Showing posts with label UoN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UoN. Show all posts

Sunday, July 09, 2017

KENYA: Current Benefits under NHIF's Basic Insurance Cover ~ w.e.f. May 2016

INTRODUCTION

The great majority of Kenyans, including University lecturers, have no clear idea of the range or magnitude benefits that they are entitled to under the National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF). This realization, made more challenging by on-going negotiations with a private insurer, finally prompted a delegation from the University of Nairobi Health Insurance Group (UNASHIG) to visit NHIF offices at Upper Hill, Nairobi, last Friday (July 7th 2017). 

The officers whom UNASHIG officials met at NHIF informed the delegation that all contributors to NHIF’s Basic or Standard cover enjoy (with effect from May 2016) the same benefits equally, whether they pay KES 1,700/-, 500 or only 150/- per month. Concerning Inpatient treatment, NHIF pays a daily rate towards all aspects of care, not a bed rate. The daily Inpatient rate ranges from a minimum of KES 1,500/- to a maximum of KES 4,000/-, depending on the hospital you choose. This daily rate is payable for a total of 180 days (or 6 months) only, in any given year. The daily rate at Nairobi Hospital, for example, is KES 4,000/-. Thus, the maximum that NHIF can pay for 180 days at Nairobi Hospital is KES 720,000/-.


The purpose of an enhanced group cover, such as UNASHIG seeks, would be to bridge the gap between the expenses billed by the patient’s combined service providers and the amounts that NHIF is obliged to pay under the provisions of the Basic Inpatient cover, as specified below. In our quest for enhanced group cover, the big question which we must collectively answer is: How high do we want to go above the respective components of the Basic Cover specified below, and can we afford it all?  READ MORE

ALSO READ: Mauri Yambo (March 2015) "Insurance in Traditional African Society ~ 'Thinking Aloud' "

Tuesday, March 21, 2017

Conversations: Toward the UoN Medical Insurance Scheme

INTRODUCTION

There has been a felt need for medical insurance at the University of Nairobi since the late 1990s. The capacity of the University Health Services (UHS) to provide needed services gradually weakened in tandem with increasing staff numbers (plus the more rapidly growing number of dependents) and declining capitation by the national government. As it did so, the need for an insurance scheme grew. And yet everyone was stuck in the mindset that any enhancement of service delivery and related cover must be employer-driven. Staff who could afford additional services on their own did so, of course, but they were few and far between. Dons waited for the employer to do something, even as many were blinded or distracted by the prospects of Module II pay. The employer, it increasingly seemed, waited for providence to show its hand.

Fast-forward to March 2017. With the signing of a pay deal between the National Office of the University Academic Staff Unions (UASU) and the association of university employers, everything suddenly changed. Conversations about a medical insurance scheme fully funded by academic staff themselves began in earnest, spurred by pent-up frustrations with the status quo, and perhaps also by the prospects of a more responsive remuneration regime. 

What follows below is essentially an abbreviated transcript of the conversations that University of Nairobi dons have been having lately. This had actually started in the last days of a WhatsApp group called Lecturers' Strike. The group's essential purpose had been to keep UASU members posted on the twists and turns of the pay negotiations sparked-off by a national strike declared in January 2017. 

When a deal was struck and the strike called off on March 13th, those who had signed on to that WhatsApp group left in droves, as if running away from something; as if fear was not the only thing one had to fear. But not before the need to continue with discussions already started about two topics was emphasized: a new sacco and don-driven medical insurance. 

While some shifted to a national idea dubbed Mhadhiri, a more focused WhatsApp group called UoN Medical Insurance Group was formed on March 16, 2017. A total of 86 academic staff had joined the group by early morning of March 21st, but on different dates. Those who joined days after the discursive engagement had begun have asked for a better way to bring them (themselves) up to speed, than simply asking them to scrawl up and down the comments on the old group page. After all, going back to the Lecturers' Strike sounded like going to an abandoned 'dwelling' in the dark, where malevolence might prowl -- unseen. Hadn't brave folks just dashed out of the now desolate place? 

We have toyed with two options: 1) to periodically insert the earliest texts in the continuing conversation for the benefit of relative newcomers; and, 2) to shift older texts to an online platform in order to obviate looped and entangling insertions. What you find on this blog post is option 2. Not all that was said is shown here. So these are excerpts, arranged in chronological order. 


TRANSCRIPT OF OLDER CONVERSATIONS

March 13, 2017:
P.O. (2:33 PM): Strike over!

V. (2:52 PM): Kindly attend a members' meeting today at 4 pm in Senior Common Room on the 2013-2017 CBA.

M.K. (4:43 PM): Mhadhiri Sacco, join by following the link below. So far it appears uon is missing out.

M.U. (5:02-5:04 PM): 1. I fully support the Mhadhiri Sacco. We need it urgently. However, could we reflect on the formal process of establishing it?... The NO of UASU should be challenged to pick up this matter...

R.O. (5:18 PM): I don't understand background to this drive? Is Chuna no longer serving our sacco interests?

P.C. (5:21 PM): Which chuna? Have you seen the dividend it gives? A sacco associated with the employer is not always the best...

R.O. (5:27 PM): To a large extent dons have been quite aloof on Chuna issues - will they be more engaged with mhadhiri?

M.Y. (5:33 PM): I honestly think that launching a group health insurance to enhance health cover well above what the University offers would be more protective of everyone's future than any sacco, regardless of who will be at the helm. Of course I am assuming that the law permits such cover to supplement the existing one. As for a new sacco, I bet it will collapse before 2021...

M.U. (5:35 PM): The Mhadhiri Sacco can also pick the insurance cover for us as a complimentary benefit.

Anon (5:40 PM): Will finance remit contributions since they don't to external saccos?

R.O. (5:42 PM): My thought is lets clean up our Chuna!

P.C. (5:42 PM): These days one can use other avenues including Mpesa and bank orders. If we use finance on this, what happens when it delays remittances?

J.M. (5:53 PM): Let us start our own sacco and organize ourselves to augment our health insurance cover. The two could be somehow tied together...

M.Y. (9:10 PM): We tried to launch a FoA sacco [in 1999-2000] but didn't make any headway. We encountered resistance from Chuna and its support structure from the highest level at UoN and in the coop movement. We were determined but the resistance was huge...

