Showing posts with label Uncertainty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Uncertainty. Show all posts

Monday, March 12, 2018

CONCEPTS: Contingency and Contingency Planning


Contingency: Generically, the term contingency refers to an event (or events) or variables or parameters likely in the 'foreseeable future' to impact upon, shape or influence, interfere with, or intervene in (a) an identified process, or (b) the operations of an open system. Contingencies are the ‘environmental’ factors capable of affecting the processes internal to an open system. Mapping contingency scenarios -- in terms of the most likely turn(s) of events -- is an invaluable exercise, and a foundation for preparedness against specified risks or hazards. It is even more important as a guide to informed and effective response.

A related concept, Contingency Planning, refers in a more focused way to making actionable arrangements ahead of time -- based, inter alia, on predictive analytics (such as evidence-based weather forecasts) -- to deal with one or more emergencies likely to occur in the 'near-future' -- that is, within days, a few weeks or months, or "the year". That is to say, it is "a planning process from which a contingency plan is drawn" (UNHCR, 2000:36).

During this planning exercise, obviously conducted "in a state of uncertainty", options and "objectives are agreed, managerial and technical actions defined, and potential response systems put in place in order to prevent, or better respond to, an emergency" (UNHCR, 2000: 36; 2007: 68). Incidentally, in certain situations -- where events unfold in a manner contrary to previous predictions or original plans -- a contingency plan takes the form of a Plan B, as popularly understood, and as alluded to below. 

Contingency planning, as further elaborated upon by UNHCR (2007: 68), "builds organizational capacity and is thus a foundation for operations planning and all aspects of emergency response." It provides a 'hands-on' and focused opportunity to train and co-learn with likely co-responders to pre-identified types emergencies. Yet another defining characteristic of contingency planning is that it is anchored on scenario construction, which may take various forms, such as: Worst-Case v. Best-Case Scenario, Plan A v. Plan B, and Most-Likely v. Least-Likely Scenario (or turn of events). 

As noted by ASIS (1994: 101):
"Scenarios describe simulated emergency situations , including the overall sequence of events, details and timing of the specific activities. A scenario provides a set of problems that must be dealt with through the procedures outlined in the emergency management plan." [That is, the Contingency Plan]
 The word 'Contingency' may not even feature in the plan's title. Plans with the following titles or labels are in effect contingency plans: Preparedness Plan, Mitigation Plan, Emergency Response Plan, Emergency Management Plan, Business Recovery Plan, Evacuation Plan, Logistics Plan, and Search and Rescue Plan.



Updated: March 14 and 30, 2018

CONCEPT: The Precautionary Principle


The Precautionary Principle: At the 1990 Bergen Conference, a Northern follow up to the publication of Our Common Future (popularly known as the Bruntland Report on Sustainable Development), Gro Harlem Bruntland (the Norwegian Prime Minister) stirred up a storm in her opening address by calling for action to protect the environment and future generations in advance of certainty about the environmental effects of particular scientific and technological innovations and directional shifts (see O’Riordan and Cameron, 1994: 314). S
he was clearly calling for the adoption of "the precautionary principle" when she declared: “If we err in our decisions affecting the future of our children and our planet, let us err on the side of caution” (see O'Riordan and Cameron, 1994: 314).

As a concept, precaution has several synonyms and broad similes, such as: foresight, prudence, prevention, pro-activity, risk avoidance/minimization, protection, “hedge against uncertainty”, a holistic/integrated approach to the functioning of natural systems, sensitivity to future needs (O'Riordan and Cameron, 1994: 305-7); others are: defence, safeguard, security, shield, vigil, watch, surveillance, lookout and anticipation
. 

In any of its various names, precaution:
“implies committing human activity to investments where the benefits of action cannot, at the time of expenditure, be justified by conclusive scientific evidence. Other grounds for legitimation need to be present – political, ethical, legal and moral – in the sense of playing by the same rules as others in protecting the environment. Accordingly, the rationale has to be accounted for in forms that are more overtly judgmental” (O’Riordan and Cameron, 1994: 299).
The precautionary principle has strong environmental protection and legal roots in Germany. These are now underpinned by six basic concepts (which continue to be the subject of once-robust debate worldwide), namely:

1. Preventive anticipation: That is, prevent before any damage is caused. Or, when in doubt, prevent -- or disallow. 
2. Safeguarding of the environment: That is, ensuring that no potential polluter gets near the "margins of [nature's capacity for] tolerance".
3. Proportionality of response: That is, the "cost-effectiveness of margins of error" implicated/imprinted in the producer's, manufacturer's or any other potential polluter's preferred "degree of restraint" must be carefully determined. 
4. Duty of care: Meaning that the burden of proof -- of zero or neutral effect -- rests with those who propose changes that may affect the ecological balance.
5. Promoting "intrinsic natural rights": That is, a determination to maintain nature's (or the environment's) known "order of things" on planet earth.
6. Paying for past ecological debt: That is, acknowledging and settling historical debt incurred as a result of years-long or decades-long ravages of large-scale industrial and agricultural production as well as related consumption. 

READ: 
1.Timothy O'Riordan and James Cameron (1994) Interpreting the Precautionary Principle. Oxon: Earthscan. [Note: the link avails only a few preview pages. So you have to find the whole book, if interested]