Showing posts with label SACCO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SACCO. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 21, 2017

Conversations: Toward the UoN Medical Insurance Scheme

INTRODUCTION

There has been a felt need for medical insurance at the University of Nairobi since the late 1990s. The capacity of the University Health Services (UHS) to provide needed services gradually weakened in tandem with increasing staff numbers (plus the more rapidly growing number of dependents) and declining capitation by the national government. As it did so, the need for an insurance scheme grew. And yet everyone was stuck in the mindset that any enhancement of service delivery and related cover must be employer-driven. Staff who could afford additional services on their own did so, of course, but they were few and far between. Dons waited for the employer to do something, even as many were blinded or distracted by the prospects of Module II pay. The employer, it increasingly seemed, waited for providence to show its hand.

Fast-forward to March 2017. With the signing of a pay deal between the National Office of the University Academic Staff Unions (UASU) and the association of university employers, everything suddenly changed. Conversations about a medical insurance scheme fully funded by academic staff themselves began in earnest, spurred by pent-up frustrations with the status quo, and perhaps also by the prospects of a more responsive remuneration regime. 

What follows below is essentially an abbreviated transcript of the conversations that University of Nairobi dons have been having lately. This had actually started in the last days of a WhatsApp group called Lecturers' Strike. The group's essential purpose had been to keep UASU members posted on the twists and turns of the pay negotiations sparked-off by a national strike declared in January 2017. 

When a deal was struck and the strike called off on March 13th, those who had signed on to that WhatsApp group left in droves, as if running away from something; as if fear was not the only thing one had to fear. But not before the need to continue with discussions already started about two topics was emphasized: a new sacco and don-driven medical insurance. 

While some shifted to a national idea dubbed Mhadhiri, a more focused WhatsApp group called UoN Medical Insurance Group was formed on March 16, 2017. A total of 86 academic staff had joined the group by early morning of March 21st, but on different dates. Those who joined days after the discursive engagement had begun have asked for a better way to bring them (themselves) up to speed, than simply asking them to scrawl up and down the comments on the old group page. After all, going back to the Lecturers' Strike sounded like going to an abandoned 'dwelling' in the dark, where malevolence might prowl -- unseen. Hadn't brave folks just dashed out of the now desolate place? 

We have toyed with two options: 1) to periodically insert the earliest texts in the continuing conversation for the benefit of relative newcomers; and, 2) to shift older texts to an online platform in order to obviate looped and entangling insertions. What you find on this blog post is option 2. Not all that was said is shown here. So these are excerpts, arranged in chronological order. 


TRANSCRIPT OF OLDER CONVERSATIONS

March 13, 2017:
P.O. (2:33 PM): Strike over!

V. (2:52 PM): Kindly attend a members' meeting today at 4 pm in Senior Common Room on the 2013-2017 CBA.

M.K. (4:43 PM): Mhadhiri Sacco, join by following the link below. So far it appears uon is missing out.

M.U. (5:02-5:04 PM): 1. I fully support the Mhadhiri Sacco. We need it urgently. However, could we reflect on the formal process of establishing it?... The NO of UASU should be challenged to pick up this matter...

R.O. (5:18 PM): I don't understand background to this drive? Is Chuna no longer serving our sacco interests?

P.C. (5:21 PM): Which chuna? Have you seen the dividend it gives? A sacco associated with the employer is not always the best...

R.O. (5:27 PM): To a large extent dons have been quite aloof on Chuna issues - will they be more engaged with mhadhiri?

M.Y. (5:33 PM): I honestly think that launching a group health insurance to enhance health cover well above what the University offers would be more protective of everyone's future than any sacco, regardless of who will be at the helm. Of course I am assuming that the law permits such cover to supplement the existing one. As for a new sacco, I bet it will collapse before 2021...

M.U. (5:35 PM): The Mhadhiri Sacco can also pick the insurance cover for us as a complimentary benefit.

Anon (5:40 PM): Will finance remit contributions since they don't to external saccos?

R.O. (5:42 PM): My thought is lets clean up our Chuna!

P.C. (5:42 PM): These days one can use other avenues including Mpesa and bank orders. If we use finance on this, what happens when it delays remittances?

