Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Libya. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 02, 2015

World Happiness Report 2015: Ranking African Countries

According to the latest World Happiness Report 2015, Africa is not a happy continent.

READ (Especially pp. 28-30 for actual country rankings): John Helliwell, Richard Layard and Jeffrey Sachs (Eds). 2015. World Happiness Report. New York: Sustainable Development Solutions Network.

How is this relative unhappiness (dare we say "sadness"?) determined, though? In a word, empirically. First, the guiding principle for how data on happiness are captured in this report (see p. 19) is stated as follows:
We find the double usage of happiness – both as an emotional report, and as a type of life evaluation – an asset. Answers about happiness yesterday (questions asking for an emotional report) are quite different in structure from answers about happiness with life (questions asking for a judgment about life). There appears to be little doubt that respondents understand the difference and answer appropriately.26 The answers to the emotional reports are similar in structure to those for other emotions, while the “happy with life” answers, as we have already seen, are just like those for other life evaluations. 
Second, having said all that, the authors go definitively for this approach to delineating happiness (p. 20):
[The] twin facts – that life evaluations vary much more than do emotions across countries, and that these life evaluation differences are much more fully explained than are emotional differences by life circumstances – provide for us a sufficient reason for using life evaluations as our central measure for making international comparisons. But there is more. To give a central role to life evaluations does not mean we need to either ignore or downplay the important information provided by experiential measures. On the contrary, we see every reason to keep experiential measures of well-being, as well as measures of life purpose, as important elements in our attempts to measure and understand subjective well-being. This is easy to achieve, at least in principle, because our evidence continues to suggest that experienced well-being and a sense of life purpose are important influences on life evaluations, above and beyond the critical role of life circumstances.
The sum of this two-part argumentation is that our happiness level is a reflection of how our "life circumstances" frame our sense of satisfaction with our lives; that is, with our own perception of the adequacy of our lives.

What are the "life circumstances" (or predictors) used to construct narratives of happiness in WHR 2015?  Eight "life circumstances" (or predictors) are specified, as follows (see p. 17):
1. A country's GDP per capita, based on PPP
2. The availability of social support to the individual in "times of trouble"
3. Health Life Expectancy at birth
4. Freedom to shape or direct one's own life
5. Generosity: Self-report of one's philanthropic act or acts "in the past month"
6. The individual's perception of the "spread" of corruption in the public and/or private sectors
7. Positive affect: Average of previous-day affect measures for "happiness, laughter and enjoyment"
8. Negative affect: Average of "previous-day affect measures for worry, sadness and anger..."

Here's how 44 African countries are positioned in the happiness rank-order among 158 countries surveyed around the world, based on the foregoing metrics:

Country - World Rank
1. Libya - 63
2. Algeria - 68
3. Mauritius - 71
4. Nigeria - 78
5. Zambia - 85
6. Morocco - 92
7. Mozambique - 94
8. Lesotho - 97
9. Swaziland - 101
10. Tunisia - 107
11. South Africa - 113
12. Ghana - 114
13. Zimbabwe - 115
14. Liberia - 116
15. Sudan - 118
16. DRC - 120
17. Ethiopia - 122
18. Sierra Leone - 123
19. Mauritania - 124
20. Kenya - 125
21. Djibouti - 126
22. Botswana - 128
23. Malawi - 131
24. Cameroon - 133
25. Egypt - 135
26. Angola - 137
27. Mali - 138
28. Congo Brazzaville - 139
29. Comoros - 140
30. Uganda - 141
31. Senegal - 142
32. Gabon - 143
33. Niger - 144
34. Tanzania - 146
35. Madagascar - 147
36. Central Africa Republic - 148
37. Chad - 149
38. Guinea - 150
39. Ivory Coast - 151
40. Burkina Faso - 152
41. Rwanda - 154
42. Benin - 155
43. Burundi - 157
44. Togo - 158

This list suggests that African countries occupy none of the top 62 positions, or the top 39.2% of the happiest ranks, among the countries surveyed. Conversely, they occupy 29 (or 72.5%) of the bottom 40 countries -- the 40 least happy (or 'saddest') countries! The best placed country is Libya (surprise!). The worst placed is Togo, at 158th position.