M.M. (9:17 PM): I think that was then, Now we can do it. Prblm is we're good at eating instins, not growing them...

L.K. (10:32 PM): I thot this [sacco] idea is already being discussed on another platform that we were referred to... How many mhadhiri saccos will we have surely???

J.M (10:40 PM): Agree. Those interested in sacco can join the telegram forum provided.


March 14th: 
K.K (7:37 AM): If you join a SACCO whose membership comprises [Dons] from these new universities, you will be in trouble... 

T.M (9:41 AM): This lefting is reminiscent of another WhatsApp group I had been added to plan a wedding. I forgot to leave after the event until I was eventually removed long after the marriage had...

R.O. (9:44 AM): Interesting to 'watch' the Exodus! I think academics should be able to disagree amicably without disengaging.

K.O. (9:54 AM): Let us respect people's right to choose either to to leave or stay in the platform. Lefting is perfectly okay just as...

M.Y. (9:59 AM): I support the idea of a parallel Medical Scheme, but built into it must be  some form of group insurance to protect us and our dependents adequately against serious emergencies -- short term or long term. Right now we are totally exposed to such dangers.

Back to saccos. One must decide if a new well-run sacco is desirable because of the services it can deliver, or if we just want one of our own because we don't want to mix it up with the 'others' at meetings. The first sentiment is wholesome and perhaps even holy. The second is simply doomed to failure for various reasons -- besides its snootiness... 

M.U (10:15 PM): Am from UoN whwrw I go to the university clinic. But I think it is high time that we get an insurance cover than hii university clinic. KNUT has partmer with AON Insurance and teachers can jump to any hospital and be treated. They have a 700k for just outpatient.

R.O. (10:24 PM): I think this falls under the internal CBA for the UoN UASU chapter.

M. (10:45 PM): The medical insurance cover is a priority area... we need to translate this idea into action...We can trust Colleagues with insurance expertise to provide guidance and help us shop for a stable insurance company.

March 15:

M.Y. (12:00 AM): Grateful for the comments I have read on the proposed parallel medical cover. How do I think we should fund it? By pushing a resolution to allocate right from the Salaries Office 50% of the amount we have been remitting to UASU on a monthly basis. That will probably generate KES 2,500,000 per month and 30m per year from UoN Dons alone, assuming there are 2,000 of us and that those not in UASU agree to join the parallel scheme. 

The debits should go directly to an account managed by Trustees elected by contributors and independent of both UASU and varsity management.  

We can start this at UoN before we go national.

I think that service providers and intermediaries such as AAR, UAP, AON, Britam and the big hospitals will go gaga over this.

M.U. (12:44 AM): It will be much cheaper running such a scheme than even the UHS.

J.A. (6:45-6:46 AM): I fully support. Critical mass of interested persons required to move forward. Can we have advice on the nit grits please. This way we will cushion ourselves and those we represent during lean and difficult times.

Anon (6:47 AM): Every government employee is entitled to a medical allowance. We do not get this and it should be channelled to the scheme as opposed to the clinic [which] some of us cannot access because it does not make any economic sense to incur transport costs just to be referred to other hospitals.

Anon (8:20 AM): I also believe in the investment part. This could as well be a solution to the sacco proposal touted earlier in the forum. UASU investment group.

M.Y. (9:12 AM; 10:26 AM): An investment group is a great idea too. The stronger it gets, the greater the voice it will give Dons in the national economy and beyond. nd it can grow very quickly if prudently managed. Much more innovative than the conventional sacco idea.

Any Investment Group we launch must be independent of both University management and UASU. UoN Dons are perfectly capable of launching an Institution-based Investment Group.

Anon (10:29 AM): It is a better fit compared to a sacco.

M.Y. (10:46 AM): UASU is our political arm. It shouldn't scheme to hog all other aspects of our lives. Imagine Jubilee or NASA trying to seize all their members' initiatives.

O.W. (12:00 PM): Yes, these are some of the issues that we need to follow up on immediately lest we forget that there are many other issues touching on our welfare that need to be given as equal attention as remuneration!

R.O. (12:09 PM): Many interesting ideas are being floated by colleagues. It will be important to focus on a few with resolute determination to see them come to fruition. I also think it is dangerous to destroy UHS: our employer committed himself to providing high-quality health services, and we should hold him to account concerning this. This, of course, does not preclude an insurance scheme, which is a very good idea. Again, I think that if we pursue all these things simultaneously, we shall spread ourselves too thin. Let us identify one or two lines to pursuewith vigour, get them going, and then take up more.

E.A. (12:11 PM): Best suggestion R.O.

R.O. (12:20 PM): Thanks a lot, E.A! I suggest that we rename this group to reflect its vision beyond the strike.

J.M. (12:27 PM): Good idea

M. (1:02 PM): No doubt UHS @uon are doing their best under the prevailing circumstances. However, I still support an independent insurance cover which will cover dental and optical issues without a minimum refund requirement. It can be very distressing when families have to decide who gets their root canals before the other because of shortage of funds.

M.U. (2:10 PM): The entire UHS needs overhaul. We need an upgrade to to a fully fledged teaching and referral hospital. Meantime, a good insurance cover is urgent. It will save us the blushes and hassles of admission and discharge from hospitals. 

M.N (2:16 PM): The VC was looking for avenues to generate income for UoN. Starting a world class hospital to rival Aga Khan and the rest is worth trying. The land in perfect location is there, the staff are abundant and the patients are in their millions. Kazi kwetu.

M.U. (2:16 PM): Tiny parastatals like the Tourism Fund, Kevevapi, Kemri etc have excellent medical covers for staff. Why are we stuck in this stone age?

M.U. (1218 PM): They have been talking about this [World Class Hospital] issue for over a decade. Where are we? KU came from behind, they are almost done with their referral hospital...

R.O. (2:23 PM): I agree that the insurance scheme is most urgent because it would take a while to get a referral hospital.

M.M. (3:04 PM): If the list of interim officials of proposed mhadhiri sacco is genuine, it luks like another plot 2 sideline uon (remember uasu no). If that is the case, the idea is A DEAD DUCK!

K. (3:07 PM): Saw this too. No way I can continue to present myself for other deliberately marginalizing outfits. No way.

L.O. (3:29 PM): I support the dual approach. As we plan for the insurance cover the Union should see how services at UHS can be improved.

