By Mauri Yambo
In to-day's Daily Nation (February 12, 2007), it is reported that a debate has flared up within ODM-K concerning the number of delegate-votes a candidate will have to garner to win ODM-K's presidential nomination. The first point to remind ourselves is that "50% plus one" and "simple majority" mean one and the same thing. That is, 50% + 1 (which is different from 50% + 1%, except when one is talking of exactly 100 votes) is precisely where simple majority begins. It is the minimum number required to claim majority support. The upper end of simple majority -- at which one begins to talk of a landslide -- is a matter of some conjecture; but a winner is certainly entitled to claim a landslide when his or her votes equal or surpass 66.7%. The person who merely gets the highest number of votes among three or more contestants can only claim victory based on a "plurality" (not the majority) of the votes cast.
In the years since independence, one has occasionally heard of "majority tribes". The truth of the matter is that there can be only one majority -- though such a one can be created through a coalition. There is another truth, ignorance of which has deluded some political leaders with strong ethnic bases into thinking that their respective ethnic groups somehow represent the majority of Kenyan voters. No single ethnic group in Kenya is large enought to be the majority. More importantly, we do not have amidst us any two or three ethnic groups, however you mix and match them, which add up to the majority of the citizenry.
I do not know what ODM-K leaders agreed on at the relevantNaivasha meeting. Raila is reported to believe that they agreed on 50%+1. Kalonzo claims that they agreed on a plurality. Some slants in the story suggest that they agreed on a simple majority. Mutula Kilonzo seems to agree with Raila, and advises aspirants to read the implications of a simple majority (or 50% +1)correctly and hit the campaign trail accordingly.
What I know is that it would be dangerous and eventually self-defeating for any aspirant to seek victory within ODM-K simply on the basis of a plurality. How would a flag-bearer with less than the majority of the party's support (as reflected in the actual pattern of delegate-voting) -- say 25%, or even 49% -- galvanize and energize the party toward electoral victory in December 2007? How are we to imagine that those turned off by his/her narrow margin of victory would vote in December?
It may be difficult for anyone to win majority votes in the first ballot. So I expect a lot of horse-trading when the delegates meet to annoint one of the declared candidates. Woe betide the candidate whose supporting delegates cannot network or articulate his/her case -- when such horse-trading begins.
There will probably be two to five voting sessions before the winner is eventually declared. Contingency measures should be agreed upon and established ahead of time to accommodate this possibility. And I would suggest that once someone gains 50% +1, the losing candidates should have the opportunity to "offer" their votes to the actual winner. This would serve as the first move to rally the entire party behind the declared winner.
To argue that the process winning the majority of delegates would be exhausting to the candidates is in the end to look for excuses to avoid the popular mandate. It is to reveal a certain fear of real Democracy in practice. Better to expend requisite energy in order to get the party's unequevocal support behind one, than to conserve energy only to wage a losing war in December.