Showing posts with label Prime Minister. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prime Minister. Show all posts

Friday, February 18, 2011

Kenya: House Speaker Marende's ruling on President Kibaki's list of nominees

Yesterday's ruling by Kenya's Parliamentary Speaker, Kenneth Marende -- in which he returned to sender the President's list of nominees to four powerful positions provided for in the new constitution, and crucial to its timely implementation: Chief Justice (Judge Alnasir Visram), Attorney General (Prof. Githu Muigai), Director of Public Prosecutions (Kioko Kilukumi, William Ruto's ex-lawyer) and Controller of Budget (William Kirwa, allegedly a Ruto man) -- is not a victory for the Prime Minister, Raila Odinga, though it seems amply so. Ruto has lately become Kibaki's own preferred/de facto/secret Prime Minister, whose advice is heeded and whose suggested nominees (unlike Raila's) are actually nominated.

The Prime Minister acquiesced in the President's rush to short-circuit due process in a double-edged, silent, but ill-advised war -- a war against the Hague's ICC (via a gullible, bird-of-a-feather, African Union and, wishfully, the UN Security Council itself) and a war of his own succession (in which, as was clear to any adult, Raila was to be the biggest loser).

The PM had hoped that, sitting just the two of them, they would cut the cake into two even-handed parts. Bad idea. That is not Kibaki's style. The PM should have known that from the flawed February 2008 power-sharing deal, which cost him a lot of erstwhile friends, which continues to haunt him to this day, and which, ironically, PNU has been increasingly turning to its unprincipled advantage in the ever-shifting coalition landscape. The two "Princials" did consult, but obviously did not reach a consensus. Raila pulled away. The President, who appears hostage to the Ocampo Six chose to press on (needlessly, if you forget the O6)with his list.

Despite threats, Speaker Marende has done the right thing by urging the President and Prime Minister to do things right. He has asserted:

Consultations are not made if the House receives the list on which there is open disagreement between the President and the Prime Minister. As such, it is unconstitutional and the unconstitutionality cannot be cured by this House.

Worryingly, there is no guarantee that the PM would himself have done the right thing, had he been in President Kibaki's shoes these last 30 days or so. It is just that it was Kibaki's move to make, and in the eyes of many, it seems, the President made a blatant KKK move. If the CJ couldn't be his "preferred choice" (a Justice Kariuki?), then better a middle-tier Kenyan Indian (Judge Alnasir Visram) any day than someone more senior who happens to be from Nyanza -- or another middle-tier Judge from "Western", or even Mungatana's Pokomo group, if you like.

So it seems like Raila's voctory; but the victory, if it is, is pyrrhic. The toxic level in Kenya's political landscape continues to rise, as we approach 2012. The ICC and Ocampo clearly remain our best safeguard against our collective, suicidal, "darker side" as a nation. Anyone who does not see the blood-letting that is to come with the ICC taken out of the 2012 succession equation, has lost the power to reason coherently -- and lost touch even with common sense.

When Marende referred the Kibaki list to two House Committees, some ten days ago, he was roundly condemned as timid and spineless. But the wisdom in that move is that he allowed s considerable amount of national debate to take place. Many stakeholders availed themselves the opportunity to take a stand. Massive national consensus has built up, it seem clear to me,and Marende's ruling both reflects it and has been aided by it.

Was I sure then, absolutely sure, that Marende would make the ruling that he has no made? No. You can never be that sure. But I believed, based on the circumstances of the case and his previous rulings, that that was the only decision that he could make -- had to make.

So whose victory is it? First, the people of Kenya in their many ethnicities -- who are all too often ambushed with political decisions they have little time to reverse. Second, the new constitution -- which Kenyans are determined to implement and to have in its fullness. It is a victory, too, against impunity, ethnic myopia and lingering traces of an imperial presidency.

Friday, May 29, 2009

Kenya: That Unobscure Object of Ridicule

Kenya's youth no longer have any political heroes, and they have no champions. Nor do the poor and the hungry and the marginalized and those ill of health. Their erstwhile heroes have committed the political equivalent of hara kiri before their own eyes -- theirs and theirs. Any name picked from a list overpopulated by the discredited lot is likely to be met with hoots of derision and dismissive laughter, whichever name is mentioned as a possible exception and a potential hero in the days ahead.

At the helm of the political class are, of course, President Mwai Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga, the most ridiculed twosome in all of Kenya's post-independence era; a sort of two-headed gargoyle. In their official prominence, and enormous capacity for attention-grab, the pair has become that inobscure object of ridicule -- and loathing. This is a tragedy of monumental proportions, both for the duo and the nation, for all societies must have an acknowledged leadership -- which must be trusted to lead, and lead with vision and coherence to be trusted. But there is no trust here, for there is no coherence and no vision. The public interest does not matter. In its place there is brazen parochialism. And there is pathological greed, mean-spiritedness and myopic self-interest.

More and more Kenyans, it would seem, are cultivating the view that it will not matter who wins the next Presidential election in 2012. So, there may well be no "fire next time", contrary to widespread concerns here and abroad. There will be no one worth fighting for, or dying for. What is more likely to happen is that certain political fortunes will come to a dead stop at the hands of an electorate that at last rejects, with finality, their decades-old Presidential and related ambitions. Kibaki will, of course, be retiring. So the future is not as forbidding for him as for Raila, for whom time is clearly running out; and who does not seem to see that Kibaki is perhaps letting the time run out unhindered and even, by design, quirkily -- at whatever cost, that is.