M.M. (3:47 PM): We must invent a formula of dstrbtng elective posts in all our outfits 2 reflect theface of Kenya. We're in the era of devolution, human rights including women and ppl with disabilities.

P.C. (4:45 PM): I think it's better to air these sentiments at the Mhadhiri Sacco forum, this is the wrong forum for this

M.Y. (5:27 PM): How many people do we still have in this Lecturers' Strike Forum? If it is the wrong forum, can someone offer to launch a new one for those of us interested in the Medical Insurance idea and who think that a sacco, Mhadhiri or otherwise, would not be the right base for it? We need to have a meeting of UoN Dons about Med Insurance in the next two or so weeks.

O.W. (5:32 PM): The medical insurance meeting, yes I support! But also think that UASU UoN chapter should convene a quick meeting so that we agree on the agenda for 2017. We can then present to them ...a checklist of all the issues we want them to pursue next

M.Y. (5:40 PM): That's fine too. We need to have a conversation at UoN with with our UASU UoN leadership. But those who will run the scheme must be an independent board with its own mandate and account. Yes, let's meet, but not as SCR, perhaps one of the big rooms at The Tower.

M.U. (5:46-5:47 PM): I am in full support. Admin, could you please create a separate forum to address the issues M.Y is raising. I will be a member of the group.

M.U. (6:25 PM): Admin kazi kwako.

March 16:

The The UoN Medical Insurance Group was launched on WhatsApp.

Admin (11:50 AM): Any UoN Don interested in this conversation is free to join.

A total of 13 Dons registered on the first day, Dr. Agaya being the first. 

R.O. (8:03 PM): Thanks...for adding me to this group! Let us pursue this matter with determination, focus and effective strategy.

M.U. (8:08 PM): Thanks for adding me to the list. A great step in the right direction.

J.M. (8:15 PM): Thank... and support sentiments of my colleagues above.


**End of transcript available from the Lecturers' Strike Forum, just as exodus from the Forum picks up speed**


March 17th:

M. (4:22 AM): Thanks for the add. Ni ya Nini lakini?

Admin (4:54 AM): Dr..., you were [on] a list I was given to include in this WhatsApp Group. The group is dedicated to building a consensus around a much needed UoN Medical Insurance Scheme. This should help Dons fill the current gap in UHS service delivery, particularly with regard to major emergencies, which Dons have frequently encountered.

The problem is essentially financial, and the driving idea is how to leverage our collective purchasing power in order to source adequate medical cover during emergency admissions and fairly extended hospitalization or specialized care of contributing members.

Admin (5:33 AM): I should also add that Dons wish to have the flexibility which a medical card gives in terms of where one can go for checkups or medication in lesser emergencies, and when travelling or on leave.

We shouldn't be tied to just one clinic, or tied down by regulations entailing written and time-consuming pre-approval for every visit to a doctor. But certainly, every card will impose limits on how much can be spent over a set period of time.

M.U. (8:28 AM): ...And some medical covers are exceptionally good, some have very good complementary benefits. As dons, we have numerical advantage which ordinarily attracts better packages.

J.A. (8:41 AM): I can't agree more...We need serious advice on how to move forward with speed.

M. (9:19 AM): Let's be cautious... Inasmuch as insurance cards have flexibility, they have limits say kshs. 1 million for inpatient. This has to be borne in mind. Current arrangement can be strengthened...My thoughts.

M.U. (9:24 AM): The red tape and hassle at UHS when you need admission is painful. UHS has no flexibility if you [reside] far away from town. I think this initiative is [complementary] to what we have. Lastly, reforms have hardly been implemented at the UHS in spite of the many efforts.

Admin (9:22 AM): Good thoughts. We must maximize the possibilities of our collective effort. As the conversation proceeds, we'll begin to pin down details and specifics and consider various optimization options. I think at some point we will invite one or two experts in medical insurance to give us a talk. Our own home-grown Actuarial Scientists will be asked to share their calculations.

J.A. (9: 30 AM): Let us move forward carefully leveraging on available expertise from within and without... It is a matter of getting value for money... Medical costs can bring even the very richest to zero ground in a matter of days.  

M. (9:34 AM): Thanks doc. We can explore possibilities of pressing for reforms at UHS. Let's make wide consultations, as suggested, for informed choices.

J.A. (9:42 AM): How do we [reform] UHS when one cant [get] even basic medication. Remember University managers are well taken care of and so they really don't care about what goes on at the health facility... Recall what happened with education for dependants? Immediately the managers were through with educating theirs everything literally collapsed... At JKUAT the education waiver for staff children is 80% unless it has changed recently. 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

NOTICE is hereby duly served of the First General Meeting of the Founding Members of the UoN Medical Insurance Group, to be held in 8-4-4 Hall (MPH), on Main Campus, UoN, from 2 to 5 pm on Sunday, April 9, 2017.

AGENDA
1. Meeting called to order, followed by prayer(s).
2. Introductory remarks by Prof. Yambo: How we got here and where we're headed.
3. Self-introductions by Founding Members.
4. Official Naming of Medical Insurance Group.
5. Determining the Group's core function(s) and outlining its Memorandum and Articles of Association. Steps to registration.
6. Election of seven Trustees or Directors to the Board, with positions for Executive Chairperson, Secretary, Finance, Medical, Legal and Board Member (all subject to variation at the general meeting).
7. Determining the parameters of Group health insurance needs.
8. General discussion: How to identify and procure the services of a credible medical insurer.
9. Launch of the Register of Group Members. Setting of Membership fee.
10. Scheduling of presentations by prospective insurers.
11. AOB.
12. Closing of meeting. Prayers. Photos.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 








UPDATED: March 22, 2017 (9:38 AM and 9:36 PM); March 23 (8:06 AM); March 27, 2017 (10:21 PM); April 6, 2017 (7:26 PM); April 28, 2017 (10:40 PM); May 11, 2017 (6:15 PM); May 17, 2017 (2:25 PM). [To be continued. Meanwhile, any group member with objections to this transcript can make his/her views known on our WhatsApp platform, for all members to see]


Saturday, May 14, 2016

Siege and Paper Memories

May 9th 2016 was the date that CORD (Coalition for Reform and Democracy), Kenya's opposition coalition, had set for another demonstration at -- another siege of -- the IEBC (Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission) offices in Anniversary Towers, on University Way -- just across the road from the iconic gate of the Main Campus of the University of Nairobi (UoN). So what you first see in the picture-frame of the video below (taken at just about the moment ten turned to eleven am) is the UoN fraternity at the gate, witnessing the build-up to the promised demo. The squat building just inside the campus -- at the far left, next to the gate -- is the office of the students' union, SONU. Legend has it that many decades ago, in colonial Kenya, it served as the mortuary for early Nairobi Africans. The large building to the right is Hyslop Building. The smaller structure next to it is Science Building. The Fountain of Knowledge is farther to the right, well out of sight in this frame of (the camera person's) mind -- and in the order and coming disorder of the day.

