The recent power-sharing agreement in Zimbabwe, brokered by South Africa's Thabo Mbeki, is a cause for optimism for the future of governmentality in Zimbabwe, but more importantly of its long-suffering citizens in the complexity of their day-to-day lives. Skeptical as many observers were that such a deal was at all possible -- Mugabe had been so demonized, particularly in pronouncements out of London and Washington, and had so demonized himself (in rantings out of his own mouth) as to make hope for any sensible outcome of the elections itself hopeless -- there you are! We (let me use that plural and all-inclusive word) do have a deal; as good a deal as such products of political manoeuvre can be. Indeed, for Tsvangirai, a better deal nominally (in fact qualitatively, as some may insist) than Kenya's Raila brokered for himself and ODM last March.
So here we are. One obvious consequence of the deal is, to me, a triple redemption of sorts for the principals. Mugabe has succeeded in brokering his own redemption. He has recouped a measure of the social (and/or political) capital that had so precipitously eroded from his bleeding hands -- certainly in African eyes. Now, we can and will all bury him, when the time comes, without equivocation. Raila will most likely attend, perhaps with 100 bulls in tow, and with such flamboyance and depth of engagement in these matters as only he, in all of Africa, can muster.
Mbeki, likewise, has redeemed himself from the self-inflicted and precipitous slide into ignominy and ineffectualness which had been, particularly in the last year or two (if we say nothing of his quaint narrative of the causality of HIV/Aids), the hallmark of his leadership in South Africa (remember South Africa's xenophobia against fellow Africans, remember the Zuma case) and Africa as a whole (remember Darfur). In Zimbabwe, he snatched victory and optimism from the jaws of defeat and defeatism, and of pessimism. Now he can ride into that sunset, which we will all ride into -- if we are lucky to be alive when the sun sets -- with the knowledge that, whatever mars his presidential record, he will always be remembered with some fondness by all who think and remember deeply.
Tsvangirai, whom I had thought a coward when he called off his campain for the run-off elections, has redeemed himself in my eyes and, it is obvious to me, the eyes of millions of Zimbabweans. He has redeemed himself not so much in securing a deal (any coward can do that), but a good deal -- at least on paper. The taste of the pudding is in the eating, of course, but you can't eat your cake if you don't have (or bake) it! He has the ingredients, though there will be delays such as we have already witnessed -- and perhaps power outages.
Zimbabweans insist on a view that they are not Kenyans, which they are and are not, and that they do their things differently -- and perhaps in a more dignified way. The jury is out. There are many hints in the Zimbabwean deal that the Kenyan model was very much on the minds of the negotiators. Tsvangirai probably secured a better deal because Raila's, which he was clearly aware of, was in the eyes of many bad. This capacity for a quantum leap is the late-comer's advantage. Likewise, Mugabe was probably inclined to give Tsvangirai (his Oliver Twist) more because Kibaki's selfishness would be seen by history to have been greater -- in which case, on that score, Mugabe would not be at the bottom of African history's list. Did Mbeki whisper that prospect in his ear, I would like to know?
Showing posts with label Mugabe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mugabe. Show all posts
Thursday, September 25, 2008
Monday, June 30, 2008
A Peace-Keeping Force For Zimbabwe? An Idea Whose Time Will Not Come
Does anyone seriously think that either AU or UN forces are going to be sent to restore or keep the peace in Zimbabwe any time soon, or in the foreseeable future? I certainly don't. And one may even ask: To keep what peace? Dictator Mugabe is back in power, thanks in no small measure to Tsvangirai's weak will.
In the aftermath of last week's election runoff (the results of which were this time announced with speed), Tsvangirai and his MDC will have even less negotiating clout than Raila and ODM had in Kenya earlier this year. It seems to me that the Zanu-PF lot have deep contempt for Tsvangirai's leadership. It seems that they knew something about his character that the rest of us are only beginning to come to terms with.
He clearly is no Raila, and no Ruto -- and yet we all know how unsatisfactory to many of ODM's supporters the Kenyan dealmaking itself was. Tsvangirai can expect far less than that -- and little more than crumbs from Mugabe's table, insistent though he is, partly from the safety of the Dutch embassy, that talks for some kind of Grand Coalition begin.
The best he can do for the people of Zimbabwe after the election fiasco, for which he is substantially responsible by default, is to step aside for the likes of Biti and Dr. Makoni -- who seem to have more courage.