The face which the twosome appears bent on presenting to the nation elicits only opprobrium, on a large scale, which is infecting the entire political class; which, incidentally, is not guilty merely by association, but by brazen deeds, acts of omission and, in effect, broad-daylight contempt for the peoples' sovereign aspirations. There is now mutual contempt, as Parliament degenerates and descends into a den that will defend its own at every turn and every opportunity, against a public opinion that has gone hoarse in its incessant call for accountability, simple justice, equity and the practice of basic principles of elective representation.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Six Sigma Obama: Marking His First 100 Days as President

Barack Obama's two-year campaign for the White House displayed, in virtually all his speeches, policy statements and promises, a determination to deliver, not just change we could believe in, but six sigma leadership as well -- and not just for the United States. It was going to be change of Renaissance proportions, or so it often sounded (for more on the Renaissance, click here).


To mark the first 100 days of his Presidency, report cards are flying in from all over the planet. And they are all, it seems to me, quite good. All, that is, bar perfection -- and bar the likes of Newt Gingrich and Karl Rove. This morning, on CNN, some journalist types were asked how they rated him. I saw several 9/10s and one 7/10. That was getting close to accurate, but I sensed that they were suppressing some of their enthusiasm. There was no need to. It is early days yet, and if you feel that something's good, it's good. Go ahead, say it. I believe I heard one commentator say that Obama has been the most effective US president since FDR. He wasn't mincing words -- there were no words to mince.


So, how do I myself rate his Presidency over the 100 days, in terms of hard-nosed policy actions and nuance, in terms of substance and even form? I say, without equivocation, Six Sigma! Hard days will surely come in the days ahead, as the same rubber mets more of the road, and the ratings may/will slide. Comes with the territory. But things look pretty optimistic right now, around the world generally, despite the economic meltdown and the very recent outbreak of swine flu.

As a Kenyan, I have even more reason to be enthusiastic, given the kind of toxic, roller-coaster, self-serving leadership that our President, Mwai Kibaki, and Prime Minister, Raila Odinga, continue to display here at home. It is a shame tempered only by the knowledge that Obama, one of us, shines by example elsewhere; and that, precisely for that reason and that example, all is not lost.


Didn't Kenneth Marende, Speaker of Kenya's National Assembly, reinforce that essential optimism in the substance and nuance of his Solomonic ruling yesterday afternoon in Parliament, when he declared himself (to the collective relief of the nation) interim Leader of the House Business Committee for as long as Kibaki and Raila Odinga (the One Sigma duo) fail to agree on one, and publicly wrangle? Let Marende hold the seat till 2012, if you ask me! Who knows, perhaps we have just dicovered in him Kenya's Plan B!

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Rethinking Tuesday's Demonstrations by UoN Students

In a twitter I posted in the afternoon of Tuesday, March 10, I remarked that "The student demo got nastier after mid-afternoon. Whispers on campus already that the PM goofed big time by condoning it without reservation."

By "without reservation" I meant that Prime Minister Raila Odinga did not caution the students, whose planned demonstration he had so enthusiastically endorsed on human rights grounds, against the acts of hooliganism which have typically accompanied such demonstrations; that is, until Prof. George Magoha became Vice Chancellor of the University of Nairobi (UoN) about five years ago. One of his main achievements so far as VC is that student riots and general student "lawlessness", which had dogged this university for over three decades, became a thing of the past -- somehow, mysteriously, inexplicably, almost all-of-a-sudden -- as soon as he assumed office. Many of us still shake our heads at the turn-around -- at the peace and quite that the UoN has enjoyed for the last half-decade or so, and at the "possibilities" that they make possible. The Prime Minister's thoughtless act of endorsement was going to put at risk all this, many of us feared even before the scheduled day of demonstration arrived.

Unless one is dangerously out of touch with -- or does not allow oneself a judicious pause to consider the lessons of -- the recent history of student activism at the University of Nairobi, and elsewhere in Kenya, one ought to know that student demonstrations have typically degenerated into worrisome anti-social behaviour of a sort that has impacted negatively, often very negatively, on the human and property rights of other Kenyans, who also deserve protection. The Prime Minister did not have the presence of mind, or even-handedness, to ask the police to protect these other rights -- these other Kenyans. And so Tuesday came to pass as it did.

He did not need to get involved. He should not have been involved. There is no way that the killing of a university student under whatever circumstances would be allowed by the student body to go "unpunished" by way of a rowdy demonstration in the streets, and a few missed lecture-hours besides. As soon as news of the killing broke, we knew that there would be a demo this time. It even took too long to happen. It was not spontaneous, as the moment semed to demand. Perhaps there were behind-the-scenes negotiations on campus, and there were reports of threats against would-be demonstrators. Not even a Prof. Magoha, however, has the "charm" to avoid the eventuality of a demo under those brutal circumstances. So the Prime Minister had no reason or need to publicly, or privately, "restrain" him -- with or without mandate.

Now the police are blaming the PM for the embarassing consequences, and of course he has no real, convincing defence. Student leaders even went to him to apologize and express remorse face-to-face for the bad behaviour of their colleagues on Tuesday afternoon. However, the Prime Minister is yet to express his own remorse to the Kenyans whose rights were infringed upon at his apparent instigation -- and to accept responsibility for the infringement.

Sociologists say, and leaders better be reminded, that acts of commission and acts of omission are both acts -- over which "those who have responsibility" must be held responsible. In a reverse sort of reasoning, irresponsibility confers responsibility, from which one cannot escape.
The Prime Minister deigned to take away the responsibilities of UoN and Egerton University VCs on the matter of general student discipline, though he has no mandate to micro-manage universities or issue direct instructions to the police, and must now accept responsibility for Tuesday's turn of events.