We also find that Nigeria, Africa's economic giant, is ranked a lowly 78. South Africa, the second biggest economy, is 113th. Likewise, Zimbabwe is 115th, DRC 120th, Ethiopia 122nd, Kenya 125th, Egypt 135th and Tanzania 146th,

Friday, July 25, 2008

Nuclear Energy For Kenya? Not For a Long While!

It was surprising to read in one of the local dailies yesterday that the Kenyan government delegation, led by the Prime Minister, which was attending the Investment in the New Kenya conference in London, had asked UK investors to help Kenya develop a nuclear energy sector.

It was surprising on several grounds. First, the debate on the merits and demerits of nuclear power generation in Kenya has not even started here; certainly not in the public domain. This means that Kenyans are nowhere near reaching a consensus on this controversial and even dangerous idea; and that the consent of the governed is even farther from being sought or secured. Second, and following from the first, this news was breaking in London, not Nairobi -- which is not the way to go about such consequential matters.

Third, the timing of this nuclear idea could not have been worse -- and this makes both the idea and its timing patently frivolous. Why do I say so? One has simply to consider the idea in the context of the raging controversy surrounding Iran's nuclear ambitions, and the long-running geopolitical tensions fuelled by North Korea's nuclear programme (which is now to be scaled down or even, hopefully, wound up), to arrive at this unhappy conclusion. Not surprisingly, perhaps, it is reported that the audience which heard the Energy Minister's (Kiraitu Murungi's) suggestion, which was supported by the Prime Minister (Raila Odinga), responded with "laughter."
I read that laughter to signal both surprise and discomfort.

The arguments advanced for the nuclear option were essentially that: (a) it is a significantly cheaper source of electricity than hydropower; and, b) the sources of hydropower are under threat from the wanton destruction by Kenyans of water towers, the emblematic one being Mau Forest. This suggests to me that if the water towers were to be secured against destruction, then the case for the nuclear option, at this time, might not be persuasive simply on the grounds of its relative cheapness -- and when there are viable alternative sources of energy (such as geothermal, solar, wind and even coal).

So, why has the leadership failed to secure the water catchment areas -- and why are they not embarrassed to own up to this failure, and to see it for what it says about them and us? The answer, my friends, as one might say, is blowing in the uncertain political winds.

Let's face it: It is not yet the time for nuclear power generation in Kenya, and it is not likely to be before 2050. The home-grown technical expertise and capital base for such a venture are simply not there yet -- and are decades away from being in place. Kenya does not yet have a private sector entity with the muscle to do so, and the public sector is paralyzed by self-interest and private deals -- which are not in the public interest. If we were to go for nuclear energy now, we might in effect be doing it for other interests with greater financial muscle and political motivation: such as Libya's sovereign wealth fund, to which we seem to be surrendering everything that matters lately (oil pipelines, oil refineries, petrol stations, hotels and prime city plots).

The level of corruption in the country remains too high to allow for the safe introduction of nuclear technology at this time. One remembers, for example, that we could not, in the recent past, ensure the procurement of appropriate water purification chemicals, instead of plain chalk. How, in this kind of atmosphere, are we going to ensure the safe keeping and disposal of spent nuclear fuel-rods? And how are we going to protect the public from the dangers of radiation leaks and other accidents arising from a dysfunctional and intrusive polity? In whose parochial hands are we going to insist that the contracting for -- and, more importantly, control of -- nuclear facilities must always be?

The national political tectonics are also still too volatile to have such a facility in the country, which might be the focus of attention of warring ethnic bands. Before we can start serious planning, let us go through another three to five general elections to have some clarity about the stability and direction of our political culture and institutions. In the meantime, let us empower our universities to build up a critical mass of expertise in this and related fields. And let us allow time for our private sector to mature and acquire the requisite capacity. In the meantime, let us fully exploit our potential in hydro, geothermal, solar, wind, coal and fossil fuel.

