the very eye of the storm. More academics left the university. More parents took their children elsewhere or abroad.
Module II, an income generating strategy based on the provision of the very services which it is the university’s mission to provide, began somewhat inconspicuously at this university in 1998. There are varying accounts as to its true genesis. Some trace its inspiration back to the establishment of the mortuary facility at the university’s Chiromo Campus, some to the Makerere experiment in income generation, others simply to the final realization that neither the government nor the donor community had the means or the inclination to restore the University of Nairobi to its “old glory”, much less to reengineer it into a “top flight” global institution of the 21st century. Be that as it may, this realization that we were, in the end, on our own has proven a most energizing and empowering frame of mind.
If 8.4.4 was imposed on the university’s body politic from the outside, Module II was created internally. That essential difference explains why, compared to the former, the latter has grown so dynamically in so short a time – despite considerable initial skepticism, even from within.
Following in the footsteps of the Faculties of Commerce and Law, the Faculty of Arts admitted its first intake of Module II students in January 1999, when 87 students registered for various B.A. courses. Considerable curriculum development, which had begun in earnest in October 1998, continued even after that first intake.
Thus, when the second intake arrived in May 1999, it had a selection of over 17 market-responsive M.A. degrees and postgraduate Diplomas, 14 B.A. degrees, 2 Bridging Courses, 5 Ordinary Diplomas, and 7 Certificate courses to choose from depending on need. During the September 1999 intake, a new degree programme (B.A. in Public Administration) was offered to students by the Department of Political Science and Public Administration. There have been even more programmes in the new millennium, details of which are provided throughout this prospectus. Among these will be Mathematics, which in a way conjoins Module II with this Faculty’s roots, and a number of courses in the Department of Geography. Several departments are also revamping their M.A. programmes in readiness for the future.
The Faculty’s Curriculum Committee has its hands full with programme documents from the departments. The Faculty has become a virtual 24x7 “idea factory”, with Just-In-Time ambitions. Though we have started with astoundingly meagre resources, we are working hard to make our students an integral part of all this. Tell-tale signs of positive change have begun to appear, as one will witness any Saturday at the Main Campus: around the Great Court, near the Fountain of Knowledge, inside the Main Library – and in the corridors of Gandhi Wing, where six of the Faculty’s ten departments as well as the Dean’s Office are located.
What is absolutely pleasing in all of this is that more and more Kenyans are voting with their feet and cheque books in support of Module II. For us in the Faculty of Arts, that support means even more: it is proving that the irrelevance which Arts supposedly embodied was always, in reality, a mirage. We will do all we can to retain it. As we continue to subscribe to the call “Let the programmes be market-driven”, we are encouraged by the realization that many of our programmes are already proving to be so driven.
As we stand, one must of course ask: is that support ill-advised? We believe not, for the disciplines that make up the Faculty of Arts do permit all sorts of permutations and combinations the connecting threads of which are the abilities and frames of mind absolutely necessary for navigating, and surviving, in a 21st century which promises to be, above all, one of intense and in so many ways instant global and local communication and exchange and networking, of cultural hybridity, of unprecedented mass travel and nomadic existence – in which the most essential survival kit must surely include the ability to articulate one’s thought and to understand (and stand!) otherness.
Signed
PROF. MAURI YAMBO
DEAN, FACULTY OF ARTS.
NOTE: Data on the Faculty’s early history to 1981/82 was gleaned from the Faculty’s earlier prospectus, and from other University of Nairobi records.
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Smart Move -- Raila and Kalonzo!
By Prof. Mauri Yambo
It was reassuring to hear the two ODM-K leading lights, Raila and Kalonzo, come out so clearly -- and quite passionately -- early in the week in support of the delegate option for nominating the ODM-K presidential candidate. Raila's arguments were quite detailed and persuasive, and quite impressive for having been made at a public rally and therefore essentially off-the-cuff. Kalonzo reminded us that this has been his view all along, and there is reason to believe him.
Uhuru was quite brave to have come out a few days earlier -- and indeed he received some flack for it. Part of his reason for preferring this method, he indicated obliquely in a TV soundbite -- and historians will have to check out his claim -- was that the consensus option had indeed been exercised, after a crude fashion, in 2002! His point was that prospective successors to President Moi within the then ruling party has agreed to have Moi anoint one of them as the flag-bearer in the 2002 , and to support Moi's choice. But when Moi settled for Uhuru, the others jumped ship -- with disastrous consequences for the "project".