It is precisely due to those events that Prof. Magoha is reported in one of today's newspapers to have asked politicians to stay away from university affairs. I would add: they haven't been quite helpful when and where we truly needed them; for example, when(ever) we were fighting for better terms of service. Instead, they have shed obligatory and crocodile tears. "It was very sad to see them behaving that way and I hope we are allowed to run the university as we should," Prof. Maguha said, and added:
"I was a spectator like everybody else and I would prefer to get instructions
from my employer. How do I take action on those who were rioting when the
protests were sanctioned by someone with more authority than me? They should
have allowed us to take control."
Of course, Raila's diehard supporters have been arguing, none-too-soon, that his PNU opponents took advantage of the occasion by inserting thugs, thuggery and looting into the demonstrations -- all in order to "tarnish his name." That's plausible, alright, but he should have known that he was dangling a temptation they couldn't resist. He should have denied them the opportunity to do just that by staying judiciously away from forever byzantine campus politics. If you ask me, he tarnished his own name all by himself -- a flawed mind-set that has become increasingly and worryingly characteristic since the Grand Coalition was crafted in February 2008 (indeed, some of us push the date back to November 2007). The safest way to not tarnish a name is to do the right thing -- consistently, all the time, all over the place.

Ironically, as it is apparently turning out -- according to postmortem findings of three pathologists and to witness accounts reported in today's newspapers (but which must be corroborated) -- Mr. Godwin Ogato, the student (the third person) whose death more directly prompted the demonstrations, was shot at close range with a pistol; after the police (who were reportedly carrying only G3 and/or AK-47 guns) had retrieved Mr. Paul Oulu's body from the halls and "were driving away."

I think that one of the most serious threats that we encounter and endure in our public and private institutions, of all kinds, is the "Tyranny of the Boss". Just as there is a culture of impunity, there is a culture of tyranny; but it is marked as tyranny only when the shoe is on the other foot. Thus, the boss is all-knowing. The boss has all the answers. The boss is never wrong. No other opinion matters. Don't contradict the boss. The boss has a good name. To criticize the boss is to the boss' name. Leave the boss alone. Don't embarass the boss. The boss knows what he/she is doing, keep to your own corner. The end justifies the means. Give the boss time.

Prof. Magoha would like to see the UoN allowed to run its own affairs itself, from within. Fair enough, but the university is not the VC, and the VC is not the university. The VC must have the humility to acknowledge that there are many smart minds at the UoN. It is simply a fact that there are many who were here long before he joined UoN. These are long-standing bearers of the institution's memory and values -- and indeed the strengths that enabled UoN to weather the many challenges of the Eighties and Nineties, and have made it possible for it to become, at last, what it is today.

University governance, while remaining jealously "within", must itself be broadly inclusive, genuinely consultative and respectfully consensus-based. There has not been enough of that in recent years. Instead, many academics feel excluded from key decisions that deeply affect them, and administrators are intimidated (and the academic staff union apparently co-opted) into "rubber-stamp" silence.

Prof. Magoha is a good man. We get on well -- though I am inclined, as is rather well-known, to speak my mind -- partly because I keep my distance, and partly because I no longer hold an administrative position that requires frequent attendance in the VC's presence. I personally like him, and like it that way. I think he has the capacity to change. It is not too late. That way, we can all, together, meet the rest of the country halfway, with heads held high.

Monday, February 23, 2009

Ruto Wants Waki's Envelope to Head to The Hague, Now!

William Ruto, energized by his emphatic victory against a vote of no confidence moved in Parliament last week, over the maize scandal, has now turned his attention to that other matter of post-election violence, in which nearly everyone believes he was so complicit that his name cannot but be in the list in Waki's envelope. In a surprising move, he declared over the weekend, as reported in the media, that Kofi Annan should take Waki's envelope straight to the Hague. To him, all this talk of a local tribunal and a two-month extension of Waki's deadline is merely a waste of time -- a beating about the bush -- which he will have none of.

In this, Ruto is openly disagreeing with Raila, the Prime Minister, who is mulling another initiative to establish a local tribunal as an alternative to the Hague, despite that idea's recent rejection by a Parliament in which Raila's coalition has a slim majority. And I agree with him. Raila even reported, astonishingly, that Annan had allowed Kenya a two month extension, at most; astonishing because nobody seemed to know that Annan had the mandate to extend/alter Waki's deadline, and nobody, except perhaps Raila, believes that he has. Let's let it go now!

The country's future political health clearly requires a visit to the Hague. The paradox is that a presumed culprit is all for it, while those who would presumably benefit from his fall -- and who would like to see him suffer and out of the way -- rather nervously want to keep him as far away from that same Hague as they possibly can! He wants to go, but they don't want him to -- a perfect sado-masochist bind.

Are there beans they fear he will spill, even as he falls? Might such spilling lead to their own irreparable fall -- their own inevitable path to that same place? I see that Sudan's Al Bashir is increasingly and publicly beside himself with trepidation arising from his own likely indictment by the mighty ICC, a date with which is not a picnic -- and from which, in the end, no one can hide. If Ruto was, he seems no longer to be; but someone else apparently is! What is it that someone knows that Ruto knows that shouldn't be known by Tom, Dick and Harry -- and Wanjiku?

If President Kibaki and Raila -- who on a previous occasion Ruto had said should be the ones going to the Hague (since, he had argued, all post-election violence was carried out in their name) -- want a local tribunal for the spanner-boys, the small men, of the violence, that's fine. However, the big boys should all be headed to the Hague, to meet their match. They can have all the time they want there, as we watch with waning interest from afar. All that may be far from good for many, but it will be good from far for just as many.

Monday, February 09, 2009

William Ruto, Time To Step Aside

Let me add my voice to the intensifying call for William Ruto, Kenya's Minister for Agriculture, to step aside over the maize scandal in the ministry he heads. Accumulating evidence suggests that tycoons and other businessmen allied to him have benefited in corrupt ways from the sale of maize meant for poor and starving Kenyans.