Certainly, Mugabe must go (though, now, God only knows when). But so must Tsvangirai!
In the aftermath of last week's election runoff (the results of which were this time announced with speed), Tsvangirai and his MDC will have even less negotiating clout than Raila and ODM had in Kenya earlier this year. It seems to me that the Zanu-PF lot have deep contempt for Tsvangirai's leadership. It seems that they knew something about his character that the rest of us are only beginning to come to terms with.
He clearly is no Raila, and no Ruto -- and yet we all know how unsatisfactory to many of ODM's supporters the Kenyan dealmaking itself was. Tsvangirai can expect far less than that -- and little more than crumbs from Mugabe's table, insistent though he is, partly from the safety of the Dutch embassy, that talks for some kind of Grand Coalition begin.
The best he can do for the people of Zimbabwe after the election fiasco, for which he is substantially responsible by default, is to step aside for the likes of Biti and Dr. Makoni -- who seem to have more courage.
Certainly, Mugabe must go (though, now, God only knows when). But so must Tsvangirai!
Labels:
AU,
Biti,
Election,
Grand Coalition,
Kenya,
Makoni,
MDC,
Mugabe,
Negotiation,
ODM,
Peace-Keeping Force,
Production,
Raila,
Ruto,
Tsvangirai,
UN,
Zanu-PF,
Zimbabwe
Monday, June 23, 2008
Zimbabwe: Tsvangirai's Eleventh-Hour Capitulation
All things considered, Tsvangirai’s withdrawal, Sunday, from Zimbabwe’s Presidential runoff elections, less than a week away now, is a betrayal of the worst kind. He has betrayed the memory and the sacrifice of all the martyrs of Zimbabwe’s second liberation; and of many others in Africa and elsewhere who have too often been betrayed by the very leaders in whose names they, in effect, died. And he has betrayed the constitutional process that should anchor the larger democratic process in an organized society. He has done so under some quaint reading, perhaps, of the Gandhi’s tradition of non-violence; or under the mere guise of that.
Now tyrant Mugabe is going to gain undeserved, and almost incontestable, victory. Obscene as that victory will be, Mugabe will now not be under any pressure, such as he might have been, to explain away his declaration of victory, or any discrepancy between the votes he got last March and those he might have claimed in the runoff. Tsvangirai has declared that victory for him, and has legitimized Mugabe’s new term – and the pathological leadership that it perpetuates.
Tsvangirai forgets that he was in the runoff not by the simple declaration of his candidacy (such as came into play in March 2008), but because the people had forced a runoff on Mugabe – and only he was constitutionally entitled to challenge the tyrant in the second round. One would have thought that he was keenly aware of his historic duty in this matter – a duty to run – and of the historicity of this moment for Zimbabwe, and for Africa. One would have thought that he felt, deeply, equal to the task; but clearly, one thought wrong. Instead, he has become hostage to fear. There is no profile in courage here.
I have given up on him, who has given up on the runoff. While Mugabe mockingly pleads with him to not give up the electoral fight, Tsvangirai will now be hoping, it seems, that what he has failed to do he can get Mbeki, whose incompetence is increasingly obvious and increasingly frustrating, to do for him; and if not Mbeki, then SADC; and if not SADC, then AU. Or perhaps the UN! That’s timidity itself. No one is going to do it for you, Morgan!
Tsvangirai has become, just so plainly, too terrified to go on. Much as he may try, he will not explain away this surrender. For the rest of us, it is his loss of nerve that is so disempowering. You see, you cannot win when you capitulate!
The best thing he can do right now is to change his mind and run -- against Mugabe! It is not too late. If he does not, it might just be too late to save his own leadership -- and Zimbabwe!
Now tyrant Mugabe is going to gain undeserved, and almost incontestable, victory. Obscene as that victory will be, Mugabe will now not be under any pressure, such as he might have been, to explain away his declaration of victory, or any discrepancy between the votes he got last March and those he might have claimed in the runoff. Tsvangirai has declared that victory for him, and has legitimized Mugabe’s new term – and the pathological leadership that it perpetuates.
Tsvangirai forgets that he was in the runoff not by the simple declaration of his candidacy (such as came into play in March 2008), but because the people had forced a runoff on Mugabe – and only he was constitutionally entitled to challenge the tyrant in the second round. One would have thought that he was keenly aware of his historic duty in this matter – a duty to run – and of the historicity of this moment for Zimbabwe, and for Africa. One would have thought that he felt, deeply, equal to the task; but clearly, one thought wrong. Instead, he has become hostage to fear. There is no profile in courage here.
I have given up on him, who has given up on the runoff. While Mugabe mockingly pleads with him to not give up the electoral fight, Tsvangirai will now be hoping, it seems, that what he has failed to do he can get Mbeki, whose incompetence is increasingly obvious and increasingly frustrating, to do for him; and if not Mbeki, then SADC; and if not SADC, then AU. Or perhaps the UN! That’s timidity itself. No one is going to do it for you, Morgan!
Tsvangirai has become, just so plainly, too terrified to go on. Much as he may try, he will not explain away this surrender. For the rest of us, it is his loss of nerve that is so disempowering. You see, you cannot win when you capitulate!
The best thing he can do right now is to change his mind and run -- against Mugabe! It is not too late. If he does not, it might just be too late to save his own leadership -- and Zimbabwe!
Labels:
2008,
Africa,
AU,
Capitulation,
Mbeki,
Mugabe,
Runoff Elections,
SADC,
Second Liberation,
Tsvangirai,
UN,
Zimbabwe
Wednesday, June 04, 2008
Barack Obama: Presumptive Presidential Nominee of the Democratic Party
Yesterday, 3rd June 2008, was a truly historic day on many accounts in the United States -- and in Kenya. Dare I add Africa and the world at large? Circumspection, alone, holds me back -- but not my [My! My! My!] exclamation! Since we are hours ahead of America here in Kenya, that moment of glory, when Obama reached and then passed the pivotal total of 2118 pledged delegates and superdelegates, a moment which will be etched indelibly (dare I say for eons?) in the annals of at least two great countries, actually occurred very early this morning -- June 4th. A son of Kenya (for that he is) -- alright, a son of America and Kenya both -- had won a presidential marathon in that same America in which Kenyan runners are so used to winning marathons; and in which Americans are so used to seeing, and cheering, them! Cheers, America! And cheers Jatelo!
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
Labels:
2008,
America,
CNN,
Delegate,
Democrat,
East African,
Election,
Hillary,
Jackson,
Jatelo,
Kenya,
Leader,
Mugabe,
Obama,
President,
Republican,
Runners,
Somalia,
Tanzania,
Vice President
Friday, May 02, 2008
Zimbabwe: Presidential Election Run-Off
Zimbabweans might just be vindicated in their reported claim that they do their politics differently from Kenyans, and that the "Kenyan way" (the Kenyan inclination to resort to violence to resolve political/electoral disputes) is not only not for them but also something not to write home about. I guess we'll just have to wait a little longer and see.
The month-long delay in announcing the results of the general elections -- both Presidential and Parliamentary -- led world opinion to the conclusion that here was a country which was violating basic electoral principles and trashing democracy even more blatantly than Kenya. Mugabe was simply going to go on despite his apparent rejection by the governed -- a rejection which seemed confirmed by the Electoral Commission's refusal (under orders from above, it was feared) simply to report how the people had actually voted. He appeared hell-bent on confirming all the negatives that were being labelled on him.
But then the results of Parliamentary elections were announced after a suspenseful wait which, it appeared (while it lasted), would not end. And MDC turned out the winner with a majority. Soon, however, a highly ssuspicious decision was made to recount parliamentary votes in just about the number of constituencies which gave MDC its majority. Eventually, however, that majority was confirmed -- to the surprise of most observers (including yours truly) who had feared the worst of intentions on the part of the ruling party. But MDC supporters were in no mood to celebrate, their eyes unblinkingly cocked, as it were, on the main prize -- the Presidency.
And then, about a month after the March 29th elections, it was officially announced that MDC's Tsvangirai had actually, sobject to verification, received more votes than Zanu-PF's Mugabe (47% to 43%). This was, of course, taken by MDC as Mugabe's way of subverting the people's will, since MDC believed what its own figures told it -- namely, that Tsvangirai had scored an outright win with some 50.3% of the Presidential votes cast. The percentages officially announced meant, of course, that there would have to be a run-off between the two leading candidates, according to a constitution which stipulates that a winner on the first ballot must obtain at least 50% plus one of all the Presidential votes cast.
