Showing posts with label 2005. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2005. Show all posts

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Nine-Point Road Map to a More Inclusive Constitution By Jamhuri Day, 2005.

By

Prof. Mauri Yambo

[Nairobi: September 22, 2005]

INTRODUCTION: In the afternoon of September 22, 2005, UASU Nairobi Chapter hosted a panel-forum in Taifa Hall, University of Nairobi. The panel was chaired by Dr. Winnie Mitula (Chairperson of UASU Nairobi Chapter). The panellists included Prof. V. Simiyu (History), Prof. P. Wanyande (Political Science), myself (Sociology) and several others. The following nine points constituted my initial submission. This post is published purely for the record, as it has clearly been overtaken by events. Or has it, entirely?

1. Do not postpone the referendum scheduled for November 21, 2005. Instead, deal with the contentious issues and table the necessary amendments to the Wako Bill in Parliament. It can be done. It must be done.

2. Adopt the Bomas provisions for the appointment of a Prime Minister. In the interest of Multi-party and Parliamentary democracy, the PM should be “the member of the Assembly who is the leader of the of the largest political party, or coalition of parties, represented in the Assembly.” If he/she is “unable to command the confidence of the Assembly,” then the Bomas Plan B should come into force. However, if within sixty days Parliament is still unable to agree on a Prime Minister, then, instead of dissolving the Assembly at this juncture, the President should have the power to appoint a Prime Minister from among the members of Parliament who will immediately assume his/her duties and proceed to establish a “Government of National Unity” or a “Grand Coalition.” Should this effort fail in the next thirty days, then the President should dissolve Parliament and call fresh general elections.

3. In order to secure our multi-party democracy, no MP should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister without the written consent of his/her political party; and, in any case, no MP who is not a member of the ruling or grand coalition should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister[1].

4. Our political history suggests that if we are to secure party loyalty and discipline, strengthen the Assembly’s watchdog role and reinforce the principle of “separation of powers,”then we must entrench in the Constitution the requirement that all party coalitions be concluded and formalized in writing, and be signed by persons competent to do so and representing the respective parties in the coalition. Each party must attach to the coalition document a supporting resolution adopted by its executive body. Copies of the coalition agreement, and the supporting resolutions, must be deposited with the Speaker of the Assembly.

5. Members of the National Assembly appointed Minister or Deputy Minister should retain their seats in the Assembly, and no person who is not a member of the National Assembly should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister.

6. A specific formula should be inserted in the constitution to entrench the principle that not less than one third of all seats in the National Assembly shall be occupied by women. The formula should establish “Supra Constituencies,” whose boundaries should coincide with those of a district or a combination of contiguous districts, as the Electoral and Boundaries Commission may determine from time to time, in such a way as to ensure that one third of all National Assembly seats shall always be available for contest by women at a general election.

7. While the President shall be both the Head of State and Head of Government, the Prime Minister shall be the Leader of Government Business both within and outside Parliament. As proposed in the Bomas draft, the President shall appoint and dismiss the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister shall nominate, and the President shall appoint, the two Deputy Prime Ministers and “not less than fifteen or more than twenty ministers and deputy ministers,”subject to approval by Parliament. Contrary to Bomas, however, Cabinet meetings shall be chaired by the President, and in his/her absence (or upon written delegation by the President) by the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister “shall co-ordinate the work of the ministries and the preparation of legislation, and is responsible to [both the President and] Parliament.”

8. Consistent with the foregoing, the President should have all the other functions stipulated in the Bomas draft.

9. Parliament must retain the power to pass a vote of no confidence in the President, the Deputy President, the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Ministers, the Ministers and Deputy Ministers.



[1] This would entrench Section 17, subsection 5, of The National Assembly and Presidential Elections Act (CAP 7), which states that: “No person who is elected or nominated as a member of the National Assembly with the support of or as a supporter of a political party (other than the party whose candidate has been elected President [change that to read “other than a party in the ruling coalition] at an election) shall be appointed Minister [or Deputy Minister] of the Government of Kenya under section 16 of the Constitution without the concurrence of the party which supported him for election or nominated him...”

Sunday, January 28, 2007

Democracy Eventually Catches Up With The Leaders

By Prof. Mauri Yambo

Kenya’s political climate in the 21st century is quite different from what it was when Jomo Kenyatta was president, and during most of Moi’s 24-year presidency. The year 2002 was a dramatic watershed. Kenya’s experience suggests that in countries steeped in years of one-man rule, the “democratic bug” – some would now call it the democratic meme (a sort of “mind virus”) – is first genuinely, and even innocently, caught by the people (the voters). Eventually, it must catch up with the leaders too – both those in power and in opposition.

Through many sacrifices, shifting coalitions and unforgettable cliff-hangers, Kenya’s democratic space has in the last decade and a half evolved to be, now, much wider, deeper and more vibrant. In the post-2002 period, it continues to evolve. But not fast enough. In particular, the democratic space within political parties remains scandalously under-evolved – and the membership under-involved!