Back to the picture-frame: Barricading University Way -- as if laying preemptive siege on a single-minded horde that's yet to arrive for its own siege -- and looking west, is but one contingent of the Riot Police, in full gear, mobilized for the occasion and recently re-tooled for rapid, and potentially vicious, crowd control. There are dancers, too -- CORD's passionate ramming rod for such events -- in the street, just in front of the police vehicles, slyly whipping up the passions, raising its very body heat and flexing its soft underbelly and easy to read power. But you can't see them in the still. You simply have to take it from the chronicler.

IMAGES: Of Siege

I'm just thinking: Harry Thuku -- Besigye's precursor, to a degree -- never had such abundance of attention and such seasoned avant garde when he was arrested in 1922, nearly a century ago and less than half a kilometer away, across what is now the Main Campus. But he has a road to his name now. So the Main Campus is triangulated by three roads: Harry Thuku Road, University Way and Uhuru Highway (which by some sort of sleight-of-hand belongs to Kenya's current President). UoN shares the triangle with the National Theatre, Kenya Broadcasting Corporation, some offices of the British Council, and a Synagogue that somehow always remains invisible even to those who routinely see, better still sense, it. Some would argue that Harry Thuku Road actually runs through the Main Campus, slicing the engineering sciences and certain varsity sections off the triangle -- of which, nonetheless, they are an integral part.

Mothers Day having just gone by uneventfully on Sunday, no one was seriously expecting to see the Mother Of All this Monday -- the Mother of All Demonstrations. Still, there was palpable suspense all over here, and, as I gathered, all over town. Suspense but hardly fear. Clear anticipation of some version of blood, sweat and tears.

In the calm before the storm, I casually walked by, by the tail of the beast, but did not escape the unblinking eye of the camera. The picture-frame stirs into motion when you press play, and plays. Over and over as often as you press. Which is what one did later that evening, not knowing what one was about to come upon oneself. And then one saw oneself. Out of body. Look!

Look, I later shouted out in a tweet, to no one in particular (which is how it is in Twitterverse), "The man casually crossing 2ward #KoinangeSt in a white shirt, a briefcase in his left hand, is Yours Truly"

Look!



HERE: The tweet exchange that Nyar gi Jommo and I had following that exclamation


Now, back to earth: 
UoN may be at the edge of downtown Nairobi, but it's the city's intellectual epicentre, much to the chagrin of those who are chagrined. Over the years, too, politicians of various persuasions have gravitated toward it, seeking to tap into the idealistic energy and numerical power of its student "form of life" -- or to smother it with sanctimonious flabberghast. When UoN students get in a foul mood, the whole city sits up -- with a little shudder, perhaps, which is not of course how it's supposed to be. The academics, on the other hand, have quietly gone about the business of advancing disciplines and growing careers, under difficult circumstances. In the process they have raised UoN's global profile to surprising heights, without really sensing how their individual inputs add up to this. Yet much of this fuzzy input remains to be added still.

READ:  Can the University Help Make Better Cities?

The location of IEBC offices on University Way was not without expected though unstated collateral benefit to CORD's protest organizers. This despite the fact that UoN students were only recently back after some three weeks of forced closure -- just prior to which a disaffected faction had burned the insides of that very SONU office I have alluded to, perhaps thereby, with subliminal intent, 'cremating' its mortuary past, at last. Moreover, end-of-semester exams were beginning this very same week. When I crossed, then, it was the calm before the gas and water storm that could only be guessed at ahead of time. You could sense it, even downtown. The calm did come to a teary coda.

WATCH: Gas and Water Storm I

WATCH: Gas and Water Storm II

Here's @NyargiJommo's impressive picture of the day


I remember.

I remember back in 1968 when we demonstrated against 'Russian' occupation of sovereign Czechoslovakia, a country which doesn't exist anymore in the form(ation) that we fought for. A few of us highly motivated student types, members of NUKS (National Union of Kenya Students) -- which ceased to exist decades ago too, but whose Secretary for Foreign Affairs I was that year -- walked a few streets (including Kenyatta Avenue) one morning in downtown Nairobi, in holy but momentary anger and baby-boomer disgust at the occupation and the abduction of Alexander Dubcek, leader of The Prague Spring. A contingent of uniformed but unarmed police walked closely behind us, uttering not a word, the better to keep the peace -- which was under no threat. Hardly any of us knew how to pronounce Czechoslovakia, and so there was a cacophony of pronunciations -- which was fun in itself and an eye-opening reward for the marching.

The city hardly knew that there was a student procession that morning, unless you happened somehow to be nearby, until we, brave souls, appeared on national TV that night, in black and white. Alors, there were more policemen than students there on that grand occasion! It was the policemen (seemingly) who were demonstrating, and we students paving the way -- forward. Hilarity! I don't know if that video still exists at KBC. It would be fun to see it again. There was no KTN in those days, you may recall. Nor no NTV. I think if you saw the video you'd chuckle too. And perhaps shout: There goes the prof, again! It would be to be back to the future.

I remember.

I remember back in 2002 when we marched from Kombewa to Holo, in Kisumu Rural Constituency, to protest against the rigging of party elections through the eleventh-hour "direct nomination" of one of the aspirants for the Parliamentary seat. Nobody at headquarters in Nairobi listened, and there was no structure to besiege at Holo. We were too far away to have impact. A number of those who made the decision were expected to be on University Way this May 9th, and did indeed show up -- to fight against rigging and that sort of thing. The irony was palpable, but that's how things often are.

And so I crossed University Way and ran some errands, away from the camera's wide angle -- unaware for the 'moment' that I had not escaped capture.