MDC has rejected the official figures, and threatens to boycott the run-off. This would be extremely unwise, and would be something of the very "Kenyan way" which Zimbabweans are disdainful of. You cannot be both a player and referee -- a contestant who arrogates to himself/herself the right to announce who the winner is (precisely/invariably the contestant). The threat to boycott is also based on another kind of fear, reflected in what is already happening. The fear is that Mugabe's goons will terrorize opposition strongholds to ensure a narrow victory in the second round.
But the MDC leadership has survived this terror before, and should not appear overly inclined to flee. Staying put is a posture it can indeed learn from Kenyans -- or re-learn from its own recent past. The Kenyans, of course, are at a different point in the trajetory of political succession -- the December 2007 elections having presented a real opportunity to elect Kenya's fourth President since independence in 1963. Zimbabwean's are still struggling to replace their founding President, by the ballot.
Legitimate as the fear of violence and intimidation may be, Tsvangirai and his MDC must agree to participate in the Presidential run-off election. They owe this to themselves, to Zimbabweans, to Africans (including Kenyans) and to Democracy in general. Let them use the vaunted Zimbabwean discipline to block all rigging avenues and mount a winning campaign -- just as they did in March. Let them call on all well-wishers to help them monitor the run-off. If they don't participate, they certainly cannot (will not) win. If they do participate, in alliance hopefully with Simba Makoni's side, victory appears certain. Perhaps this is Mugabe's honourable exit strategy. And even if it is not, let us see this election season to its logical conclusion
The month-long delay in announcing the results of the general elections -- both Presidential and Parliamentary -- led world opinion to the conclusion that here was a country which was violating basic electoral principles and trashing democracy even more blatantly than Kenya. Mugabe was simply going to go on despite his apparent rejection by the governed -- a rejection which seemed confirmed by the Electoral Commission's refusal (under orders from above, it was feared) simply to report how the people had actually voted. He appeared hell-bent on confirming all the negatives that were being labelled on him.
But then the results of Parliamentary elections were announced after a suspenseful wait which, it appeared (while it lasted), would not end. And MDC turned out the winner with a majority. Soon, however, a highly ssuspicious decision was made to recount parliamentary votes in just about the number of constituencies which gave MDC its majority. Eventually, however, that majority was confirmed -- to the surprise of most observers (including yours truly) who had feared the worst of intentions on the part of the ruling party. But MDC supporters were in no mood to celebrate, their eyes unblinkingly cocked, as it were, on the main prize -- the Presidency.
And then, about a month after the March 29th elections, it was officially announced that MDC's Tsvangirai had actually, sobject to verification, received more votes than Zanu-PF's Mugabe (47% to 43%). This was, of course, taken by MDC as Mugabe's way of subverting the people's will, since MDC believed what its own figures told it -- namely, that Tsvangirai had scored an outright win with some 50.3% of the Presidential votes cast. The percentages officially announced meant, of course, that there would have to be a run-off between the two leading candidates, according to a constitution which stipulates that a winner on the first ballot must obtain at least 50% plus one of all the Presidential votes cast.
MDC has rejected the official figures, and threatens to boycott the run-off. This would be extremely unwise, and would be something of the very "Kenyan way" which Zimbabweans are disdainful of. You cannot be both a player and referee -- a contestant who arrogates to himself/herself the right to announce who the winner is (precisely/invariably the contestant). The threat to boycott is also based on another kind of fear, reflected in what is already happening. The fear is that Mugabe's goons will terrorize opposition strongholds to ensure a narrow victory in the second round.
But the MDC leadership has survived this terror before, and should not appear overly inclined to flee. Staying put is a posture it can indeed learn from Kenyans -- or re-learn from its own recent past. The Kenyans, of course, are at a different point in the trajetory of political succession -- the December 2007 elections having presented a real opportunity to elect Kenya's fourth President since independence in 1963. Zimbabwean's are still struggling to replace their founding President, by the ballot.
Legitimate as the fear of violence and intimidation may be, Tsvangirai and his MDC must agree to participate in the Presidential run-off election. They owe this to themselves, to Zimbabweans, to Africans (including Kenyans) and to Democracy in general. Let them use the vaunted Zimbabwean discipline to block all rigging avenues and mount a winning campaign -- just as they did in March. Let them call on all well-wishers to help them monitor the run-off. If they don't participate, they certainly cannot (will not) win. If they do participate, in alliance hopefully with Simba Makoni's side, victory appears certain. Perhaps this is Mugabe's honourable exit strategy. And even if it is not, let us see this election season to its logical conclusion
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)