All of this can only help nurture internal democracy within Kenya's political parties, which have so far proven quite archaic in their governance -- and blindly, self-destructively Machiavellian.
It was reassuring to hear the two ODM-K leading lights, Raila and Kalonzo, come out so clearly -- and quite passionately -- early in the week in support of the delegate option for nominating the ODM-K presidential candidate. Raila's arguments were quite detailed and persuasive, and quite impressive for having been made at a public rally and therefore essentially off-the-cuff. Kalonzo reminded us that this has been his view all along, and there is reason to believe him.
Uhuru was quite brave to have come out a few days earlier -- and indeed he received some flack for it. Part of his reason for preferring this method, he indicated obliquely in a TV soundbite -- and historians will have to check out his claim -- was that the consensus option had indeed been exercised, after a crude fashion, in 2002! His point was that prospective successors to President Moi within the then ruling party has agreed to have Moi anoint one of them as the flag-bearer in the 2002 , and to support Moi's choice. But when Moi settled for Uhuru, the others jumped ship -- with disastrous consequences for the "project".
All of this can only help nurture internal democracy within Kenya's political parties, which have so far proven quite archaic in their governance -- and blindly, self-destructively Machiavellian.
Sunday, January 28, 2007
Democracy Eventually Catches Up With The Leaders
By Prof. Mauri Yambo
Kenya’s political climate in the 21st century is quite different from what it was when Jomo Kenyatta was president, and during most of Moi’s 24-year presidency. The year 2002 was a dramatic watershed. Kenya’s experience suggests that in countries steeped in years of one-man rule, the “democratic bug” – some would now call it the democratic meme (a sort of “mind virus”) – is first genuinely, and even innocently, caught by the people (the voters). Eventually, it must catch up with the leaders too – both those in power and in opposition.
Through many sacrifices, shifting coalitions and unforgettable cliff-hangers, Kenya’s democratic space has in the last decade and a half evolved to be, now, much wider, deeper and more vibrant. In the post-2002 period, it continues to evolve. But not fast enough. In particular, the democratic space within political parties remains scandalously under-evolved – and the membership under-involved!
Party governance, even among opposition parties, remains steeped in the big-man mindset of yesteryear, no matter how many position papers are developed in the name of democracy. However, 2007 may be a landmark year, certainly for opposition parties, and particularly for ODM-K. The party must somehow choose a presidential candidate in the next six months, and rally behind that choice, without tearing itself apart. Obviously, the party of the incumbent (President Kibaki), whichever party it is, will not be under the same kind of pressure in 2007. Its choice is already in State House, and will run again – unopposed by any of the GNU parties.
So what is ODM-K going to do? How, exactly, is it going to choose its presidential, parliamentary and civic candidates? In the name of democracy, the answer should be obvious – and yet there is much beating about the bush. There is much lingering suspicion among the party luminaries, though they will publicly deny it. And MPs continue to hog party organs and functions as though no one else has a voice, a mind or an iota of legitimacy.
Consistent with basic democratic principles, party rank-and-file should be involved in choosing party candidates at various levels, through direct voting during primaries in respective constituencies, and/or a graduated delegate system. Such voting may be by secret ballot or some version of queuing (mlologo). The former is preferably, though the logistics and cost of doing so may be prohibitive, even at the constituency level, for a cash-strapped party.
If the 2002 experience is anything to go by, the direct-voting route favours incumbents, or aspirants who have the ears of those at headquarters – and who offer to foot the bill. Queuing is a public spectacle whose results, in an organized environment, are there for all to see. However, it disenfranchises those who arrive after the lining- up phase is closed and the counting begins, or who must leave before it is completed. And so it has too many flaws itself to be adopted during general elections proper.
Though there has been much debate and agonizing about how ODM-K should choose its Presidential candidate, some agreement seems at last to have been arrived at. What is unsettling many observers (members of the silent majority) is that, having agreed on the version of the delegate system to adopt for nominating its presidential candidate, and how the actual voting will broadly be conducted, some ODM-K luminaries seem to be developing cold feet even before the ink dries on the paper on which their agreement was presumably penned. We are back to the notion that, somehow, a consensus among the aspirants is the best way to choose the presidential candidate. Great danger lurks in this apparent change of mind.
In the first place, a consensus cannot by definition be imposed – particularly among forces of roughly equal power or influence. Consensus implies unanimity among those involved in trying to reach it. Consequently, no consensus can be reached which does not in fact anoint the aspirant who believes, rightly or wrongly, that the delegate system would deliver him or her the nomination which the consensus might, by subterfuge, deny him or her. To threaten such a candidate with ostracism and even expulsion from the party is to threaten the very existence of the very party whose presidential candidate every luminary wants to be. As I see it, and I want to be forthright here, consensus, as it is conceived of now, is just another word for Tosha! Because of 2002, and of what has transpired in Kenyan politics since, Tosha has become a dirty five-letter word. The sooner it is abandoned the better it with be for the social capital of those associated with it.
Secondly, attempts to broker a consensus among ODM-K luminaries and those close to them – away from the ordinary members’ prying eyes – are a very loud and clear message that the leaders (at least some of them) do not trust the people, who trust them. They do not trust the people’s judgement on this matter. But why on this matter, and why now, if the people’s judgement in 2002 and 2005 continues to be the subject of so much chest-thumping? Moreover, these attempts bring to mind a discredited practice exemplified by Mayor Daley’s Chicago of the 1950s and ’60s. Senator Obama, and ODM-K’s donors such as NDI and IRI, would caution us against this practice, if we chose to consult them or heed their advice.
I believe that the delegate system will choose for ODM-K not only the right candidate but more importantly the only presidential candidate it can legitimately and democratically choose – indeed, the winning candidate. The challenge for each aspirant is to network within genuine democratic parameters such as these to put together a winning combination. Power comes from the people. We should consistently preach this and show that we mean it by practicing it. And as Mwalimu Nyerere used to say, though he did not treat his own opponents kindly (but that was another era, which must not return), “It can be done!”
To suggest that voters registered in certain regions should by definition be disqualified from the ODM-K presidential nomination process – or that their votes should be less than equal (that is, a fraction) those of their counterparts in other regions – is to tell them to take or keep their support elsewhere. You cannot win by being associated with such a view, or by forgoing such large chunks of votes! It simply does not make sense – even in the name of enlightened self-interest.
Come to think of it, that is the same kind of “Siasa mbaya, maisha mbaya” attitude, in top government circles, which has denied an equitable share of development resources and state appointments to “opposition areas” from 1963 to 2007! The widespread rejection of this attitude across the country provides the basic explanation for the equally widespread support, reported in recent months by Steadman, which ODM-K continues to enjoy.
It should be expected that the eventual ODM-K candidate will campaign in all regions of the country during the actual presidential elections, and will not surrender any votes anywhere to anyone. This, one suspects, will also be President Kibaki’s strategy for victory.
The trouble with trying too hard to tilt the democratic process in one’s favour, to ensure one’s own victory, is that one’s opponents or co-contestants – if they are not to be presumed dumb – can see through this too clearly for one’s eventual comfort. This is particularly so in arenas where the goodwill of at least some of one’s peers is a prerequisite for the looked-for victory. They may for a time be silent or muted, or even confused, about what they see, but such seeing and such machinations are a lethal combination. The combination has easily predictable consequences. For our political leaders, this is the fundamental lesson of Kenya’s general elections of 2002, and the referendum of 2005. The end does not, should not, always justify the means.
What is my prognosis? Attempts to broker a consensus will fail. For the sake of Democracy, they should not and must not succeed! Democracy will catch up with ODM-K luminaries and MPs in 2007. For goodness’ sake, the D in the party’s name stands for Democratic – without quote unquote! ODM-K will choose its presidential candidate through the delegate system, which will perhaps have been amended more than once between now and June. The losing presidential aspirants will rally fairly forcefully behind the winner – perhaps on the uncertain promise of the Prime Minister’s job.
Abandoning the party after a well-organized leadership selection exercise via the delegate system would spell doom to the political future, nationally, of those who do so. And, it seems mathematically clear to me at this point, the chosen candidate will have a better that 50-50 chance of winning the actual presidential elections in 2007. However, should ODM-K formally break up before its candidate is officially nominated, into pro-consensus and anti-consensus camps, then – from that moment of split and long before the elections are actually held – the country will know the winner of the 2007 presidential elections, and that the winner will be the incumbent, President Mwai Kibaki.
