Showing posts with label Digital Divide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Digital Divide. Show all posts

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Cohen on Changing the Sacred Rite of Peer Review

Patricia Cohen had an interesting piece in a very recent issue of New York Times. Essentially, she reports that a "trailblazing" experiment is under way, particularly in the humanities, on alternative ways of vetting scholarly works for publication in journals, and even books, that were traditionally peer-reviewed. All of this assault on the citadel, which remained essentially 'unassailable' during the second half of the twentieth century and even farther back, is thanks to the wider spaces and resources increasingly made available by the web to both sides of the publishing divide -- the publisher and the (would-be) published -- as well as the digital divide itself.

In this new dispensation, the power to pass judgment on the quality and publishability of a scholarly submission is to be devolved well beyond small rings of anonymous experts (peer reviewers) to online "brown-bag" sessions -- a shifting kind of e-brownbag community, if you like -- in which as many experts and apprentices ('grad students') with "the time" can equally participate.

There are a number of reasons why scholars in the developing world would view this new trend with even more interest than she probably imagines when she writes:

"Clubby exclusiveness, sloppy editing and fraud have all marred peer review on occasion. Anonymity can help prevent personal bias, but it can also make reviewers less accountable; exclusiveness can help ensure quality control but can also narrow the range of feedback and participants. Open review more closely resembles Wikipedia behind the scenes...".


Still, as Cohen notes, this "open-door policy" poses some dangers:
1. Peer review would turn into some kind of "American Idol" spectacle [Now, only a select few pick the idols: who are typically American in American publications, and European in European ones].
2. Reviewers might not be as, at once, incisive and 'blunt' in public as they have been in private, working "blindly" [Which was a good thing].
3. Comments might not be as "comprehensive and conceptual" as they have been, and instead become "short and episodic" texts, fired at "warp speed" [Which, putting the speed aside, would be 'degenerate'].
4. 'Know-nothings' would rule the process [Which would be a terrible blow to professionalism and disciplinary excellence].

Read more here

Saturday, May 09, 2009

Cocacolonization, McDonaldization, Globalization

The purpose of this brief note is to identify certain useful links on the above theme(s), for my Tourism and Sociological Theory classes -- to the extent that this is still necessary, given the significantly narrowing digital divide for increasingly tech savvy and increasingly "wired" students in many parts of the Third World, including Kenya (where we await with somewhat bated breath the launch of fibre-optic Internet connection with the rest of the world later this year).

Regardless of how narrow the divide has become, however, the starting point in any class reading list is always what the professor identifies as the key texts. We all know that. QED.

Globalization has several important dimensions and drivers, among these being Cocacolonization and McDonaldization. Cocacolonization and McDonaldization, as processes (even processes of domination), have always been interrogated in the broader context of America's popular-cultural domination, benign or otherwise, of the world, particularly since WWII -- a domination which they do help to drive -- and of the consequences and future of that domination qua Americanization or globalization.

A great deal has been written about globalization, far less about Cocacolonization and McDonaldization. It is, furthermore, easier to access (online or in hard copy) texts on globalization, than it is to have a good read on Cocacolonization. Not only that, while the concept of McDonaldization is readily associated with American sociologist George Ritzer, the origins of Cocacolonization as a scholar's (or ideologue's) concept remain fuzzy; though it has been claimed that "Ugly" Americans themselves coined the term cocacolonization. If so, the coining represented a double-barreled assault on the sensibilities of the rest of the world -- certainly then.

I will periodically update this note/post as the need arises, and as time allows. In the meantime, here are online links to some interesting readings

Sources:

1. A link focusing on Cocacolonization rather than, as one might expect, globalization; but the two stand as one: http://www.angelfire.com/folk/globalization/

2. Richard F. Kuisel (1991) "Coca-Cola and the Cold War: The French Face Americanization, 1948-1953", pp. 76-106, in French Historical Studies, Vol. 17, No. 1 (Spring 1991) [Here Kuisel chronicles Coca-Cola's invasion of Europe, and what the French did or did not do about it]: http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/286280.pdf

3. Mark Pendergrast (1993), "A Brief History of Coca-Colonization" : http://www.nytimes.com/1993/08/15/business/viewpoints-a-brief-history-of-coca-colonization.html

4. Allan Brian Ssenyonga, "Americanization or Globalization?" : http://www.globalenvision.org/library/33/1273

5. Keith Porter, "Americanization vs. Globalization": http://www.globalenvision.org/library/8/691/

6. Joseph Nye (2004) "Globalization is not Americanization": http://usforeignpolicy.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?zi=1/XJ&sdn=globalization&zu=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.taipeitimes.com%2FNews%2Fedit%2Farchives%2F2004%2F10%2F22%2F2003207970

7. Commentary on George W. Bush's Notion of Globalization: http://www.globalenvision.org/library/8/617/

8. Wikipedia on Globalization [Though the link is already given in the text, it is given here too with the note that it provides many and very useful links and references on globalization and related concepts]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Globalization

9. Luke Martell (2007), "The Third Wave in Globalization Theory",
pp. 173-196, in International Studies Review, 9, 2, (Summer 2007): http://www.sussex.ac.uk/Users/ssfa2/thirdwaveweb.htm

10: On George Ritzer's McDonaldization [this link already provided in the text]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonaldization