A belated happy new year to all.
Bloody though it has begun, a prayer--
That this be a less conflicted year
Than 2008. That there be healing.
Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2008. Show all posts
Friday, January 09, 2009
Wednesday, December 31, 2008
The Year, It Seems, Will End With a Whimper!
The year 2008, it seems, will end with a whimper -- such as it did not begin with. So it seems, at 5.14 p.m., here in Nairobi.
Of course, I know there is bloody fighting over there in the Middle East [Israel does have an inalienable right to defend itself, and Palestinians have a God-given right to a safe and secure home. So, where does that leave the Hamas militants who unilaterally provoked the latest bloodbath?]
But I'm talking about Nairobi and about Kenya, as I watch the year tick away toward the last midnight. The bloodbath that began this time last year was here, not there.
And yet, as they say, it aint over till it's over. There are a few hours yet.
How was your last day of the year? Quiet and ordinary was mine. A little pensive, thinking back to this time last year; which is why this year began, for us, as it did -- and seemingly will end quite differently. A lot pensive, in fact.
Did a little walkabout in town. Bought two (perhaps contraband) CDs of Congolese Oldies and Goodies (Veve's music). Some memories die hard.
Even bumped into my VC at a supermarket in town -- completely unexpectedly. He was gracious enough to step over for to exchange a few pleasantries. Of course he is always gracious in those one-on-ones. That's my experience. But we hadn't previously met at a supermarket, or even outside the campus. It was, then, a surprise encounter -- and I was rather surprised at my surprise.
It has been a quite year for me, and in several ways quite re-energizing. I think Joan, my wife, would agree. But I have to stop this blogging now, for I have to go see her, before the year runs out.
Of course, I know there is bloody fighting over there in the Middle East [Israel does have an inalienable right to defend itself, and Palestinians have a God-given right to a safe and secure home. So, where does that leave the Hamas militants who unilaterally provoked the latest bloodbath?]
But I'm talking about Nairobi and about Kenya, as I watch the year tick away toward the last midnight. The bloodbath that began this time last year was here, not there.
And yet, as they say, it aint over till it's over. There are a few hours yet.
How was your last day of the year? Quiet and ordinary was mine. A little pensive, thinking back to this time last year; which is why this year began, for us, as it did -- and seemingly will end quite differently. A lot pensive, in fact.
Did a little walkabout in town. Bought two (perhaps contraband) CDs of Congolese Oldies and Goodies (Veve's music). Some memories die hard.
Even bumped into my VC at a supermarket in town -- completely unexpectedly. He was gracious enough to step over for to exchange a few pleasantries. Of course he is always gracious in those one-on-ones. That's my experience. But we hadn't previously met at a supermarket, or even outside the campus. It was, then, a surprise encounter -- and I was rather surprised at my surprise.
It has been a quite year for me, and in several ways quite re-energizing. I think Joan, my wife, would agree. But I have to stop this blogging now, for I have to go see her, before the year runs out.
Labels:
2008,
Bloodbath,
Congolese,
Hamas,
Israel,
Joan,
Kenya,
Middle East,
Nairobi,
Palestine,
VC,
Veve
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
The Nyangoma-Kogelo Man, c.2008
First see the Razzi's picture. Then read this caption:
He wears his own mask. And
He carries his own water-
Gourd. Bathed is he, truly,
In the glare -- of the very
Sun he is. Our very eyes.
Yet no eye is believable!
Weighs what is to become
In his own right hand.
As we have weighed ours.
Walks as he walks toward
What he must 'deed become.
That's how we walked the earth.
He wears his own mask. And
He carries his own water-
Gourd. Bathed is he, truly,
In the glare -- of the very
Sun he is. Our very eyes.
Yet no eye is believable!
Weighs what is to become
In his own right hand.
As we have weighed ours.
Walks as he walks toward
What he must 'deed become.
That's how we walked the earth.
Sunday, December 14, 2008
Independence Day
The people deserve the leaders they get, so the saying goes. Then the leaders get the respect they deserve from the people, who deserve them, or so it seems these days.
Kenya's Independence Day celebrations of 12th December 2008, the 45th since 1963, were the most chaotic ever. We prefer to call it Jamhuri Day – Republic Day – for on December 12th 1964, exactly a year after independence, Kenya became a republic – finally putting an end to the Queen of England’s constitutional role as Kenya’s residual Head of State. That same Elizabeth II who, once upon a time in Kenya, went up a tree a princess and came down a queen the very following morning! We still love her!
A DIGRESSION: Don’t get me wrong: chaos, Santayana teaches, is any order that causes confusion in our minds. The confusion is not in the order, not in the extant state of affairs, but in our minds, says he. It’s the mind that the order, ordered as the order might be, confuses. Yet Santayana does not say whose mind’s eye sees the order when our minds are, as he sees it, confused. DIGRESSION ENDS.
For the first time ever, unthinkable (funny?) but it’s true, the President could not finish his address to the nation – historically the centerpiece of the day’s events. The speech is in fact supposed to cascade throughout the country. Not only is it aired live by the electronic media, but the text is also read out, though not simultaneously, in all of Kenya’s Provinces by the Provincial Commissioners (PCs), in all the Districts by the DC’s, and in all the Divisions by the District Officers (DOs). In the Districts and Divisions, the occasion offers an opportunity to local dignitaries to address the gatherings before the President’s speech is read and the proceedings closed.
Incidentally, on this same occasion last year, near Holo, the Kisumu West DC would not let me talk, though he was aware of my presence and allowed others conected to the incumbent MP, who was himself not there. I belonged to the wrong party, I suppose; but I also thought he was trying to stay on the right side of an incumbent several aspirants were trying to dislodge. I was of course disgusted, and I could see that other people were too. I felt the kind of discust which I imagine all gagging engenders, and which the President must have felt this December 12th.
But some eight Kilometers away at Kombewa, last year, I had caught up with the on-going events at the Divisional level, and the DO, a lady, had let me speak without a fuss and even with the respect befitting a parliamentary aspirant. I was pleased and, let me confess, offered crates of soda to the 150 or so raia in attendance. Others drank too. It was a hot day, but talk about cocacolonization! I also knew that the President entertains plenty at State House on this day, after the public gathering, but he does not use his own money!
Back to this year: It is not Yambo who cannot speak at the District gathering, I was happily at my computer “on” Gandhi Wing this time, but the President who cannot complete his speech, and so continue a tradition, at the national event! It is not Yambo whom some District “arm of government” with no civic virtue stops, but the President (and I suspect the Prime Minister) whom the people give the respect they think he deserves (both deserve) these days – just about two weeks from the first anniversary of his ECK-declared ”victory”, and the latter's "defeat”!
Exactly what happened this December 12th, and why, is all over Saturday's newspapers. Let me summarize as follows: There were demonstrations and heckling in Nairobi and certain other parts of Kenya at venues where the day’s celebrations were held. The crowd was simply not its usual cheering self – something which had been noticed with less buzz at Raila’s home-coming party in the Kibera slums about two weeks ago. It had reason, reasons, to be glum. And serious security lapse was witnessed, at the VIP section of Nyayo Stadium, the venue. An un-vetted man with an agenda, a Mr. Frederick Odhiambo – a known member of Bunge la Wananchi (Parliament of the People, or The People’s Parliament) – deliberately found his way to a seat just ten meters away from the President. He did not sit quietly throughout, nor did make noise till close to the end (which is when his presence was noticed by the President’s security detail, and his unscripted noise caused a helter-skelter of action) – which is when the Nyayo Stadium show came to a sudden stop!
Let’s put it this other way: The public’s foul mood was already much in evidence when that happened. And so was the President’s. Both President Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga had already been openly heckled. The manhandling earlier in the day, in full view of the crowd, of a protesting Mong’are (aka Nyambane), one of Kenya’s most famous comedians, had not helped matters. It was all so contagious, as Christakis might have noted were he there. Still, the belated discovery of Odhiambo’s presence was the proximate catalyst for that abrupt end.
Three wedge issues were the reason for all this unbecoming turn of events on a great ceremonial day. First, the continuing shortage and escalating price of unga (maize flour) and other consumables across the country. This is partly the consequence of widespread post-election violence which the country suffered early this year, and partly the result of mafia-like scheming in certain high places broadly in the docket of the Minister for Agriculture. Talk on the street is that YK92 is regrouping at the Ministry. Lack of access to unga of course means njaa (hunger), which sections of the crowd periodically reminded the leaders of.
Second, the disquieting continuation of tax-free emoluments to Parliamentarians and other holders of constitutional offices. Third, the passage by Parliament of the much-resented Media Bill -- the Kenya Communications (Amendment ) Bill, 2008, known in certain quarters as the ICT Bill – whose effect will be, inter alia, to vigorously gag the media, and which now awaits only the President’s assent before it becomes law.
It is of course hypocritical for certain circles in ODM to declare belatedly that they will take government to court, a government in which they are coalition partners, if the President signs the Media Bill into law. Where were they when Parliament, in which they control nearly 50% of the votes, was voting in the bill? Yet that is not the only reason for the public’s gripe, and it is hypocritical to make pronouncements and act as though it is. Why have they not mobilized their voting block to get Parliamentarians to pay taxes like other law-abiding citizens? In fact, to demonstrate seriousness of purpose and unequivocal empathy with the people, ODM MPs should voluntarily ask for their pay to be taxed as they wait for Parliament to act. Anything less than that is just so much hot air.
Kenya's Independence Day celebrations of 12th December 2008, the 45th since 1963, were the most chaotic ever. We prefer to call it Jamhuri Day – Republic Day – for on December 12th 1964, exactly a year after independence, Kenya became a republic – finally putting an end to the Queen of England’s constitutional role as Kenya’s residual Head of State. That same Elizabeth II who, once upon a time in Kenya, went up a tree a princess and came down a queen the very following morning! We still love her!
