Showing posts with label Guevara. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guevara. Show all posts

Monday, August 11, 2008

Celebrity, Graffiti and Leadership

On Saturday, August 09, 2008, John Rubery published a piece titled "Celebrity Obama chasing after celebrities", in which he said, inter alia:

"Two recent John McCain ads have mocked Barack Obama's celebrity status. The Obama camp acted like a bunch of cry babies, calling the first commercial a "dishonest attack." Of course if Obama had a legislative record to run on after three years in the US Senate--How many of his bills have been enacted into law?--they wouldn't need to have responded in such a fashion. The ads were effective--Obama is increasingly looking like a lightweight..."

And he added: "The Telegraph of London reveals tonight that the Democrats will place quite a few Hollywood celebrities in prominent roles at their convention later this month.
The decision to let some of them take to the center stage is a calculated gamble by Mr. Obama to stick to his guns in courting the celebrity vote. It comes after his Republican rival John McCain landed a telling blow last week, mocking him as the "Paris Hilton" of the White House race in a so-called "attack ad". Mr Obama's strategists have concluded that the publicity gains from rubbing shoulders with actors like George Clooney, Ben Affleck and Matt Damon will outweigh the risks of appearing lightweight. The list of those approved for credentials to attend the event includes the actress Gwyneth Paltrow, who recently filmed a campaign advertisement for Mr. Obama, who is expected to bring her friend Madonna. Hollywood royalty, including Quentin Tarantino, Spike Lee, Warren Beatty, Susan Sarandon, Forrest Whitaker and Scarlett Johansson, will also be in Denver, as well as singers Kanye West and Wyclef Jean. Michael Douglas and Catherine Zeta Jones may also put in an appearance."

There are, of course, celebrities, and then there are celebrated leaders -- leaders whom the public put on a symbolic pedestal for the vision, and preferably the record, which they personify. To know the difference between the two is to know what politics and leadership are all about. Celebrity may be fleeting, but may also last a long time -- feeding on our less than critical adulation. On the other hand, while autocratic leadership may be perpetuated ad nauseam by force of arms, charismatic or "rational-legal" leadership must always, in the end, come to terms with the test of delivery. Certain leaders have achieved celebrity status, without being "mere celebrities". These include, in our time: Mahatma Gandhi, John Kennedy, Patrice Lumumba, Charles De Gaul, Nelson Mandela, Martin Luther King, Ronald Reagan, Che Guevara, Nasser, Pierre Trudeau and Tony Blair (for a while). By popular will, Obama has joined this select group, while McCain never will.

I posted a response to Rubery's piece as follows (I have amended the post somewhat):

The celebrity crowd is, as you suggest, mostly lightweight; people who are, as has been said of Paris Hilton (and as can be said of most), "famous for being famous." These are people whose fame make them think they have a mandate to "throw their weight" at every public policy matter, and at other things which don't quite matter.

But there's the paradox: being famous pads upon their shoulders a weight they can throw around, and which we others cannot fail to see, or feel. So, we cannot simply assume their light weight -- if we are not to be, ourselves, small-minded in our snootiness (or snooty in our small-mindedness). Or if we are not in Hilton's eyes to appear, like McCain, "wrinkly" tasteless and out of what should be our own depths.

So we must interrogate what is to be deemed truly light of weight, and what is to be heavy-duty. And let's not forget that it is McCain who provoked Paris Hilton to react to his clumsy association of what she and Spears ordinarily do (plus how they do carry themselves in public) with the serious campaign which Obama is waging (and with the ground-breaking candidacy which he represents). And her sarcastic video response told the world that it was McCain who appeared "hare-brained" (or lightweight), when there is no reason otherwise to believe he is, in comparison to Obama and to her (and the likes of her) and in terms of leadership in general and the energy debate in particular.

Let me add: It seems to me that Obama's joining that select group of celebrated leaders has deeply disturbed Sen McCain; and his recent Grand Tour must have brought McCain's discomfort to a head. So what does Team McCain do? There is no speculation here, it is there for all to see: They rush to spray graffiti and throw other dirt on the most telling images of Obama's Tour. In doing so, they hope, they will have sufficiently polluted them to prevent Obama from even thinking of using them in his Fall campaign -- as widely anticipated.