Party governance, even among opposition parties, remains steeped in the big-man mindset of yesteryear, no matter how many position papers are developed in the name of democracy. However, 2007 may be a landmark year, certainly for opposition parties, and particularly for ODM-K. The party must somehow choose a presidential candidate in the next six months, and rally behind that choice, without tearing itself apart. Obviously, the party of the incumbent (President Kibaki), whichever party it is, will not be under the same kind of pressure in 2007. Its choice is already in State House, and will run again – unopposed by any of the GNU parties.

So what is ODM-K going to do? How, exactly, is it going to choose its presidential, parliamentary and civic candidates? In the name of democracy, the answer should be obvious – and yet there is much beating about the bush. There is much lingering suspicion among the party luminaries, though they will publicly deny it. And MPs continue to hog party organs and functions as though no one else has a voice, a mind or an iota of legitimacy.

Consistent with basic democratic principles, party rank-and-file should be involved in choosing party candidates at various levels, through direct voting during primaries in respective constituencies, and/or a graduated delegate system. Such voting may be by secret ballot or some version of queuing (mlologo). The former is preferably, though the logistics and cost of doing so may be prohibitive, even at the constituency level, for a cash-strapped party.

If the 2002 experience is anything to go by, the direct-voting route favours incumbents, or aspirants who have the ears of those at headquarters – and who offer to foot the bill. Queuing is a public spectacle whose results, in an organized environment, are there for all to see. However, it disenfranchises those who arrive after the lining- up phase is closed and the counting begins, or who must leave before it is completed. And so it has too many flaws itself to be adopted during general elections proper.

Though there has been much debate and agonizing about how ODM-K should choose its Presidential candidate, some agreement seems at last to have been arrived at. What is unsettling many observers (members of the silent majority) is that, having agreed on the version of the delegate system to adopt for nominating its presidential candidate, and how the actual voting will broadly be conducted, some ODM-K luminaries seem to be developing cold feet even before the ink dries on the paper on which their agreement was presumably penned. We are back to the notion that, somehow, a consensus among the aspirants is the best way to choose the presidential candidate. Great danger lurks in this apparent change of mind.

In the first place, a consensus cannot by definition be imposed – particularly among forces of roughly equal power or influence. Consensus implies unanimity among those involved in trying to reach it. Consequently, no consensus can be reached which does not in fact anoint the aspirant who believes, rightly or wrongly, that the delegate system would deliver him or her the nomination which the consensus might, by subterfuge, deny him or her. To threaten such a candidate with ostracism and even expulsion from the party is to threaten the very existence of the very party whose presidential candidate every luminary wants to be. As I see it, and I want to be forthright here, consensus, as it is conceived of now, is just another word for Tosha! Because of 2002, and of what has transpired in Kenyan politics since, Tosha has become a dirty five-letter word. The sooner it is abandoned the better it with be for the social capital of those associated with it.

Secondly, attempts to broker a consensus among ODM-K luminaries and those close to them – away from the ordinary members’ prying eyes – are a very loud and clear message that the leaders (at least some of them) do not trust the people, who trust them. They do not trust the people’s judgement on this matter. But why on this matter, and why now, if the people’s judgement in 2002 and 2005 continues to be the subject of so much chest-thumping? Moreover, these attempts bring to mind a discredited practice exemplified by Mayor Daley’s Chicago of the 1950s and ’60s. Senator Obama, and ODM-K’s donors such as NDI and IRI, would caution us against this practice, if we chose to consult them or heed their advice.

I believe that the delegate system will choose for ODM-K not only the right candidate but more importantly the only presidential candidate it can legitimately and democratically choose – indeed, the winning candidate. The challenge for each aspirant is to network within genuine democratic parameters such as these to put together a winning combination. Power comes from the people. We should consistently preach this and show that we mean it by practicing it. And as Mwalimu Nyerere used to say, though he did not treat his own opponents kindly (but that was another era, which must not return), “It can be done!”

To suggest that voters registered in certain regions should by definition be disqualified from the ODM-K presidential nomination process – or that their votes should be less than equal (that is, a fraction) those of their counterparts in other regions – is to tell them to take or keep their support elsewhere. You cannot win by being associated with such a view, or by forgoing such large chunks of votes! It simply does not make sense – even in the name of enlightened self-interest.

Come to think of it, that is the same kind of “Siasa mbaya, maisha mbaya” attitude, in top government circles, which has denied an equitable share of development resources and state appointments to “opposition areas” from 1963 to 2007! The widespread rejection of this attitude across the country provides the basic explanation for the equally widespread support, reported in recent months by Steadman, which ODM-K continues to enjoy.

It should be expected that the eventual ODM-K candidate will campaign in all regions of the country during the actual presidential elections, and will not surrender any votes anywhere to anyone. This, one suspects, will also be President Kibaki’s strategy for victory.