A DIGRESSION: Don’t get me wrong: chaos, Santayana teaches, is any order that causes confusion in our minds. The confusion is not in the order, not in the extant state of affairs, but in our minds, says he. It’s the mind that the order, ordered as the order might be, confuses. Yet Santayana does not say whose mind’s eye sees the order when our minds are, as he sees it, confused. DIGRESSION ENDS.
For the first time ever, unthinkable (funny?) but it’s true, the President could not finish his address to the nation – historically the centerpiece of the day’s events. The speech is in fact supposed to cascade throughout the country. Not only is it aired live by the electronic media, but the text is also read out, though not simultaneously, in all of Kenya’s Provinces by the Provincial Commissioners (PCs), in all the Districts by the DC’s, and in all the Divisions by the District Officers (DOs). In the Districts and Divisions, the occasion offers an opportunity to local dignitaries to address the gatherings before the President’s speech is read and the proceedings closed.
Incidentally, on this same occasion last year, near Holo, the Kisumu West DC would not let me talk, though he was aware of my presence and allowed others conected to the incumbent MP, who was himself not there. I belonged to the wrong party, I suppose; but I also thought he was trying to stay on the right side of an incumbent several aspirants were trying to dislodge. I was of course disgusted, and I could see that other people were too. I felt the kind of discust which I imagine all gagging engenders, and which the President must have felt this December 12th.
But some eight Kilometers away at Kombewa, last year, I had caught up with the on-going events at the Divisional level, and the DO, a lady, had let me speak without a fuss and even with the respect befitting a parliamentary aspirant. I was pleased and, let me confess, offered crates of soda to the 150 or so raia in attendance. Others drank too. It was a hot day, but talk about cocacolonization! I also knew that the President entertains plenty at State House on this day, after the public gathering, but he does not use his own money!
Back to this year: It is not Yambo who cannot speak at the District gathering, I was happily at my computer “on” Gandhi Wing this time, but the President who cannot complete his speech, and so continue a tradition, at the national event! It is not Yambo whom some District “arm of government” with no civic virtue stops, but the President (and I suspect the Prime Minister) whom the people give the respect they think he deserves (both deserve) these days – just about two weeks from the first anniversary of his ECK-declared ”victory”, and the latter's "defeat”!
Exactly what happened this December 12th, and why, is all over Saturday's newspapers. Let me summarize as follows: There were demonstrations and heckling in Nairobi and certain other parts of Kenya at venues where the day’s celebrations were held. The crowd was simply not its usual cheering self – something which had been noticed with less buzz at Raila’s home-coming party in the Kibera slums about two weeks ago. It had reason, reasons, to be glum. And serious security lapse was witnessed, at the VIP section of Nyayo Stadium, the venue. An un-vetted man with an agenda, a Mr. Frederick Odhiambo – a known member of Bunge la Wananchi (Parliament of the People, or The People’s Parliament) – deliberately found his way to a seat just ten meters away from the President. He did not sit quietly throughout, nor did make noise till close to the end (which is when his presence was noticed by the President’s security detail, and his unscripted noise caused a helter-skelter of action) – which is when the Nyayo Stadium show came to a sudden stop!
Let’s put it this other way: The public’s foul mood was already much in evidence when that happened. And so was the President’s. Both President Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga had already been openly heckled. The manhandling earlier in the day, in full view of the crowd, of a protesting Mong’are (aka Nyambane), one of Kenya’s most famous comedians, had not helped matters. It was all so contagious, as Christakis might have noted were he there. Still, the belated discovery of Odhiambo’s presence was the proximate catalyst for that abrupt end.
Three wedge issues were the reason for all this unbecoming turn of events on a great ceremonial day. First, the continuing shortage and escalating price of unga (maize flour) and other consumables across the country. This is partly the consequence of widespread post-election violence which the country suffered early this year, and partly the result of mafia-like scheming in certain high places broadly in the docket of the Minister for Agriculture. Talk on the street is that YK92 is regrouping at the Ministry. Lack of access to unga of course means njaa (hunger), which sections of the crowd periodically reminded the leaders of.
Second, the disquieting continuation of tax-free emoluments to Parliamentarians and other holders of constitutional offices. Third, the passage by Parliament of the much-resented Media Bill -- the Kenya Communications (Amendment ) Bill, 2008, known in certain quarters as the ICT Bill – whose effect will be, inter alia, to vigorously gag the media, and which now awaits only the President’s assent before it becomes law.
It is of course hypocritical for certain circles in ODM to declare belatedly that they will take government to court, a government in which they are coalition partners, if the President signs the Media Bill into law. Where were they when Parliament, in which they control nearly 50% of the votes, was voting in the bill? Yet that is not the only reason for the public’s gripe, and it is hypocritical to make pronouncements and act as though it is. Why have they not mobilized their voting block to get Parliamentarians to pay taxes like other law-abiding citizens? In fact, to demonstrate seriousness of purpose and unequivocal empathy with the people, ODM MPs should voluntarily ask for their pay to be taxed as they wait for Parliament to act. Anything less than that is just so much hot air.
Labels:
2008,
Agriculture,
Chaos,
Christakis,
Elizabeth II,
Holo,
Indepencence,
Kenya,
Kibaki,
Kisumu,
Kombewa,
Media Bill,
Mong'are,
Nairobi,
Odhiambo,
ODM,
Parliament,
Raila,
Santayana,
Tax
Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Gallup Poll: Latest Numbers From Kenya
Results of the most recent Gallup poll in Kenya -- conducted between June 19 and July 9, 2008 -- were released to the media on Monday, September 8th. Though the poll covered a fairly wide range of issues, the two leading newspapers ( Daily Nation and The Standard) headlined the poll results with the public's verdict on the President's and the Prime Minister's performance. So let us start with that.
President Kibaki's approval rating stands at only 63%, while Prime Minister Raila Odinga has a rating of 85%. This large, 22 percentage-point, advantage for the PM is surprising only in its magnitude and not in its skew. It reflects the general perception that the PM has been more visibly active in public affairs than the President, since March. The President's laid-back approach to things (all things considered) is well known, if not legendary. Has it not often been claimed that he never found a fence he didn't (wouldn't?) sit on? In the end, though, he seems to always have it (have things go) his way, doesn't he?
In contrast, Raila thrives on media attention, and is patently indefatigable. Moreover, while the President's role is clearly defined in the constitution, so that Kibaki does not have to endeavour to carve a niche for himself, or to prove himself, the PM's role continues to lack clear definition, and one suspects that Raila seeks to define it, in the public's eye, by word and deed -- on a day-to-day basis -- if those (including him!) who should do so constitutionally are dragging their feet.
In the process, though he is supposed to coordinate, he ends up seeming, or falling to the temptation, to take over the roles he was supposed merely to coordinate. He has been learning on-the-job, without much of local experience to draw on. Jomo Kenyatta's 12-month stint in the PM's seat so long ago (from December 12, 1963 to December 12, 1964) has not been much of a help in the absence of written memoirs and in view of the dramatically different or changed circumstances.
He has, in other words, been learning by doing -- and ruffling some feathers in the process. But the public sees all this as hard work. At least two ministers (Uhuru and Mwakwere) and/or their supporters have publicly complained that the PM is encroaching on their ministerial turf. I suspect that several other ministers have had their feathers just as ruffled -- though the public sees all this as whining, and the whining as not being in the public interest. That's just one step away (isn't it?) from being reshuffled, if it were not for the "letter" of the Grand Coalition agreement.
The truth of the matter, however, is that the PM has a habit of appropriating ministers' shine and basking in their limelight -- and he sucks out all the oxygen from the room. And the point is that he should give ministers a chance to get some credit for work well done, for that is a major component of what motivated public servants thrive on. It would be worrisome, long-term, if, in the structure of our politics, the PM should be the only minister who should shine. It would be worrisome because it would distort our politics and the structure of our public administration.
Let us now turn to other issues covered in the poll. When asked to identify "the most pressing problem that the coalition Government must address", the respondents mentioned the following (the figures in parenthesis represent the percentage of all respondents who mentioned a given problem):
Poverty (17%)
Inflation (17%)
Creating Jobs (11%)
Constitutional Reform (9%)
Unemployment (7%)
Resettlement of Internally Displaced Persons (7%)
Land Reform (7%)
Food Shortage (6%)
Education (3%)
Tax Reduction (2%)
Violence (2%)
Insecurity (2%)
Prosecution of Those Implicated in Post-Election Violence (1%)
Health Care (1%)
Road System (1%)
Water (1%)
Electricity (1%)
Other (1%)
Don't Know or No Response (2%).
[The percentages do not add up to 100]
Nominally, then, the top ten problems are: poverty, inflation, an insufficiency of jobs, constitutional reform, unemployment, IDPs, land reform, food shortage, education and taxation. But we need some aggregation here. That is to say, certain problems can be "collapsed" to give us a shorter list.
The need to create jobs arises only because there is unemployment, and when the two problems are combined into one (say, unemployment) we get to (18%). Poverty and unemployment are twins, and these two give us a "super problem" (even before we include food shortage)accounting for 35% of all responses. In a similar vein, the IDP problem is directly intertwined with the land reform problem, violence and insecurity (which are not in the nominal top ten) and the problem of dealing with perpetrators of post-election violence. Taken together, these five problems account for 19% of the responses.
Based on this re-aggregation, we get the following top 5 problems, which account for 86% of all responses:
1. Unemployment and Poverty (35%)
2. Land Reform, IDPs and related Insecurity and Violence (19%)
3. Inflation (17%)
4. Constitutional Reform (9%)
5. Food Insecurity (6%).
It is surprising that the water problem ranks so low. It would likewise be surprising that constitutional reform is among the top five problems, except that, in the eyes of Kenyans, a successfully concluded constitutional reform agenda would provide a consequential answer to two other problems in the top five: Land Reform... (19%) and Food Insecurity (6%). Inflation compounds unemployment and poverty, as well as food insecurity. It is an ever-present challenge to those who must govern -- and to those who struggle the most, daily, against hand-to-mouth existence.