Particularly troublesome have been the claims that his friends and/or business/political associates have made windfall profits from the plight of ordinary citizens. It is alleged in various circles that they recently "procured" thousands of bags of maize at a give-away price from the state-owned National Cereals and Produce Board, without moving the consignment an inch from NCPB premises (One beneficiary, recently appointed by Ruto to a reconstituted NCPB board, was reportedly allocated a whopping 600,000 bags). They then "sold" the produce at inflated prices to millers, who incurred additional cost to transport the maize from NCPB themselves. The millers, of course, eventually passed their cost to the consumers.

Ruto, the erstwhile Youth For KANU '92 activist, sees nothing wrong in any of this -- including why millers were not allowed to buy the maize directly from NCPB -- and claims that it is "a scandal that never was." He has publicly sworn not to resign. Meanwhile, ODM, his political party (he is one of its two Deputy Chairmen), has wrapped its protective if half-hearted arms around him, claiming that he is the victim of NSIS (National Security and Intelligence Services) campaign of character assasination.

If Ruto will not resign, then he must be made to. In fact, the heat must turn on Raila Odinga, the Prime Minister and ODM leader. An increasingly agitated public, which is aware that Ruto is probably also among those in Waki's envelope who are bound for the War Crimes Court at the Hague, will expect Raila to write to the President (as stipulated in the Grand Coalition accord) asking that Ruto be relieved of his duties, at least for now. If Raila does not do so, very soon, then the public's nagging perception that he himself is soft on corruption will only grow.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Kenya: A Tale of Two Prime Ministers, One De Facto and One Ceremonial

Kenya's all-powerful opposition, embodied in ODM, fought spiritedly for the creation of the post of an Executive Prime Minister and a ceremonial President. Alas, what ODM ended up with in the Grand Coalition was the post of, to all intents and purposes, a ceremonial Prime Minister! How did that happen under our very noses, and how is the situation to be rectified within the strict confines of the democratic process?

In an interview with Edmund Sanders of the Los Angeles Times, which appeared on page 8 of Kenya's The Standard on Saturday of 10 January 2009, Raila Odinga made a stunning admission. He stated (indeed "argued") that Mr. Francis Muthaura, the Permanent Secretary in the Office of the President, is (as has always been the case) Kenya's de facto Prime Minister. He made this remark when asked about his relations with Mwai Kibaki, who even in the Grand Coalition government remains, constitutionally, the country's Executive President -- meaning that he is at once the head-of-state, the head of government and commander in chief of the armed forces. Here is the verbatim answer (I have highlighted the main point):
"It's fairly positive and cordial. We have weekly meetings in which we compare notes and agree on agendas. The problem really is with people you call the president's men, the powers behind the throne. They try to undermine. You find they try to frustrate implementation. There is an office in the civil service that used to be very powerful...permanent secretary of the office of the president. That was the [de facto] prime minister, but headed by a civil servant. He's still there."
He was then asked, "So you are competing with that office?" His answer put a spotlight on how Mr. Muthaura exercised his de facto (indeed constitutional) powers of "supervision and coordination". He worked (always in the name of the President) through the Permanent Secretaries, traditionally the accounting officers of their respective ministries. In this way, he technically bypassed ministers (through whom the Prime Minister was supposed to "supervise and coordinate") government ministries. Here's what Raila said (emphasis mine):
"He's still holding regular meetings with the permanent secretaries [of
government ministries] and giving them instructions.
These president's men want to be like the prefect for the permanent secretaries who supervise the workings of the government, but that is now the function of the prime minister. Sometimes there is a conflict."
The question he was not asked is: does that conflict suggest unconstitutional conduct by Muthaure, or an unresolved "overlap" in the constitutional job descriptions of the Permanent Secretary and the Prime minister? To my mind, there is an ironic "overlap" which should have been sorted out constitutionally before the Grand Coalition agreement was signed last year.

Clearly, ODM was aware of the role that the said Permanent Secretary's office has played since Kenya became a republic. It was ODM's responsibility (and it was in its fundamental interest) to raise the red flag on this -- before the agreement was signed and the flawed duties of office assumed! I think the ODM side was naively satisfied with the (Prime Minister's) job title, forgetting that substantive power, in any corporate entity, lies in the job description. That is an elementary management fact. We should never find ourselves in a situation where two job descriptions are identical; but if we inadvertently do, the way to deal with it is to immediately eliminate one, or to rewrite its description.

Can the situation be reversed along the lines that Raila seems to suggest? That is, can the Prime Minister's job description be enlarged and enriched by stealthily "clawing power from the presidency" -- ostensibly through an "erosion" of day-to-day practice reinforced with well-timed voice (and threats of exit), all of which will make it unnecessary to go the more straightforward constitutional amendment way? Not quite; and even if it were possible, it would be unconstitutional -- and it would be dangerous. I think it is important to respect the rule of law. Law, which is surely an ass we must respect, has effectively given us two Prime Ministers for the value of one (and even one Prime Minister for the value of two), neither of whom is about to cede perfectly legitimate power to the other, simply on the other's muscular say so.

In the Sunday Nation of January 11, 2009 (p. 16), James Orengo claims that Mr. Muthaura is acting illegally. I think he is wrong on this one. Mutula Kilonzo, in the same issue, rejects the suggestion that the office of the Head of Public Service be abolished so that its functions may be performed by the PS in the PM's office -- that, certainly, would be a solution (but Kilonzo dismisses it as attempting a coup). Instead, he argues, "If ODM wants powers of the President, then let them bring a motion to amend the Constitution. There are no shortcuts."