The trouble with trying too hard to tilt the democratic process in one’s favour, to ensure one’s own victory, is that one’s opponents or co-contestants – if they are not to be presumed dumb – can see through this too clearly for one’s eventual comfort. This is particularly so in arenas where the goodwill of at least some of one’s peers is a prerequisite for the looked-for victory. They may for a time be silent or muted, or even confused, about what they see, but such seeing and such machinations are a lethal combination. The combination has easily predictable consequences. For our political leaders, this is the fundamental lesson of Kenya’s general elections of 2002, and the referendum of 2005. The end does not, should not, always justify the means.

What is my prognosis? Attempts to broker a consensus will fail. For the sake of Democracy, they should not and must not succeed! Democracy will catch up with ODM-K luminaries and MPs in 2007. For goodness’ sake, the D in the party’s name stands for Democratic – without quote unquote! ODM-K will choose its presidential candidate through the delegate system, which will perhaps have been amended more than once between now and June. The losing presidential aspirants will rally fairly forcefully behind the winner – perhaps on the uncertain promise of the Prime Minister’s job.

Abandoning the party after a well-organized leadership selection exercise via the delegate system would spell doom to the political future, nationally, of those who do so. And, it seems mathematically clear to me at this point, the chosen candidate will have a better that 50-50 chance of winning the actual presidential elections in 2007. However, should ODM-K formally break up before its candidate is officially nominated, into pro-consensus and anti-consensus camps, then – from that moment of split and long before the elections are actually held – the country will know the winner of the 2007 presidential elections, and that the winner will be the incumbent, President Mwai Kibaki.

Can the country live with that? Sure. We have done so since 2003. Can the losing luminaries do so? Yes, at a terrible price. The inevitable consequence of a second Kibaki victory would be a passionate scramble for new leadership in various areas across the country, as Democracy finally catches up with the remaining diehards – reluctant democrats. Democracy should be a quality of mind inscribed in our routine practice, not merely something we occasionally preach.

Only one eventuality can radically change much of the above scenario, while still delivering victory to President Kibaki in 2007. It is the push particularly by LDP, unlikely to succeed this year, to make ODM-K strictly a party of regional parties allowing only for corporate membership and run on the basis of a coalition of “like-minded” parties. While it has become too late to choose the ODM-K flag-bearer this way this year, this scenario is entirely possible in 2012.

Nairobi: Sunday, January 28, 2007.

Saturday, January 13, 2007

IPOs and Kenyan Politicians

Kenyan politicians must root for the small investor. It is in their best interest. There are now over 500,000 such investors. By election time later in 2007, their number will probably have reached 750,000, particularly with the expected Safaricom IPO. Most of these are young Kenyans, and there is a growing number of women -- who refuse to be left behind. Their recent involvement in the stock market will be one potent reason for them to vote one way or another at the next general elections. They will at last have something very tangible to protect, something directly and personally beneficial to them.That’s a lot of votes to lose, for those who rub them the wrong way!

The small investor is a very determined and perceptive lot. Determined because the poverty line gives them nightmares, and they are driven to stay above it – well above. Perceptive in that they have discovered two things. First, that a well managed stock market offers them the most promising opportunity for asset-building, on a scale which no politician has offered them since the heyday (some decades ago now) of land-buying groups; and for staying above the poverty line despite widespread neglect by politicians. And they know that group land-buying, part of the old ethnicity, was essentially a kitchen cabinet project which politicians in many parts of the country did not have the motivation to emulate or counter -- and no discernible inclination to match for the benefit of their own constituents, as opposed to their own personal gain!

Second, that there is real “magic of compounding” in the stock market which politicians, themselves a perceptive lot, have all along known about and quietly enjoyed but which, left to their own devices, would rather not share with wananchi. We say: Keep this gate open! Share the planet!

It is one thing to fault the 2006 IPOs on the grounds that, starting with the “book building”scam attempted during the KenGen IPO, efforts were made to favour institutional investors (and some efforts succeeded, particularly in subsequent IPOs); or to query the mystery and illegal 5% holding by a third party in Safaricom; or to take measures to ensure that CMA and NSE do not “even think about it” in 2007 and beyond. But it is quite another and dangerous thing to make blanket statements of intention to repossess for the state, presumably by executive order or through a parliamentary vote, the shares which investors bought in 2006. Repossess and then do what? This would clearly be a case of repossess and dispossess. Dispossess for whose benefit?

In an election year, in which the margin of victory is unlikely to be larger than that witnessed during the 2005 referendum, it is highly risky and probably political suicide to make 750,000 individual investors highly nervous about the future of their hard-won, and now compounded, assets; or about the future of IPOs in general. Individual (or “small-holder”) shareholding is beginning to acquire the characteristics and passions of a new ethnicity, politician beware. It is a passion, indeed, that is sweeping the whole world – including the ex-communist states of China and Russia.