On top of the list of Kenyan's problems "right now", unquestionably and expectedly, are the twin problems of unemployment and poverty (35%). It would have been surprising if the Gallup poll had found otherwise. But, in that case, did the Gallup poll set out to establish the obvious? Far from it. What is important in the poll result is the relative magnitudes of the problems, as seen by Kenyans at this time. So, we now have a kind of baseline, from which we will track future trends. Who knows: the water problem may begin to rise in subsequent polls, and likewise the health problem. On the other hand, the IDP and land reform problems might decline -- but hopefully only in step with their proper resolution, rather than due to official neglect and a diversion of public attention.
President Kibaki's approval rating stands at only 63%, while Prime Minister Raila Odinga has a rating of 85%. This large, 22 percentage-point, advantage for the PM is surprising only in its magnitude and not in its skew. It reflects the general perception that the PM has been more visibly active in public affairs than the President, since March. The President's laid-back approach to things (all things considered) is well known, if not legendary. Has it not often been claimed that he never found a fence he didn't (wouldn't?) sit on? In the end, though, he seems to always have it (have things go) his way, doesn't he?
In contrast, Raila thrives on media attention, and is patently indefatigable. Moreover, while the President's role is clearly defined in the constitution, so that Kibaki does not have to endeavour to carve a niche for himself, or to prove himself, the PM's role continues to lack clear definition, and one suspects that Raila seeks to define it, in the public's eye, by word and deed -- on a day-to-day basis -- if those (including him!) who should do so constitutionally are dragging their feet.
In the process, though he is supposed to coordinate, he ends up seeming, or falling to the temptation, to take over the roles he was supposed merely to coordinate. He has been learning on-the-job, without much of local experience to draw on. Jomo Kenyatta's 12-month stint in the PM's seat so long ago (from December 12, 1963 to December 12, 1964) has not been much of a help in the absence of written memoirs and in view of the dramatically different or changed circumstances.
He has, in other words, been learning by doing -- and ruffling some feathers in the process. But the public sees all this as hard work. At least two ministers (Uhuru and Mwakwere) and/or their supporters have publicly complained that the PM is encroaching on their ministerial turf. I suspect that several other ministers have had their feathers just as ruffled -- though the public sees all this as whining, and the whining as not being in the public interest. That's just one step away (isn't it?) from being reshuffled, if it were not for the "letter" of the Grand Coalition agreement.
The truth of the matter, however, is that the PM has a habit of appropriating ministers' shine and basking in their limelight -- and he sucks out all the oxygen from the room. And the point is that he should give ministers a chance to get some credit for work well done, for that is a major component of what motivated public servants thrive on. It would be worrisome, long-term, if, in the structure of our politics, the PM should be the only minister who should shine. It would be worrisome because it would distort our politics and the structure of our public administration.
Let us now turn to other issues covered in the poll. When asked to identify "the most pressing problem that the coalition Government must address", the respondents mentioned the following (the figures in parenthesis represent the percentage of all respondents who mentioned a given problem):
Poverty (17%)
Inflation (17%)
Creating Jobs (11%)
Constitutional Reform (9%)
Unemployment (7%)
Resettlement of Internally Displaced Persons (7%)
Land Reform (7%)
Food Shortage (6%)
Education (3%)
Tax Reduction (2%)
Violence (2%)
Insecurity (2%)
Prosecution of Those Implicated in Post-Election Violence (1%)
Health Care (1%)
Road System (1%)
Water (1%)
Electricity (1%)
Other (1%)
Don't Know or No Response (2%).
[The percentages do not add up to 100]
Nominally, then, the top ten problems are: poverty, inflation, an insufficiency of jobs, constitutional reform, unemployment, IDPs, land reform, food shortage, education and taxation. But we need some aggregation here. That is to say, certain problems can be "collapsed" to give us a shorter list.
The need to create jobs arises only because there is unemployment, and when the two problems are combined into one (say, unemployment) we get to (18%). Poverty and unemployment are twins, and these two give us a "super problem" (even before we include food shortage)accounting for 35% of all responses. In a similar vein, the IDP problem is directly intertwined with the land reform problem, violence and insecurity (which are not in the nominal top ten) and the problem of dealing with perpetrators of post-election violence. Taken together, these five problems account for 19% of the responses.
Based on this re-aggregation, we get the following top 5 problems, which account for 86% of all responses:
1. Unemployment and Poverty (35%)
2. Land Reform, IDPs and related Insecurity and Violence (19%)
3. Inflation (17%)
4. Constitutional Reform (9%)
5. Food Insecurity (6%).
It is surprising that the water problem ranks so low. It would likewise be surprising that constitutional reform is among the top five problems, except that, in the eyes of Kenyans, a successfully concluded constitutional reform agenda would provide a consequential answer to two other problems in the top five: Land Reform... (19%) and Food Insecurity (6%). Inflation compounds unemployment and poverty, as well as food insecurity. It is an ever-present challenge to those who must govern -- and to those who struggle the most, daily, against hand-to-mouth existence.
On top of the list of Kenyan's problems "right now", unquestionably and expectedly, are the twin problems of unemployment and poverty (35%). It would have been surprising if the Gallup poll had found otherwise. But, in that case, did the Gallup poll set out to establish the obvious? Far from it. What is important in the poll result is the relative magnitudes of the problems, as seen by Kenyans at this time. So, we now have a kind of baseline, from which we will track future trends. Who knows: the water problem may begin to rise in subsequent polls, and likewise the health problem. On the other hand, the IDP and land reform problems might decline -- but hopefully only in step with their proper resolution, rather than due to official neglect and a diversion of public attention.
Wednesday, August 27, 2008
Hillary Clinton's Speech at the Democratic National Convention, August 26, 2008
Hillary Clinton's speech in mile-high Denver, Colorado, on August 25th, laid to rest a number of nagging questions and worries. Questions and worries about loyalty and betrayal, about ship-jumping and proper rules of the game, about race and gender and evenhandedness when it is someone else's fair turn to carry the mantle; questions and worries about the likelihood of victory, and even of defeat, in the face of all this -- defeat of a party seemingly about to tear apart with victory in plain sight.
It was a well-crafted speech delivered with finesse and from the heart. No one can seriously doubt her commitment now to her party's cause in the coming elections. No one will doubt her respect for Democracy's verdict.
She has clearly put principle and party before self. And I think her party -- its members -- will remember her for a long, long time. They will remember her very, very fondly.
Those who watched her entire speech, including yours truly, will too. They will never forget her graciousness and strength of character, which, admittedly, was latelt out of sight to those who did not support her -- did not, indeed, care much for her -- in the heat of a prolonged nomination battle.
No one knows what the final verdict will be in November, in the Presidential elections. And yet one gets the feeling that by an historic act of will, by the sheer performance of one person, the door to the White House has somehow, just that palpably, shut in McCain's face. One gets the feeling that things are going to begin to get "elephant" for a Republican lot which, this same August, had begun to dream, against earlier odds, an impossible dream.
And no one knows what lies in Hillary's future. Yet there is this faint hint, in the aftermath of her delivery, that her party is not about to see the last of her, and that she is "not done with it" just yet. Indeed, in that singular delivery, she brought herself forth anew -- in an amazing moment of re-birth. She blazed an invisible path which no one will have the strength to cross, and which may yet see a woman in the White House, within a decade, as President -- a President called Hillary.
It was a well-crafted speech delivered with finesse and from the heart. No one can seriously doubt her commitment now to her party's cause in the coming elections. No one will doubt her respect for Democracy's verdict.
She has clearly put principle and party before self. And I think her party -- its members -- will remember her for a long, long time. They will remember her very, very fondly.
Those who watched her entire speech, including yours truly, will too. They will never forget her graciousness and strength of character, which, admittedly, was latelt out of sight to those who did not support her -- did not, indeed, care much for her -- in the heat of a prolonged nomination battle.
No one knows what the final verdict will be in November, in the Presidential elections. And yet one gets the feeling that by an historic act of will, by the sheer performance of one person, the door to the White House has somehow, just that palpably, shut in McCain's face. One gets the feeling that things are going to begin to get "elephant" for a Republican lot which, this same August, had begun to dream, against earlier odds, an impossible dream.
And no one knows what lies in Hillary's future. Yet there is this faint hint, in the aftermath of her delivery, that her party is not about to see the last of her, and that she is "not done with it" just yet. Indeed, in that singular delivery, she brought herself forth anew -- in an amazing moment of re-birth. She blazed an invisible path which no one will have the strength to cross, and which may yet see a woman in the White House, within a decade, as President -- a President called Hillary.
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
Michelle Obama's Speech at the Democratic Convention
Michelle Obama delivered a memorable steech at the Convention on the opening night, August 25th, 2008. Here's the video clip.
And here's a transcript of the speech.
And here's a transcript of the speech.
Monday, August 11, 2008
Mama Mariana's Relatives
Mama Mariana Odongo Othieno died at 78 years of age in the morning of August 8th, 2008. She died at Aga Khan Hospital, Nairobi, after a couple of months of illness. She should have lived another 5 to ten years. Alas, it was not to be!
More than one billion Chinese, and several billion more around the world, had looked forward to 08/08/08 with great anticipation -- that date marking, not coincidentally, the opening ceremonies of the Beijing Olympics. But we, Mama Mariana's immediate relatives, had not thought for a moment that the date would turn out to be, for us, what it became. Yet that, as they say, is life. Beginnings and endings lap each other, and overlap.
She had many immediate relatives, some now gone but many very much around. Let me mention some, by relation (as listed in the August 11, 2008 issue of the Daily Nation newspaper):
Wife of Mr. James Othieno Olute of Ukwala, Ugenya, Kenya.
Beloved mother of: Charles Omondi Olute, the late Philip Othieno, Emma Mabachi, Joan Yambo, Anna Othieno, Scholastica Agutu, Beatrice Ahere and the late Benedict Othieno.