It's not going to be easy to give Raila what Raila wants. So we are stuck with a tale of two Prime Ministers, one de facto and one ceremonial. Ceremonial in the sense that he is most publicly visible in the press conferences and "launching" ceremonies which the Ministers he supervises and coordinates are so clearly fond of. Ceremonial, too, in that, as Raila reckons, the real work he is supposed to do is substantively being done by another!

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Kriegler's Verdict

South Africa's Judge Johann Kriegler, Chair of Kenya's Kriegler Commission (and the person who oversaw South Africa's first post-apartheid elections), held a press conference in Nairobi last Friday, September 19th, at which he highlighted the Commission's findings regarding the controversy and widespread violence that surrounded Kenya's Presidential elections held in December 2007. The Commission's main task had been to determine who actually had won the contest, Kibaki or Raila, and to recommend the way forward.


Why had the Commission been seen as the vehicle for settling the dispute? According to Kofi Annan, "They had considered everything, recount, re-tallying or forensic audit, all agreed an independent committee was the viable option."


What was the verdict of the Kriegler Commission, as reported in the media? First and foremost, that it was impossible to determine who actually won the Presidential contest. Why? Because in the December elections, his Commission had found, "ballot boxes were stuffed all over the country...there was vote-buying, bribery, intimidation, and women were not allowed to stand for certain offices."


And this was not a one-off event. As he had noted on KTN's live TV show Thursday night (see last week's issue of The Standard on Saturday):
"You have been having very bad elections for many years, you have had violence, fraud, vote buying, bribery, intimidation, so election after election you have been prepared for that process... It has now caught up with you and it was a lesson that made Kenyans think of what to do...with what has not been a very good election track record."

Moreover, he added, this "problem of many decades" is:

"...partly the leaders, partly the people, partly your history, partly the electoral commission's fault...everybody has some answering to do for what went wrong that day."

So that now, he said at the press conference:

"If you think it's vital to find out if there was rigging at KICC [where voting results from the country's 210 constituencies were tallied by the Kivuitu-led Electoral Commission] to determine if Raila or Kibaki won...God help you! We could not." And, "If we didn't settle somebody's wish as to who won, I am sorry we are not members of a Jockey Club, we had a job to do."

In his view (in The Standard on Saturday), "The integrity of the process and the credibility of the results were so gravely impaired by...manifold irregularities and defectsthat it is irrelevant whether or not there was actual rigging at the national tally centre. The results are irretrievably polluted."


Hey, wait a minute, a number of commentators have argued: Doesn't that mean that President Kibaki is in office illegally? No, answered the Judge on TV Thursday night, "but I do think the question of the legitimacy of the elections will become a very serious problem in future if people do not decide that they are tired of playing games of democracy and decide that they are entitled to choose their leaders through the ballot."


Clearly, pending specific constitutional reforms, a disputed Presidential election favours any incumbent who believes he/she has won, and on that basis chooses to stay put. On what grounds would the opponent(s) legally, or even forcefully, remove him/her in order to take over? Failure to determine who won does not now, as it did not in January, add any iota of rationale or legitimacy for a Raila takeover. Thus, we can only look to the future for a solution, starting now -- if not yesterday.


One option for the future is to constitutionally mandate the Speaker or Chief Justice, or, in their "absence" (or due to specified incapacity), or their deputies, to assume the office of Acting President while disputed results are sorted out -- even through a fresh election.


Concurrent with this would have to be the requirement that no swearing-in of a new President, or an incumbent in his/her second term, shall take place earlier than 14 days from the date of the announcement of the Presidential election results. This will give time for petitions to be lodged and heard, and will discourage the mischief of hurried and even secretive swearings-in which Kenya has witnessed twice already.


The Kriegler Commission's verdict has, at the very least, put a stamp of judicial authority on an educated view which most thoughtful Kenyans had already silently formed months ago -- as early as January. There are millions of this silent majority, who nevertheless found themselves powerless to influence the post-election turn of events in the crucial first 40 to 60 days or so. Both the President (Kibaki) and the Prime Minister (Raila) have now accepted the verdict, and promised to implement its recommendations. We will just have to wait and see.


Clearly, the Electoral Commission would have to be overhauled, as recommended. However, if there was one item that the Kriegler Commission failed to pay adequate attention to, it was the even greated mess that occurred within the constituencies in relation to Parliamentary and Civic elections. These were so intertwined with the Presidential elections that it is something of a deliberate abdication of duty not to have included in the Commission's terms of reference items specific to these levels, and not to have had something sobstantial to say in the report.


We cannot clean up the presidential election process if we do not also, or first, clean up the process at these lower levels. In very many constituencies, the agents of the presidential candidates were also the agents of their parties' parliamentary and civic candidates -- or vice versa. I saw it in Kisumu Rural. Doing all the dirty work for the presidential candidate, or seeming to, provided a perverse sort of justification (and cover) for doing as much dirty work as was necessary to ensure the parliamentary or civic candidate's own victory.


The corruption is systemic, but has so far been treated as the secret weapon for electoral victory -- which the likes of Kriegler should not be made fully privy to, and certainly should not take away in one "pathetic" instance of inquiry. That's why we'll just have to wait and see.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Gallup Poll: Latest Numbers From Kenya

Results of the most recent Gallup poll in Kenya -- conducted between June 19 and July 9, 2008 -- were released to the media on Monday, September 8th. Though the poll covered a fairly wide range of issues, the two leading newspapers ( Daily Nation and The Standard) headlined the poll results with the public's verdict on the President's and the Prime Minister's performance. So let us start with that.

