Showing posts with label Humanitarian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Humanitarian. Show all posts

Thursday, April 05, 2018

CONCEPT: Ethics in Emergency and Disaster Management

As a concept, Ethics is derived from the Greek word ethikos (meaning 'arising from habit'). Ethikos in turn arose from an older Greek word ethos (which refers to the custom, character, disposition or core values of a given social entity -- which may range from the individual to the corporate group). Ethics is about conduct. Conduct, Herbert Spencer (1892: 10) pointed out, was the opposite of "purposeless actions"; which was straightforward enough, and yet sufficiently intriguing to catch thoughtful attention. But Spencer (1820-1903), whom we should all read these days, worried that attempts to see good conduct as an ethical ideal might degenerate into a tautology, equating it with a purposefulness and perfection of action. Perfection need not be the 'culminating' ideal, but here is the case he made:
"It is strange that a notion so abstract as that of perfection, or a certain ideal completeness of nature, should ever have been thought one from which a system of guidance can be evolved; as it was in a general way by Plato and more distinctly by Jonathan Edwardes. Perfection is synonymous with goodness in the highest degree; and hence to define good conduct in terms of perfection, is indirectly to define good conduct in terms of itself." (Spencer, 1892: 33)
He suggested that there was only one way out of this logjam -- the means-ends way. Thus: "...the notion of perfection like the notion of goodness can be framed only in relation to ends" (Spencer, 1892: 33). In the diverse fields of scientific and emergency management work, the concept of ethics pertains, certainly from the Spencerian perspective, to any or all dimensions of professional conduct in terms of its conformity with, threats to, or violations of, the highest value propositions of a given field of practice. 

For present purposes, then, ethics -- or more specifically, professional ethics -- refers to a code of acceptable conduct or practice on the part of an individual, group or corporate entity as guided by the highest normative principles or best traditions, or collective 'hopes', of a discipline or profession. Thus, Weber (1964: 129-130) points out, inter alia, that:
"From a sociological point of view an 'ethical' standard is one to which [people] attribute a certain type of value and which, by virtue of this belief, they treat as a valid norm governing their action. In this sense it can be spoken of as defining what is ethically good in the same way that action which is called beautiful is measured by aesthetic standards. It is possible for ethically normative beliefs of this kind to have a profound influence on action in the absence of any sort of external guarantee. This is often the case when the interests of others would be little affected by their violation."
Weber continued to say that 'ethical beliefs' could also be 'guaranteed' by religion, or firmly adhered to on account of the "disapproval of violations and the consequent boycott"; or by the probability of, or actual, legal action (Weber, 1964: 130).

The entire value-chain of humanitarian response and related emergency and disaster management work is in principle guided by implicit and explicit ethical standards. All these fall under the 'umbrella' goal of delivering "the greatest good for the greatest number" of people in actual or impending distress. A number of key concepts interrogated in the present series speak to certain elements of those standards. Among these concepts are: Climate Change, Contamination, Contingency, Deforestation, Disaster, Emergency, Entitlement, Famine, Hunger, Non-Refoulement, Pollution, Response, The Precautionary Principle and Triage.  



NOTE: The bulk of the above text is extracted, with some changes, from a longer discourse on ethics as a pivotal standard of scientific research, as referenced below. 

Sunday, March 11, 2018

CONCEPT: Government Service Packages (GSPs)


Government Service Packages (GSPs): The idea of GSPs, which had been tried before in Sarajevo and elsewhere, really took off during the Rwanda genocide of 1994. As their name suggests, GSPs (sometimes called simply "Service Packages") were conceived of as "a last resort in exceptionally large emergencies" justifying the use of "military and civil defence assets" (UNHCR, 2000: 359). 

It was argued that the scale of GSP missions, such as the one in Rwanda, was so large as to restrict involvement to UN member states with the requisite logistical and related material capacity for 'extra-budgetary donations in kind'. The mobilizing and coordinating functions of GSPs were assigned to UNHCR's top management in Geneva, obviously with allowance for behind-the-scenes consultations with the UN's most influential member-states. 

However, as the Rwanda crisis quickly and amply showed, the host-government's 'organic' involvement in the operations of a GSP intervention was too critical a requirement for success to wish away (Kent, 1996: 64-85; Wright, 1996: 54-56). That was a hard lesson learnt on the ground. On the other hand, built into GSP operations from the start was a formal undertaking that operations (a) would be of 'limited' duration; and, (b) would not "replace the traditional response capacity of NGOs". 

T
here are now over 20 GSPs (a number of them looking from a distance like nation-building propositions). Prior to 2004, these  included: Air Operations Cell, Strategic Airlift, Theatre Airlift, Airport Ground Handling, Warehousing/Storekeeping, Road Transport, Field Hospital, Hydrological Survey, Water Tanker Operation, "Surface Water", Borehole Drilling, Water Treatment, Water Distribution, Water Storage, Latrine Construction, Vector Control, Solid Waste Management, Waste Water System, Site Development and Road Construction (UNHCR, 2000: 359). The hugely destructive Indian Ocean Tsunami of December 26, 2004 brought rise, in actual practice (if not formally, to two or three new GSP: The Field/Tented Mortuary, DNA Identification and related Forensic/Tracing Services.


REFERENCES

Humanitarian Practice Network (1996) 'Service Packages': The Role of Military Contingents in Emergencies

Kent, Randolph (1996) "The Integrated Operations Centre in Rwanda: Coping with Complexity", pp. 64-85, in Jim Whitman and David Pocock, Eds., After Rwanda: The Coordination of United Nations Humanitarian Assistance. London: Macmillan Press Limited.

W
right, Neill (1996) "The Hidden Cost of Better Coordination", pp. 54-56, in Jim Whitmann and David Pocock, Eds. After Rwanda: The Coordination of United Nations Humanitarian Assistance. London: Macmillan Press Limited.