Showing posts with label U-Shaped. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U-Shaped. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

On Being Ahead of the Curve

On CNN's Quest Means Business, Richard Quest last night sought to know from three leading G20 personalities whether "we" (if I got him right), presumably G20 we, were "ahead of the curve"? The phrase, I believe, had been used earlier in the day by Timothy Geithner, the new US Treasury Secretary. Mr. Quest interrogated the concept by means of a simple, u-shaped (not s-shaped) curve drawn on a hand-held whiteboard.

Despite not being quite sure of the concept himself, the first time Mr. Quest posed the question, he correctly inserted another curve taking off from and running, partially, above the "base" (or "standard" or average) curve. The second and third time he showed the audience his curve, however, he clearly suggested that being "ahead of the curve" was somehow simply a question of where along the "base" curve one was. That was wrong.

The Canadian Finance Minister was correct to say, "I think we are on it"; though even he was apparently not so firmly grounded as to the correct meaning of the term "ahead of the curve." The Argentinian Central Bank boss was quite emphatic that "No, we are not ahead of the curve." As far as I could tell, he had not been shown the graphic, however, and so one does not quite know if he is a master of the concept.

The "curve" alluded to is, typically, the learning curve, a variant of which is the experience curve. The latter is more appropriate in the present circumstances. The learning curve is a logistic curve, and reflects the standard or average or "normal" progression among a class of members or units or entities over time. The basic characteristic of learning curves, indeed most if not all curves, is that they are typically plotted on two axes, X and Y.

In the present case, G20 members are taken to be the referent "class of members" whose progression the "base curve" that Quest was displaying to his TV audience represents. If that is so, then no G20 member can possibly be ahead of the curve shown, or even farther along it than any or all of the rest. Where G20 members are, individually and collectively, along the curve at any pont of time is a function of only one metric, the total time-frame plotted in the graphic.

By the same token, one cannot be ahead of the learning or experience curve by simply being farther along it than the rest, if that were theoretically possible. The learning curve is not a concrete, singular road along which we must all ride. It is a conceptualized, mean path. To be ahead of the (standardized) curve, then, is to be on another curve altogether, "above" the standard one. Above all, it is to be not a member of the pack in question. It is to have and to display a better than the pack's average trajectory. It follows from the foregoing that if one is below average, then one is likewise on another curve, in another trajectory, "below" the pack's.

It is conceivable, of course, that a "base" curve could be plotted for, say, the US alone as some sort of standard -- in the same way as the US dollar, or gold, is a standard. In that case, it would be legitimate for any and all of the other G20 members to ask whether or not they were "ahead of the US curve", or for the US to seek to know if it was ahead of any or all of their respective curves. And this is probably the way Richard Quest should have framed his question.

The fundamental point in all of the foregoing is that you cannot possibly be ahead of your own curve.