UPDATED: May 14, 2016; May 16, 2016.

Thursday, April 10, 2014

Past Papers

Past Papers is a powerful meme in student circles. The drive to lay one's hands on past examination papers has been around for decades, as I remember. Having them was, so it was presumed, a legitimate way to reduce the vagaries of chance in the examination room; a way to read the examiner's mind ahead of time and to 'prosper'. That is, a way to level the playing field, and thus to optimize the probable score. Did it ever work? It did, I think, for many, over the years. But it required a certain capacity for predictive deduction, a method of dealing with fuzzy or 'big' data and seeing the future that we used without knowing the term that stood for it. Let me restate that, just to stay on the point a moment longer: we practised predictive deduction long, long before we were to know that we had been engaged in it. I suppose that there are many such moments, such abductions, in all our pasts. The room for error and anxiety was always considerable, for just as many -- despite the method.

You will find more discussion of predictive deduction applications in this text. 

Lecturers at the UoN make available to their students past papers and/or other material related to their courses via one or more of the following ways: (1) selectively giving out excess originals, (2) making photocopies at their own expense for use by class (usually small classes), (3) temporarily placing scarce 'originals' in on-campus photocopy kiosks, (4) lending copies directly to class reps to enable class members to make and pay for their own copies at places of their choice, (5) distributing copies as email attachments.

The university library system is supposed to be depository of past papers from all faculties, but the service is far from satisfactory because the system simply isn't working. It won't until all the material is properly gathered at the end of each examination period, meticulously collated and classified, serialized and -- above all -- posted online. Until then, I am happy to make my past papers available on my blog, having installed my own scanning equipment at home. There is none at the office.

Still, the pressure to update sets of papers in a timely manner remains a 'clerical' challenge, what with all the other stuff that one must simultaneously do. I still send by email a good number of sets, more particularly the most recent papers.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Rethinking Tuesday's Demonstrations by UoN Students

In a twitter I posted in the afternoon of Tuesday, March 10, I remarked that "The student demo got nastier after mid-afternoon. Whispers on campus already that the PM goofed big time by condoning it without reservation."

By "without reservation" I meant that Prime Minister Raila Odinga did not caution the students, whose planned demonstration he had so enthusiastically endorsed on human rights grounds, against the acts of hooliganism which have typically accompanied such demonstrations; that is, until Prof. George Magoha became Vice Chancellor of the University of Nairobi (UoN) about five years ago. One of his main achievements so far as VC is that student riots and general student "lawlessness", which had dogged this university for over three decades, became a thing of the past -- somehow, mysteriously, inexplicably, almost all-of-a-sudden -- as soon as he assumed office. Many of us still shake our heads at the turn-around -- at the peace and quite that the UoN has enjoyed for the last half-decade or so, and at the "possibilities" that they make possible. The Prime Minister's thoughtless act of endorsement was going to put at risk all this, many of us feared even before the scheduled day of demonstration arrived.

Unless one is dangerously out of touch with -- or does not allow oneself a judicious pause to consider the lessons of -- the recent history of student activism at the University of Nairobi, and elsewhere in Kenya, one ought to know that student demonstrations have typically degenerated into worrisome anti-social behaviour of a sort that has impacted negatively, often very negatively, on the human and property rights of other Kenyans, who also deserve protection. The Prime Minister did not have the presence of mind, or even-handedness, to ask the police to protect these other rights -- these other Kenyans. And so Tuesday came to pass as it did.

He did not need to get involved. He should not have been involved. There is no way that the killing of a university student under whatever circumstances would be allowed by the student body to go "unpunished" by way of a rowdy demonstration in the streets, and a few missed lecture-hours besides. As soon as news of the killing broke, we knew that there would be a demo this time. It even took too long to happen. It was not spontaneous, as the moment semed to demand. Perhaps there were behind-the-scenes negotiations on campus, and there were reports of threats against would-be demonstrators. Not even a Prof. Magoha, however, has the "charm" to avoid the eventuality of a demo under those brutal circumstances. So the Prime Minister had no reason or need to publicly, or privately, "restrain" him -- with or without mandate.

Now the police are blaming the PM for the embarassing consequences, and of course he has no real, convincing defence. Student leaders even went to him to apologize and express remorse face-to-face for the bad behaviour of their colleagues on Tuesday afternoon. However, the Prime Minister is yet to express his own remorse to the Kenyans whose rights were infringed upon at his apparent instigation -- and to accept responsibility for the infringement.

Sociologists say, and leaders better be reminded, that acts of commission and acts of omission are both acts -- over which "those who have responsibility" must be held responsible. In a reverse sort of reasoning, irresponsibility confers responsibility, from which one cannot escape.
The Prime Minister deigned to take away the responsibilities of UoN and Egerton University VCs on the matter of general student discipline, though he has no mandate to micro-manage universities or issue direct instructions to the police, and must now accept responsibility for Tuesday's turn of events.

It is precisely due to those events that Prof. Magoha is reported in one of today's newspapers to have asked politicians to stay away from university affairs. I would add: they haven't been quite helpful when and where we truly needed them; for example, when(ever) we were fighting for better terms of service. Instead, they have shed obligatory and crocodile tears. "It was very sad to see them behaving that way and I hope we are allowed to run the university as we should," Prof. Maguha said, and added:
"I was a spectator like everybody else and I would prefer to get instructions
from my employer. How do I take action on those who were rioting when the
protests were sanctioned by someone with more authority than me? They should
have allowed us to take control."
Of course, Raila's diehard supporters have been arguing, none-too-soon, that his PNU opponents took advantage of the occasion by inserting thugs, thuggery and looting into the demonstrations -- all in order to "tarnish his name." That's plausible, alright, but he should have known that he was dangling a temptation they couldn't resist. He should have denied them the opportunity to do just that by staying judiciously away from forever byzantine campus politics. If you ask me, he tarnished his own name all by himself -- a flawed mind-set that has become increasingly and worryingly characteristic since the Grand Coalition was crafted in February 2008 (indeed, some of us push the date back to November 2007). The safest way to not tarnish a name is to do the right thing -- consistently, all the time, all over the place.

