Showing posts with label Grand Coalition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Grand Coalition. Show all posts

Friday, February 20, 2009

A Foul Governmentality

It was supposed to be a somber prayer and fund-raising occasion at the Kenyatta International Conference Centre, Nairobi, yesterday, for the victims of the recent Nakumatt Downtown and Sachang'wan fire disasters. The guests of honour were Kenya's President and Prime Minister. There were prayers, indeed, and some Kshs. 80,000,000 (or just over US$1 million) was raised -- a near-record of sorts, I understand. There was much more, as the unexpected stole the show to drive home the public's outrage at rampant high-level stealing in public offices. The dailies reported the proceedings in detail.

In an obviously pre-meditated move, five of Kenya's leading clerics, under the umbrella of the Inter-Religious Forum, seized the opportunity of the nationally televised occassion to put a spotlight on the leaders' failure to lead, and their "beggar thy subject" governmentality. They touched on the problems of internally displaced persons, youth unemployment and extra-judicial killings, noting that no obvious or genuine effort was being made to solve any.

Archbishop Nzimbi, of the Anglican Church, led the charge against shameless plunder of public assets, and even threatened mass action. Prof. Abdulghafur El-Busaidy, of the Supreme Council of Kenya Muslims, saw politicians as "the greatest threat to peace and prosperity," and forcefully accused them of dividing Kenyans along ethnic lines, unilaterally increasing their own allowances and refusing to pay tax. Bishop Adoyo, of the Evangelical Alliance of Kenya, pointedly told the leaders, "You have been reluctant to punish some of your perceived friends who are corrupt and greedy...We urge you to take charge and restore equity, justice, unity and dignity of all Kenyans." The people, he noted, were "discouraged, ashamed, disillusioned and angry." The other men of the cloth were just as critical, emphasizing that Kibaki and Raila were presiding over grand corruption.

The two principals of the Grand Coalition government should be getting used to this sort of thing -- this public rebuke by people they cannot fire but might be tempted to "silence" -- as it will not cease while they continue to watch as their colleagues and appointees engage in a corrupt feeding-frenzy. Namwamba, of the stalled Grand Opposition, may have been incorporated into, or compromised by, a system which is bent on monopolizing all political power; but silencing Voice is a hard thing. It just keeps popping up. The thing is not to silence it, but to answer it -- and not with empty, faded, pathetic promises, or a plea for more time.

Just a week ago an Anglican cleric was reported by the media to have received an immediate tongue lashing from Raila in Bondo, during Jaramogi Odinga's anniversary services, for declaring that the Coalition Government had failed the people. Raila wanted the coalition, which had not even marked its first anniversary (which comes on February 28th), to be judged less harshly and, in particular, to be given more time to deliver on its promises. I see a connection between the harsh rebuke of the cleric in Bondo and the uncompromising stand taken by the clerics in Nairobi (where Raila opted for relative silence) and Kisumu a week later.

Kenyans are past being deceived with posturings and promises and words -- their own words regurgitated by luminaries bent on building political dynasties and family fortunes in the billions (of $s, Sterling, Euros, or whatever), even as they, the people, knowingly watch.

Deeds, man, deeds!

Monday, February 09, 2009

William Ruto, Time To Step Aside

Let me add my voice to the intensifying call for William Ruto, Kenya's Minister for Agriculture, to step aside over the maize scandal in the ministry he heads. Accumulating evidence suggests that tycoons and other businessmen allied to him have benefited in corrupt ways from the sale of maize meant for poor and starving Kenyans.

Particularly troublesome have been the claims that his friends and/or business/political associates have made windfall profits from the plight of ordinary citizens. It is alleged in various circles that they recently "procured" thousands of bags of maize at a give-away price from the state-owned National Cereals and Produce Board, without moving the consignment an inch from NCPB premises (One beneficiary, recently appointed by Ruto to a reconstituted NCPB board, was reportedly allocated a whopping 600,000 bags). They then "sold" the produce at inflated prices to millers, who incurred additional cost to transport the maize from NCPB themselves. The millers, of course, eventually passed their cost to the consumers.

Ruto, the erstwhile Youth For KANU '92 activist, sees nothing wrong in any of this -- including why millers were not allowed to buy the maize directly from NCPB -- and claims that it is "a scandal that never was." He has publicly sworn not to resign. Meanwhile, ODM, his political party (he is one of its two Deputy Chairmen), has wrapped its protective if half-hearted arms around him, claiming that he is the victim of NSIS (National Security and Intelligence Services) campaign of character assasination.

If Ruto will not resign, then he must be made to. In fact, the heat must turn on Raila Odinga, the Prime Minister and ODM leader. An increasingly agitated public, which is aware that Ruto is probably also among those in Waki's envelope who are bound for the War Crimes Court at the Hague, will expect Raila to write to the President (as stipulated in the Grand Coalition accord) asking that Ruto be relieved of his duties, at least for now. If Raila does not do so, very soon, then the public's nagging perception that he himself is soft on corruption will only grow.

Monday, June 30, 2008

A Peace-Keeping Force For Zimbabwe? An Idea Whose Time Will Not Come

Does anyone seriously think that either AU or UN forces are going to be sent to restore or keep the peace in Zimbabwe any time soon, or in the foreseeable future? I certainly don't. And one may even ask: To keep what peace? Dictator Mugabe is back in power, thanks in no small measure to Tsvangirai's weak will.

In the aftermath of last week's election runoff (the results of which were this time announced with speed), Tsvangirai and his MDC will have even less negotiating clout than Raila and ODM had in Kenya earlier this year. It seems to me that the Zanu-PF lot have deep contempt for Tsvangirai's leadership. It seems that they knew something about his character that the rest of us are only beginning to come to terms with.

He clearly is no Raila, and no Ruto -- and yet we all know how unsatisfactory to many of ODM's supporters the Kenyan dealmaking itself was. Tsvangirai can expect far less than that -- and little more than crumbs from Mugabe's table, insistent though he is, partly from the safety of the Dutch embassy, that talks for some kind of Grand Coalition begin.

The best he can do for the people of Zimbabwe after the election fiasco, for which he is substantially responsible by default, is to step aside for the likes of Biti and Dr. Makoni -- who seem to have more courage.

Certainly, Mugabe must go (though, now, God only knows when). But so must Tsvangirai!

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

On the Importance of Being Namwamba

Just three months ago, as I have exclaimed elsewhere, who would have imagined that Kenya's talking heads would be as embroiled in the Grand Opposition debate as they are? I didn't. Still, I am certainly enjoying this enthralling phase of our political evolution. Enthralling, that is, if Namwamba and his team don't betray the cause.

It's all been very dialectical. First, the general election of December 2007. Then the disputed presidential election results. Then the chaos and the blood-letting. "Den cometh Koffi, den de peace -- which only a true peacemaker bringeth." Then Kibaki and Raila negotiate an unbelievably skewed distribution of cabinet slots. Then the fallout of disappointment at Raila's performance, left alone with Kibaki. In Kisumu, that disappointment exploded a few weeks ago into what must be the first true expression of proletarian (and semi-proletarian) disenchantment with the dominant power structure in those parts! The rest, as one might say, is this unfolding -- this current -- history that we are very much a part of.

On the night Kenya's parliament elected the new speaker, my impression of Namwamba was of someone who needed to grow up a just little more. Less than three months later, he has become the symbol, the robust new face, of Kenya's never-say-die politics. In a way, he is the new Orengo (and perhaps Raila, if he can secure a solid political base).

How did things change so fast that Raila, the doyen of opposition politics, is now seen as the apologist for an established political order of which he is only tenuously a part; the defender of a status quo which seeks to concentrate political power (and then economic power) in the hands of the very wenyewe whom the Second Liberation was supposed to "drive out of town"? Whichever way it happened, it is the very reason for the rise of Namwamba and his team -- motley as it is, and flawed as some of its members are.

"We are now in government," Raila reminds the team (in an earlier day they would have been the vinyangalika) -- who must be shown and kept in their place. If they want to form a Grand Opposition, then they must resign from parliament and seek fresh mandate from the people under the banner of parties of their choice. Certainly not ODM or PNU, without which they (with the exception of Jirongo and only a fistful more) would not be in parliament now.

Since ODM and PNU are in government, he reasons, and their members cannot be both in government and opposition. That, in his view, is an irreconcilable contradiction. The cabinet even convinced itself that it had the power to veto the Grand Coalition. Veto it as what? As an insolent thought? As a piece of legislation yet to be tabled? Then ODM called a meeting at Safari Park Hotel to thrash out this apparent confusion of memes. According to reports, however, only some 40 out of 96 ODM MPs (including Namwamba and "the little Ruto") attended. There was a stalemate.

I don't know what Namwamba's career path is going to be in the years and decades to come, but right now he has a very important role to play -- a role so dramatically abandoned by Raila at potentially the moment of his greatest triumph yet. Right now, Ababu (Don't-abandon-the-cause) Namwamba is the symbol of hope for a system of governance with proper checks and balances -- a system disdainful of private interest masquerading as public interest.

The idea of the Grand Opposition is borne of necessity. With almost everybody in government now, it is something of a deception, and politically fraudulent, to insist that Namwamba and his team seek to establish what could equally be achieved by the back bench -- achieved, that is, without in the process ruffling the feathers of the mighty. In the present circumstances, clearly, the back bench would be a divide-and-rule device, a smokescreen for grand mischief. As a solution, it is highly unsatisfactory vis-a-vis the right of the people to express and realize their will, unfettered, through their elected representatives. It is indeed a corrosion and even a negation of that right. And it displays a basic and hidden fear, on the part of those who would use the parliamentary system to ascend to power, of the principle of advice-and-consent -- in the true meaning of the term -- which ought to govern all democratic discourse.

So such negations must in turn, or preemptively, be negated. It is all very dialectical, as I said. But our history is peopled by individuals who rose on the back of the people's aspirations for a good life, only to succumb to the lure of personal aggrandizement, or the fear (in the face of unrelenting intimidation and assault) of unbearable personal loss. I don't know how Namwamba will deal with such pressure, which will surely come. But let him run the good race. As long as he can, let him carry the baton -- in this race whose length, in time and space, no one can tell. Someone will surely be there when it is time to pass the baton. Namwamba's historic significance is that he was there when it needed to be passed.

And his team should take solace in the fact that those opposed to the Grand Opposition will soon ask for its support to pass in parliament whatever version of the new constitution the Grand Coalition will craft for the people's approval. The time for a quid pro quo awaits in the near distance -- near, yes, but out of view for the near-sighted who want to eat their cake and have it.

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

The Price of Liberty in Kenya: Grand Coalition versus Grand Opposition

The overwhelming majority of Kenyans agreed, it seems to me, that a Grand Coalition Government was necessary on two purely pragmatic grounds. First, it was the only sure way to prevent the country from falling apart in an orgy of violence following last December's general elections. Second, it was not really possible to determine which candidate had actually won the Presidential race -- much as ODM had claimed, using its own inconclusive and even flawed evidence, that Raila had won without question. And yet, it was clear to nearly everyone, Kibaki and PNU had stolen the Presidential vote -- with a lot of help from Kivuitu and others at ECK.

What was not in dispute was that ODM was the single largest party in the new parliament. Its leader was Raila Amolo Odinga. So when Koffi Annan eventually brokered a compromise at the end of last February, it was clear that power-sharing would have to be spearheaded by Kibaki and Raila. Since Kibaki was not going to give up the President's seat -- being, inter alia, the incumbent -- and nobody, not even Raila, had the wherewithall or wits to ease him out, the only viable option was to create the Executive Prime Minister's seat for Raila, and to work out a formula for equal power-sharing at the cabinet and other levels (in particular, at the level of Assistant Ministers, Permanent Secretaries, Ambassadors and High Commissioners, and top positions in the parastatals). Surrogates were to negotiate details of the deal, with the two principals having the final say regarding issues on which the negotiators failed to agree. Eventually, there was no real agreement between the negotiating teams, and the two principals decided to take the bull by the horn at Sagana.

The size and composition of the cabinet, and the apportioning of ministries between PNU and ODM, as agreed at Sagana, clearly signalled to most Kenyans that ODM had been seriously, if not cynically, short-changed. Kibaki, long dismissed as indecisive and incapable of standing toe-to-toe with Raila (Agwambo), had not only outwitted Raila but also proved to be a savvier negotiator. In the process, he had exposed to the wider public a character flaw in Raila which some close observers of Raila's public life have for some time now quietly worried and/or grumbled about -- not without a large dose of despair and even exasperation.

The flaw is, simply, that when left alone with "the other side," he is more likely than not to end up siding/agreeing with that side -- to his side's chagrin. Some observers believe that they have figured him out even more finely, arguing that what drives Raila is not any malice toward any friend or ally -- but purely and simply self-interest (regardless of the consequences).

Raila argues that the power-sharing was more than numerically equitable, if you look at it all with a fine tooth-comb. But no one believes him. Not even his thousands of fanatical, long suffering, followers in Kisumu City and its environs -- as the events of last Saturday suggest. He argues, moreover, that the ministries that he negotiated with Kibaki for ODM were fairly distributed among the ODM fraternity. But no one believes that either -- with the possible exception of the actual beneficiaries of that rather skewed distribution. There is considerable disquiet about that skewness in Rift Valley and Nyanza, and even parts of Western Province -- all bedrock of ODM support. And there is exasperation that he did not get the ministries of foreign affairs and finance.

Now, as I see it, it is this disquiet that is driving the call for a Grand Opposition in parliament -- to be underpinned by an act of parliament for additional political cover. And Raila is, of course, vehemently opposed to the idea. Is there any merit -- is there a compelling reason -- for the Grand Opposition?

In principle, Raila is right. There should be no grounds whatsoever for members of a party, elected to parliament under its banner, to technically decamp to another grouping of whatever kind -- for this has the very real potential of taking away, extra-democratically, their party's legitimately won parliamentary/legislative power. Parliamentary majority represents any party's understanding of the very basis of parliamentary/legislative power in a multi-party democracy. It is what drives all inter-party contests during and between general elections. It is why party discipline is taken so seriously. A party's parliamentary voting block is its only armament.

Proponents of a legislated Grand Opposition, on the other hand, argue that they are driven by an equally, if not loftier, principle: keeping the country from sliding back into a de facto one-party state. That is, creating a circuit-breaker against those who might be tempted to revive the Moi-era type of dictatorship. They imagine that only a Grand Opposition can resonate with the public as the people's voice, quite distinct from the government's voice. Moreover, only such a legislated Grand Opposition would qualify as an official opposition -- and an official opposition is provided for in the constitution. In their view, the Grand Coalition violates this important constitutional provision.

Yet it can equally or more persuasively be argued that what gives potency to the call for a Grand Coalition is a set of very pragmatic considerations -- not quite considerations of principle. One, ODM is controlled by a hard-core of self-centred individuals who, unless kept constantly on their toes, will simply use party and governmental structures to favour themselves and reward their cronies, while using party discipline to put rebellious backbenchers themselves on a short leash. The backbenchers seek to avoid the danger of being "whipped" at will to support all programmes and motions, even of questionable value, tabled in parliament by their colleagues "in government". They do not want to be denied by the party hierarchy the opportunity to participate meaningfully in setting parliament's agenda and running its committees. They do not want to be compelled to look the other way when bad governance rears its head.

Two, ODM backbenchers, in particular, have seen how dismally their "principal" performed during his final negotiations with Kibaki for cabinet and Permanent Secretary slots. They are bound to wonder how many more skewed deals between the President and the Prime Minister they can endure in silence till the next general elections. More specifically, they fear that the government agenda for the next five years will be PNU-driven, at the expense of broad-based ODM interests. They fear, moreover, that the Prime Minister does not see the danger, given his poor one-on-one negotiating skills. They can point to how the IDP issue is being handled as another clear evidence of this. In their view, it has been mandled hurriedly, one-sidedly, without due regard to history, and with Raila's acquiescence.

Since the 1980s, Raila has cultivated the political persona of a fearless, unstoppable representative of the people's will -- and a fearsome adversary with a fanatical power-base. The political brand he has created is next to none in Kenya and the region. He has rightfully earned the nickname Agwambo. So it was in amazement that the massive rally in Kisumu last Saturday, and the millions who tuned to their TVs or radio, heard him characterize ODM's entry into the Coalition Government as a surrender. "He who surrenders lives to fight another day," he argued. It might have been a slip of the tongue. The saying is,correctly, "He who retreats lives to..." He seemed to have realized the misspeak, as he immediately added the Maoist phrase "Two steps forward, one step backward" -- which captures the notion of inexorable forward-motion, despite short-term reverses. But what the audience heard was "surrender!" The live audience did not seem to like much of what he had to say that day, and was very loud about it -- and that must be a worry.

In Kisumu, and at Bondo, he was particularly worked up about the idea of a Grand Opposition. He argued that it was unnecessary and intended to undermine the government -- of which ODM was now, belatedly to be sure, a part. He asked its proponents, whom he labelled frustrated self-seekers, to resign and seek a fresh mandate from the voters.

But the proponents are already accusing him and others opposed to the move(such as ODM-K's Kalonzo Musyoka) of "dictatorial and draconian" tendencies, and of personalizing the issue. They insist that they will carry on, and will not resign their parliamentary seats. It is not known, however, wnat would happen to the Grand Opposition if its proponents -- particularly Isaac Ruto, Ababu Namwamba and Julius Kones -- were to be offered Assistant Minister positions tomorrow; or if they were to be thrown out of their political parties, forcing them to stand for re-election.

Having written the bulk of the foregoing yesterday, I now read in today's (Wednesday's) local daily that the Speaker of the National Assembly, Mr. Kenneth Marende, yesterday threw a spanner in the works. He announced that backbench MPs were free to form a Grand Opposition without having to stand for re-election. There was, indeed, as he pointed out, a provision for an opposition in parliament, although parliament could expunge the provision if it deemed it detrimental. Clearly, however, expunging it would require the concurrence of the 85 or so MPs who already support the Grand Opposition, and whose support would be required to deliver the new constitution promised by ODM by April 2009.

On largely pragmatic grounds, I think the Grand Coalition is a good idea whose time has suddenly, surprisingly, emphatically, come. It is an idea which was hardly conceivable even two months ago. It is intended to undermine the Prime Minister. Rather, it underscores the old adage that the price of liberty is eternal vigilance. The Prime Minister should support it for the good of the country, and for his own good. Do I think that we will have a new constitution by April 2009? We may have a new constitution, but not the kind of comprehensive constitution which ODM has been promising. Far from it, given the twists and turns we have witnessed since January 2008.