President Kibaki's approval rating stands at only 63%, while Prime Minister Raila Odinga has a rating of 85%. This large, 22 percentage-point, advantage for the PM is surprising only in its magnitude and not in its skew. It reflects the general perception that the PM has been more visibly active in public affairs than the President, since March. The President's laid-back approach to things (all things considered) is well known, if not legendary. Has it not often been claimed that he never found a fence he didn't (wouldn't?) sit on? In the end, though, he seems to always have it (have things go) his way, doesn't he?

In contrast, Raila thrives on media attention, and is patently indefatigable. Moreover, while the President's role is clearly defined in the constitution, so that Kibaki does not have to endeavour to carve a niche for himself, or to prove himself, the PM's role continues to lack clear definition, and one suspects that Raila seeks to define it, in the public's eye, by word and deed -- on a day-to-day basis -- if those (including him!) who should do so constitutionally are dragging their feet.

In the process, though he is supposed to coordinate, he ends up seeming, or falling to the temptation, to take over the roles he was supposed merely to coordinate. He has been learning on-the-job, without much of local experience to draw on. Jomo Kenyatta's 12-month stint in the PM's seat so long ago (from December 12, 1963 to December 12, 1964) has not been much of a help in the absence of written memoirs and in view of the dramatically different or changed circumstances.

He has, in other words, been learning by doing -- and ruffling some feathers in the process. But the public sees all this as hard work. At least two ministers (Uhuru and Mwakwere) and/or their supporters have publicly complained that the PM is encroaching on their ministerial turf. I suspect that several other ministers have had their feathers just as ruffled -- though the public sees all this as whining, and the whining as not being in the public interest. That's just one step away (isn't it?) from being reshuffled, if it were not for the "letter" of the Grand Coalition agreement.

The truth of the matter, however, is that the PM has a habit of appropriating ministers' shine and basking in their limelight -- and he sucks out all the oxygen from the room. And the point is that he should give ministers a chance to get some credit for work well done, for that is a major component of what motivated public servants thrive on. It would be worrisome, long-term, if, in the structure of our politics, the PM should be the only minister who should shine. It would be worrisome because it would distort our politics and the structure of our public administration.

Let us now turn to other issues covered in the poll. When asked to identify "the most pressing problem that the coalition Government must address", the respondents mentioned the following (the figures in parenthesis represent the percentage of all respondents who mentioned a given problem):

Poverty (17%)
Inflation (17%)
Creating Jobs (11%)
Constitutional Reform (9%)
Unemployment (7%)
Resettlement of Internally Displaced Persons (7%)
Land Reform (7%)
Food Shortage (6%)
Education (3%)
Tax Reduction (2%)
Violence (2%)
Insecurity (2%)
Prosecution of Those Implicated in Post-Election Violence (1%)
Health Care (1%)
Road System (1%)
Water (1%)
Electricity (1%)
Other (1%)
Don't Know or No Response (2%).
[The percentages do not add up to 100]

Nominally, then, the top ten problems are: poverty, inflation, an insufficiency of jobs, constitutional reform, unemployment, IDPs, land reform, food shortage, education and taxation. But we need some aggregation here. That is to say, certain problems can be "collapsed" to give us a shorter list.

The need to create jobs arises only because there is unemployment, and when the two problems are combined into one (say, unemployment) we get to (18%). Poverty and unemployment are twins, and these two give us a "super problem" (even before we include food shortage)accounting for 35% of all responses. In a similar vein, the IDP problem is directly intertwined with the land reform problem, violence and insecurity (which are not in the nominal top ten) and the problem of dealing with perpetrators of post-election violence. Taken together, these five problems account for 19% of the responses.

Based on this re-aggregation, we get the following top 5 problems, which account for 86% of all responses:

1. Unemployment and Poverty (35%)
2. Land Reform, IDPs and related Insecurity and Violence (19%)
3. Inflation (17%)
4. Constitutional Reform (9%)
5. Food Insecurity (6%).

It is surprising that the water problem ranks so low. It would likewise be surprising that constitutional reform is among the top five problems, except that, in the eyes of Kenyans, a successfully concluded constitutional reform agenda would provide a consequential answer to two other problems in the top five: Land Reform... (19%) and Food Insecurity (6%). Inflation compounds unemployment and poverty, as well as food insecurity. It is an ever-present challenge to those who must govern -- and to those who struggle the most, daily, against hand-to-mouth existence.

On top of the list of Kenyan's problems "right now", unquestionably and expectedly, are the twin problems of unemployment and poverty (35%). It would have been surprising if the Gallup poll had found otherwise. But, in that case, did the Gallup poll set out to establish the obvious? Far from it. What is important in the poll result is the relative magnitudes of the problems, as seen by Kenyans at this time. So, we now have a kind of baseline, from which we will track future trends. Who knows: the water problem may begin to rise in subsequent polls, and likewise the health problem. On the other hand, the IDP and land reform problems might decline -- but hopefully only in step with their proper resolution, rather than due to official neglect and a diversion of public attention.

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

The Price of Liberty in Kenya: Grand Coalition versus Grand Opposition

The overwhelming majority of Kenyans agreed, it seems to me, that a Grand Coalition Government was necessary on two purely pragmatic grounds. First, it was the only sure way to prevent the country from falling apart in an orgy of violence following last December's general elections. Second, it was not really possible to determine which candidate had actually won the Presidential race -- much as ODM had claimed, using its own inconclusive and even flawed evidence, that Raila had won without question. And yet, it was clear to nearly everyone, Kibaki and PNU had stolen the Presidential vote -- with a lot of help from Kivuitu and others at ECK.