J.M. (5:53 PM): Let us start our own sacco and organize ourselves to augment our health insurance cover. The two could be somehow tied together...

M.Y. (9:10 PM): We tried to launch a FoA sacco [in 1999-2000] but didn't make any headway. We encountered resistance from Chuna and its support structure from the highest level at UoN and in the coop movement. We were determined but the resistance was huge...

M.M. (9:17 PM): I think that was then, Now we can do it. Prblm is we're good at eating instins, not growing them...

L.K. (10:32 PM): I thot this [sacco] idea is already being discussed on another platform that we were referred to... How many mhadhiri saccos will we have surely???

J.M (10:40 PM): Agree. Those interested in sacco can join the telegram forum provided.


March 14th: 
K.K (7:37 AM): If you join a SACCO whose membership comprises [Dons] from these new universities, you will be in trouble... 

T.M (9:41 AM): This lefting is reminiscent of another WhatsApp group I had been added to plan a wedding. I forgot to leave after the event until I was eventually removed long after the marriage had...

R.O. (9:44 AM): Interesting to 'watch' the Exodus! I think academics should be able to disagree amicably without disengaging.

K.O. (9:54 AM): Let us respect people's right to choose either to to leave or stay in the platform. Lefting is perfectly okay just as...

M.Y. (9:59 AM): I support the idea of a parallel Medical Scheme, but built into it must be  some form of group insurance to protect us and our dependents adequately against serious emergencies -- short term or long term. Right now we are totally exposed to such dangers.

Back to saccos. One must decide if a new well-run sacco is desirable because of the services it can deliver, or if we just want one of our own because we don't want to mix it up with the 'others' at meetings. The first sentiment is wholesome and perhaps even holy. The second is simply doomed to failure for various reasons -- besides its snootiness... 

M.U (10:15 PM): Am from UoN whwrw I go to the university clinic. But I think it is high time that we get an insurance cover than hii university clinic. KNUT has partmer with AON Insurance and teachers can jump to any hospital and be treated. They have a 700k for just outpatient.

R.O. (10:24 PM): I think this falls under the internal CBA for the UoN UASU chapter.

M. (10:45 PM): The medical insurance cover is a priority area... we need to translate this idea into action...We can trust Colleagues with insurance expertise to provide guidance and help us shop for a stable insurance company.

March 15:

M.Y. (12:00 AM): Grateful for the comments I have read on the proposed parallel medical cover. How do I think we should fund it? By pushing a resolution to allocate right from the Salaries Office 50% of the amount we have been remitting to UASU on a monthly basis. That will probably generate KES 2,500,000 per month and 30m per year from UoN Dons alone, assuming there are 2,000 of us and that those not in UASU agree to join the parallel scheme. 

The debits should go directly to an account managed by Trustees elected by contributors and independent of both UASU and varsity management.  

We can start this at UoN before we go national.

I think that service providers and intermediaries such as AAR, UAP, AON, Britam and the big hospitals will go gaga over this.

M.U. (12:44 AM): It will be much cheaper running such a scheme than even the UHS.

J.A. (6:45-6:46 AM): I fully support. Critical mass of interested persons required to move forward. Can we have advice on the nit grits please. This way we will cushion ourselves and those we represent during lean and difficult times.

Anon (6:47 AM): Every government employee is entitled to a medical allowance. We do not get this and it should be channelled to the scheme as opposed to the clinic [which] some of us cannot access because it does not make any economic sense to incur transport costs just to be referred to other hospitals.

Anon (8:20 AM): I also believe in the investment part. This could as well be a solution to the sacco proposal touted earlier in the forum. UASU investment group.

M.Y. (9:12 AM; 10:26 AM): An investment group is a great idea too. The stronger it gets, the greater the voice it will give Dons in the national economy and beyond. nd it can grow very quickly if prudently managed. Much more innovative than the conventional sacco idea.

Any Investment Group we launch must be independent of both University management and UASU. UoN Dons are perfectly capable of launching an Institution-based Investment Group.

Anon (10:29 AM): It is a better fit compared to a sacco.

M.Y. (10:46 AM): UASU is our political arm. It shouldn't scheme to hog all other aspects of our lives. Imagine Jubilee or NASA trying to seize all their members' initiatives.

