It was supposed to be a somber prayer and fund-raising occasion at the Kenyatta International Conference Centre, Nairobi, yesterday, for the victims of the recent Nakumatt Downtown and Sachang'wan fire disasters. The guests of honour were Kenya's President and Prime Minister. There were prayers, indeed, and some Kshs. 80,000,000 (or just over US$1 million) was raised -- a near-record of sorts, I understand. There was much more, as the unexpected stole the show to drive home the public's outrage at rampant high-level stealing in public offices. The dailies reported the proceedings in detail.
In an obviously pre-meditated move, five of Kenya's leading clerics, under the umbrella of the Inter-Religious Forum, seized the opportunity of the nationally televised occassion to put a spotlight on the leaders' failure to lead, and their "beggar thy subject" governmentality. They touched on the problems of internally displaced persons, youth unemployment and extra-judicial killings, noting that no obvious or genuine effort was being made to solve any.
Archbishop Nzimbi, of the Anglican Church, led the charge against shameless plunder of public assets, and even threatened mass action. Prof. Abdulghafur El-Busaidy, of the Supreme Council of Kenya Muslims, saw politicians as "the greatest threat to peace and prosperity," and forcefully accused them of dividing Kenyans along ethnic lines, unilaterally increasing their own allowances and refusing to pay tax. Bishop Adoyo, of the Evangelical Alliance of Kenya, pointedly told the leaders, "You have been reluctant to punish some of your perceived friends who are corrupt and greedy...We urge you to take charge and restore equity, justice, unity and dignity of all Kenyans." The people, he noted, were "discouraged, ashamed, disillusioned and angry." The other men of the cloth were just as critical, emphasizing that Kibaki and Raila were presiding over grand corruption.
The two principals of the Grand Coalition government should be getting used to this sort of thing -- this public rebuke by people they cannot fire but might be tempted to "silence" -- as it will not cease while they continue to watch as their colleagues and appointees engage in a corrupt feeding-frenzy. Namwamba, of the stalled Grand Opposition, may have been incorporated into, or compromised by, a system which is bent on monopolizing all political power; but silencing Voice is a hard thing. It just keeps popping up. The thing is not to silence it, but to answer it -- and not with empty, faded, pathetic promises, or a plea for more time.
Just a week ago an Anglican cleric was reported by the media to have received an immediate tongue lashing from Raila in Bondo, during Jaramogi Odinga's anniversary services, for declaring that the Coalition Government had failed the people. Raila wanted the coalition, which had not even marked its first anniversary (which comes on February 28th), to be judged less harshly and, in particular, to be given more time to deliver on its promises. I see a connection between the harsh rebuke of the cleric in Bondo and the uncompromising stand taken by the clerics in Nairobi (where Raila opted for relative silence) and Kisumu a week later.
Kenyans are past being deceived with posturings and promises and words -- their own words regurgitated by luminaries bent on building political dynasties and family fortunes in the billions (of $s, Sterling, Euros, or whatever), even as they, the people, knowingly watch.
Deeds, man, deeds!
Showing posts with label KICC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label KICC. Show all posts
Friday, February 20, 2009
A Foul Governmentality
Labels:
Adoyo,
Anglican,
Bondo,
Corruption,
El-Busaidy,
Evangelical,
Governmentality,
Grand Coalition,
Jaramogi Odinga,
Kenya,
Kibaki,
KICC,
Muslim,
Nairobi,
Nakumatt,
Namwamba,
Nzimbi,
Raila,
Sachang'wan
Tuesday, September 23, 2008
Kriegler's Verdict
South Africa's Judge Johann Kriegler, Chair of Kenya's Kriegler Commission (and the person who oversaw South Africa's first post-apartheid elections), held a press conference in Nairobi last Friday, September 19th, at which he highlighted the Commission's findings regarding the controversy and widespread violence that surrounded Kenya's Presidential elections held in December 2007. The Commission's main task had been to determine who actually had won the contest, Kibaki or Raila, and to recommend the way forward.