What was not in dispute was that ODM was the single largest party in the new parliament. Its leader was Raila Amolo Odinga. So when Koffi Annan eventually brokered a compromise at the end of last February, it was clear that power-sharing would have to be spearheaded by Kibaki and Raila. Since Kibaki was not going to give up the President's seat -- being, inter alia, the incumbent -- and nobody, not even Raila, had the wherewithall or wits to ease him out, the only viable option was to create the Executive Prime Minister's seat for Raila, and to work out a formula for equal power-sharing at the cabinet and other levels (in particular, at the level of Assistant Ministers, Permanent Secretaries, Ambassadors and High Commissioners, and top positions in the parastatals). Surrogates were to negotiate details of the deal, with the two principals having the final say regarding issues on which the negotiators failed to agree. Eventually, there was no real agreement between the negotiating teams, and the two principals decided to take the bull by the horn at Sagana.

The size and composition of the cabinet, and the apportioning of ministries between PNU and ODM, as agreed at Sagana, clearly signalled to most Kenyans that ODM had been seriously, if not cynically, short-changed. Kibaki, long dismissed as indecisive and incapable of standing toe-to-toe with Raila (Agwambo), had not only outwitted Raila but also proved to be a savvier negotiator. In the process, he had exposed to the wider public a character flaw in Raila which some close observers of Raila's public life have for some time now quietly worried and/or grumbled about -- not without a large dose of despair and even exasperation.

The flaw is, simply, that when left alone with "the other side," he is more likely than not to end up siding/agreeing with that side -- to his side's chagrin. Some observers believe that they have figured him out even more finely, arguing that what drives Raila is not any malice toward any friend or ally -- but purely and simply self-interest (regardless of the consequences).

Raila argues that the power-sharing was more than numerically equitable, if you look at it all with a fine tooth-comb. But no one believes him. Not even his thousands of fanatical, long suffering, followers in Kisumu City and its environs -- as the events of last Saturday suggest. He argues, moreover, that the ministries that he negotiated with Kibaki for ODM were fairly distributed among the ODM fraternity. But no one believes that either -- with the possible exception of the actual beneficiaries of that rather skewed distribution. There is considerable disquiet about that skewness in Rift Valley and Nyanza, and even parts of Western Province -- all bedrock of ODM support. And there is exasperation that he did not get the ministries of foreign affairs and finance.

Now, as I see it, it is this disquiet that is driving the call for a Grand Opposition in parliament -- to be underpinned by an act of parliament for additional political cover. And Raila is, of course, vehemently opposed to the idea. Is there any merit -- is there a compelling reason -- for the Grand Opposition?

In principle, Raila is right. There should be no grounds whatsoever for members of a party, elected to parliament under its banner, to technically decamp to another grouping of whatever kind -- for this has the very real potential of taking away, extra-democratically, their party's legitimately won parliamentary/legislative power. Parliamentary majority represents any party's understanding of the very basis of parliamentary/legislative power in a multi-party democracy. It is what drives all inter-party contests during and between general elections. It is why party discipline is taken so seriously. A party's parliamentary voting block is its only armament.

Proponents of a legislated Grand Opposition, on the other hand, argue that they are driven by an equally, if not loftier, principle: keeping the country from sliding back into a de facto one-party state. That is, creating a circuit-breaker against those who might be tempted to revive the Moi-era type of dictatorship. They imagine that only a Grand Opposition can resonate with the public as the people's voice, quite distinct from the government's voice. Moreover, only such a legislated Grand Opposition would qualify as an official opposition -- and an official opposition is provided for in the constitution. In their view, the Grand Coalition violates this important constitutional provision.

Yet it can equally or more persuasively be argued that what gives potency to the call for a Grand Coalition is a set of very pragmatic considerations -- not quite considerations of principle. One, ODM is controlled by a hard-core of self-centred individuals who, unless kept constantly on their toes, will simply use party and governmental structures to favour themselves and reward their cronies, while using party discipline to put rebellious backbenchers themselves on a short leash. The backbenchers seek to avoid the danger of being "whipped" at will to support all programmes and motions, even of questionable value, tabled in parliament by their colleagues "in government". They do not want to be denied by the party hierarchy the opportunity to participate meaningfully in setting parliament's agenda and running its committees. They do not want to be compelled to look the other way when bad governance rears its head.

Two, ODM backbenchers, in particular, have seen how dismally their "principal" performed during his final negotiations with Kibaki for cabinet and Permanent Secretary slots. They are bound to wonder how many more skewed deals between the President and the Prime Minister they can endure in silence till the next general elections. More specifically, they fear that the government agenda for the next five years will be PNU-driven, at the expense of broad-based ODM interests. They fear, moreover, that the Prime Minister does not see the danger, given his poor one-on-one negotiating skills. They can point to how the IDP issue is being handled as another clear evidence of this. In their view, it has been mandled hurriedly, one-sidedly, without due regard to history, and with Raila's acquiescence.

Since the 1980s, Raila has cultivated the political persona of a fearless, unstoppable representative of the people's will -- and a fearsome adversary with a fanatical power-base. The political brand he has created is next to none in Kenya and the region. He has rightfully earned the nickname Agwambo. So it was in amazement that the massive rally in Kisumu last Saturday, and the millions who tuned to their TVs or radio, heard him characterize ODM's entry into the Coalition Government as a surrender. "He who surrenders lives to fight another day," he argued. It might have been a slip of the tongue. The saying is,correctly, "He who retreats lives to..." He seemed to have realized the misspeak, as he immediately added the Maoist phrase "Two steps forward, one step backward" -- which captures the notion of inexorable forward-motion, despite short-term reverses. But what the audience heard was "surrender!" The live audience did not seem to like much of what he had to say that day, and was very loud about it -- and that must be a worry.

In Kisumu, and at Bondo, he was particularly worked up about the idea of a Grand Opposition. He argued that it was unnecessary and intended to undermine the government -- of which ODM was now, belatedly to be sure, a part. He asked its proponents, whom he labelled frustrated self-seekers, to resign and seek a fresh mandate from the voters.