O.W. (12:00 PM): Yes, these are some of the issues that we need to follow up on immediately lest we forget that there are many other issues touching on our welfare that need to be given as equal attention as remuneration!

R.O. (12:09 PM): Many interesting ideas are being floated by colleagues. It will be important to focus on a few with resolute determination to see them come to fruition. I also think it is dangerous to destroy UHS: our employer committed himself to providing high-quality health services, and we should hold him to account concerning this. This, of course, does not preclude an insurance scheme, which is a very good idea. Again, I think that if we pursue all these things simultaneously, we shall spread ourselves too thin. Let us identify one or two lines to pursuewith vigour, get them going, and then take up more.

E.A. (12:11 PM): Best suggestion R.O.

R.O. (12:20 PM): Thanks a lot, E.A! I suggest that we rename this group to reflect its vision beyond the strike.

J.M. (12:27 PM): Good idea

M. (1:02 PM): No doubt UHS @uon are doing their best under the prevailing circumstances. However, I still support an independent insurance cover which will cover dental and optical issues without a minimum refund requirement. It can be very distressing when families have to decide who gets their root canals before the other because of shortage of funds.

M.U. (2:10 PM): The entire UHS needs overhaul. We need an upgrade to to a fully fledged teaching and referral hospital. Meantime, a good insurance cover is urgent. It will save us the blushes and hassles of admission and discharge from hospitals. 

M.N (2:16 PM): The VC was looking for avenues to generate income for UoN. Starting a world class hospital to rival Aga Khan and the rest is worth trying. The land in perfect location is there, the staff are abundant and the patients are in their millions. Kazi kwetu.

M.U. (2:16 PM): Tiny parastatals like the Tourism Fund, Kevevapi, Kemri etc have excellent medical covers for staff. Why are we stuck in this stone age?

M.U. (1218 PM): They have been talking about this [World Class Hospital] issue for over a decade. Where are we? KU came from behind, they are almost done with their referral hospital...

R.O. (2:23 PM): I agree that the insurance scheme is most urgent because it would take a while to get a referral hospital.

M.M. (3:04 PM): If the list of interim officials of proposed mhadhiri sacco is genuine, it luks like another plot 2 sideline uon (remember uasu no). If that is the case, the idea is A DEAD DUCK!

K. (3:07 PM): Saw this too. No way I can continue to present myself for other deliberately marginalizing outfits. No way.

L.O. (3:29 PM): I support the dual approach. As we plan for the insurance cover the Union should see how services at UHS can be improved.

M.M. (3:47 PM): We must invent a formula of dstrbtng elective posts in all our outfits 2 reflect theface of Kenya. We're in the era of devolution, human rights including women and ppl with disabilities.

P.C. (4:45 PM): I think it's better to air these sentiments at the Mhadhiri Sacco forum, this is the wrong forum for this

M.Y. (5:27 PM): How many people do we still have in this Lecturers' Strike Forum? If it is the wrong forum, can someone offer to launch a new one for those of us interested in the Medical Insurance idea and who think that a sacco, Mhadhiri or otherwise, would not be the right base for it? We need to have a meeting of UoN Dons about Med Insurance in the next two or so weeks.

O.W. (5:32 PM): The medical insurance meeting, yes I support! But also think that UASU UoN chapter should convene a quick meeting so that we agree on the agenda for 2017. We can then present to them ...a checklist of all the issues we want them to pursue next

M.Y. (5:40 PM): That's fine too. We need to have a conversation at UoN with with our UASU UoN leadership. But those who will run the scheme must be an independent board with its own mandate and account. Yes, let's meet, but not as SCR, perhaps one of the big rooms at The Tower.

M.U. (5:46-5:47 PM): I am in full support. Admin, could you please create a separate forum to address the issues M.Y is raising. I will be a member of the group.

M.U. (6:25 PM): Admin kazi kwako.

March 16:

The The UoN Medical Insurance Group was launched on WhatsApp.

Admin (11:50 AM): Any UoN Don interested in this conversation is free to join.

A total of 13 Dons registered on the first day, Dr. Agaya being the first. 

R.O. (8:03 PM): Thanks...for adding me to this group! Let us pursue this matter with determination, focus and effective strategy.

