Showing posts with label Community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Community. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 27, 2018

CONCEPT: Community


Community: In sociology, a community is typically a face-to-face group or 'aggregation' of families and individuals living in relatively close proximity with each other and bound together by certain genealogical and/or 'social ties' as well as ecological/geographical factors, or givens, to which their livelihoods are more or less physically tied. All of this generates reasons and opportunities for joint action at the local level, and hence such ideas as "self-help groups" 
[more accurately harambee (= let's pull together) groups], "the therapeutic community", "mutual-aid groups" and "community policing".

Ferdinand Toennies made a widely acknowledged distinction between Community (Gemeinschaft) and Society (Gesellschaft). By his reckoning, a community displayed the characteristics outlined above, which were typical of all pre-modern (or traditional) and usually rural and isolated collectivities. According to Emile Durkheim, a community thus organized was held together by the centrifugal pull of sameness or similarity; that is , by what one may call the logic of "birds of a feather". 


In contrast, the heterogeneity manifest in a modern society, due principally to widespread division of labour beyond household and community boundaries, was welded together by a crucial byproduct of that very division of labour -- namely, the "mutual dependence" of those who could no longer directly produce the resources required for their own full subsistence, but were now bound together, if more impersonally, by the operations of "market exchange".

In an influential empirical study of respondents' conceptualizations of "community", K. MacQueen et al (2001) identified five core elements of a community. These were: Locus (a sense of place, which can be both located and described by those concerned), Sharing (common interests -- values, norms, mindset, ideology, vision, activities, skin color), Joint action (which serves as a source of cohesion and identity, and includes opportunities/contexts, structures or 'arenas' for socializing, conversation, gossip and get-together), Social ties (interpersonal relations - encompassing sub-elements such as family units, lovers, friends, neighbors and support groups) and Diversity (that is, "social complexity" or heterogeneity due to the presence of sub-communities within or migrants into the community -- sub-communities or migrants characterized by distinct identities such as clan, ethnic group, race, religion, caste, occupational status and unequal family standing) 


[To be updated]

Tuesday, December 09, 2008

The Happiness Contagion

Happiness, it seems, is a communal thing. The more people we have around us that are happy, the happier we are; in part on account of their being happy in the first place and in part, yes, because we do, or happen to, know them and to be close to them. Tell that to the "happy native"!


This major re-discovery is brought to our attention by two exciting scholars: Nicholas Christakis (Department of Health Care Policy, Harvard Medical School, and Department of Sociology, Harvard University) and James Fowler (Department of Political Science, University of California, San Diego).

In a longitudinal social network study published in the British Medical Journal on December 4th, 2008, and titled "Dynamic spread of happiness in a large social network: longitudinal analysis over 20 years in the Framingham Heart Study," the authors report that happiness is contagious and that it spreads dynamically within social networks.

The two authors had sought to "evaluate whether happiness can spread from person to person and whether niches of happiness form within social networks." The specific social network of interest to them was the pre-existing Framingham Heart Study social network, in the state of Massachusetts. The heart study social network has existed since 1948. The authors tracked data on 4,739 participants (or "egos") -- the "offspring cohort" of the participants of the original 1948 study -- for a twenty-year period, running from 1983 to 2003.

But "egos" alone do not a network make. To highlight the dimensions of the network the authors chose to deal with, let us quote them at length:



"Each ego in this cohort is connected to other people via friendship, family, spousal, neighbour, and coworker relationships. Each relationship is a "social tie." Each person who has a relationship with an ego was called an "alter." For example, one ego in the offspring cohort had 18 alters: a mother, a father, a sister, two brothers, three children, two friends, five neighbours, and three coworkers. We wanted to know how each of these alters influences an ego. Many of the alters also happened to be members of a studied cohort in Framingham, which means that we had access to detailed information about them as well. Overall, within the entire Framingham Heart Study social network, composed of both the egos and any detected alters in any Framingham Heart Study cohort, there were 12067 individuals who were connected at some point in 1971-2003."

The study yielded six major findings:

1. That "Clusters of happy and unhappy people" were "visible in the network" and that "the relationship between people’s happiness extends up to three degrees of separation (for example, to the friends of one’s friends’ friends)."

2.That being surrounded by many happy people and being "central in the network" make one "more likely to become happy in the future."

3. That, moreover, "clusters of happiness" are precisely the consequence of "the spread of happiness", rather than the symptom of "a tendency for people to associate with similar individuals."

4. That living within a mile (some 1.6km) of a friend who becomes happy increases the probability that one is likewise happy by 25%. The probability increases by 8% among coresident spouses, 14% among siblings who live within 1.6 km of each other, and 34% among next-door neighbours.

5. That this happiness contagion is "not seen between coworkers."

6. That time and geographical separation have a weakening effect on this contagion.


The authors' main conclusion from the study is this:

"People’s happiness depends on the happiness of others with whom they are connected. This provides further justification for seeing happiness, like health, as a collective phenomenon."

If happiness is as contagious as that, is it really a stretch to infer that community life is likewise contagious? Might not all this "contagious" (this viral) thinking also lead us to the more fundamental conclusion that humans are social animals not because they are social (they live in social groups) -- that would be a tautology -- but because social life is itself contagious? But in what ways would this contagion be different from Durkheimian solidarity?

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

On Not Being Afraid To Be An Example That Inspires

In On Becoming The Example, Kimmy Sharing Light wrote:


"When we watch our children start a new journey, or life challenge, they look for role models or inspiration. We usually never think of being an inspiration for them." And she added that "whatever we do, we need to have the aim of becoming an example, an inspiration for others."
I posted a comment on her blog with the following words, which, in their mix, impose upon me a re-varnishing duty which I cannot avoid, even as I repeat them:

You ask elsewhere: "How do people judge you?" And you answer: BY OUR ACTIONS." That's right. Talk can reveal the inner soul, and talk can inspire; but talk, as someone or other keeps saying, is cheap.

To be inspired is to be fired up. The question is: By what? By whom? Yet "whom" is an imperfect word, for what it brings to mind in the first instance is a kind of singularity that is too confined and, as an anchor of sorts, too confining. The only safe "whom" is a plural "whom." But we, as individualities, are a part of that -- or a part of it as well. That's what you had in mind I think. And that's the main story.

As for the question "By what?", the essential answer remains, in your own words: BY OUR ACTIONS. But any layered answer we attempt returns us to the base, to the realization, that the "what" can be many things, and can never be the one size that fits all. It may be a moment that sits up; or an event that rewires the brain by refreshing pictures in the mind. Yet words too -- as JFK's, as MLK's, as Obama's, as Kimmy's -- can inspire. If we live by them.

In a community enriched by social capital, and to anyone over five or six or seven years -- I hit "t" for tears for a moment there, but caught myself (so, no oops) -- there are many points and instances of light besides mother or father or older sibling. As they say, "it takes a village."


But the village is more than the sum of the people, for it has many parts, and fuses nurture and nature in ways we strive to understand, but typically do only in half-measures.


And it sometimes takes, yes, tears -- to come upon the true path to our destiny. And not tears of joy.