What McCain's team forgot as they plotted this devious scheme was that Spears and Hilton -- this new kind of political graffiti -- were a kind that can fight back! In fighting back, Paris Hilton has achieved what seemed impossible: she has wiped off all the graffiti and all the dirt.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Mandela at 90

This past weekend, Nelson Mandela was in London to attend a music concert organized to celebrate his 90th birthday and raise funds for his South African aids charity. For many around he world, Mandela at 90 is certainly an occasion for pause and reflection.

Watching him on TV as he walked haltingly and with much help across the concert stage and across the screen – there to be seen rather than to see, and to give a dutiful speech – one thing stood out among all else: Madiba has become just too frail for this kind of thing – and for the visual and psychic comfort of those whose inner wish is to remember him as a father-figure who was forever strong and all-enduring and in full command of the only resource they could not take away during all those terrible and terribly long years he stood alone – his spirit.

It is no wonder that he himself saw it fit to use the occasion to declare, with touching finality and mindful of the struggle that must surely continue and yet of which he would no longer have the strength to be a real part: “It is your hands now.” Seeing Will Smith behind him there on stage as he spoke, looking at once attentive and happy to be there and yet perplexed in the presence – the very presence – of the great man, whom he had introduced as the “Birthday Boy” but who probably didn’t, couldn’t, return the attention; seeing Will Smith there like that,
his own youthful energy just below the surface, I wondered what he was thinking – and thought that he wondered how he would, in his turn, carry himself at Six Score and Six.

Seeing Mandela thus, one couldn’t help but remember how it had been one afternoon in ’90, when, at 72, he had walked at last out of prison and out of a 27-year banishment from, to all intents and purposes, the world as we knew it – and even as had known him. He who walked out of that prison that day into our waiting, suspenseful, and in the end quizzical gaze was another man – a man from another world – whom we, utterly surprised, felt we had never seen. And if he was the man, as surely he was – all the people and institutions that mattered told us so – we had not been sufficiently conditioned to see him as he had become. He was, then, an alien who did not match our mental image of the man in prison whose release we had long clamoured for, in our different ways, and had awaited with bated breath when it at last became clear that he would be free.

Even then his walk, in Winnie’s arm, had not been quite steady, as I recall. Now, eighteen years later, it had, unmistakably, a foreboding aura about it – which, it seemed, enveloped everyone whom he left on that stage with Will.

Yet the Mandela we first encountered that afternoon in ’90 was the physical Mandela, while the one we had been waiting for was in fact a transcendent Mandela – a man whose true value ran deeper and wider and farther, and was in the end borderless and timeless; whose entire life was the story of all that is good in good men – good in the few men who are truly good. It is that latter Mandela who, a colossus, has strode the globe these past two decades or so with so much ease and charm (easy charm) and class – such infectious human warmth and kindness. It is that same Mandela who so quickly became the father-figure to so many, mighty and “low”, around the world who had no fathers, or no fathers to talk of (or to talk to) – and even those who (themselves fathers or mothers, sons or daughters) had fathers but wanted something intangibly, reachably more.

To flip the imagery: what we didn’t realize, what we forgot, in that instant of shock and disabuse in ‘90, was that Time idealizes – Time and absence. Time and absence may prepare us for the watts, but not the warts, attendant upon the hero – upon his return. What we didn’t realize, too, was that the picture into which we wanted to re-frame him – as a one-sided act of reacquaintance – as he walked out was itself another kind of prison, another kind of confinement, out of which he must also walk if we were to know him as he had become, out of view, and as we were subsequently to know him.

As we worry that we will see less and less of Madiba in the coming months and years, there are those who worry that the artist’s unfettered hand may with the passage of time leave us with a lasting image (akin to Guevara’s or Mona Lisa’s) over which they will not have had the last word. All I can say to that lesser worry is: if it happens, so be it!