M.U. (8:08 PM): Thanks for adding me to the list. A great step in the right direction.

J.M. (8:15 PM): Thank... and support sentiments of my colleagues above.


**End of transcript available from the Lecturers' Strike Forum, just as exodus from the Forum picks up speed**


March 17th:

M. (4:22 AM): Thanks for the add. Ni ya Nini lakini?

Admin (4:54 AM): Dr..., you were [on] a list I was given to include in this WhatsApp Group. The group is dedicated to building a consensus around a much needed UoN Medical Insurance Scheme. This should help Dons fill the current gap in UHS service delivery, particularly with regard to major emergencies, which Dons have frequently encountered.

The problem is essentially financial, and the driving idea is how to leverage our collective purchasing power in order to source adequate medical cover during emergency admissions and fairly extended hospitalization or specialized care of contributing members.

Admin (5:33 AM): I should also add that Dons wish to have the flexibility which a medical card gives in terms of where one can go for checkups or medication in lesser emergencies, and when travelling or on leave.

We shouldn't be tied to just one clinic, or tied down by regulations entailing written and time-consuming pre-approval for every visit to a doctor. But certainly, every card will impose limits on how much can be spent over a set period of time.

M.U. (8:28 AM): ...And some medical covers are exceptionally good, some have very good complementary benefits. As dons, we have numerical advantage which ordinarily attracts better packages.

J.A. (8:41 AM): I can't agree more...We need serious advice on how to move forward with speed.

M. (9:19 AM): Let's be cautious... Inasmuch as insurance cards have flexibility, they have limits say kshs. 1 million for inpatient. This has to be borne in mind. Current arrangement can be strengthened...My thoughts.

M.U. (9:24 AM): The red tape and hassle at UHS when you need admission is painful. UHS has no flexibility if you [reside] far away from town. I think this initiative is [complementary] to what we have. Lastly, reforms have hardly been implemented at the UHS in spite of the many efforts.

Admin (9:22 AM): Good thoughts. We must maximize the possibilities of our collective effort. As the conversation proceeds, we'll begin to pin down details and specifics and consider various optimization options. I think at some point we will invite one or two experts in medical insurance to give us a talk. Our own home-grown Actuarial Scientists will be asked to share their calculations.

J.A. (9: 30 AM): Let us move forward carefully leveraging on available expertise from within and without... It is a matter of getting value for money... Medical costs can bring even the very richest to zero ground in a matter of days.  

M. (9:34 AM): Thanks doc. We can explore possibilities of pressing for reforms at UHS. Let's make wide consultations, as suggested, for informed choices.

J.A. (9:42 AM): How do we [reform] UHS when one cant [get] even basic medication. Remember University managers are well taken care of and so they really don't care about what goes on at the health facility... Recall what happened with education for dependants? Immediately the managers were through with educating theirs everything literally collapsed... At JKUAT the education waiver for staff children is 80% unless it has changed recently. 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

NOTICE is hereby duly served of the First General Meeting of the Founding Members of the UoN Medical Insurance Group, to be held in 8-4-4 Hall (MPH), on Main Campus, UoN, from 2 to 5 pm on Sunday, April 9, 2017.

AGENDA
1. Meeting called to order, followed by prayer(s).
2. Introductory remarks by Prof. Yambo: How we got here and where we're headed.
3. Self-introductions by Founding Members.
4. Official Naming of Medical Insurance Group.
5. Determining the Group's core function(s) and outlining its Memorandum and Articles of Association. Steps to registration.
6. Election of seven Trustees or Directors to the Board, with positions for Executive Chairperson, Secretary, Finance, Medical, Legal and Board Member (all subject to variation at the general meeting).
7. Determining the parameters of Group health insurance needs.
8. General discussion: How to identify and procure the services of a credible medical insurer.
9. Launch of the Register of Group Members. Setting of Membership fee.
10. Scheduling of presentations by prospective insurers.
11. AOB.
12. Closing of meeting. Prayers. Photos.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 