Why had the Commission been seen as the vehicle for settling the dispute? According to Kofi Annan, "They had considered everything, recount, re-tallying or forensic audit, all agreed an independent committee was the viable option."
What was the verdict of the Kriegler Commission, as reported in the media? First and foremost, that it was impossible to determine who actually won the Presidential contest. Why? Because in the December elections, his Commission had found, "ballot boxes were stuffed all over the country...there was vote-buying, bribery, intimidation, and women were not allowed to stand for certain offices."
And this was not a one-off event. As he had noted on KTN's live TV show Thursday night (see last week's issue of The Standard on Saturday):
Moreover, he added, this "problem of many decades" is:
So that now, he said at the press conference:
In his view (in The Standard on Saturday), "The integrity of the process and the credibility of the results were so gravely impaired by...manifold irregularities and defectsthat it is irrelevant whether or not there was actual rigging at the national tally centre. The results are irretrievably polluted."
Hey, wait a minute, a number of commentators have argued: Doesn't that mean that President Kibaki is in office illegally? No, answered the Judge on TV Thursday night, "but I do think the question of the legitimacy of the elections will become a very serious problem in future if people do not decide that they are tired of playing games of democracy and decide that they are entitled to choose their leaders through the ballot."
Clearly, pending specific constitutional reforms, a disputed Presidential election favours any incumbent who believes he/she has won, and on that basis chooses to stay put. On what grounds would the opponent(s) legally, or even forcefully, remove him/her in order to take over? Failure to determine who won does not now, as it did not in January, add any iota of rationale or legitimacy for a Raila takeover. Thus, we can only look to the future for a solution, starting now -- if not yesterday.
One option for the future is to constitutionally mandate the Speaker or Chief Justice, or, in their "absence" (or due to specified incapacity), or their deputies, to assume the office of Acting President while disputed results are sorted out -- even through a fresh election.
Concurrent with this would have to be the requirement that no swearing-in of a new President, or an incumbent in his/her second term, shall take place earlier than 14 days from the date of the announcement of the Presidential election results. This will give time for petitions to be lodged and heard, and will discourage the mischief of hurried and even secretive swearings-in which Kenya has witnessed twice already.
The Kriegler Commission's verdict has, at the very least, put a stamp of judicial authority on an educated view which most thoughtful Kenyans had already silently formed months ago -- as early as January. There are millions of this silent majority, who nevertheless found themselves powerless to influence the post-election turn of events in the crucial first 40 to 60 days or so. Both the President (Kibaki) and the Prime Minister (Raila) have now accepted the verdict, and promised to implement its recommendations. We will just have to wait and see.
Clearly, the Electoral Commission would have to be overhauled, as recommended. However, if there was one item that the Kriegler Commission failed to pay adequate attention to, it was the even greated mess that occurred within the constituencies in relation to Parliamentary and Civic elections. These were so intertwined with the Presidential elections that it is something of a deliberate abdication of duty not to have included in the Commission's terms of reference items specific to these levels, and not to have had something sobstantial to say in the report.
We cannot clean up the presidential election process if we do not also, or first, clean up the process at these lower levels. In very many constituencies, the agents of the presidential candidates were also the agents of their parties' parliamentary and civic candidates -- or vice versa. I saw it in Kisumu Rural. Doing all the dirty work for the presidential candidate, or seeming to, provided a perverse sort of justification (and cover) for doing as much dirty work as was necessary to ensure the parliamentary or civic candidate's own victory.
The corruption is systemic, but has so far been treated as the secret weapon for electoral victory -- which the likes of Kriegler should not be made fully privy to, and certainly should not take away in one "pathetic" instance of inquiry. That's why we'll just have to wait and see.
Why had the Commission been seen as the vehicle for settling the dispute? According to Kofi Annan, "They had considered everything, recount, re-tallying or forensic audit, all agreed an independent committee was the viable option."
What was the verdict of the Kriegler Commission, as reported in the media? First and foremost, that it was impossible to determine who actually won the Presidential contest. Why? Because in the December elections, his Commission had found, "ballot boxes were stuffed all over the country...there was vote-buying, bribery, intimidation, and women were not allowed to stand for certain offices."