Mother-in-law of: Mary Omondi, Victor Mabachi, Prof. Mauri Yambo, Sam Agutu and Frank Ahere.
Sister of: Hellena Akoth, the late Joseph Okoth, Lucas Oduor, the late Theresa Okello, Cll. George Ouma Rarieya, the late Rosa Anyango, Luke Obok Rarieya, Amos Otieno Osur, Erustus Onyango and Marie Rarieya, among others.
Sister-in-law of: Tabitha Rarieya, Esther Otieno Osur, Margaret Akoth, Margaret Anyango, Maria Mbanda, Rosa Akoth, Anna Agola, Maria Osolo, Maria Asande, Clementina Ochieng', Debora and Anna of Gem, Ochieng Olute and others.
Grandmother of: Natabhona Mabachi, Nahama Mabachi, Grado Mabachi, Ochieng' Omondi, Sharon Omondi, Angela Omondi, Tina Omondi, Bella Othieno, Alex Othieno, Kwach Yambo, Chikka Yambo, Rege Yambo, Diana Othieno, Cindy Agutu, Robert Agutu, Lisa Agutu, Natasha Ahere, Tim Ahere and Martin Ahere.
Burial will take place on 23rd August 2008 at her Ukwala home.
More than one billion Chinese, and several billion more around the world, had looked forward to 08/08/08 with great anticipation -- that date marking, not coincidentally, the opening ceremonies of the Beijing Olympics. But we, Mama Mariana's immediate relatives, had not thought for a moment that the date would turn out to be, for us, what it became. Yet that, as they say, is life. Beginnings and endings lap each other, and overlap.
She had many immediate relatives, some now gone but many very much around. Let me mention some, by relation (as listed in the August 11, 2008 issue of the Daily Nation newspaper):
Wife of Mr. James Othieno Olute of Ukwala, Ugenya, Kenya.
Beloved mother of: Charles Omondi Olute, the late Philip Othieno, Emma Mabachi, Joan Yambo, Anna Othieno, Scholastica Agutu, Beatrice Ahere and the late Benedict Othieno.
Mother-in-law of: Mary Omondi, Victor Mabachi, Prof. Mauri Yambo, Sam Agutu and Frank Ahere.
Sister of: Hellena Akoth, the late Joseph Okoth, Lucas Oduor, the late Theresa Okello, Cll. George Ouma Rarieya, the late Rosa Anyango, Luke Obok Rarieya, Amos Otieno Osur, Erustus Onyango and Marie Rarieya, among others.
Sister-in-law of: Tabitha Rarieya, Esther Otieno Osur, Margaret Akoth, Margaret Anyango, Maria Mbanda, Rosa Akoth, Anna Agola, Maria Osolo, Maria Asande, Clementina Ochieng', Debora and Anna of Gem, Ochieng Olute and others.
Grandmother of: Natabhona Mabachi, Nahama Mabachi, Grado Mabachi, Ochieng' Omondi, Sharon Omondi, Angela Omondi, Tina Omondi, Bella Othieno, Alex Othieno, Kwach Yambo, Chikka Yambo, Rege Yambo, Diana Othieno, Cindy Agutu, Robert Agutu, Lisa Agutu, Natasha Ahere, Tim Ahere and Martin Ahere.
Burial will take place on 23rd August 2008 at her Ukwala home.
Labels:
08/08/08,
2008,
Aga Khan Hospital,
Agutu,
Ahere,
Beijing,
Daily Nation,
Mabachi,
Mama Mariana,
Maria,
Olute,
Olympics,
Osur,
Othieno,
Rarieya,
Ukwala,
Yambo
Friday, August 08, 2008
Mama Mariana: RIP
On the opening day of the Olympiad,
As the world revels,
The angels have opened Heaven's Gate
For her. And she alone.
What a day she has up and gone!
There,
Awaits her all the goodness
Of the
Afterlife.
Having herself been good -- in this.
There's never a day to go,
Never a good day.
It's never the day.
Never a good day!
As the world revels,
The angels have opened Heaven's Gate
For her. And she alone.
What a day she has up and gone!
There,
Awaits her all the goodness
Of the
Afterlife.
Having herself been good -- in this.
There's never a day to go,
Never a good day.
It's never the day.
Never a good day!
Thursday, August 07, 2008
University of Nairobi: ISO 9001-2000 Certification
The University of Nairobi received its ISO 9001-2000 certification this morning, at a feel-good ceremony in Taifa Hall. The Vice Chancellor, Prof. George Magoha, presided over the proceedings, at which the Guest of Honour was Dr. Sally Kosgey, Minister for Higher Education, Science and Technology.
In attendance were, among others, the University Chancellor (Dr. Joe Wanjui), the Chairman of the University Council (Mr. John Simba), two former Vice Chancellors (Prof. Francis Gichaga and Prof. Crispus Kiamba) and the two current Deputy Vice Chancellors. Professor Kiamba is the current Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Higher Education , Science and Technology.
Taifa Hall was full: with invited guests, the university's academic (including yours truly) and non-academic staff and students. The ceremony lasted just over an hour, after it got started at around ten.
The speeches were warm and good-natured. Everyone was in a celebratory mood, and wanted to have fun -- such as could be had. The Minister renewed acquaintances with her former colleagues here, mentioning in her speech Prof. Odingo and Mr. Jasper Okelo. She taught history here for a time some 28 years ago. Citing a recent encounter in Canada, the Chancellor, I thought, wanted to spur the university to help, in some way (which way I did not quite get) to clean up Nairobi River, which flows nearby.
The VC reported that the university's next cohort of graduands (due to graduate in December) would be the first in the university's history (did I hear him right?) to complete their studies without any interruption (due to previously common university closures occasioned by chronic student strikes). I have not checked the records, but that would mean, for the first time, four academic years of uninterrupted campus peace -- a period which roughly overlaps with 67% of Prof. Magoha's tenure as Vice Chancellor.
The Great Court was full of great white tents, and most of the celebrants proceeded there for refreshments after Taifa Hall. It was a warm sunny day.
Following so soon after the July 2008 Webometrics report, which ranked UoN first in the country, second in East Africa (after the University of Dar Es Salaam), and 25th in Africa, the ISO certification was reason enough for Prof. Magoha to assert that the University of Nairobi is the premier university in the region. I thought the Minister agreed. I agree.
The challenge will be to maintain the ISO certification -- with reviews being undertaken twice a year. I believe the university is up to the challenge, but sight must not be lost of the need to include academics more collegially and dialogically in the university's governance system -- and of the fact that they are both service providers and service users.
In attendance were, among others, the University Chancellor (Dr. Joe Wanjui), the Chairman of the University Council (Mr. John Simba), two former Vice Chancellors (Prof. Francis Gichaga and Prof. Crispus Kiamba) and the two current Deputy Vice Chancellors. Professor Kiamba is the current Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Higher Education , Science and Technology.
Taifa Hall was full: with invited guests, the university's academic (including yours truly) and non-academic staff and students. The ceremony lasted just over an hour, after it got started at around ten.
The speeches were warm and good-natured. Everyone was in a celebratory mood, and wanted to have fun -- such as could be had. The Minister renewed acquaintances with her former colleagues here, mentioning in her speech Prof. Odingo and Mr. Jasper Okelo. She taught history here for a time some 28 years ago. Citing a recent encounter in Canada, the Chancellor, I thought, wanted to spur the university to help, in some way (which way I did not quite get) to clean up Nairobi River, which flows nearby.
The VC reported that the university's next cohort of graduands (due to graduate in December) would be the first in the university's history (did I hear him right?) to complete their studies without any interruption (due to previously common university closures occasioned by chronic student strikes). I have not checked the records, but that would mean, for the first time, four academic years of uninterrupted campus peace -- a period which roughly overlaps with 67% of Prof. Magoha's tenure as Vice Chancellor.
The Great Court was full of great white tents, and most of the celebrants proceeded there for refreshments after Taifa Hall. It was a warm sunny day.
Following so soon after the July 2008 Webometrics report, which ranked UoN first in the country, second in East Africa (after the University of Dar Es Salaam), and 25th in Africa, the ISO certification was reason enough for Prof. Magoha to assert that the University of Nairobi is the premier university in the region. I thought the Minister agreed. I agree.
The challenge will be to maintain the ISO certification -- with reviews being undertaken twice a year. I believe the university is up to the challenge, but sight must not be lost of the need to include academics more collegially and dialogically in the university's governance system -- and of the fact that they are both service providers and service users.
Labels:
2008,
Dialogue,
Gichaga,
Great Court,
Higher Education,
ISO 9001-2000,
Kiamba,
Kosgey,
Magoha,
Taifa Hall,
U of Dar Es Salaam,
U of Nairobi,
UoN,
Vice Chancellor,
Wanjui,
Webometrics
Monday, June 23, 2008
Zimbabwe: Tsvangirai's Eleventh-Hour Capitulation
All things considered, Tsvangirai’s withdrawal, Sunday, from Zimbabwe’s Presidential runoff elections, less than a week away now, is a betrayal of the worst kind. He has betrayed the memory and the sacrifice of all the martyrs of Zimbabwe’s second liberation; and of many others in Africa and elsewhere who have too often been betrayed by the very leaders in whose names they, in effect, died. And he has betrayed the constitutional process that should anchor the larger democratic process in an organized society. He has done so under some quaint reading, perhaps, of the Gandhi’s tradition of non-violence; or under the mere guise of that.
Now tyrant Mugabe is going to gain undeserved, and almost incontestable, victory. Obscene as that victory will be, Mugabe will now not be under any pressure, such as he might have been, to explain away his declaration of victory, or any discrepancy between the votes he got last March and those he might have claimed in the runoff. Tsvangirai has declared that victory for him, and has legitimized Mugabe’s new term – and the pathological leadership that it perpetuates.