UPDATED: March 22, 2017 (9:38 AM and 9:36 PM); March 23 (8:06 AM); March 27, 2017 (10:21 PM); April 6, 2017 (7:26 PM); April 28, 2017 (10:40 PM); May 11, 2017 (6:15 PM); May 17, 2017 (2:25 PM). [To be continued. Meanwhile, any group member with objections to this transcript can make his/her views known on our WhatsApp platform, for all members to see]


Friday, May 29, 2009

Directors' Shareholding at Cooperative Bank of Kenya: A Stink to High Heaven

Like other Kenyans, I am proud of our country's cooperative movement, which is a shining example around the world. And I am proud of the Cooperative Bank of Kenya (CBK), a state institution which had its IPO only last December. Before the IPO, only cooperative societies had a real chance of buying CBK shares in bulk. For retail investors, there was one over-the-counter route to obtaining CBK shares, for a good number of years. This was what is now Suntra Investment Bank, which is presently weakened by scandal of huge proportions.

I have just had a look at CBK's Annual Report and Accounts for 2008, which has just been released. I am talking in particular of pages 144 to 146, which, thanks to an aspect of Kenya's corporate law, obliges the bank and other publicly quoted companies to show the distribution of shares among the bank's top 10 shareholders, the bank's own Directors, and different categories of the bank's shareholders. If you peruse those pages too, you will, as I do, smell a rat that stinks to high heaven.

CBK has a total of 3,492,369,900 issued shares, and a total of 116,068 shareholders. That averages at 30,088 shares per shareholder, regardless of category. More importantly, Kenyan individual shareholders own 939,112,300 shares, and there are 112,774 of them. This averages at only 8,327 shares per Kenyan individual shareholder. Alas, among CBK'S seventeen Directors (who own a total of 138,995,700 shares), the average is a staggering 8,176,217 shares (that's more than 981 times the number owned by the average Kenyan investor).

In fact, if you compute the average for Kenyan individual investors without including the shares held by the Directors: the total number of shares held by Kenyan individuals (non-directors) drops to 800,116,600 shares, and the average among the 112,757 of them drops to 7,095 shares per individual (which is 1,152 times less than the average for the Directors).

We can look at the directors' allocations to themselves in even starker light, as follows:
1. The Managing Director owned, as at the end of December 2008, a total of 68,121,000 shares.
2. The Chairman of the Board owned 8,000,000 shares
3.The Vice Chairman owned 7,700,000 shares
4. The Company Secretary owned 5,090,000 shares
5. The Commissioner of Cooperatives owned 2,750,000 shares
6. Five other Directors also owned just over 5 million shares each
7. Three other Directors owned exactly 5,000,000 shares each
8. One Director owned 2,750,000 shares
9. One Director owned 2,310,000 shares, and another owned 2,300,000 shares
10. The "poorest Director", representing the Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Finance, owned what you may call a "token" of 1,000,000 shares! [Currently each share sells at around KES 6.50, or US$0.083]

The circumstances under which these stupendous amounts were allocated and paid for require a forensic investigation. The Directors should step aside while this happens, for, clearly, there has been no transparency here. Previous annual reports of the company may suggest where these shares came from over the years. For at least a couple of years after the bomb blast, annual reports showed significant amounts of issued shares, without explanation as to who was receiving them. The public has reason to need to know now. At the SACCOs, and at the bank's registry, officials did not seem to ever know that additional shares were being made available each year for purchase by members. What Suntra did over the counter, as far as one knew, was to match retail buyers and retail sellers who had owned their shares for some time, perhaps even since before the bomb blast, which nearly reduced the bank to a rubble, in August 1998.

The shares previously held by individual cooperative societies, amounting to 64.56% of the total, were (wisely in my view) grouped together, just before the IPO, under a corporate entity called Co-opholdings Co-operative Society Ltd. This ensured, and still does, control of the bank by the country's cooperative movement. However, the then acting Minister for Finance, John Michuki, issued a strange edict prior to the IPO which keeps secret for some five years or so the identities of the societies (and perhaps other "entities") brought together under that corporate entity. Let us hope that there are not even more rats under cover there. Five years may be too long to find out the truth!

Thursday, August 07, 2008

Bomb Blast of August 7, 1998: Tenth Anniversary

Today, Thursday, marks the tenth anniversary of the August 7th, 1998 bomb blast in Nairobi, and almost simultaneously in Dar-Es-Salaam. The Nairobi blast killed some 245 people, and injured and maimed some 5,000 more. As far as I cat tell, indeed, it was the single largest international terrorist attack in history, before 9/11.