But the proponents are already accusing him and others opposed to the move(such as ODM-K's Kalonzo Musyoka) of "dictatorial and draconian" tendencies, and of personalizing the issue. They insist that they will carry on, and will not resign their parliamentary seats. It is not known, however, wnat would happen to the Grand Opposition if its proponents -- particularly Isaac Ruto, Ababu Namwamba and Julius Kones -- were to be offered Assistant Minister positions tomorrow; or if they were to be thrown out of their political parties, forcing them to stand for re-election.

Having written the bulk of the foregoing yesterday, I now read in today's (Wednesday's) local daily that the Speaker of the National Assembly, Mr. Kenneth Marende, yesterday threw a spanner in the works. He announced that backbench MPs were free to form a Grand Opposition without having to stand for re-election. There was, indeed, as he pointed out, a provision for an opposition in parliament, although parliament could expunge the provision if it deemed it detrimental. Clearly, however, expunging it would require the concurrence of the 85 or so MPs who already support the Grand Opposition, and whose support would be required to deliver the new constitution promised by ODM by April 2009.

On largely pragmatic grounds, I think the Grand Coalition is a good idea whose time has suddenly, surprisingly, emphatically, come. It is an idea which was hardly conceivable even two months ago. It is intended to undermine the Prime Minister. Rather, it underscores the old adage that the price of liberty is eternal vigilance. The Prime Minister should support it for the good of the country, and for his own good. Do I think that we will have a new constitution by April 2009? We may have a new constitution, but not the kind of comprehensive constitution which ODM has been promising. Far from it, given the twists and turns we have witnessed since January 2008.

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Nine-Point Road Map to a More Inclusive Constitution By Jamhuri Day, 2005.

By

Prof. Mauri Yambo

[Nairobi: September 22, 2005]

INTRODUCTION: In the afternoon of September 22, 2005, UASU Nairobi Chapter hosted a panel-forum in Taifa Hall, University of Nairobi. The panel was chaired by Dr. Winnie Mitula (Chairperson of UASU Nairobi Chapter). The panellists included Prof. V. Simiyu (History), Prof. P. Wanyande (Political Science), myself (Sociology) and several others. The following nine points constituted my initial submission. This post is published purely for the record, as it has clearly been overtaken by events. Or has it, entirely?

1. Do not postpone the referendum scheduled for November 21, 2005. Instead, deal with the contentious issues and table the necessary amendments to the Wako Bill in Parliament. It can be done. It must be done.

2. Adopt the Bomas provisions for the appointment of a Prime Minister. In the interest of Multi-party and Parliamentary democracy, the PM should be “the member of the Assembly who is the leader of the of the largest political party, or coalition of parties, represented in the Assembly.” If he/she is “unable to command the confidence of the Assembly,” then the Bomas Plan B should come into force. However, if within sixty days Parliament is still unable to agree on a Prime Minister, then, instead of dissolving the Assembly at this juncture, the President should have the power to appoint a Prime Minister from among the members of Parliament who will immediately assume his/her duties and proceed to establish a “Government of National Unity” or a “Grand Coalition.” Should this effort fail in the next thirty days, then the President should dissolve Parliament and call fresh general elections.

3. In order to secure our multi-party democracy, no MP should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister without the written consent of his/her political party; and, in any case, no MP who is not a member of the ruling or grand coalition should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister[1].

4. Our political history suggests that if we are to secure party loyalty and discipline, strengthen the Assembly’s watchdog role and reinforce the principle of “separation of powers,”then we must entrench in the Constitution the requirement that all party coalitions be concluded and formalized in writing, and be signed by persons competent to do so and representing the respective parties in the coalition. Each party must attach to the coalition document a supporting resolution adopted by its executive body. Copies of the coalition agreement, and the supporting resolutions, must be deposited with the Speaker of the Assembly.

5. Members of the National Assembly appointed Minister or Deputy Minister should retain their seats in the Assembly, and no person who is not a member of the National Assembly should be appointed Minister or Deputy Minister.

6. A specific formula should be inserted in the constitution to entrench the principle that not less than one third of all seats in the National Assembly shall be occupied by women. The formula should establish “Supra Constituencies,” whose boundaries should coincide with those of a district or a combination of contiguous districts, as the Electoral and Boundaries Commission may determine from time to time, in such a way as to ensure that one third of all National Assembly seats shall always be available for contest by women at a general election.

7. While the President shall be both the Head of State and Head of Government, the Prime Minister shall be the Leader of Government Business both within and outside Parliament. As proposed in the Bomas draft, the President shall appoint and dismiss the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister shall nominate, and the President shall appoint, the two Deputy Prime Ministers and “not less than fifteen or more than twenty ministers and deputy ministers,”subject to approval by Parliament. Contrary to Bomas, however, Cabinet meetings shall be chaired by the President, and in his/her absence (or upon written delegation by the President) by the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister “shall co-ordinate the work of the ministries and the preparation of legislation, and is responsible to [both the President and] Parliament.”

8. Consistent with the foregoing, the President should have all the other functions stipulated in the Bomas draft.

9. Parliament must retain the power to pass a vote of no confidence in the President, the Deputy President, the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Ministers, the Ministers and Deputy Ministers.



[1] This would entrench Section 17, subsection 5, of The National Assembly and Presidential Elections Act (CAP 7), which states that: “No person who is elected or nominated as a member of the National Assembly with the support of or as a supporter of a political party (other than the party whose candidate has been elected President [change that to read “other than a party in the ruling coalition] at an election) shall be appointed Minister [or Deputy Minister] of the Government of Kenya under section 16 of the Constitution without the concurrence of the party which supported him for election or nominated him...”