Showing posts with label Universality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Universality. Show all posts

Friday, November 27, 2015

Validity ~ A Key Standard of Scientific Research

Validity ~ A Key Standard of scientific Research


By Prof. Mauri Yambo
(1996; updates: 2004, 2006, 2015)


INTRODUCTION

Nine key standards, or principles, of scientific research can be gleaned from texts on research method. As I see them, they are:


3. Control
4. Measurability
5. Validity
6. Reliability (Pending)
7. Objectivity (Pending)
8. Ethics 
9. Representativeness.

I say something about each of the nine standards in separate posts, as shown in the links above. What I want to briefly talk about here is the validity standard. 


Validity means the applicability, genuineness, appropriateness or truthfulness of the methods, instruments, tools, measures (or indicators), or arguments used in the quest for knowledge, or search for answers to vexing questions – and therefore of the conclusions arrived at.  


CLICK HERE To Access the Full Text of "Validity ~ A Key Standard of Scientific Research"


























[CSO 302, CSO 501]

Sunday, November 08, 2015

CSO 302: Nine Key Standards of Scientific Research


INTRODUCTION TO NINE STANDARDS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH

Certain broad standards, principles or criteria have been established for determining what scientific research is all about, and what it is not. That is, the standards help us to determine in some detail whether, or the extent to which, a proposed or completed study meets the expectations of the relevant scientific community -- in the present case, Sociology. They all apply, to a greater or lesser degree, to quantitative or qualitative research, or a combination of the two. The identity or image of Sociology as a discipline, or of any other discipline for that matter, does not somehow disappear just because one wishes to do qualitative, or indeed quantitative, research.

We can clearly identify nine such standards or criteria. These are: universality, replicability, control, measurability (Leedy, 1980: 46); validity, reliability, objectivity, ethics (Comte, 1853; Durkheim, 1982; Weber, 1964: 126-130; Giddens, 1993: 114-116) and representativeness (Sarantakos, 1994: 18-26; Weber, 1964: 110). The cited authors are only examples of scholars who have engaged in conversations about these standards. 

I enthusiastically take the opportunity to share with the reader my own understanding and critique of each of the standards, and of related conversations by other scholars, on separate blog pages. Links to the respective blog pages are embedded in the list below, and readers are invited to click on each at their convenience:

3. Control
4. Measurability
5. Validity
6. Reliability (Pending)
7. Objectivity (Pending)
8. Ethics 
9, Representativeness.


Let me, as I conclude this brief piece, invite debate. The more robust the debate, the better all around.

P.S: An earlier version of this introduction was published in early November 2015, but was quickly withdrawn ('reverted to draft') to allow for more of the nine key standards to first appear. Six standards have now been published. The seventh, "Ethics", has taken more time than previously anticipated -- as the filling of one gap or other in the narrative revealed the exciting need to do yet another, and so on -- but is nearly done. The remaining two will follow soon after it. The release of this updated introduction today (January 25th, 2016) thus appeared as appropriate as it was ever going to be, and so here it is.


References
American Sociological Association, ASA (1999) Code of Ethics and Policies and Procedures of the ASA Committee on Professional Ethics. Washington, DC: ASA

Becker, Lawrence C. and Charlotte B. Becker, Eds (2003) A History of Western Ethics. Second Edition. New York and London: Routledge.

British Sociological Association, BSA (2002) Statement of Ethical Practice for the British Sociological Association. Durham: BSA (consider the PDF version provided)

Comte, Auguste (1853) The Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte. Volume I. Trans. Harriet Martineau. New York: D. Appleton and Co.

Cooper, John M. (2003) "Classical Greek Ethics", pp. 9-18, in Lawrence C. Becker and Charlotte B. Becker (2003) A History of Western Ethics. Second Edition. New York and London: Routledge.

Durkheim, Emile (1957) Professional Ethics and Civic Morals. Trans. Cornelia Brookfield. Longon and New York: Routledge.

Durkheim, Emile (1982) The Rules of Sociological Method and Selected Texts on Sociology and Its Method. Edited with an Introduction by Steven Lukes. Trans: W.D. Halls. New York: The Free Press

Giddens, Anthony (1993) New Rules of Sociological Method: A Positive Critique of Interpretative Sociologies. Second Edition. Stanford: Stanford University Press

International Sociological Association (2001) Code of Ethics. Madrid: ISA

Jones, Robert Alun (1986) Emile Durkheim: An Introduction to Four Major Works. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. (CLICK HERE: Excerpts from Jones' book focusing on Durkheim's The Rules of Sociological Method)

Kahn, Charles H. (2003) "Presocratic Greek Ethics", pp. 1-8), in Lawrence C. Becker and Charlotte B. Becker (2003) A History of Western Ethics. Second Edition. New York: Routledge.

Leedy, Paul D (1980) Practical Research: Planning and Design. Second Edition. New York:  Macmillan Publishing Co.