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Kimunya's Departure From Treasury

There is little to cheer in Amos Kimunya's departure, as Amos Kimunya, from the cabinet and Ministry of Finance last Tuesday. He was merely "stepping aside," he reasoned himself into a certain anti-frenzy, avoiding thus a not-at-all-certain death. And that's good for him and his family -- and us. There is little to cheer about; instead, there is much to reflect upon. Cheers, nonetheless, to President Kibaki for displaying a rare firm hand -- for re-affirming what was hitherto only tell-tale and all-too-sporadic -- in the name of accountable governance.

Departures of such high-profile public figures -- who are so easily caught up in a self-created air of untouchability, and numbed by our cheering and all the opportunity for self-aggrandizement that's still theirs for the taking -- are going to have to be routine, if ordinary Kenyans are to have a fighting chance against hard life.

There is little to cheer because impunity and the temptation to pull a fast one and to hide the truth -- even truth which cannot be hidden in broad daylight and even in the dark (truth which cannot escape the knowing rumour) -- still stalk the land.

There is much to reflect upon because (and I'll make only four points for now): One, Libya, with its relatively large sovereign wealth fund, is, it seems to me, making willing prostitutes of certain of our revered politicians; politicians who think (or hope) we don't really think (when we really do), and who would like to believe that we cannot work our thoughts into believing all that we're hearing (when we can) -- though they so cleverly endeavour to scorch it (and with it our very thoughts and ascendant beliefs).

How else does one explain the sudden "ever-presence" (effervescence) of Tamoil and Oilibya -- and the unprompted but subliminally incriminating declarations that no leader is indispensable? Is Parliament's Finance Committee or the Cockar Commission really going to reveal the flesh-and-blood identities of the Kenyan interests associated with these outfits, and to tell us if they had anything to do with the Grand Regency saga as it has unfolded? Will they, too, face the music -- or will we be, once again, put in our place and silenced by threats of raw blood?

Two, with Kimunya's departure, and assuming that he will not be returning to Treasury even if he were to return to the cabinet, all eyes are back on President Kibaki: will he this time escape bad routine (indeed bad karma) -- and the perception that he cannot bring himself to appoint anyone from outside "Mount Kenya" to the top post at Treasury? Will he go against the grain and appoint someone from elsewhere in Kenya to succeed Kimunya, and not in an acting capacity? There is sufficient talent in Parliament for that -- for what would be a healthy dose of realism and 21st century nationalism. That would be reason to cheer -- even if mutedly -- and not at Kimunya's expense. Rather, at the expense of narrow-mindedness and parochialism.

What would be disastrous -- utterly disastrous to true meritocracy -- would be to elevate Oburu Oginga, the present Assistant Minister at Treasury, to Kimunya's post. There would simply be no rhyme or reason for that, as I think very many Kenyans believe. Not only do they believe that, they dread the prospect and implications of such appointment.

Three, many Kenyans still believe that Libya played an important part in the bombing of Norfolk Hotel, in Nairobi, at the end of 1980. Some twenty eight years later, Kenyans in high places are trying to outdo each other to deliver the iconic Grand Regency Hotel to that same Gaddafi. They are crazy enough! Americans are being "handsomely" compensated for Lockerbie. Did Kenya receive a cent (or a dime)specifically for the deaths and other damage at Norfolk -- or did the compensation quietly go into certain of our politicians' palms and pockets?

Four, I think Kimunya's background in "pure" accountancy denied him the political sensibilities and social skills to navigate the treacherous waters in which a Minister for Finance, or any politician we should emulate, must swim. Often, this glaring lack presented as arrogance and ethnic chauvinism -- but it was at root fatally flawed incapacity to lead a public-life attuned maximally to the cross-currents of a multi-cultural society; and to the need for broad-based equity, in a nation that remains highly unequal and polarized. Before his tendency toward spectacularly bad judgement showed itself in Grand Regency, we had seen it most tellingly in the Safaricom IPO saga, and in the key appointments that he made as Minister.

Yet, I fear, there remains a handful of Kimunyas in both PNU and ODM! On this matter, indeed, there is not an iota of difference between ODM and PNU. Our unease, as Kenyans, remains acute.

[This post was first drafted and saved on Wednesday, July 9, 2008. It was updated and published on Friday, July 11]