And this was not a one-off event. As he had noted on KTN's live TV show Thursday night (see last week's issue of The Standard on Saturday):
"You have been having very bad elections for many years, you have had violence, fraud, vote buying, bribery, intimidation, so election after election you have been prepared for that process... It has now caught up with you and it was a lesson that made Kenyans think of what to do...with what has not been a very good election track record."
Moreover, he added, this "problem of many decades" is:
"...partly the leaders, partly the people, partly your history, partly the electoral commission's fault...everybody has some answering to do for what went wrong that day."
So that now, he said at the press conference:
"If you think it's vital to find out if there was rigging at KICC [where voting results from the country's 210 constituencies were tallied by the Kivuitu-led Electoral Commission] to determine if Raila or Kibaki won...God help you! We could not." And, "If we didn't settle somebody's wish as to who won, I am sorry we are not members of a Jockey Club, we had a job to do."
In his view (in The Standard on Saturday), "The integrity of the process and the credibility of the results were so gravely impaired by...manifold irregularities and defectsthat it is irrelevant whether or not there was actual rigging at the national tally centre. The results are irretrievably polluted."
Hey, wait a minute, a number of commentators have argued: Doesn't that mean that President Kibaki is in office illegally? No, answered the Judge on TV Thursday night, "but I do think the question of the legitimacy of the elections will become a very serious problem in future if people do not decide that they are tired of playing games of democracy and decide that they are entitled to choose their leaders through the ballot."
Clearly, pending specific constitutional reforms, a disputed Presidential election favours any incumbent who believes he/she has won, and on that basis chooses to stay put. On what grounds would the opponent(s) legally, or even forcefully, remove him/her in order to take over? Failure to determine who won does not now, as it did not in January, add any iota of rationale or legitimacy for a Raila takeover. Thus, we can only look to the future for a solution, starting now -- if not yesterday.
One option for the future is to constitutionally mandate the Speaker or Chief Justice, or, in their "absence" (or due to specified incapacity), or their deputies, to assume the office of Acting President while disputed results are sorted out -- even through a fresh election.
Concurrent with this would have to be the requirement that no swearing-in of a new President, or an incumbent in his/her second term, shall take place earlier than 14 days from the date of the announcement of the Presidential election results. This will give time for petitions to be lodged and heard, and will discourage the mischief of hurried and even secretive swearings-in which Kenya has witnessed twice already.
The Kriegler Commission's verdict has, at the very least, put a stamp of judicial authority on an educated view which most thoughtful Kenyans had already silently formed months ago -- as early as January. There are millions of this silent majority, who nevertheless found themselves powerless to influence the post-election turn of events in the crucial first 40 to 60 days or so. Both the President (Kibaki) and the Prime Minister (Raila) have now accepted the verdict, and promised to implement its recommendations. We will just have to wait and see.
Clearly, the Electoral Commission would have to be overhauled, as recommended. However, if there was one item that the Kriegler Commission failed to pay adequate attention to, it was the even greated mess that occurred within the constituencies in relation to Parliamentary and Civic elections. These were so intertwined with the Presidential elections that it is something of a deliberate abdication of duty not to have included in the Commission's terms of reference items specific to these levels, and not to have had something sobstantial to say in the report.
We cannot clean up the presidential election process if we do not also, or first, clean up the process at these lower levels. In very many constituencies, the agents of the presidential candidates were also the agents of their parties' parliamentary and civic candidates -- or vice versa. I saw it in Kisumu Rural. Doing all the dirty work for the presidential candidate, or seeming to, provided a perverse sort of justification (and cover) for doing as much dirty work as was necessary to ensure the parliamentary or civic candidate's own victory.
The corruption is systemic, but has so far been treated as the secret weapon for electoral victory -- which the likes of Kriegler should not be made fully privy to, and certainly should not take away in one "pathetic" instance of inquiry. That's why we'll just have to wait and see.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)