Ironically, as it is apparently turning out -- according to postmortem findings of three pathologists and to witness accounts reported in today's newspapers (but which must be corroborated) -- Mr. Godwin Ogato, the student (the third person) whose death more directly prompted the demonstrations, was shot at close range with a pistol; after the police (who were reportedly carrying only G3 and/or AK-47 guns) had retrieved Mr. Paul Oulu's body from the halls and "were driving away."

I think that one of the most serious threats that we encounter and endure in our public and private institutions, of all kinds, is the "Tyranny of the Boss". Just as there is a culture of impunity, there is a culture of tyranny; but it is marked as tyranny only when the shoe is on the other foot. Thus, the boss is all-knowing. The boss has all the answers. The boss is never wrong. No other opinion matters. Don't contradict the boss. The boss has a good name. To criticize the boss is to the boss' name. Leave the boss alone. Don't embarass the boss. The boss knows what he/she is doing, keep to your own corner. The end justifies the means. Give the boss time.

Prof. Magoha would like to see the UoN allowed to run its own affairs itself, from within. Fair enough, but the university is not the VC, and the VC is not the university. The VC must have the humility to acknowledge that there are many smart minds at the UoN. It is simply a fact that there are many who were here long before he joined UoN. These are long-standing bearers of the institution's memory and values -- and indeed the strengths that enabled UoN to weather the many challenges of the Eighties and Nineties, and have made it possible for it to become, at last, what it is today.

University governance, while remaining jealously "within", must itself be broadly inclusive, genuinely consultative and respectfully consensus-based. There has not been enough of that in recent years. Instead, many academics feel excluded from key decisions that deeply affect them, and administrators are intimidated (and the academic staff union apparently co-opted) into "rubber-stamp" silence.

Prof. Magoha is a good man. We get on well -- though I am inclined, as is rather well-known, to speak my mind -- partly because I keep my distance, and partly because I no longer hold an administrative position that requires frequent attendance in the VC's presence. I personally like him, and like it that way. I think he has the capacity to change. It is not too late. That way, we can all, together, meet the rest of the country halfway, with heads held high.

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Prof. E.S. Atieno-Odhiambo, RIP

Some time between 2 p.m. and 3 p.m. on Thursday, February 26th, as I looked out of a window on Gandhi Wing (at the University of Nairobi), I thought I saw Prof. Atieno-Odhiambo stop to talk spiritedly to someone I didn't know. He, Atieno, was headed toward The Fountain of Knowledge, from the direction of Central Administration. My first thought was, "Ah, so Atieno is in town" (in Nairobi visiting us, his former colleagues at UoN, as he occasionally did during his many years at Rice University in Texas). On closer look, however, I saw that it was not the Prof. but someone else entirely. Someone I didn't know either. The person who had momentarily looked like Atieno "became" (morphed into) another before my eyes. Well, it so so happens. And so I dismissed the scene as one of those things, and didn't give it another thought -- concluding that Atieno must surely still be at Rice.

So I was quite taken aback last night at around 9.20 p.m. when my sister-in-law told me, and my wife confirmed, that -- according to the day's Standard newspaper (which I hadn't fully "gone through" yet, as the day had been filled with errands and an early graduate lecture) -- Prof. Atieno-Odhiambo had died (of 'dementia', as reported by his wife) at a hospital in Kisumu City, Kenya, on Wednesday, February 25. That was, incidentally, the same day that George Rarieya (Uncle George) died. I was quite, quite taken aback! I hadn't known that Atieno was back in the country. My thoughts suddenly ran back to that Thursday scene, and I just shook my head in disbelief as I recounted it (my wife, Joan, and her sister giving me a telling look).

When we got back home I checked The Standard and confirmed that it was really true.

Atieno was a leading scholar -- in Kenya, Africa and the world. He ventured boldly beyond the presumed boundaries of his discipline (history), and so extended them. He was much respected, and much liked, by many who knew and remember him (and who are still here) at the University of Nairobi. One of his most memorable works is the one he co-authored with David William Cohen, titled, Burying SM: The Politics of Knowledge and the Sociology of Power in Africa.

S.M. Otieno had been a dignified and very professional city lawyer with a deep sense of what it meant to be a cosmopolitan Kenyan, and what it meant to be charitable. He was a true embodiment of the Kenya (and Kenyans) we want. He had married across ethnic lines, but the cultural-and-legal controversy surrounding his place of burial, following his death in December 1986, sparked off the worst inter-ethnic animosity (since TJ Mboya's assassination in Nairobi 1969) between members of the Kikuyu and Luo communities -- to which his wife and he respectively belonged.

Perhaps even more insightful and intellectually riveting is the book, again co-authored with William David Cohen, titled Risks of Knowledge: Investigations Into the Death of the Hon. Minister John Robert Ouko in 1990. I read an extensive excerpt a few years ago, and was greatly impressed.

Surely, Atieno-Odhiambo has died too soon!

He was one of those few you always looked forward to seeing again, with feeling, upon their return, however brief, to the country. It was not supposed to be like this!

P.S. 1. For an obituary by David Cohen, posted on March 4, click here; 2. Click here for Cabral Pinto's opinion, posted on March 6th.

Thursday, August 07, 2008

University of Nairobi: ISO 9001-2000 Certification

The University of Nairobi received its ISO 9001-2000 certification this morning, at a feel-good ceremony in Taifa Hall. The Vice Chancellor, Prof. George Magoha, presided over the proceedings, at which the Guest of Honour was Dr. Sally Kosgey, Minister for Higher Education, Science and Technology.

In attendance were, among others, the University Chancellor (Dr. Joe Wanjui), the Chairman of the University Council (Mr. John Simba), two former Vice Chancellors (Prof. Francis Gichaga and Prof. Crispus Kiamba) and the two current Deputy Vice Chancellors. Professor Kiamba is the current Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Higher Education , Science and Technology.

Taifa Hall was full: with invited guests, the university's academic (including yours truly) and non-academic staff and students. The ceremony lasted just over an hour, after it got started at around ten.

The speeches were warm and good-natured. Everyone was in a celebratory mood, and wanted to have fun -- such as could be had. The Minister renewed acquaintances with her former colleagues here, mentioning in her speech Prof. Odingo and Mr. Jasper Okelo. She taught history here for a time some 28 years ago. Citing a recent encounter in Canada, the Chancellor, I thought, wanted to spur the university to help, in some way (which way I did not quite get) to clean up Nairobi River, which flows nearby.