Sarantakos, Sortirios (1994) Social Research. London: The Macmillan Press

Weber, Max (1964) The Theory of Social and Economic Organization. Edited with an Introduction by Talcott Parsons. New York: The Free Press

Saturday, November 07, 2015

Universality: A Key Standard of Scientific Research

Nine key standards, or principles, of scientific research can be gleaned from texts on research method. As I see them, these are:

1. Universality
3. Control
4. Measurability
5. Validity
6. Reliability (Pending)
7. Objectivity (Pending)
8. Ethics 
9. Representativeness.

I say something about each of the nine standards in separate posts, as shown in the links above. What I want to briefly talk about here is the universality standard. 

Universality: 

The tern universality has roots in the broader conception of a pervasive universe, of which we are all inescapably a part. More specifically, it is anchored in the related notion of universals. Thus:
"Universals are features (e.g., redness or tallness) shared by many individuals, each of which is said to instantiate or exemplify the universal...The metaphysical issue is whether or not these features exist independently of the particular things that have them:  realists hold that they do; nominalists hold that they do not; conceptualists hold that they do so only mentally"(A Dictionary of Philosophical terms, in Garth Kemerling (2011) The Philosophy Pages. available online).
Thus, moreover, "evolutionary universals", as Talcott Parsons argues, are those similitudes, those patterns of resemblance, which scholarship detects -- recognizes -- in the evolution of human society.

Armstrong (1986, 1989) understands that universals do have particulars, the very constituents or components which make universals possible in the first place. Moreover, the particulars of any one universal resemble one another. As resembling constituents of universals multiply within and across universals, what we end up with is identity, which, to repeat, is borne out of resemblance, and which in the end it morphs out of. And so, one can see, universals are made of common particulars.Thus:
"If we consider ordinary, first-order, particulars, then . . . two things, while remaining two, can resemble exactly. At least exact resemblance is possible (assuming that the Identity of Indiscernibles is not a necessary truth). In the limit, resemblance of particulars does not give identity. But now consider the resemblance of universals. As resemblance of properties [monadic universals] gets closer and closer, we arrive in the limit at identity. Two become one. This suggests that as resemblance gets closer, more and more constituents of the resembling properties are identical, until all the constituents are identical and we have identity rather than resemblance." [This quote is from Armstrung (1989) as found in Pautz (1977). The original article is yet to be accessed]  
So universality is ultimately "standardized" via the metamorphosis of its resembling parts into a more holistic identity recognized by the, or at the very least a, scientific community. The universality standard requires that any research project should be designed and planned in such a way that any competent researcher, not just the one(s) who wrote the proposal,  should be able to successfully undertake it. (Leedy, 1980: 46). In this sense, the research project has a life of its own, independent of any particular researcher, within the confines of the relevant discipline or scientific community.

Universality demands a high level of discipline and transparency in the research habits of all who do research. In a sense, too, universality makes all scientific discoveries part of a common, with standard operating procedures and the common ownership of the discoveries claimed and accumulated across geographies, disciplines and time.

READ: Universal (metaphysics)

ALSO READ: Professor JeeLou Lin "D.M. Armstrong, Universals: An Opinionated Introduction"


To partially sum it all up, let's see in this quotation how the International Council for Science (ICSU) defines the universality of Science:
"The universality of science in its broadest sense is about developing a truly global scientific community on the basis of equity and non-discrimination. It is also about ensuring that science is trusted and valued by societies across the world. As such, it incorporates issues related to the conduct of science; capacity building; science education and literacy; access to data and information and the relationship between science and society..." (see ICSU)
Furthermore, a noteworthy point -- on the importance of doubt and criticism (including self-criticism) in all claims to, or efforts to affirm, scientific discovery -- is made by Michel Paty (2001: 8) who, inspired by Descartes's Discourse on Method, argues that:
"...the idea of of universality, as well as ideas of reason and of demonstrative (and even objective) science, with which it has a constitutive link, carries with it the requirement of its own criticism...[Thus]... the only true knowledge is that knowledge that, for every thinking subject, overcomes the obstacles [posed] by doubt."

REFERENCES:
Armstrong, D.M. (1986) "In Defense of Structural Universals", Australasian Journal of Philosophy 64 (1986) pp. 85-88.

Leedy, Paul D. (1980) Practical Research: Planning and Design. Second Edition. New York:  Macmillan Publishing Co.,


Parsons, Talcott (1964) "Evolutionary Universals in Society" American Sociological Review, Vol. 29, Issue 3 (June, 1964), pp. 339-357


Paty, Michel (2001). "Universality of Science : Historical Validation of a Philosophical Idea." in Habib, S. Irfan and Raina, Dhruv. Situating the history of science : Dialogues with Joseph Needham, Oxford India Paperbacks, p. 303-324, 2001.  [see p. 7 of the pdf version given in this link]

Pautz, Adam (1977) "An Argument Against Armstrong's Analysis of the resemblance of Universals"




~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
CSO 302