Can the country live with that? Sure. We have done so since 2003. Can the losing luminaries do so? Yes, at a terrible price. The inevitable consequence of a second Kibaki victory would be a passionate scramble for new leadership in various areas across the country, as Democracy finally catches up with the remaining diehards – reluctant democrats. Democracy should be a quality of mind inscribed in our routine practice, not merely something we occasionally preach.
Only one eventuality can radically change much of the above scenario, while still delivering victory to President Kibaki in 2007. It is the push particularly by LDP, unlikely to succeed this year, to make ODM-K strictly a party of regional parties allowing only for corporate membership and run on the basis of a coalition of “like-minded” parties. While it has become too late to choose the ODM-K flag-bearer this way this year, this scenario is entirely possible in 2012.
Nairobi: Sunday, January 28, 2007.
Kenya’s political climate in the 21st century is quite different from what it was when Jomo Kenyatta was president, and during most of Moi’s 24-year presidency. The year 2002 was a dramatic watershed. Kenya’s experience suggests that in countries steeped in years of one-man rule, the “democratic bug” – some would now call it the democratic meme (a sort of “mind virus”) – is first genuinely, and even innocently, caught by the people (the voters). Eventually, it must catch up with the leaders too – both those in power and in opposition.
Through many sacrifices, shifting coalitions and unforgettable cliff-hangers, Kenya’s democratic space has in the last decade and a half evolved to be, now, much wider, deeper and more vibrant. In the post-2002 period, it continues to evolve. But not fast enough. In particular, the democratic space within political parties remains scandalously under-evolved – and the membership under-involved!
Party governance, even among opposition parties, remains steeped in the big-man mindset of yesteryear, no matter how many position papers are developed in the name of democracy. However, 2007 may be a landmark year, certainly for opposition parties, and particularly for ODM-K. The party must somehow choose a presidential candidate in the next six months, and rally behind that choice, without tearing itself apart. Obviously, the party of the incumbent (President Kibaki), whichever party it is, will not be under the same kind of pressure in 2007. Its choice is already in State House, and will run again – unopposed by any of the GNU parties.
So what is ODM-K going to do? How, exactly, is it going to choose its presidential, parliamentary and civic candidates? In the name of democracy, the answer should be obvious – and yet there is much beating about the bush. There is much lingering suspicion among the party luminaries, though they will publicly deny it. And MPs continue to hog party organs and functions as though no one else has a voice, a mind or an iota of legitimacy.
Consistent with basic democratic principles, party rank-and-file should be involved in choosing party candidates at various levels, through direct voting during primaries in respective constituencies, and/or a graduated delegate system. Such voting may be by secret ballot or some version of queuing (mlologo). The former is preferably, though the logistics and cost of doing so may be prohibitive, even at the constituency level, for a cash-strapped party.
If the 2002 experience is anything to go by, the direct-voting route favours incumbents, or aspirants who have the ears of those at headquarters – and who offer to foot the bill. Queuing is a public spectacle whose results, in an organized environment, are there for all to see. However, it disenfranchises those who arrive after the lining- up phase is closed and the counting begins, or who must leave before it is completed. And so it has too many flaws itself to be adopted during general elections proper.
Though there has been much debate and agonizing about how ODM-K should choose its Presidential candidate, some agreement seems at last to have been arrived at. What is unsettling many observers (members of the silent majority) is that, having agreed on the version of the delegate system to adopt for nominating its presidential candidate, and how the actual voting will broadly be conducted, some ODM-K luminaries seem to be developing cold feet even before the ink dries on the paper on which their agreement was presumably penned. We are back to the notion that, somehow, a consensus among the aspirants is the best way to choose the presidential candidate. Great danger lurks in this apparent change of mind.
In the first place, a consensus cannot by definition be imposed – particularly among forces of roughly equal power or influence. Consensus implies unanimity among those involved in trying to reach it. Consequently, no consensus can be reached which does not in fact anoint the aspirant who believes, rightly or wrongly, that the delegate system would deliver him or her the nomination which the consensus might, by subterfuge, deny him or her. To threaten such a candidate with ostracism and even expulsion from the party is to threaten the very existence of the very party whose presidential candidate every luminary wants to be. As I see it, and I want to be forthright here, consensus, as it is conceived of now, is just another word for Tosha! Because of 2002, and of what has transpired in Kenyan politics since, Tosha has become a dirty five-letter word. The sooner it is abandoned the better it with be for the social capital of those associated with it.
Secondly, attempts to broker a consensus among ODM-K luminaries and those close to them – away from the ordinary members’ prying eyes – are a very loud and clear message that the leaders (at least some of them) do not trust the people, who trust them. They do not trust the people’s judgement on this matter. But why on this matter, and why now, if the people’s judgement in 2002 and 2005 continues to be the subject of so much chest-thumping? Moreover, these attempts bring to mind a discredited practice exemplified by Mayor Daley’s Chicago of the 1950s and ’60s. Senator Obama, and ODM-K’s donors such as NDI and IRI, would caution us against this practice, if we chose to consult them or heed their advice.
I believe that the delegate system will choose for ODM-K not only the right candidate but more importantly the only presidential candidate it can legitimately and democratically choose – indeed, the winning candidate. The challenge for each aspirant is to network within genuine democratic parameters such as these to put together a winning combination. Power comes from the people. We should consistently preach this and show that we mean it by practicing it. And as Mwalimu Nyerere used to say, though he did not treat his own opponents kindly (but that was another era, which must not return), “It can be done!”
To suggest that voters registered in certain regions should by definition be disqualified from the ODM-K presidential nomination process – or that their votes should be less than equal (that is, a fraction) those of their counterparts in other regions – is to tell them to take or keep their support elsewhere. You cannot win by being associated with such a view, or by forgoing such large chunks of votes! It simply does not make sense – even in the name of enlightened self-interest.
Come to think of it, that is the same kind of “Siasa mbaya, maisha mbaya” attitude, in top government circles, which has denied an equitable share of development resources and state appointments to “opposition areas” from 1963 to 2007! The widespread rejection of this attitude across the country provides the basic explanation for the equally widespread support, reported in recent months by Steadman, which ODM-K continues to enjoy.
It should be expected that the eventual ODM-K candidate will campaign in all regions of the country during the actual presidential elections, and will not surrender any votes anywhere to anyone. This, one suspects, will also be President Kibaki’s strategy for victory.
The trouble with trying too hard to tilt the democratic process in one’s favour, to ensure one’s own victory, is that one’s opponents or co-contestants – if they are not to be presumed dumb – can see through this too clearly for one’s eventual comfort. This is particularly so in arenas where the goodwill of at least some of one’s peers is a prerequisite for the looked-for victory. They may for a time be silent or muted, or even confused, about what they see, but such seeing and such machinations are a lethal combination. The combination has easily predictable consequences. For our political leaders, this is the fundamental lesson of Kenya’s general elections of 2002, and the referendum of 2005. The end does not, should not, always justify the means.
What is my prognosis? Attempts to broker a consensus will fail. For the sake of Democracy, they should not and must not succeed! Democracy will catch up with ODM-K luminaries and MPs in 2007. For goodness’ sake, the D in the party’s name stands for Democratic – without quote unquote! ODM-K will choose its presidential candidate through the delegate system, which will perhaps have been amended more than once between now and June. The losing presidential aspirants will rally fairly forcefully behind the winner – perhaps on the uncertain promise of the Prime Minister’s job.
Abandoning the party after a well-organized leadership selection exercise via the delegate system would spell doom to the political future, nationally, of those who do so. And, it seems mathematically clear to me at this point, the chosen candidate will have a better that 50-50 chance of winning the actual presidential elections in 2007. However, should ODM-K formally break up before its candidate is officially nominated, into pro-consensus and anti-consensus camps, then – from that moment of split and long before the elections are actually held – the country will know the winner of the 2007 presidential elections, and that the winner will be the incumbent, President Mwai Kibaki.
Can the country live with that? Sure. We have done so since 2003. Can the losing luminaries do so? Yes, at a terrible price. The inevitable consequence of a second Kibaki victory would be a passionate scramble for new leadership in various areas across the country, as Democracy finally catches up with the remaining diehards – reluctant democrats. Democracy should be a quality of mind inscribed in our routine practice, not merely something we occasionally preach.
Only one eventuality can radically change much of the above scenario, while still delivering victory to President Kibaki in 2007. It is the push particularly by LDP, unlikely to succeed this year, to make ODM-K strictly a party of regional parties allowing only for corporate membership and run on the basis of a coalition of “like-minded” parties. While it has become too late to choose the ODM-K flag-bearer this way this year, this scenario is entirely possible in 2012.
Nairobi: Sunday, January 28, 2007.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)