The VC reported that the university's next cohort of graduands (due to graduate in December) would be the first in the university's history (did I hear him right?) to complete their studies without any interruption (due to previously common university closures occasioned by chronic student strikes). I have not checked the records, but that would mean, for the first time, four academic years of uninterrupted campus peace -- a period which roughly overlaps with 67% of Prof. Magoha's tenure as Vice Chancellor.

The Great Court was full of great white tents, and most of the celebrants proceeded there for refreshments after Taifa Hall. It was a warm sunny day.

Following so soon after the July 2008 Webometrics report, which ranked UoN first in the country, second in East Africa (after the University of Dar Es Salaam), and 25th in Africa, the ISO certification was reason enough for Prof. Magoha to assert that the University of Nairobi is the premier university in the region. I thought the Minister agreed. I agree.

The challenge will be to maintain the ISO certification -- with reviews being undertaken twice a year. I believe the university is up to the challenge, but sight must not be lost of the need to include academics more collegially and dialogically in the university's governance system -- and of the fact that they are both service providers and service users.

Friday, August 01, 2008

Top 30 Varsities (July 2008): Who's Number One Now, Who's Number One Then?

The latest (July 2008) Webometrics web-presence ranking of over 16,000 universities around the world ranks Massachusetts Institute of Technology (in the US) first in the world, and of course in the US. The world ranking places the University of Cape Town (in South Africa) number one position in Africa -- and a respectable 385th in the world. The University of Dar Es Salaam (in Tanzania), ranks first in both Tanzania and East Africa, 24th in Africa and 4,334th in the world. The University of Nairobi -- "the mother and father" of public universities, indeed all universities, in Kenya -- ranks first in Kenya, second in East Africa, 25th in Africa and 4,338th in the world. UoN was not Kenya's number one six months ago, Egerton University was. Shortly after Egerton University was declared number one, Kenyatta University (KU) was, in turn, declared Kenya's number one public university in terms of the match between its declared performance targets and actual performance attainments; but KU has fared badly in terms of global web-presence. So, who's really number one in Kenya, and how long will the cheers last? It is as though a version of the theory of relativity is at play here -- in Kenya and in Africa. If so, what about around the world?

For a full list of Africa's Top 100 universities, click on this link >>> Top 100 Universities in Africa . The list (first reported in the Sunday Standard edition of July 27, 2008) shows that all but one of the Top ten of those 100 universities are to be found in South Africa. The other is in Egypt.

Indeed, as the list below shows, among the Top 30 in Africa, 11 are in South Africa, 5 in Egypt, 3 in Morocco, 2 in Kenya, 2 in Namibia, and 1 in each of the following: Algeria, Mauritius, Mozambique, Rwanda, Senegal, Tanzania, and Zimbabwe. Rounding off Africa's Top 30 list is National University of Rwanda, which is ranked 5, 002 in the world. Conspicuously absent from the list are universities in Nigeria, Africa's political and economic powerhouse -- with, moreover, a long tradition of university education. Ghana's absence is likewise conspicuous and surprising. But just as surprising are the inclusion of one Rwandese and two Namibian institutions, given the two countries' relatively shorter "post-independence" history. Namibian institutions are in fact ranked 21st and 22nd in Africa, and 4,270 and 4,275, respectively, in the world. In either case, Namibian institutions are ahead of their counterparts throughout East Africa. University of Zimbabwe (17 in Africa and 4,001 in the world) is also placed higher than any of its counterparts in East Africa, despite Zimbabwe's terrible economic and political circumstances.

List of Top 30 Universities in Africa:

(Country and World Ranking in Brackets)
1. University of Cape Town (South Africa: 385)
2. Stellenbosch University (South Africa: 654)
3. Rhodes University (South Africa: 722)
4. University of Pretoria (South Africa: 734)
5. University of the Witwatersrand (South Africa: 831)
6. University of the Western Cape (South Africa: 1,218)
7. University of Kwazulu Natal (South Africa: 1,313)
8. University of South Africa (South Africa: 1,499)
9. American University in Cairo (Egypt: 1,654)
10. Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (South Africa: 2,145)
11. Cairo University (Egypt: 2,934)
12. University of the Free State (South Africa: 2,946)
13. Université Cheikh Anta Diop de Dakar (Senegal: 2,962)
14. University of Johannesburg (South Africa: 3,704)
15. University of Mauritius (Mauritius: 3,756)
16. Université Cadi Ayyad (Morocco: 3,961)
17. University of Zimbabwe (Zimbabwe: 4,001)
18. Mansoura University (Egypt: 4,002)
19. Ain Shams University (Egypt: 4,112)
20. University of Namibia (Namibia: 4,223)
21. Polytechnic of Namibia (Namibia: 4,270)
22. Al Akhawayn University Ifrane (Morocco: 4,275)
23. Université Abdelmalek Essadi (Morocco: 4,309)
24. University of Dar Es Salaam (Tanzania: 4,334)
25. University of Nairobi (Kenya: 4,338)
26. Université Abou Bekr Belkaid Tlemcen (Algeria: 4,452)
27. Arab Academy for Science & Technology and Maritime Transport (Egypt: 4,552)
28. Universidade Eduardo Mondlane (Mozambique: 4,689)
29. Strathmore University Nairobi (Kenya: 4,780)
30. National University of Rwanda (Rwanda: 5,002)


How was the global ranking carried out? We are told, first of all, that:

"The unit for analysis is the institutional domain, so only universities and research centres with an independent web domain are considered. If an institution has more than one main domain, two or more entries are used with the different addresses. About 5-10% of the institutions have no independent web presence, most of them located in developing countries. Our catalogue of institutions includes not only universities but also other Higher Education institutions following the recommendations of UNESCO. Names and addresses were collected from both national and international sources..."

So, what are the criteria? Four ranks -- V, S, R and Sc -- were developed, as we will see presently. These were then combined "according to a formula where each one has a different weight". The formula is presented as follows:

Webometrics Rank (position)=4*RankV+2*RankS+1*RankR+1*RankSc

The principle underlying this formula was that:

"University activity is multi-dimensional and this is reflected in its web presence. So the best way to build the ranking is combining a group of indicators that measures these different aspects."