I was on the third floor of Gandhi Wing, at the University of Nairobi, when the blast occurred at around 10.30 that Friday morning. It was so loud it couldn't have occurred much farther away than Lillian's, just across University Way, or so I thought in that instant. But it was also muted enough that, it did not necessarily sound like a bomb. In fact, my first thought had been that a very badly maintained bus, or some other vehicle, had grossly back-fired!

Soon enough, however, it became clear, as we went up and down Gandhi Wing, that the incident was farther away. As we gathered in small groups, we began to see smoke rising somewhere else, across town. At first we thought that the incident had occurred in the general direction of the industrial area, and then maybe the railway station, and then maybe somewhere in the vicinity of the station, or even NHC building. In hindsight, we were, unwittingly, skirting the issue -- the "epicentre."

From where we stood, we could see a scattering of rather agitated people running away from, and in the general direction, of the billowing smoke. Then we began to see pieces of paper everywhere in the smoky sky, over Moi Avenue and slightly to the east of it; and it seemed that some force kept releasing more and more paper into the sky. Clearly, some office had suffered a catasprophic blast, accompanied by fire. [Some of that paper eventually landed on the roof of Gandhi Wing; and when we went there to check, we found a slightly burnt photocopy of someone's national ID card and some other paper].

Before long, the quickly evolving story began to acquire clarity through word-of-mouth and such telephone calls as could yield concrete answers. That was before TV news kicked in with the facts, as could immediately be reported -- and it did not take long to do that. We heard of Ufundi Coop Building (which housed a teachers' SACCO) and Co-operative Bank House. We heard that the Minister of Education, Mr. Joseph Kamotho -- who was at that time engrossed (as I recall) in a tussle with the teachers' union -- was caught up in the blast.

This piece of news caused conspiracy theories to fly, including the one about the government of President Moi somehow having a hand in the blast -- with Kamotho as the target. What saved the day for Moi, and the nation, was the news which arrived very quickly out of Dar Es Salaam that there had been an explosion there as well. It would have been very difficult, otherwise, to exonerate Moi -- as the political atmosphere was quite charged at the time, as I recall.

The two explosions were quickly seen, then, as a coordinated terrorist act targeting US embassies in the two capitals. For a while, thereafter, we expected to get similar news from Kampala, but it never came. I think thast the realization that the country had been attacked by external forces helped to calm down the country, and to draw it closer. We were able to share in the grief of August 7th as one nation.

I did not visit "the site" of the blast that Friday, for it just did not seem to me the thing to do. Instead, I drove home at lunch time, having decided to defer my visit to the site, such as it could be, to Saturday. I did go on Saturday, and there were many Kenyan onlookers on that day -- as there were going to be for many of the days that followed. Police had cordoned off much of the blast area, as there was active search and rescue activity going on (including the matter of saving Rose). I would not, in fact, get the opportunity to stand at the base of the severely ripped-off Coop Bank Building, until three months or so later. And when I did, the enormity of what had happened at that place really sank in, even as I stood there those many days after the event.

That same weekend of the blast, I drafted a memo to my Vice Chancellor proposing a course in Disaster Management. Never got a reply. In the week that followed, I began to sell the idea of the course to my colleagues in the Department of Sociology, and to look into expanded possibilities. Soon enough, the idea of a course evolved into an entire Masters programme in Disaster Management -- and into a comprehensive Module II MA programme in the Department. From my base in the Department, I was quickly thrust into the Faculty's Curriculum Development and Income Generation Committees, where I spearheaded the crafting of what became the Faculty's Module II Programme. I was elected Dean of the Faculty of Arts at the end of 1998, but that's another story.

What I would like to emphasize here, as I conclude, is that the bomb blast of August 7th, tragic as it was, became the catalyst, in a very direct way, for the graduate programme in Disaster Management at the University of Nairobi. I can make that claim without any fear of contradiction. But it was also probably the main reason (a) I became Dean, and (b) the Faculty's Module II programme (from undergraduate to postgraduate) took off when, and with the singlemindedness, it did.