Tsvangirai forgets that he was in the runoff not by the simple declaration of his candidacy (such as came into play in March 2008), but because the people had forced a runoff on Mugabe – and only he was constitutionally entitled to challenge the tyrant in the second round. One would have thought that he was keenly aware of his historic duty in this matter – a duty to run – and of the historicity of this moment for Zimbabwe, and for Africa. One would have thought that he felt, deeply, equal to the task; but clearly, one thought wrong. Instead, he has become hostage to fear. There is no profile in courage here.
I have given up on him, who has given up on the runoff. While Mugabe mockingly pleads with him to not give up the electoral fight, Tsvangirai will now be hoping, it seems, that what he has failed to do he can get Mbeki, whose incompetence is increasingly obvious and increasingly frustrating, to do for him; and if not Mbeki, then SADC; and if not SADC, then AU. Or perhaps the UN! That’s timidity itself. No one is going to do it for you, Morgan!
Tsvangirai has become, just so plainly, too terrified to go on. Much as he may try, he will not explain away this surrender. For the rest of us, it is his loss of nerve that is so disempowering. You see, you cannot win when you capitulate!
The best thing he can do right now is to change his mind and run -- against Mugabe! It is not too late. If he does not, it might just be too late to save his own leadership -- and Zimbabwe!
Now tyrant Mugabe is going to gain undeserved, and almost incontestable, victory. Obscene as that victory will be, Mugabe will now not be under any pressure, such as he might have been, to explain away his declaration of victory, or any discrepancy between the votes he got last March and those he might have claimed in the runoff. Tsvangirai has declared that victory for him, and has legitimized Mugabe’s new term – and the pathological leadership that it perpetuates.
Tsvangirai forgets that he was in the runoff not by the simple declaration of his candidacy (such as came into play in March 2008), but because the people had forced a runoff on Mugabe – and only he was constitutionally entitled to challenge the tyrant in the second round. One would have thought that he was keenly aware of his historic duty in this matter – a duty to run – and of the historicity of this moment for Zimbabwe, and for Africa. One would have thought that he felt, deeply, equal to the task; but clearly, one thought wrong. Instead, he has become hostage to fear. There is no profile in courage here.
I have given up on him, who has given up on the runoff. While Mugabe mockingly pleads with him to not give up the electoral fight, Tsvangirai will now be hoping, it seems, that what he has failed to do he can get Mbeki, whose incompetence is increasingly obvious and increasingly frustrating, to do for him; and if not Mbeki, then SADC; and if not SADC, then AU. Or perhaps the UN! That’s timidity itself. No one is going to do it for you, Morgan!
Tsvangirai has become, just so plainly, too terrified to go on. Much as he may try, he will not explain away this surrender. For the rest of us, it is his loss of nerve that is so disempowering. You see, you cannot win when you capitulate!
The best thing he can do right now is to change his mind and run -- against Mugabe! It is not too late. If he does not, it might just be too late to save his own leadership -- and Zimbabwe!
Labels:
2008,
Africa,
AU,
Capitulation,
Mbeki,
Mugabe,
Runoff Elections,
SADC,
Second Liberation,
Tsvangirai,
UN,
Zimbabwe
Sunday, June 08, 2008
Hillary's Long Goodbye
I watched Hillary's concession speech, and her endorsement of Obama as their party's presidential nominee, on CNN, Saturday evening. She should have endorsed him sooner, though. I think the "long" delay has done only damage to the already shaken Clinton legacy. Still, I was impressed by the historicity of the moment, and by her no less historic delivery. I felt admiration for her dry, dry-eyed and inner strength -- in contrast to the all-red (all out) Bill. And I felt genuinely sorry for her, wondering why she should not try again in 2016.
She has moved closer to having an important role in the coming Obama administration -- and it is surely coming. As I have pointed out in my blog, however, there are great risks to her being Obama's running mate. Not in 2008 -- perhaps in 2012, should there be an opening.
I think the first female President of the US will most likely be one who has shattered, really shattered, the glass ceiling into more than 18 million pieces all on her own -- to the much debatable extent that heroes do these things alone -- and not, as was tragically Hillary's unsolicited and inescapable fate, essentially on the back of her husband's record (as a two-term US President!). But by 2016 Hillary (who's healthy enough, it seems to me) will most certainly have "atoned" (with extended duty and absence from the highest table)for her easy path to the 2008 campaign, as a former First Lady, and may be that female who at last shatters what now remains only, though so enticingly, cracked.
She has moved closer to having an important role in the coming Obama administration -- and it is surely coming. As I have pointed out in my blog, however, there are great risks to her being Obama's running mate. Not in 2008 -- perhaps in 2012, should there be an opening.
I think the first female President of the US will most likely be one who has shattered, really shattered, the glass ceiling into more than 18 million pieces all on her own -- to the much debatable extent that heroes do these things alone -- and not, as was tragically Hillary's unsolicited and inescapable fate, essentially on the back of her husband's record (as a two-term US President!). But by 2016 Hillary (who's healthy enough, it seems to me) will most certainly have "atoned" (with extended duty and absence from the highest table)for her easy path to the 2008 campaign, as a former First Lady, and may be that female who at last shatters what now remains only, though so enticingly, cracked.
Labels:
2008,
2012,
2016,
Bill Clinton,
Concession,
Duty,
Endorsement,
Female President,
First Lady,
Glass Ceiling,
Hillary,
Legacy,
Nominee,
Obama,
Obama Administration,
Running Mate,
US
Wednesday, June 04, 2008
Barack Obama: Presumptive Presidential Nominee of the Democratic Party
Yesterday, 3rd June 2008, was a truly historic day on many accounts in the United States -- and in Kenya. Dare I add Africa and the world at large? Circumspection, alone, holds me back -- but not my [My! My! My!] exclamation! Since we are hours ahead of America here in Kenya, that moment of glory, when Obama reached and then passed the pivotal total of 2118 pledged delegates and superdelegates, a moment which will be etched indelibly (dare I say for eons?) in the annals of at least two great countries, actually occurred very early this morning -- June 4th. A son of Kenya (for that he is) -- alright, a son of America and Kenya both -- had won a presidential marathon in that same America in which Kenyan runners are so used to winning marathons; and in which Americans are so used to seeing, and cheering, them! Cheers, America! And cheers Jatelo!
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
While in neighbouring Tanzania on that momentous night, Jesse Jackson aptly noted on CNN (I believe I heard him correctly) that Obama's veins flow with the blood of two continents! And I think he thinks -- as Obama and millions of Democrats and Independents and even some Republicans think -- that the time has, this time, come; come for the dream deferred to be at last lived.
Here in Kenya, where the average political leader is a crook of one kind or another (and/or ring-fenced by crooks with a till to loot), where party primaries (if they are held at all)are typically "won" by those who pay the largest monetary tribute to the leader (under the guise of the party), and where local and national elections are habitually rigged(stress habit), with impunity, in favour of those who have thus won the party leader's favour, is it any wonder that millions of us have been so enthralled by, so suspensefully glued to, Obama's indomitable quest -- first as an underdog and then as the much-maligned front-runner -- and are now so thrilled by his present victory, and the victory which (we see) is to come?
To Kenyans, the most important lesson of Obama's primary victory is this: you can be a successful politician without being a crook. Conversely, crookedness is not at all "genetically" (inescapably) programmed into political forms of life. Nor is mean-spiritedness. And self-centeredness, which invariably breeds self-aggrandizement, should not be a feature, let alone the defining feature, of political ambitions or public life generally.
Crookedness may be the way things are, concretely, here and now in Kenya (and elsewhere); but it is not the way things must be. Nor the only way these things can be. It is not that politicians cannot help themselves, but must lie, cheat and steal. All too often, what is read -- indeed, misread -- as typical is only that which we have refused or failed to check, and have instead irrationally accepted as rational; that is, rationalized. Impunity thrives on such rationalization, even as it sucks out all the creative energies in our field of play.
If Obama should win in November, I think certain politicians, with an attitude and bad habits, here in Kenya (and let me say elsewhere in Africa) will begin to notice that the unrequited public attention and adulation which they have for long enjoyed will begin rapidly to wane. You see, there will be another (more electrifying) standard and standard-bearer to be measured against. There will be another Jatelo whose wholesomeness of character will put a glaring spotlight on the blemishes in these other characters. May he win, then, in November! And may he never deviate from the promise that he has become; the promise that his electorate, and we here, have come to see in him!
Last night Hillary refused to concede, but that's OK. She will, still. What would be obscene, and utterly unacceptable, would be to trade (or to seek to trade) her concession for the Vice Presidency. I have remarked upon her unsuitability in another blog. What transpired last night only reinforces that view.
I know, though, that a trade of that kind(widely hailed as the only escape from civil war) occurred right here in Kenya just a few months ago, following a disputed presidential election which degenerated into widespread inter-ethnic violence. Many observers believe that the violence was in part instigated or encouraged by political leaders, too used to double-speak for our own good, who doubled up as underground warlords. In the latest issue of The East African, a weekly newspaper, there is, instructively, a chilling account of serious arms-smuggling, as late as last March (which was after the February signing of the peace accord between PNU and ODM) from Somalia into Kenya (and into the hands of an unnamed militia group here). AU (Ugandan) peace-keeping forces in Somalia are, disappointingly, implicated in this smuggling. The point here is that this is the very antithesis of Obama's brand of politics, to which the world is now going to have to pay attention. But does Hillary want to emulate Kenyan politicians, having recently made reference to Mugabe's bad ways?
Labels:
2008,
America,
CNN,
Delegate,
Democrat,
East African,
Election,
Hillary,
Jackson,
Jatelo,
Kenya,
Leader,
Mugabe,
Obama,
President,
Republican,
Runners,
Somalia,
Tanzania,
Vice President
Tuesday, June 03, 2008
Kenya's Vernacular Radio Stations: To Ban Or Not To Ban?