This provided the rationale for identifying indicators for the respective ranks. In this respect, we are told that:

"Almind & Ingwersen proposed the first Web indicator, Web Impact Factor (WIF), based on link analysis that combines the number of external inlinks and the number of pages of the website, a ratio of 1:1 between visibility and size. This ratio is used for the ranking but adding two new indicators to the size component: Number of documents, measured from the number of rich files in a web domain, and number of publications being collected by Google Scholar database."

The four indicators in the Webometrics formula are further elaborated as follows:

1. Web Visibility (V): This refers to the number of external inlinks. "total number of unique external links received (inlinks) by a site" as recorded via Yahoo Search, Live Search and Exalead. For each engine, it is stated, "results are log-normalised to 1 for the highest value and then combined to generate the rank."

2. Web Size (S): the number of pages in an institution's website, captured by four search engines: Google, Yahoo, Live Search and Exalead. Here, too, it is stated that "For each engine, results are log-normalised to 1 for the highest value. Then for each domain, maximum and minimum results are excluded and every institution is assigned a rank according to the combined sum."

3. Number of documents -- that is, Rich Files (R) -- hosted by the website: These were counted using Google, as long as they were in any of the following file formats (which were deemed most relevant to "academic and publication activities", as well as being accommodative of different volumes of text): Adobe Acrobat (.pdf), Adobe PostScript (.ps), Microsoft Word (.doc) and Microsoft Powerpoint (.ppt). The Google results for each file type were merged "after log-normalising in the same way as described before."

4. Number of publications in the website's database, as verified through Google Scholar search -- Scholar (Sc): "Google Scholar provides the number of papers and citations for each academic domain." This "publications" indicator is quite liberally defined, seeing that it includes all "papers, reports and other academic items" captured in the search.


Three related rationales or considerations, broader in their sweep than the indicators per se, informed the ranking process -- a process which the publishers admit is a work in progress, useful (and defensible) as it is in its present form. There will of course be spirited debate.

The three rationales were, to use the publisher's words:

1. Relevance and validity of the indicators: "The choice of the indicators was done according to several criteria (see note), some of them trying to catch quality and academic and institutional strengths but others intending to promote web publication and Open Access initiatives. The inclusion of the total number of pages is based on the recognition of a new global market for academic information, so the web is the adequate platform for the internationalization of the institutions. A strong and detailed web presence providing exact descriptions of the structure and activities of the university can attract new students and scholars worldwide . The number of external inlinks received by a domain is a measure that represents visibility and impact of the published material, and although there is a great diversity of motivations for linking, a significant fraction works in a similar way as bibliographic citation. The success of self-archiving and other repositories related initiatives can be roughly represented from rich file and Scholar data. The huge numbers involved with the pdf and doc formats means that not only administrative reports and bureaucratic forms are involved. PostScript and Powerpoint files are clearly related to academic activities."

2. Measures of outcomes rather than inputs, as far as possible: "Data on inputs are relevant as they reflect the general condition of a given establishment and are more frequently available. Measures of outcomes provide a more accurate assessment of the standing and/or quality of a given institution or program. We expect to offer a better balance in the future, but [the] current edition intend[s] to call...attention to incomplete strategies, inadequate policies and bad practices in web publication before attempting a more complete scenario."

3. Weighting of different indicators: "The current rules for ranking indicators including the described weighting model has (sic) been tested and published in scientific papers. More research is still [to be] done on this topic, but the final aim is to develop a model that includes additional quantitative data, especially bibliometric and scientometric indicators."

It is clear that universities which want to improve their global and continental ranking will have to work on the criteria set by this ranking entity, even as those criteria evolve. Developing-country institutions should be actively involved in that evolution, and in the attendant debate.

To my mind, the criteria, as so far developed, are surprisingly empathetic to the general circumstances of Third World universities; and in particular are quite accommodative of those with a strong research-and-publications record, plus a sense of the esteem-value of a dynamic web presence. They are far less subjective (or otherwise biased), and avail a significantly more level playing-field, compared to the rule of thumb which has usually guided the rankings not just of institutions but also of the academics, who make such institutions possible at all. That rule of thumb has been designed largely to capture and highlight institutions' relative funded-research record and volumes of refereed publications in "international" journals and books -- and partly to reflect institutions' relative reputations as judged by prominent scholars (usually/historically based in the West). If "egalitarian" never endorsed the absence of effort, these criteria are, in a word, quite egalitarian.

Of course, money still talks in other ways; and explains the concentration of world scholars in US universities, which (let's not forget) have the remuneration packages and "working environments" to attract and retain them. However, the Webometric rankings are a pointer to the possibility that money does not entirely talk -- and to the greater possibility that academic institutions and academics, with a joint passion for excellence, can excel in this world, recardless of the part of the world in which they happen to be.

As I conclude, let us consider for a moment the latest list of the Top 30 universities in the world:

Rank Name of University (Country)
1. Massachusetts Institute of Technology (USA)
2. Harvard University (USA)
3. Stanford University (USA)
4. University of California Berkeley (USA)
5. Pennsylvania State University (USA)
6. University of Michigan (USA)
7. Cornell University (USA)
8. University of Minnesota (USA)
9. University of Wisconsin Madison (USA)
10. University of Texas Austin (USA)
11. University of Illinois Urbana Champaign (USA)
12. University of Pennsylvania (USA)
13. University of Washington (USA)
14. Carnegie Mellon University (USA)
15. Columbia University New York (USA)
16. Purdue University (USA)
17. University of California Los Angeles (USA)
18. University of Florida (USA)
19. University of Chicago (USA)
20. University of Maryland (USA)
21. University of Arizona (USA)
22. Texas A&M University (USA)
23. Georgia Institute of Technology (USA)
24. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University (USA)
25. Princeton University (USA)
26. University of Cambridge (UK)
27. Michigan State University (USA)
28. University of Toronto (Canada)
29. University of North Carolina Chapel Hill (USA)
30. Rutgers University (USA).

All but two of the world's Top 30 universities are based in the United States. The two are University of Cambridge (ranked 26th) and University of Toronto (ranked 28th). But that's a long way from when Al-Azhar was the one and only university in the ("known"?) world. Let me then, in view of all this, frame differently the question I posed earlier: If vesion of the theory of relativity is at play in the world ranking that we have looked at, what and how long is it going to take for a non-US university to become the world's number one? Will that be in our lifetime?