Showing posts with label Anonymous. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anonymous. Show all posts

Saturday, February 28, 2015

A Turn, Always

There's always a turn in the road -- indeed, many turns -- which you have never taken, and may long have been intrigued by. Take such a turn, and you will see: see things you've never seen, and which not even the Internet has an account of whatsoever, from your way of seeing. And not just see: feel. Have feelings that make you not simply the person you presently are, but the one you're becoming, truly.

I took such a ('left') turn today, and came upon many lovely homes that I'd never seen, in which people live that I don't know -- perhaps just don't know yet, or perhaps know but have not imagined live quietly here -- in a serene neighborhood which was suddenly new to me. 

Hardly a resident on the sidewalks, but a scatter of parked and parking cars -- arranged as the neighborhood and the city desire that visitors arrange them. Hardly any sight or sound of children behind the fencings, nor of their parents and minders. Not of their older siblings and cousins either. 

A sense, nevertheless, of an unstoppable digital migration. A sense that belying the laid back physical ambiance was a vigorous and dedicated electronic chatter all over the air.

Anonymous people, then; yet people I have probably seen elsewhere -- in the streets of downtown Iborian, in the suburban malls, in other 'elsewheres'. Or who have seen me drive by -- seen the car I drive (and which is my, truly my, wife's) driven by as frequently as they think they remember. 

People who may even remember my face from behind the wheel, or from many chance encounters in public places, shared venues. People you wouldn't want to call strangers, because you had this deep feeling that living in the same city somehow bonded you, the all of you, mysteriously and gladly, into a oneness; and that the bonding was the reason the city continued to be as it was -- and to evolve as it was.

But one guessed, alright, that today the residents were probably there, taking it easy near mid-day on a sun-shiny Saturday. Or if not, then, perhaps like me, they were mostly out -- the day being what it was, the time seeming proper: out to/from the supermarkets, out to/from the malls, out to/from the barbers and the "saloons" and the tailors and the petrol stations and all the places worth being at.

I was, thusly, 'left' to my own devices. I was on my "own O!" 

I soon came to a dead end, though, and did a U Turn at once disappointing and prepared for. The turn I'd taken didn't exit at the other end and so couldn't take me to a road I'd thought/hoped/ doubted it might -- the hope that had prompted me to take the turn in the first place, on this day.

I turned left, at the point I'd moments earlier turned left, and drove home.

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Cohen on Changing the Sacred Rite of Peer Review

Patricia Cohen had an interesting piece in a very recent issue of New York Times. Essentially, she reports that a "trailblazing" experiment is under way, particularly in the humanities, on alternative ways of vetting scholarly works for publication in journals, and even books, that were traditionally peer-reviewed. All of this assault on the citadel, which remained essentially 'unassailable' during the second half of the twentieth century and even farther back, is thanks to the wider spaces and resources increasingly made available by the web to both sides of the publishing divide -- the publisher and the (would-be) published -- as well as the digital divide itself.

In this new dispensation, the power to pass judgment on the quality and publishability of a scholarly submission is to be devolved well beyond small rings of anonymous experts (peer reviewers) to online "brown-bag" sessions -- a shifting kind of e-brownbag community, if you like -- in which as many experts and apprentices ('grad students') with "the time" can equally participate.

There are a number of reasons why scholars in the developing world would view this new trend with even more interest than she probably imagines when she writes:

"Clubby exclusiveness, sloppy editing and fraud have all marred peer review on occasion. Anonymity can help prevent personal bias, but it can also make reviewers less accountable; exclusiveness can help ensure quality control but can also narrow the range of feedback and participants. Open review more closely resembles Wikipedia behind the scenes...".


Still, as Cohen notes, this "open-door policy" poses some dangers:
1. Peer review would turn into some kind of "American Idol" spectacle [Now, only a select few pick the idols: who are typically American in American publications, and European in European ones].
2. Reviewers might not be as, at once, incisive and 'blunt' in public as they have been in private, working "blindly" [Which was a good thing].
3. Comments might not be as "comprehensive and conceptual" as they have been, and instead become "short and episodic" texts, fired at "warp speed" [Which, putting the speed aside, would be 'degenerate'].
4. 'Know-nothings' would rule the process [Which would be a terrible blow to professionalism and disciplinary excellence].

Read more here