Kenya’s ex-President, Daniel Arap Moi, wants the Government to ban the country’s “mushrooming” crop of vernacular radio stations, according to Saturday Nation of May 31, 2008. His reasons for this are that they are giving rise to “tribal chiefs”, and are fanning ethnic animosity by serving as vehicles for divisive politics. He justifies his call with the example of Rwanda in the early nineties, when broadcasts from such stations prompted anarchy and a genocidal orgy. The catalytic factor there, however, was not the existence of the stations per se but rather the assassination of the Rwandese President, Juvenal Habyarimana, when his plane was downed as it approached Kigali. The culprits remain at large still; as well camouflaged now, perhaps, as when they carried out their murderous act in 1994.
Still, the ex-President has a valid example. This is reinforced by Kenya’s own experience in January and February of 2008, particularly in the expansive Rift Valley. Protests against the announced presidential election results quickly took a violent turn. The violence then quickly became inter-ethnic because, in the eyes of ODM supporters in the Rift Valley and parts of Western Province, the “stolen presidential election” meant that there was not going to be a resolution of the land issue this time either. There was not going to be a resolution, just as there had not been during the 24-year presidency of Arap Moi, himself a son of the Rift Valley -- a 24-year reign during which Moi was, indeed, l’état.
The land issue – precisely who (or which ethnic community) really was entitled to the land that colonial farmers left behind at independence, or soon thereafter? -- had remained unresolved for much longer than the 24 years, in fact; that is, since independence on December 12, 1963. During the 2007 campaign, ODM supporters had been promised by their political leaders, in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, that this time around the issue would at last be resolved, upon the much-anticipated victory of ODM’s presidential and parliamentary candidates. This time, the justice that Moi had failed or neglected to dispense for 24 years would e dispensed, with finality.
Needless to say, then, the inter-ethnic violence in Kenya was triggered by a disputed presidential election result, and by adverse message it signaled vis-Ã -vis the land issue, not by the existence of the radio stations as such. There have been claims, to be sure, that certain radio stations in the Rift Valley and elsewhere did prompt their listeners to xenophobic pillage and murder – and revenge. In Rwanda, fortunately, such urgings were recorded by those who would subsequently prosecute the perpetrators. I am not aware that similar recordings exist in Kenya to serve as evidence for the prosecution – perhaps I have not paid sufficient attention to the adduced evidence. If such recordings exist, they should be used in court without fear or favour.
The said Saturday Nation issue reminds the reader that Moi made a similar but unsuccessful banning call in August 2000, when he was still president, arguing that radio stations should broadcast only in English and Kiswahili – Kenya’s official and national languages, respectively. But his own Minister for Information at the time, Mr. Johnstone Makau, would hear none of it, arguing that “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture.” It is intriguing that Moi allowed his minister to win that particular argument.
That “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture” is precisely the point, but we can say more: These radio stations are the only viable, nearly always-on and commute-free channels of contact with the world beyond the confines of the village for a wide cross-section of Kenya’s rural communities, where English and Kiswahili remain at the margin of daily life. They are an indispensable source of broadcasts rich in locally relevant content: news (local, regional and national), announcements (including funeral announcements, the occasional obituary and visits by dignitaries and government officials), entertainment (particularly music, comedy and story-telling), radio-evangelism, language-teaching (particularly of urban youth, since many of these broadcasts reach urban areas as well) and the growth of the vernaculars themselves, as broadcasters struggle to domesticate new concepts or standardize usages arising from day-to-day local living or from farther afield. Lately, mobile phones (some 13 million Kenyans have them now, out of a population of 35 million) have emphatically arrived to challenge the vernacular radio stations as channels of communication, but not in the domain of impersonal or mass communication.
Vernacular radio stations are tailor-made avenues for reaching members of local communities during emergencies and disaster situations, and should be recognized as such in emergencies, scenario-building and disaster plans. When easily accessible and trusted information sources, and easily understood messages are at a premium, vernacular radio stations are an asset, not a liability.
What is more, these stations already offer sustainable jobs to more Kenyans than, I believe, are employed abroad in our embassies and high commissions. They also extend marketing and advertising channels to parts of the Kenyan market which manufacturers and service providers, usually based in the cities, would find it harder to reach than they now do. Viewed thus, they are an essential component of wealth-creation in the country. Demand for their services grows demand for radios and batteries, thereby further sustaining local industries and jobs, to the extent that these are not undercut by subsidized or cheaper imports.
The foregoing suggests that the use of vernacular radio stations in ways that subvert the national good tends to coincide with the onset of transitional periods, or periods of high anxiety that cut across ethnicities and regions to engulf a whole country – such as during general elections. If that is the case, then the challenge to policy-makers is how to put in place measures that effectively monitor and punish, early enough, errant stations in their specificities – during those periods of great risk. The policy solution should not be unimaginative and too unself-critical. We should not impose blanket punishment against vernacular radio stations as a generic category, in the mistaken calculation that one offender implicates and damns all. During periods of normalcy, live and let live is clearly the norm across the country – and should be the catch-phrase.
In conclusion, it needs to be said that to ban vernacular radio stations would be to ban the future, or certainly to attempt to do so. In the sense that these radio stations are almost by definition, given their foregoing characterization, an integral part of the African renaissance -- which several thinkers have been calling for or endeavouring to realize, in our time. That is, moreover, if one defines the African renaissance as the simultaneous re-flowering and re-configuration – indeed, the elevation (or levitation?) to a distinctly higher plane – of the African way of life, and of the associated modes of expressing it.
Still, the ex-President has a valid example. This is reinforced by Kenya’s own experience in January and February of 2008, particularly in the expansive Rift Valley. Protests against the announced presidential election results quickly took a violent turn. The violence then quickly became inter-ethnic because, in the eyes of ODM supporters in the Rift Valley and parts of Western Province, the “stolen presidential election” meant that there was not going to be a resolution of the land issue this time either. There was not going to be a resolution, just as there had not been during the 24-year presidency of Arap Moi, himself a son of the Rift Valley -- a 24-year reign during which Moi was, indeed, l’état.
The land issue – precisely who (or which ethnic community) really was entitled to the land that colonial farmers left behind at independence, or soon thereafter? -- had remained unresolved for much longer than the 24 years, in fact; that is, since independence on December 12, 1963. During the 2007 campaign, ODM supporters had been promised by their political leaders, in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, that this time around the issue would at last be resolved, upon the much-anticipated victory of ODM’s presidential and parliamentary candidates. This time, the justice that Moi had failed or neglected to dispense for 24 years would e dispensed, with finality.
Needless to say, then, the inter-ethnic violence in Kenya was triggered by a disputed presidential election result, and by adverse message it signaled vis-Ã -vis the land issue, not by the existence of the radio stations as such. There have been claims, to be sure, that certain radio stations in the Rift Valley and elsewhere did prompt their listeners to xenophobic pillage and murder – and revenge. In Rwanda, fortunately, such urgings were recorded by those who would subsequently prosecute the perpetrators. I am not aware that similar recordings exist in Kenya to serve as evidence for the prosecution – perhaps I have not paid sufficient attention to the adduced evidence. If such recordings exist, they should be used in court without fear or favour.
The said Saturday Nation issue reminds the reader that Moi made a similar but unsuccessful banning call in August 2000, when he was still president, arguing that radio stations should broadcast only in English and Kiswahili – Kenya’s official and national languages, respectively. But his own Minister for Information at the time, Mr. Johnstone Makau, would hear none of it, arguing that “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture.” It is intriguing that Moi allowed his minister to win that particular argument.
That “vernacular is part of the Kenyan culture” is precisely the point, but we can say more: These radio stations are the only viable, nearly always-on and commute-free channels of contact with the world beyond the confines of the village for a wide cross-section of Kenya’s rural communities, where English and Kiswahili remain at the margin of daily life. They are an indispensable source of broadcasts rich in locally relevant content: news (local, regional and national), announcements (including funeral announcements, the occasional obituary and visits by dignitaries and government officials), entertainment (particularly music, comedy and story-telling), radio-evangelism, language-teaching (particularly of urban youth, since many of these broadcasts reach urban areas as well) and the growth of the vernaculars themselves, as broadcasters struggle to domesticate new concepts or standardize usages arising from day-to-day local living or from farther afield. Lately, mobile phones (some 13 million Kenyans have them now, out of a population of 35 million) have emphatically arrived to challenge the vernacular radio stations as channels of communication, but not in the domain of impersonal or mass communication.
Vernacular radio stations are tailor-made avenues for reaching members of local communities during emergencies and disaster situations, and should be recognized as such in emergencies, scenario-building and disaster plans. When easily accessible and trusted information sources, and easily understood messages are at a premium, vernacular radio stations are an asset, not a liability.
What is more, these stations already offer sustainable jobs to more Kenyans than, I believe, are employed abroad in our embassies and high commissions. They also extend marketing and advertising channels to parts of the Kenyan market which manufacturers and service providers, usually based in the cities, would find it harder to reach than they now do. Viewed thus, they are an essential component of wealth-creation in the country. Demand for their services grows demand for radios and batteries, thereby further sustaining local industries and jobs, to the extent that these are not undercut by subsidized or cheaper imports.
The foregoing suggests that the use of vernacular radio stations in ways that subvert the national good tends to coincide with the onset of transitional periods, or periods of high anxiety that cut across ethnicities and regions to engulf a whole country – such as during general elections. If that is the case, then the challenge to policy-makers is how to put in place measures that effectively monitor and punish, early enough, errant stations in their specificities – during those periods of great risk. The policy solution should not be unimaginative and too unself-critical. We should not impose blanket punishment against vernacular radio stations as a generic category, in the mistaken calculation that one offender implicates and damns all. During periods of normalcy, live and let live is clearly the norm across the country – and should be the catch-phrase.
In conclusion, it needs to be said that to ban vernacular radio stations would be to ban the future, or certainly to attempt to do so. In the sense that these radio stations are almost by definition, given their foregoing characterization, an integral part of the African renaissance -- which several thinkers have been calling for or endeavouring to realize, in our time. That is, moreover, if one defines the African renaissance as the simultaneous re-flowering and re-configuration – indeed, the elevation (or levitation?) to a distinctly higher plane – of the African way of life, and of the associated modes of expressing it.
Labels:
1963,
1994,
2000,
2007,
2008,
Election,
Ethnic,
Genocide,
Habyarimana,
Kenya,
Moi,
ODM,
Radio,
Rift,
Rwanda,
Vernacular,
Violence,
Western,
Xenophobia
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Hillary Clinton for VP?
With the campaign season winding down for this year's nomination of the Democratic Party's flag-bearer, media attention has increasingly turned to the question of who is to be the Presidential nominee's running-mate. That nominee is most certainly now going to be Barack Obama, but is Hillary Clinton a suitable nominee for Vice President?
Many arguments have been put forth in the print and electronic media (including the blogosphere) in support of her nomination as the party's candidate for VP. Let us recall a few. Some argue, even insist, that this is the only way that her millions of ardent supporters -- women, working-class whites and older (baby-boomer) voters -- will vote for the Democratic ticket. Related to that, others point out that if she is not part of the ticket, then she (or the Clinton family as a whole)will not campaign with any enthusiasm for their party's nominee. As an aside, it is pointed out that Al Gore lost to Bush II in 2000 at least in part because he did not make full use of the magic of Brand Clinton.
Moreover, since she has proven to be "more electable" than Obama, she cannot simply be ignored. Indeed, Obama's impending victory at the party's convention in August will be a hollow one, it is argued, because he has failed to win the swing (or red) states which a Democrat must win in the general elections this November to enter the White House. These states include West Virginia, Kentucky, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Ohio -- not to mention the other must-win states such as California and New York, both of which Hillary also won. And if Florida and Michigan votes were to be discounted, and their delegates not fully seated or not seated at all at the Democratic convention, then the party would essentially be giving the nod to an impostor whom the voters will duly reject in November. So the argument goes, notwithstanding the fact that Obama has so far actually won more states, more pledged delegates and more popular votes, and is leading in the superdelegate-count. In fact, his lead is mathematically insurmountable for Hillary.
Hillary insists that she is not a quitter, and that she will fight until the party officially has a nominee, before which the matter of Florida and Michigan must be resolved. Even before it is, however, she is already claiming to have the majority of the popular votes cast -- that is, when you include, yes, Florida and Michigan. Despite party rules and tradition which give the nod based on delegates, not popular votes, she would like to rewrite the rules and the tradidion, presumably just for this campaign season, to have as the criterion for nomination the majority of popular votes cast. Conveniently ignored, for the moment is that though Gore led Bush by some 500,000 popular votes in 2002, Bush became president because the law gives the nod to the candidate who has the majority of votes in the electoral college, adding up to some 270 votes -- not the popular votes.
Lately, however, Hillary has begun publicly to acknowledge that the odds of her winning the nomination are slim, but she fights on. However, some in her campaign team have begun pushing for her nomination for VP. Even her husband, Bill Clinton, has begun quietly to spearhead the campaign for the number two slot for her. He is doing so while insisting that she is the one the party should nominate for President if it is to have any reasonable hope of returning to the White House after the November election.
Many in Obama's camp, and many non-partisan commentators, have a different view. They believe that Hillary's negative poll-rating (lately in the upper 60s), partly related to her campaign style, her years as a Washington insider and her husband's record in the White House, would be a real drag on Obama's campaign and Presidence -- predicated as it is on change ("Change You Can Believe In"). It would represent, so the argument goes, a return of sorts of the Clintons (and related scandals)to the White House. Obama would not be his own man -- the Clintons would constantly try to upstage him, and Bill would continue to speak, in calculated but always deniable ways, out of turn. In effect, he would be an elephant who would soon run out of China -- and run Obama out of the China Shop (the White House); but none too soon for Hillary to launch her campaign for 2012.
The notion that Obama needs Hillary for victory in November must be interrogated in context. Yes, JFK chose LBJ as his running-mate in 1960, despite the viciousness of that nomination season. The duo did win, but to say that they were not real buddies is to understate it. Kennedy was assassinated in Texas (only incidentally Johnsons' home-state)in 1963, and Johnson became President. He was sworn into office while airborne -- somewhere between Dallas and Washington, D.C. -- on the same Air Force One that was returning the slain President's body back to Washington, D.C.
Johnson and RFK did not see eye-to-eye -- at all, it seems -- and there are many who would argue that the blame for this must be apportioned equally. Johnson won the 1964 Presidential election with a landslide, with Hubert Humphrey (not RFK) as his running-mate, for his own full term. He was entitled to stand again in 1968, but chose not to after (after, as many observers might insist) RFK declared his own candidacy. And then, of course, RFK was assassinated, in California. Johnson did not change his mind about standing -- probably weighed down by the Viet Nam war.
Hillary has lately used RFK's assassination as one reason for her continued campaign for the Democratic nomination. This has sparked off a firestorm. But she pleads innocence, arguing that she harbours no macabre wishes. This, her campaign insists, is not one of the big thunderbolts from the blue sky -- bigger than Obama's comments about "bitter" (and presumably mostly white) rural folk who cling to religion, guns and even bigotry; and bigger than Rev. Wright's rantings -- she had on her mind which might strike Obama and force him out of the race. She needed to be there, as an active candidate, when that hopefully happened -- lest some other (less worthy? less entitled?)candidate jump into the fray. It was, rather, merely a factual but probably ill-considered reference to how long earlier contests (including her own husband's in 1992)have lasted. Ill-considered in May even, as it turns out, after she had made the same reference last March!
I think Hillary and Bill are too selfishly calculating for her to be Obama's running-mate. It seems that they would accept the VP slot only because it would further their interest; and that interest does not necessarily include Obama's victory in November 2008, or possible re-election in 2012. In fact, his victory would be her final loss -- and Bill's. So who says that as nominee for Vice President she would campaign energetically for the ticket's victory this November. And even if they were to win in November, what assurance is there that there would be no persistent attempts to handicap Obama in order to ensure her own ascendancy in 2012? I think that this kind of thinking must have informed LBJ's choice of a running-mate for the 1964 elections.
There are pundits who point out that the Clintons did not fully involve themselves in Al Gore's presidential bid in 2000 -- though, in their view, it was Gore who chose to keep Bill on the sidelines. Probably there is some truth in that -- the same truth which explains why McCain is not too keen to have Bush II publicly involved in his campaign. Other pundits claim that the Clintons were not really enthusiastic about Kerry's bid in 2004, either. In both campaigns, it is pointed out, Hillary's own presidential ambitions could only be furthered by Gore's and then Kerry's failures.
Now, available evidence amply shows that these ambitions of Hillary's were alive and kicking even while the Clintons were still in the White House. I may add that they probably give the definitive reason why she did not leave Bill (and the White House) after the Lewinski scandal. To do so would have been to abandon her own self-constructed future, a future which Obama out of nowhere now stands in the way of -- insolently, disrespectful of proper pecking order.
Let me illustrate my own unease with Hillary being Number Two with the contents of an excerpt from Sally Bedell Smith's book For Love of Politics which appeared in the Vanity Fair edition of November 2007 [the book itself was scheduled for publication in February, 2008]. I have read the excerpt,not yet the book. What does Smith say? Despite some kind of written "pre-nuptial" between Bill the President and Gore the Vice President, Hillary invariably stood in the way; "She was the absolutely necessary person he had to have to bounce things up against, and he was that for her." So the constitutional two-some of President and Vice President became a three-some, with Hillary's inclusion in the making of all major decisions. No wonder she claims to have the experience which Obama does not have -- and which David Gergen, a Presidential advisor, considered then a "rolling disaster".
Smith notes, however, that Hillary's political life reached a milestone on November 6, 1998 -- the day Senator Moynihan declared that he would not seek a fifth term in November 2000 as a Senator from New York. Since the Clintons had already been eying that seat for months, it took her only a few days after the announcement to decide that she would run for that seat. Smith adds that as a sitting President, Bill was in a unique position to boost his vice-president's candidacy, "But in 1999 those resources were diverted from Gore to Hillary 'in a big way'" -- and, Governor Mario Cuomo had noted then, the "implications for Gore [were] very serious."
"Not only was Hillary unavailable as a campaigner" for Gore, Smith says, "she was poaching top Democratic fund-raisers and donors who would normally concentrate on the vice president" -- who had announced his own run for President in June 1999 (while the Clinton family was away in Europe). And even before Hillary's senate campaign officially kicked off, she had on one occasion insisted on being invited to a Gore fund-raiser organized by Gore's wife Tipper and her friends in Los Angeles. She was, only to ask for donations for herself from the same audience -- in front of Tipper! That was not to be the end of her, and Bill's, mean-spiritedness.
Smith observes that Bill's behaviour throughout 2000, the last year of his own presidency, "betrayed ambivalence about a Gore victory, at least one earned on the vice president's own terms." This behaviour manifested itself in "making passive-aggressive remarks, belittling Gore in private, grabbing the spotlight with his own star turns, and continuing to argue his innocence in various scandals."
And Hillary's own Senate campaign interests increasingly collided with Gore's presidential ambitions, as was dramatized in September 2000 in a tussle over who should publicize the Federal Trade Commission's report on violence in the media -- the First Lady running for Senate, or the Vice President running for President. To beat her to a limelight which she insisted on sharing -- if necessary, a negotiated sharing -- Gore and Lieberman (his running mate) secretly arranged a New York Times newsbreak, which appeared in the morning of the same September 11 when the FTC report was scheduled for release.
On election night in November 2000, Hillary won her Senate fight, while Gore embarked on a month-long "political purgatory" on account of the Florida recount, which eventually gave Busth the presidency. But, "Almost immediately [after Hillary's victory, and presumably before the Florida recount was completed] the rumors started about a Hillary presidential candidacy in 2004 or 2008," Smith points out.
As I have followed the contest during this primary season on TV and the Internet, and in the print media, I have come to the conclusion that, like many others, that Obama must look for another running-mate. If Hillary wants to be president, it shouldn\t be on Obama's stabbed back. She can leave him alone to fail on his own this November. Then she will be free try her luck again in 2012. I have seen a list of 5 or so perfectly capable running-mates for Obama.
Many arguments have been put forth in the print and electronic media (including the blogosphere) in support of her nomination as the party's candidate for VP. Let us recall a few. Some argue, even insist, that this is the only way that her millions of ardent supporters -- women, working-class whites and older (baby-boomer) voters -- will vote for the Democratic ticket. Related to that, others point out that if she is not part of the ticket, then she (or the Clinton family as a whole)will not campaign with any enthusiasm for their party's nominee. As an aside, it is pointed out that Al Gore lost to Bush II in 2000 at least in part because he did not make full use of the magic of Brand Clinton.
Moreover, since she has proven to be "more electable" than Obama, she cannot simply be ignored. Indeed, Obama's impending victory at the party's convention in August will be a hollow one, it is argued, because he has failed to win the swing (or red) states which a Democrat must win in the general elections this November to enter the White House. These states include West Virginia, Kentucky, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Ohio -- not to mention the other must-win states such as California and New York, both of which Hillary also won. And if Florida and Michigan votes were to be discounted, and their delegates not fully seated or not seated at all at the Democratic convention, then the party would essentially be giving the nod to an impostor whom the voters will duly reject in November. So the argument goes, notwithstanding the fact that Obama has so far actually won more states, more pledged delegates and more popular votes, and is leading in the superdelegate-count. In fact, his lead is mathematically insurmountable for Hillary.
Hillary insists that she is not a quitter, and that she will fight until the party officially has a nominee, before which the matter of Florida and Michigan must be resolved. Even before it is, however, she is already claiming to have the majority of the popular votes cast -- that is, when you include, yes, Florida and Michigan. Despite party rules and tradition which give the nod based on delegates, not popular votes, she would like to rewrite the rules and the tradidion, presumably just for this campaign season, to have as the criterion for nomination the majority of popular votes cast. Conveniently ignored, for the moment is that though Gore led Bush by some 500,000 popular votes in 2002, Bush became president because the law gives the nod to the candidate who has the majority of votes in the electoral college, adding up to some 270 votes -- not the popular votes.
Lately, however, Hillary has begun publicly to acknowledge that the odds of her winning the nomination are slim, but she fights on. However, some in her campaign team have begun pushing for her nomination for VP. Even her husband, Bill Clinton, has begun quietly to spearhead the campaign for the number two slot for her. He is doing so while insisting that she is the one the party should nominate for President if it is to have any reasonable hope of returning to the White House after the November election.
Many in Obama's camp, and many non-partisan commentators, have a different view. They believe that Hillary's negative poll-rating (lately in the upper 60s), partly related to her campaign style, her years as a Washington insider and her husband's record in the White House, would be a real drag on Obama's campaign and Presidence -- predicated as it is on change ("Change You Can Believe In"). It would represent, so the argument goes, a return of sorts of the Clintons (and related scandals)to the White House. Obama would not be his own man -- the Clintons would constantly try to upstage him, and Bill would continue to speak, in calculated but always deniable ways, out of turn. In effect, he would be an elephant who would soon run out of China -- and run Obama out of the China Shop (the White House); but none too soon for Hillary to launch her campaign for 2012.
The notion that Obama needs Hillary for victory in November must be interrogated in context. Yes, JFK chose LBJ as his running-mate in 1960, despite the viciousness of that nomination season. The duo did win, but to say that they were not real buddies is to understate it. Kennedy was assassinated in Texas (only incidentally Johnsons' home-state)in 1963, and Johnson became President. He was sworn into office while airborne -- somewhere between Dallas and Washington, D.C. -- on the same Air Force One that was returning the slain President's body back to Washington, D.C.
Johnson and RFK did not see eye-to-eye -- at all, it seems -- and there are many who would argue that the blame for this must be apportioned equally. Johnson won the 1964 Presidential election with a landslide, with Hubert Humphrey (not RFK) as his running-mate, for his own full term. He was entitled to stand again in 1968, but chose not to after (after, as many observers might insist) RFK declared his own candidacy. And then, of course, RFK was assassinated, in California. Johnson did not change his mind about standing -- probably weighed down by the Viet Nam war.
Hillary has lately used RFK's assassination as one reason for her continued campaign for the Democratic nomination. This has sparked off a firestorm. But she pleads innocence, arguing that she harbours no macabre wishes. This, her campaign insists, is not one of the big thunderbolts from the blue sky -- bigger than Obama's comments about "bitter" (and presumably mostly white) rural folk who cling to religion, guns and even bigotry; and bigger than Rev. Wright's rantings -- she had on her mind which might strike Obama and force him out of the race. She needed to be there, as an active candidate, when that hopefully happened -- lest some other (less worthy? less entitled?)candidate jump into the fray. It was, rather, merely a factual but probably ill-considered reference to how long earlier contests (including her own husband's in 1992)have lasted. Ill-considered in May even, as it turns out, after she had made the same reference last March!
I think Hillary and Bill are too selfishly calculating for her to be Obama's running-mate. It seems that they would accept the VP slot only because it would further their interest; and that interest does not necessarily include Obama's victory in November 2008, or possible re-election in 2012. In fact, his victory would be her final loss -- and Bill's. So who says that as nominee for Vice President she would campaign energetically for the ticket's victory this November. And even if they were to win in November, what assurance is there that there would be no persistent attempts to handicap Obama in order to ensure her own ascendancy in 2012? I think that this kind of thinking must have informed LBJ's choice of a running-mate for the 1964 elections.
There are pundits who point out that the Clintons did not fully involve themselves in Al Gore's presidential bid in 2000 -- though, in their view, it was Gore who chose to keep Bill on the sidelines. Probably there is some truth in that -- the same truth which explains why McCain is not too keen to have Bush II publicly involved in his campaign. Other pundits claim that the Clintons were not really enthusiastic about Kerry's bid in 2004, either. In both campaigns, it is pointed out, Hillary's own presidential ambitions could only be furthered by Gore's and then Kerry's failures.
Now, available evidence amply shows that these ambitions of Hillary's were alive and kicking even while the Clintons were still in the White House. I may add that they probably give the definitive reason why she did not leave Bill (and the White House) after the Lewinski scandal. To do so would have been to abandon her own self-constructed future, a future which Obama out of nowhere now stands in the way of -- insolently, disrespectful of proper pecking order.
Let me illustrate my own unease with Hillary being Number Two with the contents of an excerpt from Sally Bedell Smith's book For Love of Politics which appeared in the Vanity Fair edition of November 2007 [the book itself was scheduled for publication in February, 2008]. I have read the excerpt,not yet the book. What does Smith say? Despite some kind of written "pre-nuptial" between Bill the President and Gore the Vice President, Hillary invariably stood in the way; "She was the absolutely necessary person he had to have to bounce things up against, and he was that for her." So the constitutional two-some of President and Vice President became a three-some, with Hillary's inclusion in the making of all major decisions. No wonder she claims to have the experience which Obama does not have -- and which David Gergen, a Presidential advisor, considered then a "rolling disaster".
Smith notes, however, that Hillary's political life reached a milestone on November 6, 1998 -- the day Senator Moynihan declared that he would not seek a fifth term in November 2000 as a Senator from New York. Since the Clintons had already been eying that seat for months, it took her only a few days after the announcement to decide that she would run for that seat. Smith adds that as a sitting President, Bill was in a unique position to boost his vice-president's candidacy, "But in 1999 those resources were diverted from Gore to Hillary 'in a big way'" -- and, Governor Mario Cuomo had noted then, the "implications for Gore [were] very serious."
"Not only was Hillary unavailable as a campaigner" for Gore, Smith says, "she was poaching top Democratic fund-raisers and donors who would normally concentrate on the vice president" -- who had announced his own run for President in June 1999 (while the Clinton family was away in Europe). And even before Hillary's senate campaign officially kicked off, she had on one occasion insisted on being invited to a Gore fund-raiser organized by Gore's wife Tipper and her friends in Los Angeles. She was, only to ask for donations for herself from the same audience -- in front of Tipper! That was not to be the end of her, and Bill's, mean-spiritedness.
Smith observes that Bill's behaviour throughout 2000, the last year of his own presidency, "betrayed ambivalence about a Gore victory, at least one earned on the vice president's own terms." This behaviour manifested itself in "making passive-aggressive remarks, belittling Gore in private, grabbing the spotlight with his own star turns, and continuing to argue his innocence in various scandals."
And Hillary's own Senate campaign interests increasingly collided with Gore's presidential ambitions, as was dramatized in September 2000 in a tussle over who should publicize the Federal Trade Commission's report on violence in the media -- the First Lady running for Senate, or the Vice President running for President. To beat her to a limelight which she insisted on sharing -- if necessary, a negotiated sharing -- Gore and Lieberman (his running mate) secretly arranged a New York Times newsbreak, which appeared in the morning of the same September 11 when the FTC report was scheduled for release.
On election night in November 2000, Hillary won her Senate fight, while Gore embarked on a month-long "political purgatory" on account of the Florida recount, which eventually gave Busth the presidency. But, "Almost immediately [after Hillary's victory, and presumably before the Florida recount was completed] the rumors started about a Hillary presidential candidacy in 2004 or 2008," Smith points out.
As I have followed the contest during this primary season on TV and the Internet, and in the print media, I have come to the conclusion that, like many others, that Obama must look for another running-mate. If Hillary wants to be president, it shouldn\t be on Obama's stabbed back. She can leave him alone to fail on his own this November. Then she will be free try her luck again in 2012. I have seen a list of 5 or so perfectly capable running-mates for Obama.
Labels:
1968,
2000,
2004,
2008,
Bush,
Clinton,
Gore,
Hillary,
Humphrey,
JFK,
Johnson,
Kennedy,
LBJ,
Obama,
President,
RFK,
Running Mate,
Vice President,
Viet Nam,
VP
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)